The well-known Asian specialist Owen Lattimore once wrote that, in understanding Central Asian sociopolitical systems, outside observers must take into account an “appreciation of the dynamics of social groups.” Although not referring to Lattimore specifically, Edward Schatz has applied this dictum successfully in his research of clan politics in post-Soviet Kazakhstan. His book, Modern Clan Politics: The Power of “Blood” in Kazakhstan and Beyond, asks a central, yet modest, question: “What is the place of subethnic identities in modern politics?” (p. 3). Fundamental to this question is the notion that, in Kazakhstan, the clan (ru or taipa in Kazakh) and its larger social unit, the horde (zhuz, which the author refers to as “umbrella clans”), will influence the course and function of political, social, and economic transition in this new era.
The value of Schatz's work is not only the methodological approaches taken to uncover an extremely complex subject, but also the empirical applications he employed in his research. Schatz conducted focus groups, interviewed individuals, and carefully gauged the extent to which indiscernible forces determined the role that seemingly myopic clans operate in political, social, and economic relations during the period of transition. He also understands the limits to the methodological structure by arguing throughout that clan divisions persist, but do not hinge, on “identifiable mechanisms of identity reproduction” (p. 13). The mechanisms that sustained group identity, however, can be undermined by a state that deems them an obstacle to progress, but without appropriate substitutes, these identity forms will endure. That was, Schatz argues, what occurred during the Soviet era and to a considerable extent what is occurring in post-Soviet Kazakhstan today. The “shortage economy” that was endemic to the Soviet system unwittingly reinforced access networks and clans that bolstered the opportunity for unsanctioned forms to proliferate rather than dissipate. The Soviet authorities rejected clan identity and identified members by socioeconomic class or ethnic group. As Schatz writes, “if the intention of Soviet state-construction efforts was to provide an institutional order that would marginalize subethnic divisions as politically unimportant, in fact they made them more politically salient by increasing the stakes involved in competition” (p. 40). Clans, therefore, became a resource used by individuals, not groups, in their political and economic dealings. Removing clan identity from the public realm “lent clans import in private matters” (p. 53). The “concealable” nature of clans meant they became an appropriate means for “access seekers and access providers” to operate undetected by authorities who were determined to eradicate them.
In the post-Soviet era, clan identities did not reemerge in a positive sense. In fact, the Kazakhstani state stigmatized clan identities in much the same way as the Soviet state. There was not, Schatz argues, a radical rupture with the Soviet past. The multinational demographics in Kazakhstan was one reason, but so too was the desire to promote civic identity based upon the Eurasian concept that could more easily embrace and engage non-Kazakhs such as Russians, Germans, Uzbeks, and Uighurs. Kazakh language, culture, and history were promoted, but the new state was receptive to the notion that clan identity was inherently retrogressive.
The work is divided into three main parts, each containing subsections: “The Reproduction of Clans,” “The Political Dynamics of Informal Ties,” and “Managing Clans.” Schatz carefully reconstructs the role and influence of clans during the tsarist, Soviet, and post-Soviet era. The latter period is what interests the author, but revealing such an elusive form of identity was a difficult undertaking. Nonetheless, the author has uncovered strategies and tactics used by Kazakhs that are ostensibly reviled yet consistently exercised.
In addition, the work contains an excellent bibliography, and the author has included in the appendix the methods and strategies used in this work. Especially valuable are the questionnaire and information regarding the time, place, and duration of interviews and focus groups. Schatz' prose is accessible to a multidisciplinary audience, easy to read without being simplistic.
One hopes that the author will continue to trace the role and influence of clans to determine the possible durable nature of blood and kinship relations in Kazakhstan. It would be fascinating to discover in another decade if these relations have lasting value or were used ephemerally only as a coping mechanism during an uncertain transitional period. To some extent Schatz anticipates this question by arguing that more political and economic transparency would defuse the necessity for concealable networks based on kin and blood, but this is unlikely at present. The current regime in Kazakhstan has shown a reluctance to relinquish its grip on political and economic control, meaning that, for the foreseeable future, clan networks will continue to function and remain subtle forms and devices of identity and survival.
