Stanley Hauerwas often makes the comment that Christians are called to be geniuses in making friends. Following the Festschrift, Faithfulness and Fortitude, published in the United Kingdom five years earlier, this collection of essays celebrates Hauerwas's sixty-fifth birthday and shows in a way the wide range of responses to his active, and sometimes voracious, friend-making practices. These essays written by his longest conversation partners differ from one another both in terms of context and in terms of their interest areas, but have in common the depth of their insights and the authors’ appreciation of companionship with Hauerwas.
The essays are more or less focused on specific topics of Hauerwas' work. Rowan A. Greer reflects upon Augustine's views of truth within a Hauerwasian framework, which includes vision and virtue, truthfulness and tragedy, a community of character and the peaceable kingdom. The theme of friendship and truthfulness is explored by Hans S. Reinders especially in regards to people with ‘intellectual disabilities’, whose existence of dependency stands ‘paradigmatic . . . for what human existence is like’ (p. 58). Hauerwas' fathering of the ‘Radical Traditions’ series occasions Peter Ochs to provide a hypothesis for a theological justification for inter-Abrahamic scriptural reasoning for him. With the conviction which he shares with Hauerwas about ‘what does and does not count as good – and bad – theology’ (p. 262), Nicholas Lash offers a theological reading of Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness.
Meanwhile, David B. Burrell's thesis, ‘no creator; no freedom’ (p. 35), speaks for the retrieval of Aquinas' significance for theology and ethics. He counters a ‘libertarian’ tendency to identify freedom with choosing, which opens the gates to gratification and domination, with the notion that we need an operative belief within a community of faith to acquire a coherent account of the freedom. We find a similar appreciation of Alasdair MacIntyre's emphasis on a particular rational tradition in Harry Huebner's exposition on a Christian university. Huebner's contention that a primary objective of such a university is ‘the shaping of a political-social body of believers – the church’ (p. 302) conveniently leads us to the one topic which has attracted the biggest number of contributors within this collection: Constantinianism/the politics of the church.
Two of the essays have Africa as their social context. After the struggles against the injustice of apartheid in South Africa, Neville Richardson heartily embraces a Hauerwasian dictum: ‘The church does not have a social ethic; the church is a social ethic’ (p. 242). Emmanuel Katongole finds the most efficient tool for critiquing ‘the prosperity gospel’ (p. 149) of Pentecostalism in Africa, which is ‘hooked’ onto the political imagination of the nation-state politics, in the connection between particular narratives, identities and politics in Hauerwas' work. Probably the staunchest criticism of Constantinianism is found (along with Huebner's) in Arne Rasmusson's essay, ‘The Politics of Diaspora’. Against the church which ‘saw its own responsibility as directed toward’ the Roman Empire, and which consequently was led to ‘a “normalisation” of violence’ (p. 106), Rasmusson proposes that the existence of Jews of the diaspora, characterised as ‘nonsovereign, nonterritorial, and “not-in-charge”' (p. 105), is closest to Jesus’ ethic.
The polar opposite to this criticism is situated in the exaltation by H. Tristram Engelhardt, Jr of ‘St Constantine the Great, Equal-to-the-Apostles’ (p. 197). To his eyes, Hauerwas is as clear a product of Enlightenment as the Enlightenment thinkers who fall prey to his attack. However, Engelhardt's peculiar emphasis on ‘right belief’ and ‘right worship’ goes as far as declaring that he and Stan ‘could not share the same chalice. If church is communion, we were not of one church’ (p. 210)! This must be an appalling statement to another contributor, George Lindbeck, who awakens Hauerwas and his students from the ‘relative silence on ecumenism’ (p. 215).
Other invitations towards more lenient views on Constantinianism are less extreme than Engelhardt's. Robert Louis Wilken simply opposes the observation that during Constantine's reign ‘bishops became players in the game of empire’ (p. 73), to the story of a bishop who ‘stitched in a well-defined border’ between the church and the world in the seemingly seamless social fabric of his day (pp. 86–7): St Ambrose of Milan. Robert N. Bellah's sociological perspective allows him to see Constantinianism as ‘a moment full of both challenge and opportunity for the church’ instead of as ‘a catastrophe’ (p. 122). He notes that high gods and kings emerged together with the early state and he sees ‘a new Constantinianism’ (p. 129) – the recapitulation of the ‘archaic fusion of religion and state’ which confuses ‘God and king’ – in contemporary American society (p. 130). Robert W. Jenson also finds himself leaning both ways concerning the topic. His willingness to celebrate Christendom stems from his understanding of that era as one in which the church took the risk of despoiling itself in order to share its ‘high culture’ of the triune God beyond its borders (p. 158).
Among these highly sagacious writings, Bernd Wannenwetsch's proposal of ‘negative political theology’ stands out as the most brilliant appropriation of Hauerwasian (and also Yoderian) understanding of the kingdom of God and an exceptionally beautiful development of the theme. According to Revelation 21, Wannenwetsch contends, the New City is ‘marked by the “presence of the absence” of dominant features of earthly political rule such as separatism, self-preservation, and civil religion’ (p. 172). It captures the heart of Hauerwas' lifelong work, striving to do the job of a ‘Christian teacher’ following Jesus, who according to Huebner has been ‘motivated . . . above all . . . to teach and train disciples – to have them imagine a world in which God was the principal actor and into which they were invited’ (p. 301). Indeed, it is a book honouring a happy Christian man who works as hard as a bricklayer to build the kingdom of God which shines bright with the friendship with God and with one another.
