A collaboration by six anthropologists, one psychiatrist, and one anthropologist-psychiatrist, this volume delves into the moral and emotional lives of the Chinese. Departing from the predominant economic and political paradigms that have been used to analyze today's China, the authors deploy the moral and psychological framework to illustrate the complexities of remaking subjectivity in the new moral context created by rapid social and economic transformation.
The new moral individual, according to the volume, both produces and is produced by the new moral context since the 1980s, the process that epitomizes China's rapid transition to an increasingly individualized society (p. 14). As the volume contends, the new moral context emerged in consonance with the market reform. Decollectivization, privatization, and marketization of institutions—including education, medical care, and housing—created a new “enterprising and desiring” personhood by imposing new responsibilities on an individual to compete in the market economy and pursue wealth, happiness, and self-expression.
Both the introduction and Yunxiang Yan's chapter delineate in detail the transformation of the self from the past to the present. As illustrated, the past self was embedded and ensconced in family networks, social relations, and political control. This past self with an emphasis on collective identity and self-sacrifice was transformed into a new self with an emphasis on individuality and rights. This new self emerged “outside of the caste-like structure of socialist hierarchy” in the post-Mao era (p. 3), seeking to maximize self-interest and fulfill material, sexual, and emotional desires.
Central to this new subjectivity, as the volume demonstrates, is a divided self. The new self is divided by “past versus present” (p. 5). The past memory of painful experiences and untold suffering during the Cultural Revolution continues to live in the moral consciousness of the new self, posing a challenge to the new self to negotiate between the present enjoyment of prosperity and opportunities and the [in]expression of grudges and rancor of the past.
The new self is also divided by “moral versus immoral” (p. 5). Sing Lee's, Yunxiang Yan's, and Jun Jing's chapters reveal that the competing and conflicting values between individualistic interests and collective benefits have given rise to two polarized behaviors of altruistic and immoral acts. Sing Lee's chapter encapsulates the ways in which Chinese psychiatrists, caught between professional ethics and pursuit of self-interests, often succumb to economic profit and prescribe high-cost new drugs to patients. Such unethical acts, as convincingly argued by anthropologists Yan and Jing, coexist with a new trend of philanthropy and charity work. Yan demonstrates that, while some celebrities engage in altruistic behavior for the benefit of the poor, others' pursuits of economic profit lead to immoral conduct such as production and distribution of fake and poisonous food that severely endangers people's health. Jing's chapter about the collection of blood also demonstrates that altruistic conduct for the social good coalesce with selfish behavior for individual interests in today's China.
Does this new divided self hold any political significance in China today? The volume affirms that this altered personhood promises to have a profound impact on the political process and governance of China today: “the changing subjectivity of Chinese … can be understood not just as a remaking of the moral world, but perhaps as a new political reality—a reality that encourages the development of individuals and that itself involves the reshaping of governance by this new emphasis on individuals. What the longer-term significance of this societal transformation will be … remains uncertain, and yet the possibility is now real that the political process as much as moral life will become something new and different, and perhaps already has become that, something more availing for human prospects” (pp. 30–31).
While desires of this new self cohere with loyalty to the party and the state, and while the new self is simultaneously nationalistic, patriotic, and adhering to authority (p. 9), one may wonder in what ways this new self, aligned with the interests of the party and the state, can bring real challenges to the political process and governance of China today.
This book is profound, unique, and innovative in its interdisciplinary approach and contributes to China studies by adding a novel and neglected dimension to our understanding of the moral and emotional lives of the Chinese people. This book should be welcomed by scholars who have an interest in morality, selfhood, emotion, modernity, and China studies.
