This volume had its origins in a conference organized with the Oxford Roman Economy Project entitled “Shifting fluvial landscapes in the Roman World: New directions in the study of ancient rivers,” held at All Souls College at the University of Oxford in June 2014. It contains 11 chapters, comprising an introduction by T. V. Franconi, 9 substantial contributions, and a brief summation by N. Purcell.
Considering the seemingly endless proliferation of groups of papers published in collections, proceedings, commentaries, and handbooks in recent years, it is worth pausing to reflect on what makes a good collection. And given that my perspective is reflected in this review, it is also worth informing the readers. I am of the opinion that not every group of related papers makes a good collection or a worthy volume. What most collections seem to be missing is integration. In my estimation, a collection of chapters based on conference papers succeeds or fails on a few critical points. First, the introduction needs to be substantial, to be aware of the limitations of the collection, but also to create or highlight connections between the contributions. Second, each of the chapters must make a unique and significant contribution. Third, they must be organized in a thoughtful way. Fourth, the individual chapters must be integrated: that is, written or edited to highlight the thematic or subject links. The papers need to reflect – ideally refer to – each other in ways that are meaningful. All of these components of structure and cross-referencing should be signposted by the editor in the introduction. But really the points should be found throughout the work, as the chapters should also contain cross-references to each other so that the volume is not just a collection of chapters linked by a broad subject, but actually creates (and I appreciate that this is trite) a whole that is greater than the parts. Ideally, readers should be drawn from chapter to chapter, not just reading about, for example, their region or time period of particular interest. So, with that explanation of expectations for a collected volume, it is time to turn to the volume at hand, considering the points above.
The organizer of the conference on which the volume is based, Tyler V. Franconi, took on the duties of writing the preface and introduction. The preface contains the classic quote of what the volume is about and the focus on “the social and environmental context of rivers in the Roman world” (6). F. further accurately defines the collection in the introduction as “a handful of case-studies from the Roman world … [with] no claims to geographic or thematic completeness” (17). While this is true, it does underplay the range of case studies on river landscapes, which include two chapters on the Rhône and single chapters on the Rhine, Tiber, Nile, and Orontes, along with two harbor chapters and one on a variety of rivers and wadis in North Africa.Footnote 1 The introduction does the heavy lifting needed to create an integrated volume from these individual papers. It ties them together with emphasis on two significant themes: Roman impact on landscape and rivers, and rivers as agents in Roman history. It also provides needed background, which allows the chapters to stay focused without lengthy (and no doubt repetitive) introductory sections. The introduction does more than that, however. It serves to contextualize the chapters that follow in the study of rivers, and not just in the Roman world but broadly geographically and chronologically, including parallel examples from as late as World War II. It is a superb introduction to the study of fluvial landscapes and a thorough one, as the 106 items in its bibliography attest.
Turning our attention to the core of the volume, Chapters 2–10, the organization of papers is both geographical and chronological, moving from the western Roman world to the east and from the 1st c. BCE to the medieval period in Egypt. As will be familiar to those who regularly read reviews of collected works, it will be impossible to address all of the chapters equally and thoroughly. Let us start with some general comments and then turn to some specifics about individual contributions. Each of the individual chapters is excellent, well researched, well written, and well edited. All would certainly be published in a peer-reviewed journal (my personal metric for considering chapters in collected volumes). What is more impressive is that each also conforms to the stated themes of social and environmental context of rivers and their landscapes. Even the chapters on harbors are primarily concerned with sedimentation and geomorphological studies, and so fall within the themes of the volume. Perhaps the biggest outlier is also the shortest contribution. That is Chapter 2, “Watery perspectives: A Roman view on rivers” by B. Campbell. This is in many ways a continuation of the introduction and a précis of his earlier book.Footnote 2 As such it addresses more explicitly military and political themes than the other chapters, but serves as a useful reminder of their influence on the Roman impact on landscape and rivers.
Chapters 3 and 4 exemplify the sort of synergy that can be created in a collected volume where the papers engage each other. Chapter 3, “River adjustment to change: The Rhône in France during the Roman period” by J.-P. Bravard, is a broader work introducing and analyzing the hydrological sequence for the Rhône from its upper limits to Arles and the delta, based on a career of 40 years of geoarchaeology along the Rhône. It introduces the concept of an “incipient fluvial metamorphosis” (43), which seems a useful one for considering the change in meander and channel conditions along the river in the Roman period. Chapter 4, “Environmental risk in the lower Rhône valley: High water levels and floods,” by P. Leveau, focuses its attention on the hydrological and geomorphological history of a section of the river, including the plain and city of Arles. The geoarchaeology is excellent and follows the work in Bravard's chapter. Nevertheless, the chapter could have benefited from more direct consideration of the political aspects of the problem of flooding, as Campbell introduced in his chapter.Footnote 3 Writing about the failure to mitigate causes of the flooding of the Rhône at Arles, Leveau concludes, “The time between two floods does not appear to have exceeded 25 years, which was sufficient for their memory to be forgotten” (62). This seems most unlikely. Rather the interval did not encourage an urgent response by annually elected magistrates who we know were encouraged by their political system to shortsightedness in infrastructure projects, pushing the decision and expense of flood mitigation downstream, so to speak.Footnote 4
Chapter 6, “Pater Rhenus: The hydrological history of Rome's German frontier,” by T. V. Franconi, is similar to the chapters on the Rhône in its use of archaeological and geomorphological research to consider the facts and effects of fluvial changes along the Rhine from the 1st c. BCE to the 4th c. CE. Its separate contribution concerns the Rhine's role as a liminal boundary in the Roman world.
Chapter 5, “High chrono-stratigraphical resolution of the harbour sequence of Ostia: Palaeo-depth of the basin, ship draught and dredging” by J.-P. Goiran, F. Salomon, C. Vittori, and H. Delile, and Chapter 7, “Geoarchaeology of ancient harbours in lagoonal contexts: an introduction” by C. Morhange, N. Marriner, G. Bony, and C. Flaux, both address harbors but in radically different ways. Chapter 5, like F.'s chapter, is work based on coring (although only two cores, contrasted with the 4,000 with which F. works), which presents its results aided by three of the best illustrations in the volume: figures 5, 6, and 8 in the chapter. These demonstrate the power of superior visuals (and the selective application of color) in increasing reader comprehension. The rather generic title of Chapter 7 disguises its main contribution, which is to create a typology of lagoonal harbor contexts, applicable across the Roman world.
In the last three chapters agriculture is foregrounded. Chapter 8, “Rivers, wadis and climate in North Africa: Torrents and drought,” by A. Wilson, Chapter 9, “Gift of the Orontes: Fluvial landscapes of northwest Syria in Late Antiquity,” by M. Whiting, and Chapter 10, “360 days of summer: Experiencing the fluvial in Egypt's Fayyum,” by B. Haug, work well together as they more explicitly discuss the effect of fluvial landscapes and canal systems on agriculture as well as transport and other topics common to many of the chapters. Placing them together strengthened each of them and their conclusions. Haug also provides an exceptional statement of context at the start of his chapter, which shows awareness of the other papers in the volume, their methodologies, and the significant themes they address. It is the type of signposting that serves to turn a set of individual chapters into a coherent collection. That signposting is almost completely absent in the short conclusion by Purcell, a summation role he has been given before.Footnote 5 He does reference Chapters 3 and 4, but the majority of his remarks are more general and contextualizing, although unreservedly positive about the contributions of these papers. And that we agree on.
A final word about production. As one has come to expect from JRA supplements, the volume production standards are high. With the exception of fig. 11 in Chapter 4, which contains two number 4s and no number 3 in the image (despite it being listed in the caption), I found no mistakes or errors that negatively affected my understanding of the papers – not even a Greek accent mark out of place.
