No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 16 June 2005
Global Prescriptions: Gendering Health and Human Rights. By Rosalind Pollack Petchesky. New York: Zed Books, 2003. 320p. $75.00 cloth, $25.00 paper.
In her book, Rosalind Petchesky sets herself the ambitious task of analyzing the development and impact of transnational movements for women's health in the last two decades of the twentieth century. She examines them not only in relation to the changing concepts of human rights and major United Nations conferences, but within the broader political and economic context of the spread of neoliberalism, religious fundamentalisms, the HIV/AIDS pandemic, and militarism. Originally commissioned by the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development for a five-year review of the World Summit for Social Development, the book assumes a fair degree of sophistication in regard to transnational politics although the text is punctuated by short boxes that give readers a useful introduction to key policy developments.
In her book, Rosalind Petchesky sets herself the ambitious task of analyzing the development and impact of transnational movements for women's health in the last two decades of the twentieth century. She examines them not only in relation to the changing concepts of human rights and major United Nations conferences, but within the broader political and economic context of the spread of neoliberalism, religious fundamentalisms, the HIV/AIDS pandemic, and militarism. Originally commissioned by the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development for a five-year review of the World Summit for Social Development, the book assumes a fair degree of sophistication in regard to transnational politics although the text is punctuated by short boxes that give readers a useful introduction to key policy developments.
The first two chapters of Global Prescriptions focus on the rise of transnational women's health movements and the pros and cons of their participation in UN conferences, especially the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) held in Cairo in 1994. Petchesky has long been active in reproductive rights issues and has participated in feminist organizing around the ICPD. Thus, in a sense she writes as a “participant observer,” though there is little personal narrative in the text. She views the UN conferences on environment (Rio de Janeiro 1992), human rights (Vienna 1993), population (Cairo 1994), social development (Copenhagen 1995), and women (Beijing 1995) as important sites of discursive struggle as a growing coalition of women's groups, from both the North and South, came together to push for an inclusive agenda of women's rights and empowerment. The models of organizing they developed, from preconference networking to an active Women's Caucus at the conferences for lobbying governments and international agencies, proved highly successful in terms of increasing women's visibility, expanding the concept of human rights, getting new language into policy documents, and in many countries serving as an opportunity for diverse groups to come together to put pressure on the state.
Of all the conferences, the 1994 ICPD in Cairo marked the most notable “paradigm shift” as women's health groups made an alliance with the population and family planning establishment to fight off fundamentalist opposition to birth control, abortion, and sexuality education. The result was the “Cairo consensus,” in which reproductive health programs and women's empowerment were put forward as a much better means for addressing population growth than the narrow, top-down, and often coercive population control programs of the past. In feminist circles, the process of producing the consensus was far from consensual, however. The period was marked by intense and sometimes bitter struggle and debate. In particular, many women's groups were concerned that the Cairo consensus did not challenge the dominant neoliberal model of development with its emphasis on privatization of health and other social services and its negative impact on women's livelihoods.
Petchesky acknowledges these struggles and notes in retrospect how the Women's Caucus at Cairo probably should have paid more attention to the structural and macroeconomic conditions necessary for the realization of women's reproductive and sexual rights. However, she argues that “this shortsightedness reflects not so much a willful political choice or the dominance of Northern women's NGOs as deeper structural and cultural weaknesses of women's movements across the globe.” She argues that feminist activists have to some extent “internalized dominant gender norms so that macroeconomic issues (trade, finance and resource allocations), like military and security issues, are perceived as intrinsically masculine and insular terrain” (pp. 50–51).
In actuality, however, many women's groups involved in the Cairo process did have a strong and well-developed analysis of these “masculine” terrains (e.g., see Jael Silliman and Ynestra King, eds., Dangerous Intersections, 1999). And it was precisely this analysis that led them to question the strategic decision of the Women's Caucus leadership not to bargain more strongly on economic issues when negotiating the Cairo consensus. Although Petchesky is right in saying that this decision was not a simple outcome of the domination of Northern feminists and foundations over Southern activists, I would argue (as someone who also participated in the Cairo process) that no understanding of that process is complete without examining the hierarchies in transnational women's organizing, the role of strategic philanthropy in gatekeeping and amplifying certain voices over others, and the collaboration between U.S. foundations, such as the Pew Charitable Trusts, and the State Department and national security community around Cairo. The material politics of the Cairo process are integrally related to the strategic decision to leave neoliberalism out of the discussion. The discursive terrain of UN conferences is not a level playing field, even in feminist politics.
In the next two chapters, Petchesky moves away from the heady days of the UN conferences where another world seemed possible in order to examine the challenges and opportunities facing activists working on access to essential medicines to treat HIV/AIDS and on health sector reform. In both cases, the human right to health is on “a collision course with global capitalism.” These chapters offer a detailed, nuanced overview of the current political economy of health care and the problematic market-based values that underlie it. The chapter on HIV/AIDS contains case studies of movements in South Africa and Brazil to secure access to essential drugs against powerful pharmaceutical interests. The author broadens her focus here beyond women's organizing, although she continues to keep gender issues at center stage.
The penultimate chapter returns to women's movements, examining the tricky position in which women's health nongovernmental organizations now find themselves as they navigate between “the hegemonic market and the moribund welfare state” (p. 223). In many countries, as public health services decline, women's NGOs have been pressed into duty as direct service providers, often draining their energy from political advocacy work and placing them in problematic and unequal partnerships with governments and international agencies. With examples drawn from many different countries, Petchesky shows that there are no easy answers and that strategies necessarily vary according to context. Referring again to Brazil and South Africa, she argues that both countries “suggest models in which active civil society organizations and socially committed state institutions can interact to create strong systems of accountability even where some services are provided by NGOs or the private sector” (p. 243).
Against the dark backdrop of U.S. hegemony and militarism, Petchesky remains cautiously optimistic about the possibilities of democratic global governance and the role of transnational women's movements in achieving that goal. Her final chapter summarizes some of the key global prescriptions for protecting and advancing human health and well-being.