The subtitle “Desire over Protest” neatly captures Michael S. D. Hooper's overall argument about the work of Tennessee Williams: his characters privilege desire over social action. Through meticulously researched readings of Williams's plays, short stories, novels, poems, and essays—some famous, some forgotten—Hooper argues that first and foremost Williams was interested in the sexual histories, exploits, and desires of his characters rather than in politics in any kind of social sense. At its most basic, Hooper's project is reactionary. It positions itself against a variety of scholars who have turned to Williams's oeuvre in an attempt to redefine his politics concerning gender, race, class, and sexuality. Such scholarship, Hooper suggests, overly politicizes Williams and skews our understanding of the works, their thematic utterances, and their changing meaning over the course of the forty or so years of their production. Although Hooper's argument usefully returns us to discussing Williams's texts as texts, it rests on a definition of politics that would benefit from stronger definition.
The book is organized into four chapters, the first being an account of Williams's relationship with social politics and the potentially political function of his writings. The following three chapters are divided along the lines of identity that many scholars consider as the ground for Williams's politics: male homosexuality, race/ethnicity, and gender. Hooper's readings illuminate how potentially politicized characters fail to articulate a connection to the various liberation movements that might have made them overtly political.
Chapter 2, “There Will Be Pity for the Wild,” convincingly makes the case for a double bind in Williams's representation of homosexuality. Williams's male homosexual characters—whether before or after the gay liberation of the late 1960s and 1970s—are not political, but his works are also not, as some have argued, expressions of internalized homophobia. Through readings of A Streetcar Named Desire, The Glass Menagerie, Suddenly Last Summer, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, and lesser-known works, such as the plays And Tell Sad Stories of the Death of Queens … , Small Craft Warnings, and Something Cloudy, Something Clear and short stories like “Hard Candy” and “One Arm,” Hooper ultimately proves that although Williams rendered his male homosexual characters as ambivalent, he succeeded in at least documenting the presence of homosexuality. Nevertheless, that sexuality is defined in terms of individual desires and despair rather than a potential for collective political action.
Chapter 3, “Desiring Others,” reads Orpheus Descending, Sweet Bird of Youth, The Night of the Iguana, and The Rose Tattoo alongside short stories like “Big Black: A Mississippi Idyll” and “Desire and the Black Masseur” as well as films such as Baby Doll to track the evolution of Williams's writing during the civil rights struggle. Hooper illuminates the thorny relationship between race/ethnicity and sexual desires in these works, and he suggests that “Williams redraws sexual boundaries pertaining to race and nationality, extracting a principle of pleasure and little beyond it” (171).
The final analytical chapter mostly foregoes readings of canonical plays, examining instead Williams's female characters in works like Summer and Smoke, The Eccentricities of a Nightingale, Period of Adjustment, Something Unspoken, and Clothes for a Summer Hotel. Hooper maintains that these works are interested less in social structure than in sexual desire and reaches the fascinating conclusion that “Williams's most provocative breach with convention is to make sexual desire a character in its own right, a state which draws characters together but then becomes an entity that replaces the desired object, a distillation of not having” (222).
Hooper's book succeeds in highlighting the enormously powerful role of individual sexual desire across a wide swath of Williams's works. However, I found myself repeatedly wondering if the distinctions among desire, sex, and politics are as clear as Hooper would like them to be. Hooper persuasively argues that Williams's characters never escape from their individual desires, but that does not necessarily make them apolitical. The most succinct definition of Williams's sexual politics is promising: “individuals negotiating positions of advantage from within sexual relations or the promise of them. Attitudes to sex provide governing principles, re-ordering and cutting across social hierarchies. Economies of desire superimpose themselves on the politics of supply and demand and then, self-reflexively, exhibit the very capitalist markers that determine other relations” (19). Where this definition points to the potentially political function of desire in and of itself, Hooper's general definition of “the political” conflicts: “Williams is not political, though, in the sense of advocating a party line, fomenting revolution or simply being an ideologue” (21). True, the characters in these plays, short stories, novels, and films are not part of social movements and do not engage in traditional political discourse or function as dogmatic mouthpieces for any kind of revolution, but can one not understand their devotion to the fulfillment of sexual desires as political? Can one not argue that while the characters are representations of highly individualistic sexual politics, the fulfillment of such desires exists within a collective structure? Perhaps in forgoing a traditional sense of progressive politics, Williams's characters exemplify a more radical sexual politics of desire. If the book wishes to counter such conclusions, it needs a more precise definition of what, exactly, politics, sexuality, and desire mean within the logic of Williams's oeuvre.
In short, meticulous research, attention to textual detail, encyclopedic knowledge of Williams's massive body of work, and engagement with extensive scholarship combine to impress the reader looking for a new-revisionist take on Williams's representation of desire-driven identities. The book will also appeal to readers interested in the lesser-known works. Scholars of sex, race, and gender, however, will undoubtedly find much material for continued debate.
