As the world's leading receiver nation of immigrants, the United States has remained ambivalent at best and openly hostile at worst to its newcomers for all of its history. One of the most vocal of the early nativists was Benjamin Franklin. He opposed the importation of ‘blacks and tawneys’ because they undermined the more ‘lovely whites and reds’. At the same time, he fretted about the growing German population of Pennsylvania ‘who will never adopt our language or customs any more than they can acquire our complexion’ (Jon Gjerde, Major Problems in American Immigration and Ethnic History, Boston, 1998, pp. 72–3). These feelings expressed by one of the most beloved founding fathers resound through the continuing national debate regarding Mexican immigration to the United States.
This book is composed of the papers delivered at a conference of the National Bureau of Economic Research held in Cambridge, Massachusetts, in February 2005. On the whole, they represent a careful and scholarly effort to address the thorny issue of Mexican immigration, both legal and illegal. The findings have important implications for both US and Mexican policy making. However, this volume is clearly not suitable for the non-specialist. It is heavily laden with statistical analysis that is highly useful for demographers and immigration specialists, but would prove to be slow going for many undergraduates and the marginally informed public.
The book is composed of nine essays that deal with such key issues as assimilation of Mexican migrants into US society, self-employment and self selection for immigration by Mexicans in their home country, labour supply, earnings in Mexico and diffusion of Mexican immigrants throughout the United States during the 1990s. These are all critical issues in the immigration debate, but there is significant redundancy in the essays selected for this volume.
George J. Borjas establishes the parameters of the discussion of Mexican immigration to the United States by emphasising the dramatic changes that have occurred over the past twenty years. By 2003, 10.2 million Mexicans, the equivalent of nine per cent of the current Mexican population, have immigrated to the United States. Mexican immigrants comprise nearly thirty per cent of the foreign born population of the US at this time. About four of every one hundred residents of the USA are now of Mexican heritage. This surge in numbers since the 1990s has, of course, stirred the typical nativist feelings that have been evident in the USA since its beginnings. Borjas synthesises these feelings into these key issues; how will low-skilled Mexican immigrants influence the economic status of low-skilled US citizens, particularly their wage scale? Will Mexican immigrants assimilate more slowly than previous immigrant groups because of their sizeable numbers and large immigrant enclaves? And will this slow rate of assimilation lead to the creation of another underclass with all its attendant problems of poverty, crime and social dependency?
Interestingly, in their paper on labour migration from rural Mexico, Richter, Taylor and Yúnez-Naude can find only a minimal statistical link between the abolition of price supports for Mexican farmers after the establishment of NAFTA in the mid 1990s and the upsurge in immigration to the USA during that decade. Much has been written about the ‘collapse’ of Mexican agriculture during the 1990s, especially among subsistence farmers in Mexico's poorest southern states. The influx of US grains, particularly corn, into Mexico from heavily subsided US agriculture has clearly been a heavy burden for the small Mexican farmer to bear. David Card and Ethan G. Lewis present an excellent discussion of the diffusion of the five million Mexican who entered the USA in the 1990s. It is not clear from what parts of Mexico these migrants journeyed. As residents of the Northwest, Midwest, South and Mid Atlantic states can attest, the 1990s was the decade of the arrival of Mexican migrants in their home towns. The traditional Mexican enclaves in the Southwest and California are still welcoming substantial numbers of immigrants, but new immigrant networks were established in Denver, Atlanta, Raleigh-Durham, Charlotte and Portland, the cities where the highest rate of immigrant growth occurred. The authors note that, as might be expected, the new immigrants to these cities have low levels of education and work skills. They suggest that varying levels of employment opportunities explain the diffusion of Mexican immigration in the 1990s. What is not explored is the dynamics of chain migration in these new immigrant cities.
An impressive essay by Edwin P. Lazear addresses the question of Mexican assimilation in US society in a very direct way. He notes that 80% of all non-Mexican immigrants are fluent in English, but the figure for Mexicans is just 49%. The average yearly wages of Mexican immigrants are in the order of $12,000, in contrast with an average of $21,000 for non Mexican immigrants. Since US immigration policy that was reformed in the mid 1980s to favour family immigration and because Mexicans had established so many family immigrant networks in the USA before the 1990s, their networks became the vehicle for many poorly educated Mexicans to establish a new life. Given Mexico's proximity to the USA, the large Mexican population exaggerated this effect in the 1990s and beyond. There is evidence that large immigrant enclaves in the USA had impeded assimilation even through third and fourth generation Mexicans.
Living and working in Spanish-speaking communities does not differ fundamentally from the social patterns followed by German, Dutch, Italian and Polish immigrants in earlier US history. German is still spoken in the immigrant communities of west Texas after many generations. The difference is that these communities have been bi-lingual for far more than a century.
This is a useful book, but it could have been more helpful. An essay explaining the historical context of Mexican immigration from at least the early twentieth century to destinations such as the steel mills of south Chicago, or the Bracero movement during World War II, would have added an important context for these essays. There is little discussion of the very important issue of immigrant remittances to Mexico, which now total many billions of dollars per year. On the whole, however, this book will inform those scholars who are seeking to bring balance and empirical evidence to this highly emotional subject.
