Amidst a great deal of recent scholarship on the political thought of James Madison, Colleen Sheehan adds The Mind of James Madison: The Legacy of Classical Republicanism. Although much of the recent scholarship, such as George Thomas's The Madisonian Constitution, Greg Weiner's Madison's Metronome, and Gary Rosen's American Compact, had already gone far toward emphasizing Madison's political thought, these books still considered Madison's thought primarily in relation to his statesmanship. That is, most of the scholarship on James Madison has primarily considered him as a statesman who, because he was in the midst of a historic founding of a constitutional republic, became a political theorist. Sheehan's book breaks new ground in the study of Madison's political thought because she is one of the first to write about Madison primarily from the perspective of political theory in and of itself. She places Madison into a conversation with the greatest political theorists like Plato, Aristotle, and Rousseau.
In solving the practical problem of creating a stable constitutional republic, Sheehan proposes that Madison also solved a theoretical problem that had always dogged republican theorists. Having worked through the ideas of Aristotle and others, Madison “emerged with a new vision and fresh hope for republicanism.” Where republics of the past were either too small and weak to maintain themselves against internal and external foes or too large to maintain themselves as republics, Madison thought technological progress had “made possible the coincidence between republican liberty and the power of empire” (24). According to Sheehan, this had become possible because the “new age of communication … made possible the achievement of a deliberative public opinion in republican government” (85). The formation of a reasonable public opinion constitutes the solution to the endemic difficulties of republican government insofar as republics of the past tended to be unreasonable and susceptible to factions with interests averse to the common good. Although the scholarship has long accepted the premise that Madison proposes that the extended republic solves this problem by diversifying the number and thus diluting the power of factions, Sheehan also suggests that, for Madison, the extended republic finally made a deliberate republican public opinion possible. She has suggested in other work that the formation of a constitutional public opinion is a critical feature of Madison's political thought. This book now suggests that the means of communication made necessary by an extended republic makes the formation of a constitutional public opinion much more likely.
Sheehan's work emerges as a significant advance over the current scholarship on Madison. She should first be applauded for her willingness to take Madison seriously as a political theorist in his own right, apart from his statesmanship. Although I would suggest that political theory could and should learn a great deal by taking seriously a statesman-turned-theorist like Madison, we also need to appreciate the purely theoretical components of Madison's thought. Madison's unfinished Notes on Government exemplifies his theoretical conception of republican government and its solution. Sheehan takes her bearings primarily from this work, which is included in an appendix in the book. She argues that this work shows both Madison's deep comprehension of the long tradition of republican theory and his improvements on that theory.
Sheehan's argument is both compelling and provocative. No one has yet gone so far in treating Madison as a crucial voice in the long tradition of political thought. Prior scholarship had tended to treat Madison as derivative in one form or another; whether it be from Montesquieu, Hume, Locke, Aristotle, or some combination of all of them, the extant literature tends not to treat Madison's thought as having an independent standing. Or, to the extent that Madison's thought is investigated independently, as it is in the aforementioned recent work, it is examined mostly from the perspective of what light it shines on the American constitutional regime. His thought becomes part of an independent conversation within American political thought rather than a part of a much longer tradition. This is to say that Sheehan's book legitimately breaks entirely new ground, opening up a new vista of possibilities for all of those who study Madison and, more generally, for all scholars of the American founding. Sheehan turns the conversation around from an introspective examination of the meaning of Madison and the founding of which he was an integral part to a broader examination as to what the American possibility reveals about the entire republican tradition. In contrast to the pessimists who preceded him, Sheehan's Madison thought the American possibility had solved the vexing problems that dogged all republics. He aspired to become the thinker who used this possibility to cast permanent light on the theory of republicanism.
As strong as Sheehan's argument is because of its deep respect for Madison and his theoretical ambitions, it would have been much stronger if she had considered the question from the opposite angle. If Madison learned from and used the American experience to speak to republican theory, then he has done what very few theorists prior to him have: he has learned from practical political experience something of permanent theoretical value. Sheehan is so interested in taking Madison seriously as a theorist that she fails to show that his solution was predicated on the actual possibility of an extended republic in the United States. In the course of trying to find a practical solution to the endemic problems faced by the states individually and by the Articles of Confederation, Madison conceived of the extended republic, its mode of communication, and the correspondingly reasonable public opinion it made possible. Without those practical problems, it is not at all clear that Madison would have happened on this theoretical solution. Sheehan missed an opportunity to enrich the Madison-as-theorist argument even more by proposing that he actually might have been a better theorist because he was also a statesman.
Examining this relationship would also have allowed her at least to discuss what amounts to a real weakness in her argument. Madison's solution to the republican problem is so historically and geographically conditioned that it is hard to see why the argument does not amount to: “a government can achieve true and lasting republicanism if it happens to be lucky enough to have been the United States.” How can Madison have “solved” this vexing question if his solution is unique and historically conditioned? Although Sheehan might be able to answer this question, her book sometimes seems almost naive and myopic insofar as she never even raises it as a problem. A chapter-length examination of the relationship between Madison's theoretical achievements and the actual political experience in which they occurred would have significantly improved the argument of this otherwise excellent book.
