Bang's book on the Roman Bazaar is a refreshing comparative study of the Roman economy. He rightly chose another tributary empire, the Mughal Empire, as a case for comparison. There may be chronological as well as geographical differences between the two states. However, abundant similarities in their socio-political background, their agrarian structures, the development of their economies and their centralized imperial fiscal policies make them perfect candidates for a direct comparison. B. managed to find ample common ground on top of which he built his elaborate economic theoretical structure. His theory flexibly avoids (not evades) the primitivist-modernist debate, which dominates all discussions on Western ancient economies since the 1970s. As early as the first chapter, B. goes far beyond Finley's substantivist perspective or Rostovtzef's capitalist ideas. He claims that his comparison with an Oriental pre-industrial empire allows him to explore further the issues at hand from an atypical non-eurocentric, non-colonialist viewpoint. The advantages of such an approach are very useful to the historian, even if many researchers still react negatively to the prospect. In the following chapters the comparison highlights the extent of the integration of the Roman economy, the political intervention of the central government, the power of commercial institutions and their limitations.
The main theme that cuts across all chapters of the book is the economic integration of the Roman Empire. B. starts in the second chapter with an assessment of the inter-regional trade and the system of taxation. He reconsiders their importance by comparison with the economic situation in the Mughal empire. Through the means of statistical analysis he comes to the conclusion that the state-controlled GDP in the Roman Empire must have been higher than in other pre-industrial societies. In effect, the emperor's financial intervention in the economy through the imposition of taxes and through his loose administration of the provinces may have caused a degree of economic integration, while the markets were unable to do so. The inability of traders to integrate the Roman world results from (a) the slow and dangerous transportation both across the land and the sea, (b) problems with the flow of information, (c) logistical difficulties (especially for the giant markets of large urban centres where supplies were in constant danger of a breakdown), (d) low transparency in transactions, and (e) the lack of ‘tangible and overt forms of organisational power to the supply and demand across locations into a more stable relationship’. All of these may have caused price fluctuations in the short term, even though in the long run there seem to have been significant coherent features, especially in the province of Egypt. In this instance B. may have stretched his evidence a little too far in order to prove his case. The same happens in the following section, where he seems to systematically under-estimate the role and capability of institutions — such as aristocratic households, the imperial estate, imperial coinage and Roman law — to integrate the markets. At least in these cases the author acknowledges the existence of a patchy integration, despite the strong local variations. Along the same lines, he does not believe that the Pax Romana was capable of improving significantly the conditions of trade. Even the imposition of customs across the provinces, which offer protection against brigands and pirates, maintain a level of social order and allow the inter-city movement of people and goods, seem to have been undermined by the abuse of power that state officials, and in effect the state itself, exhibited. This ‘parasitical fiscalism’ seems to have created a very strong black economy that has not been studied here but may be an excellent sequel to this book, if we wish to understand fully the extent of integration. The traders seem to have relied predominately, not on the state, but on the support of their households, local communities and a range of religious organizations. This personal network allowed merchants to work effectively within risky environments and lowered the transaction costs, at least for the insiders.
Despite my objections with regard to some of B.'s hypotheses, this is an excellent book that carries us one step forward in the Roman Economy Debate. It brings into the picture the invaluable method of comparative history and explores new ways of proving or disproving accepted theories. Scholars of the ancient economy, specifically, and students of the ancient world, in general, will find it not only invaluable in terms of scholarship but also an exciting and enjoyable book.
