Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:27:23.216Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Leveraging initial conditions memory for modelling Rayleigh–Taylor turbulence

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  14 April 2025

Sébastien Thévenin
Affiliation:
CEA, DAM, DIF, Arpajon F-91297, FranceUniversité Paris-Saclay, CEA, LMCE, Bruyères-e-Châtel F-91680, France
Benoît-Joseph Gréa*
Affiliation:
CEA, DAM, DIF, Arpajon F-91297, FranceUniversité Paris-Saclay, CEA, LMCE, Bruyères-e-Châtel F-91680, France
Gilles Kluth
Affiliation:
CEA, DAM, DIF, Arpajon F-91297, FranceUniversité Paris-Saclay, CEA, LMCE, Bruyères-e-Châtel F-91680, France
Balasubramanya T. Nadiga
Affiliation:
Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM, USA
*
Corresponding author: Benoît-Joseph Gréa, benoit-joseph.grea@cea.fr

Abstract

In this study, we tackle the challenge of inferring the initial conditions of a Rayleigh–Taylor mixing zone for modelling purposes by analysing zero-dimensional (0-D) turbulent quantities measured at an unspecified time. This approach assesses the extent to which 0-D observations retain the memory of the flow, evaluating their effectiveness in determining initial conditions and, consequently, in predicting the flow’s evolution. To this end, we generated a comprehensive dataset of direct numerical simulations, focusing on miscible fluids with low density contrasts. The initial interface deformations in these simulations are characterised by an annular spectrum parametrised by four non-dimensional numbers. To study the sensitivity of 0-D turbulent quantities to initial perturbation distributions, we developed a surrogate model using a physics-informed neural network (PINN). This model enables computation of the Sobol indices for the turbulent quantities, disentangling the effects of the initial parameters on the growth of the mixing layer. Within a Bayesian framework, we employ a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method to determine the posterior distributions of initial conditions and time, given various state variables. This analysis sheds light on inertial and diffusive trajectories, as well as the progressive loss of initial conditions memory during the transition to turbulence. Furthermore, it identifies which turbulent quantities serve as better predictors of Rayleigh–Taylor mixing zone dynamics by more effectively retaining the memory of the flow. By inferring initial conditions and forward propagating the maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimate, we propose a strategy for modelling the Rayleigh–Taylor transition to turbulence.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Initial perturbation of the interface with: (a) the Fourier power spectrum of the perturbation amplitude; (b) the phase of the Fourier modes; and (c) the perturbation amplitude in the physical space.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Distribution of the DNS in the four-dimensional initial conditions space $\{\mathsf {R},\mathsf {B},\mathsf {S},\mathsf {D}\}$. Every marker corresponds to a simulation and it is coloured according to its value of $\mathsf {R}$ (red corresponds to a high value and purple to a low one). The grey areas correspond to infeasible DNS due to constraints and precautions taken to ensure a good numerical resolution. The blue and yellow star symbols indicate the parameters for the diffusive and inertial simulations detailed in § 2.3. The rectangles delimit the domain where the global sensitivity analysis is performed.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Linear growth rate $\gamma ^{\star} _0$ and (b) stability diagram of the mean wavenumber $k_0$ for all simulations. Circular markers ($\circ$) correspond to simulations in which there is at least one unstable wavenumber, whereas downward triangles ($\triangledown$) correspond to simulations where all wavenumbers in the initial spectral band are stable. The symbol colour is related to the diffusive thickness $\mathsf {D}$ (in panel a), or to the parameter $\mathsf {B}$ (in panel b) expressing if the simulation is narrow or large bandwidth. The grey region (in panel b) indicates the diffusive region where $\gamma ^{\star} _D \gt \gamma ^{\star} _0$. The two blue and yellow ${\star}$ symbols indicate the parameters for the diffusive and inertial simulations discussed in § 2.3. The rectangles define the hyper-cubic domain $\mathcal I$ where is performed the global sensitivity analysis presented in § 3.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Time evolution of the 0-D quantities $L$, $\dot L$, $\alpha ,$$\mathcal K$, $\varepsilon$, the turbulent Reynolds number $Re_T$, $\Theta$, $\varepsilon _{cc}$ and $\sin ^2 \Gamma$ evaluated for all the RT DNS. The trajectories are coloured as a function of the initial Reynolds number $\mathsf {R}$. The dashed curves evaluate the reconstruction of $\dot L ^{\star}$ using $-12 \mathcal F^{\star}$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a) Two-dimensional slices at different times of the concentration field $C$ extracted from a DNS corresponding to an inertial configuration with $\mathsf {R}=12.5$, $\mathsf {B}=0.14$, $\mathsf {S}=3.0$ and $\mathsf {D}=3.0$. (c) Same as in panel (a) but for a diffusive case with $\mathsf {R}=2.35$, $\mathsf {B}=0.14$, $\mathsf {S}=3.0$ and $\mathsf {D}=3.0$. (b) Time evolution of the 0-D quantities for the inertial and diffusive trajectories. The star symbols indicate the times of the 2-D concentration slices presented in the figure. The end of the simulations corresponds to the stop criterion detailed in § 2.3. The dashed curves evaluate the reconstruction of $\dot L ^{\star}$ using $-12 \mathcal F^{\star}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Renormalised velocity and scalar spectra for the inertial and diffusive trajectories corresponding to figure 5 and for times $t^{\star} \in \{0;12;23;36;75;109\}$ (same colours). Note that at $t^{\star} =0$, the velocity spectra is zero as we initially consider a pure interface perturbation.

Figure 6

Figure 7.(a) Relation between $\alpha$ and $\Theta$ and (b) verification of (2.10) from our DNS database. The various DNS trajectories (dotted lines) are coloured as a function of the initial Reynolds parameter $\mathsf R$ as in figure 4.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Depiction of the physics-informed neural network as a surrogate for modelling the DNS’s 0-D quantities. The total loss consists of a data-driven component, $\mathcal J _{{Data}}$, aiming to minimise the discrepancy between the neural network and DNS outputs, and a physics-informed component, $\mathcal J_{{PI}}$, formulated via automatic differentiation and assessed at new collocation points. This approach enhances the conservation of kinetic energy and scalar variance balances, enforces a constraint on $\alpha$, ensures $\dot L^{\star}$ remains positive and upholds the consistency of $L_0 ^{\star}$.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Relative error of the surrogate model’s outputs, calculated at various times across the 73 test DNS in the dataset, is displayed in a boxplot format. Due to many simulations not reaching longer durations, the number of simulations available to evaluate the error diminishes over time, as indicated in the figure.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Evolution and dispersion of the 0-D trajectories $q (t^{\star} ;\mathsf I \in \mathcal I)$ with initial conditions following the joint prior distribution in the extended domain $\mathcal I$. The mean trajectories $E[q]$ are represented by the plain line and the dashed line is the trajectory corresponding to the mean of the initial conditions $q (t^{\star} ;E[\mathsf I])$. The shaded areas indicate the zones delimited by $\pm \sqrt {V[q]}$ or the $95 \,\%$ confidence interval.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Evolution of the variances for the 0-D trajectories, $V[q(t^{\star} ;\mathsf I \in \mathcal I)]$, with initial conditions sampled with the prior distribution in the extended domain $\mathcal I$. The first-order Sobol indices $s_i^q$ are computed to disentangle the initial condition effects. Their respective contributions are indicated by the coloured areas of width $s_i^q V[q(t^{\star} ;\mathsf I)]$ in the figure.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Probability density functions (p.d.f.s) for $\alpha _\infty$ and $t_\infty ^{\star}$ using the surrogate model, with initial conditions $\mathcal {I}$ sampled in the extended domain (3.1). The mean and the variance are indicated in the legend. The first-order Sobol indices $s_i^{t_\infty ^{\star} }$ are also plotted for $t_\infty ^{\star}$. Both the standard deviation $\mathrm{Std}$ of the p.d.f.s and the surrogate error $\epsilon _{NN}$ are indicated in the figure.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Time evolution of $V[L^{\star} ]$, evaluated using the neural network surrogate model with initial conditions sampled within the extended domain $\mathcal {I}$ (solid line). The variance, reconstructed from the buoyancy-drag (BD) solution (3.3), appears as dashed lines, further broken down into contributions from variations in $\alpha _\infty$ and $t_\infty$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Values of $\alpha _\infty$ and $t^{\star} _\infty$ sampled using a log uniform distribution of the initial parameters $\mathcal I$. The symbols associated with the trajectories are coloured by the steepness $\mathsf {S}$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Conditional and unconditional probability density functions for (a) $\alpha _\infty$ and (b) $t^{\star} _\infty$ given $L^{\star} _0$. The initial conditions $\mathcal I$ are sampled using the joint prior distribution. The plain lines show the evolutions of $E[\alpha _\infty |L_0^{\star} ]$ and $E[t^{\star} _\infty |L_0^{\star} ]$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Posterior distributions $p(i,t^{\star} | \mathsf Q_2)$ projected on the 2-D planes $ (t^{\star} , i)$ (with $i \in \{\mathsf R, \mathsf B ,\mathsf S,\mathsf D \}$) and sampled using the MCMC algorithm described in § 4.1. The three observations $\mathsf Q_2$ corresponding to the buoyancy-drag state vector are taken along (a) the inertial and (b) the diffusive RT trajectories introduced in figure 5 (marked by the star symbols). The plain curves indicate the DNS trajectories and the dashed curve the corresponding neural network surrogate model.

Figure 16

Figure 17.Posterior distributions $p(\mathsf i,t^{\star} | \mathsf Q_7)$ in the 2-D planes $ (t^{\star} , i)$ (with $i \in \{\mathsf R, \mathsf B ,\mathsf S,\mathsf D \}$) and sampled using the MCMC algorithm described in § 4.1. The eight observations $\mathsf Q_7$ corresponding to the full 0-D state vector are taken along (a) the inertial and (b) the diffusive RT trajectories introduced in figure 5 (marked by the star symbols). The plain curves indicate the DNS trajectories and the dashed curve the corresponding neural network surrogate model. The black dashed lines exhibited in the $(t^{\star} ,\mathsf R)$ planes come from the sensitivity analysis, (3.4).

Figure 17

Figure 18.(a,b) Trajectories represented in the $(L^{\star} ,\dot L^{\star} )$ plane and sampled from the joint posterior distributions $p(\mathsf I, t^{\star} | \mathsf Q_{2,7})$ projected (c,d) in the $(t^{\star} , \mathsf R)$ plane. The figure shows the inference for a diffusive trajectory, where the star symbols in the $(L^{\star} ,\dot L^{\star} )$ and $(t^{\star} , \mathsf R)$ planes correspond to the observation of (a,c) $\mathsf Q_2$ or (b,d) $\mathsf Q_7$.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Ability of the various state vectors $\mathsf Q$ to infer the initial conditions from the measure $\mathcal D(\mathsf Q)$. The plot illustrates the mean and standard deviations of $\mathcal D(\mathsf Q)$ at various times, evaluated from 400 points uniformly sampled across the initial condition and time domain.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Results of MAP models constructed from (5.1) with $\Delta t^{\star} =30$ and using various state vectors indicated in the columns. (a–d) Comparison of the MAP model to the true trajectory, which corresponds to the inertial trajectory in figure 5. The grey areas indicate the level of uncertainities of the MAP trajectories. (e–h) Inferred samples of Reynolds $\mathsf R$ and time $t^{\star}$ and the posterior distributions $p(\mathsf R, t^{\star} |\mathsf Q)$ at different instants of the MAP procedure.

Figure 20

Figure 21.Ability of the various MAP models derived from (5.1) with $\Delta t^{\star} =30$ to reconstruct the 0-D trajectories corresponding to the inertial case detailed in figure 5 (black plain line).

Figure 21

Figure 22.Evolution of the (ai) supervised and (b) unsupervised losses during the training of the physics-informed neural network.