Although now often thought of exclusively as a natural philosopher, Francis Bacon did not publish his first work of natural philosophy, The Advancement of Learning, until 1605, when he was aged forty-four. As Alan Stewart observes in his introduction to the latest volume of the Oxford edition of Bacon's works, a number of factors have converged in recent years to encourage new work on earlier parts of his life, when Bacon was an up-and-coming lawyer increasingly drawn to the circle surrounding Robert Devereux, the second Earl of Essex (p. xxvi). Now, in many cases for the first time, we have the opportunity to examine Bacon's written works produced during this time.
This volume contains twenty-three works, almost all of which reflect Bacon's political and legal activities in this period; only a handful of them have previously been published. Like previous contributions to the Oxford Francis Bacon, all are printed here in versions that adhere to the principles of modern editorial scholarship, including the preservation of original orthography and the provision of facing-page translations for works originally written in a language other than English (including, here, Law French). The level of scholarship on display is deeply impressive; not only has Stewart obviously spent a considerable amount of time in archive and library collections, but he has also provided remarkably detailed commentaries accompanying each work. This edition will be considered definitive until new witnesses are (as they inevitably will be) uncovered.
The volume will be of interest to scholars keen to examine Bacon's writings on some of the most pressing political issues of his day: the twin threats of Spain and factionalism (Letter of advice to the queen (1584–1585)), the Marprelate controversy (An aduertisement touching the controuersyes of the Church of England (1589)) and religious toleration (On the religious policies of the queen (c.1589). Those seeking to chart his movements in the tangled politics of the 1580s and 1590s will also benefit from scholarly editions of such works as Certaine obseruations vppon a libell (1593), in which Bacon comes to the defence of his uncle Lord Burghley; A true report of the detestable treason intended by Doctor Roderigo Lopez (1594), which can be read as a justification for the Earl of Essex's actions against the queen's doctor; and the First letter of advice to the earl of Essex (1596), which contains the futile, in retrospect, maxim, ‘wyn the Queene’ (p. 731). The book also features Bacon's engagements with some of the legal debates of the time, including the status of royal charters (A discourse vpon the commission of Bridewell (c.1587)) and advowsons (Reading on advowsons (1588)). The political and the legal should not, of course, be thought of as separate spheres; Stewart reminds us, for example, that the Argument in Chudleigh's case (1594) coincided with Bacon's furious lobbying for a senior legal position (p. 452). Similarly, Bacon's contributions to contemporary performance culture at the Inns of Court and at court should not be seen as removed from politics; the Orations at Graies Inne revells (1594–1595), for example, takes the form of speeches of advice to a prince, a format to which Bacon returned in Essex's device (1595).
For many historians of science, however, the most enticing aspect of the publication will be the temptation to identify the early signs – what Stewart suggests Bacon would have called the ‘seeds’ (p. xxviii) – of the later natural philosophy. This temptation is difficult to indulge in the case of many of these works, where Bacon's authorship is uncertain or should be seen within the context of the Essex literary stable. This has not, of course, previously stopped scholars seeing adumbrations of his later project for the reformation of learning in texts such as Tribuit, or Giuinge that which is Due (1591) or the Orations at Graies Inne revells. Newly intriguing, though, is the opportunity to juxtapose the descriptions of the ways in which knowledge should be gathered and managed in the Letter of advice to Fulke Greville (c.1589) with Bacon's own practice in his Promus of formularies and elegancies (1594–1595). Indeed, the most startling part of Stewart's introduction is his revelation of Bacon's early adoption of the lifelong habit of reworking the same material.
Over a thousand pages long, over £200, and with none of the most famous Bacon texts, this volume is unlikely to appeal to any but specialist Baconians; for these scholars, however, it will represent a monumental achievement. The only possible criticism is that the copy-editing does not always match the quality of the scholarship; in particular, some of the page and line numbers in the commentaries do not match the text. Alan Stewart's next task is to edit Volume 2, which will feature works written up to 1602. He has set himself and his colleagues on the Oxford Francis Bacon editorial team a high bar.
