With Metabolic Living, Harris Solomon offers a groundbreaking first monograph on diabetes in Asia. The book uses the metonym of “absorption,” by which Solomon means “the possibility for bodies, substances, and environments to mingle, draw attention to each other, and even shift definitional parameters in the process” (p. 5), to analyze how people with chronic diseases negotiate food and fat in Mumbai. Employing multiple methods, including participant-observation in a neighborhood community, clinic-based interviews with doctors and patients, and observation in the food production and sales sectors, Solomon produces a fascinating account of consumption and malady that reveals the complexity of metabolic “abnormality.” The volume consists of an introduction, five key chapters, and a conclusion, interspersed with five wonderfully written ethnographic interludes that address various aspects of eating, food production, and dieting in the city.
Solomon is principally concerned with what he refers to as “metabolic living,” or what it is like to live with metabolic concerns always at the back of one's mind, even when one may lack a firm grasp of their medical definitions or biological mechanisms. Here, Solomon intentionally shifts the focus away from discourses that medicalize obesity and diabetes, which often dominate even in anthropological studies of these topics. Instead, his study of metabolic living focuses on “actions of soaking in, working, and taking in stress” (p. 21) in individuals’ lived experiences, attempting to lay bare the specific materials and specific bodies that make up the larger phenomenon of metabolic illness in India (p. 22).
Indeed, the book shines in its ability to situate its protagonists within complex and unstable relational contexts. For instance, one of Solomon's key informants, Rose, lost both her parents and her brother to what she refers to as “diabetes pressure”—and although she had not been diagnosed, Solomon notes, she “suspected that she too had tinges of this disease that she couldn't see but could sense otherwise” (p. 50). For Rose, tenshun, a transliteration of the English word “tension” and a common vernacular expression for distress across Asia, was a key agent of this intergenerational diabetes death.
Solomon's choice of absorption as an analytic lens is fitting for a study of illness and food in South Asia, as it evokes the history of ethno-psychological scholarship on Indian conceptions of personhood that emphasize permeability and context-dependency.Footnote 1 Strikingly, however, Solomon never explicitly makes this connection, perhaps because (for good reason) scholars of South Asia have become sensitized to the Orientalist implications of the claim that Indians view the world in a fundamentally unique way. Nevertheless, a critical appraisal of the literature on Indian personhood and its relation (or lack thereof) to absorption would have signaled what I see as one of the book's key strengths—its status as a compelling new chapter in the scholarship on personhood and permeability in South Asia.
Metabolic Living has some additional drawbacks that center around its narrow focus. Given Solomon's fieldwork with Indian medical scholars and women as primary informants, the book is surprisingly thin in its engagement with the robust literature on gender and metabolic disorders written in, by, and about Indians. When Solomon does engage with these scholars, as in chapter 1, they generally appear as his research subjects or interviewees. This rather problematically situates Indian women and medical practitioners as the subject of the author's wisdom, rather than his intellectual interlocutors. This makes the book more inward-looking than it needs to be, which limits its ability to converse across disciplines and national boundaries. Given that it is part of a series about global health, this is a missed opportunity. Absorption has the potential to speak to food studies, urban planning, gender studies, and global health, and Solomon may rectify this with an accessible article that addresses its broader implications for allied fields.
Metabolic Living is the first ethnographic monograph on the diabetes epidemic in South Asia, and this alone marks it as an important contribution to the study of health and illness in the subcontinent. It also provides an evocative and complex picture of being a person with a metabolic illness in Mumbai. Yet, in focusing explicitly on complexity and instability, it at times generates additional confusion around what it means to be someone with a metabolic illness in India, rather than providing clarity to this nascent area of inquiry for anthropology and South Asian studies. Given the book's lack of an explicit connection to other literatures and its strong focus on complexity, it is likely most appropriate for graduate-level courses in medical anthropology, particularly for those who have some background in Asian studies. It may be less suitable for undergraduates or those outside of anthropology. Overall, however, Metabolic Living offers an important first step in a growing body of anthropological literature on chronic diseases in Asia.
