Eve Troutt Powell's Tell This in My Memory is a wonderful addition to the growing literature on enslavement in Middle Eastern societies during the Ottoman and post-Ottoman periods. The current cycle in the study of slavery in general boasts a comparative focus that brings into the discourse a serious attempt to examine and integrate into the debate enslavement in Islamic societies. Earlier cycles were mostly concerned with the Ancient world, then the U.S. Antebellum South, and more recently the broader Atlantic world, which includes the study of enslavement in Brazil and the Caribbean Islands. The present, comparative phase also devotes more attention to microhistorical studies that endeavor to recover voices of enslaved individuals; special interest in antislavery discourse and abolition in non-Western societies is also noticeable. (For a survey of recent contributions to the literature on enslavement in Ottoman and other Islamic societies, see Madeline C. Zilfi, Women and Slavery in the Late Ottoman Empire: The Design of Difference [New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010], 239–69; and Ehud R. Toledano, As If Silent and Absent: Bonds of Enslavement in the Islamic Middle East [New Haven, Conn., and London: Yale University Press, 2007], 38–47. For the current debate over antislavery and abolition in Islamic societies, see Ehud R. Toledano, “Abolition and Anti-Slavery in the Ottoman Empire: A Case to Answer?” in A Global History of Anti-Slavery Politics in the Nineteenth Century, ed. William Mulligan and Maurice Bric [Houndsmills, U.K.: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013], 117–36.) In many ways, Troutt Powell's book fits well within the current trend.
Tell This in My Memory consists of six case studies, bringing to life individuals whose stories were entangled, in one manner or another, with enslavement; as Troutt Powell shows, bondage affected not only their actual day-to-day existence, but also shaped their very being, their identity, their self-perception, and the way they viewed the world. The protagonists are people of high status who kept enslaved Africans and Circassians in their elite households or grew up in such households and were raised by enslaved persons, or people who had been enslaved and then manumitted and given a new life, which they shaped as best as they could. Each chapter is rich in detail and provides deep insights into the life stories of those individuals, but, in the path that microhistorical studies seek to follow, each case also tells us a great deal about the society in which it occurred. In fact, and regardless of the conceptual criticism leveled at microhistory as a method of research and writing (which I do not share)—for example, that the specific cases analyzed are not representative of broader realities—the author writes some of the finest narratives in this genre that one can find within the field of Middle East studies and beyond.
The author uses, from time to time, the metaphors of maps, passports, and journeys, which we can apply to her own work as well. She begins the book in a scholarly journey among the marginal people of the colonized Sudan, continues through the spaces that enslaved Africans inhabited in the urban centers of the Ottoman Empire, lands on the route maps charted by the enslaved and the enslavers on the eastern shores of the Mediterranean, and finally migrates with her subjects to Italy and Britain of the 20th century. The book thus begins with the lives of enslaved persons in the streets of Cairo as reported by cAli Mubarak in his Khitat, a classic compiled between 1886 and 1889. We then travel to the Sudan, where the memoirs of Babikr Bedri, a “slave-owning nationalist,” serve to illustrate the approach of a benevolent, caring man, who was unable to transcend the constraints of his enslaver culture and embrace an antislavery position. Salim C. Wilson, the next person Troutt Powell introduces us to, was an enslaved African man who had been rescued by a British missionary and taken to Britain, where he became an activist for abolition, a preacher for Christianity, and an expert lecturer about the African culture he had come from.
Next we meet two prominent women, leaders in their own, respective nationalist movements, who had grown up in households where slaves were present all the time, having a major role in raising them and forming their perception of enslavement. They were Huda Shacrawi and Halide Edip Adıvar. Their references to how slaves were integrated into Ottoman imperial and Ottoman–Egyptian urban elite households are essential for understanding these socioculturally complex institutions, in which enslaved Africans and Circassians lived and worked together. Then we move to two chapters that bring forth the stories of enslaved Africans who were transplanted from their homelands to the continent of Europe, much like the chapter on Salim Wilson. Both are connected to the impact of Catholic missionary work in the Sudan that saved enslaved persons from bondage and showcased them in Italy as conversion success stories, thus giving rise to native African missionaries. The first of these two chapters relates the story of a group of such individuals, with Father Daniel, who also advocated abolition and wrote about enslavement, as the leading figure. The last chapter in the book is about the famous Saint Bakhita, whose “life has been emblematic for Sudanese refugees for decades” (p. 5), as Troutt Powell correctly observes.
The author of Tell This in My Memory is an excellent social historian with rare sensitivities to the human aspect in her work. She is a superb reader of the complex texts, in Arabic and European languages, that form the evidence for her studies, an empathetic observer of the lives of the people she writes about, and a highly effective narrator who puts together an engaging account out of the experiences of the down-and-out in the societies of the Middle East and North Africa. Troutt Powell can certainly tell a human story in a warm and deeply engaged way, without ever losing sight of the scholarly literature in the fields relevant to her investigation, skillfully weaving the most current research into her work.
Troutt Powell always addresses her reader in the first-person, as if conversing with him/her, as if addressing his/her intellectual and moral being. This is highly effective because the topic she discusses in this book is sensitive, intimate, and painful, it touches on honor and shame, and it demands that the reader take a stand on a whole range of issues—enslavement, freedom from tyranny, exploitation, and abuse, as well as feel a broad spectrum of emotions from rage and frustration to the warmth of social interaction with family and community. The author knows how to invite her audience to a profound and reflective conversation about people, their joys, and their suffering; hence, readers of Tell This in My Memory cannot remain indifferent to the plight of the men and women who populate its pages.
All in all, this book is well worth reading and assigning to students of all levels. It is a fine example of how humanly engaged, good microhistory can and should be studied and written.
