Entering into its sixth decade, the field of country music studies is thriving. During its first fifty years, country music scholars eschewed methodological orthodoxy, instead developing ad hoc methodologies that have permitted scholars to reach a deep understanding of country music's significance as both a musical and a cultural practice. As a consequence, country music scholarship—as in much popular music scholarship generally—has been indelibly shaped by its engagement with the fields of American history, sociology, anthropology, folklore, cultural studies, ethnomusicology, gender studies, and, most recently, musicology and music analysis. The volumes reviewed here bear traces of this heterodoxy and, when read in conjunction with one another, work together to complicate our understanding of the genre, its place in the popular music landscape of the United States, and its role in the lives of the people who embrace these rich musical traditions.
First published in 1998, The Encyclopedia of Country Music was, at the time, a much-needed reference source. The decision by the Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum (CMHOF&M) staff to revisit this monumental resource only fifteen years after the publication of the first edition reveals the institution's commitment to providing their constituents with up-to-date and accurate information about key country recording artists, session musicians, industry executives, and stylistic trends. This constituency is not easy to write for, however, as it includes scholars, journalists, and industry insiders as well as the thousands of country music fans who pass through CMHOF&M's doors each year. Paul Kingsbury, who edited the first edition, is joined in the new edition by CMHOF&M historians John W. Rumble and Michael McCall. They have gathered more than 150 scholars and journalists to contribute entries on country music topics from a period “confined. . . almost exclusively to the years since 1922, when country performers first began broadcasting on the new medium of radio and made their first recordings” (xi). Moreover, twelve essays (ten of which were revised from the first edition) explore broad themes and topics, including the country music industry, the iconography of country music, and the social and cultural contexts within which the music is created and consumed. The second edition of the Encyclopedia also responds to the ceaselessly changing country music landscape, sunsetting entries on artists whose significance has diminished in the decade and a half since the first edition was published and replacing them with ninety entries on new subjects.
The first edition of the Encyclopedia was characterized by clear writing and a careful attention to the myriad ways that readers might make use of the text. The second edition maintains these traits, providing valuable information in concise, yet detailed, entries. Many of the entries are illustrated with publicity photographs, providing an astute reader the opportunity to glean a great deal about costuming and visual style (a topic taken up in Holly George-Warren's essay on the subject, as well). However, the inevitable space issues that arise when compiling a resource of this magnitude required the omission of discographical information and recommendations for further reading. Although Nolan Porterfield's excellent bibliographic essay provides a list of “sixty books toward a country music library” (300), this listing necessarily overlooks the many excellent article-length studies and liner notes that have contributed to our understanding of the genre. Helping to compensate for the lack of entry-specific data is the inclusion of several detailed appendices documenting sales records for country albums, various awards (including those made by the Country Music Association, Academy of Country Music, International Bluegrass Music Association, and the Recording Industry Association of America, among others), membership in several halls of fame, and information about radio stations and country market share.
Although The Encyclopedia of Country Music, 2nd edition, is the most comprehensive encyclopedic treatment of the genre to date, it is not without a few significant oversights. To begin, astute readers will note a decidedly Southern bias in the selection of representative country artists and a Nashville bias in the discussion of country music executives. Midwestern radio and recording artists popular during the barn dance era of the 1930s and 1940s certainly make their appearance, as do some of the iconic stars of California's Bakersfield Sound and Texas's western swing and progressive country scenes, but Nashville seems to be the primary focal point of country music after World War II, despite the presence of significant regional and local scenes throughout the United States. Such a focus might be expected, however, of a museum and research archive that has been closely connected to the Nashville music industry since its inception and that has leveraged those connections to develop strong collections on Nashville-based country music.Footnote 1 Moreover, the Encyclopedia's focus on country music in the United States overlooks the important place of country music in a variety of global contexts, including the United Kingdom, Australia, Canada, and Brazil.Footnote 2 Finally, and perhaps most egregiously, women fare poorly in The Encyclopedia of Country Music, 2nd ed., earning only 135 entries as individuals and garnering another thirty-two entries when included as members of mixed-gender ensembles. Despite the presence of two pioneering historians of women in country music, Mary Bufwack and Robert K. Oermann, on the contributor list, this omission reveals one of the ongoing problems facing country music scholars and country music culture in general: the continued marginalization of women's contributions to the genre.Footnote 3
The Hank Williams Reader, edited by historians Patrick Huber, Steve Goodson, and David M. Anderson, is reflective of some of the remarkable historiographical work that has been conducted in country music studies in recent years.Footnote 4 Anthologizing sixty-three sources dealing with the life, death, and legacy of the honky-tonk hero, The Hank Williams Reader is one of the first books to approach Williams as a historical figure, a creative musician, and an icon from a rigorous, scholarly perspective. Huber, Goodson, and Anderson left few stones unturned in their search for the most provocative and revealing Williams readings, initially creating a pile of “nearly two thousand writings” (8). From long-out-of-print fan publications to the liner notes of compact disc compilations, such sources provide an excellent overview of the singer-songwriter's complex life and his even more complicated legacy. Particularly noteworthy in this collection are court documents pertaining to the 1952 divorce of Hank and Audrey Williams, a case that would cast a long shadow on the Williams estate for decades following his untimely demise. The editors have also provided a series of remarkable eulogies, including a number of letters to the editor published in Nashville and Montgomery, Alabama, newspapers. But Huber, Goodson, and Anderson have not only included trade and popular press clippings and rare archival documents in The Hank Williams Reader; rather, they have also collected some of the most influential Hank Williams scholarship, including excerpts from Roger M. Williams's Sing a Sad Song: The Life of Hank Williams and Richard Leppert and George Lipsitz's landmark 1990 essay, “‘Everybody's Lonesome for Somebody’: Age, the Body and Experience in the Music of Hank Williams.”Footnote 5 On the merit of the sources anthologized in this volume alone, The Hank Williams Reader should be useful for anyone who studies popular music in the United States.
The book is organized in seven sections. It begins with writings published during Williams's lifetime, including artist profiles, discussions of post–World War II country music economics, and arrest reports documenting Williams's turbulent lifestyle. The remaining six sections follow his posthumous life, which, considering the brevity of his career, is when many of his greatest successes as a musician and a public figure have occurred. In their presentation of these readings, Huber, Goodson, and Anderson demonstrate that Williams has proven to be an exceptionally malleable figure, a mutability that tells us much more about the attitudes that have shaped posthumous interpretations of Williams's life and work than about Williams himself. The editors have identified several “significant. . . interpretations,” including “the ‘Organization Man,’ ‘Populist Poet,’ ‘Tragic Hero,’ ‘Model Family Man,’ ‘Tabloid Celebrity,’ ‘Ordinary Guy,’ ‘Rock ’n’ Roll Pioneer,’ ‘Original Outlaw,’ ‘Lay Preacher,’ and ‘American Icon’” (9). Each of the book's sections is preceded by a brief historiographical essay in which Huber, Goodson, and Anderson place its source readings into historical, cultural, and intellectual contexts, bringing a great deal of added value to sources already quite enlightening in their own right. In addition to these broad essays, brief annotative essays precede each of the sixty-three sources in The Hank Williams Reader, providing background information specific to each source and framing the work within the context of the author's published output and the historical circumstances within which the piece was written. It is here that the editors—who admittedly do little to correct factual errors in the original sources, especially after their initial appearance in the anthology (xi)—point to some of the inaccuracies and interpretive issues that are evident in each source. The editorial decision to place these corrections in the introductory essays rather than in a series of cumbersome and intrusive footnotes is very much appreciated and makes for an eminently enjoyable reading experience.
Bluegrass biographies and memoirs have proliferated in recent years, thanks in large part to the contributions of the University of Illinois Press's Music in American Life series, which was overseen, until her retirement, by Judy McCulloh, a bluegrass fanatic who encouraged her friends in the bluegrass community to share their stories with fans and scholars. Recent publications in that series have included biographies of banjoist J. D. Crowe and dobroist Josh Graves.Footnote 6 Despite these important works, dozens of significant bluegrass artists have yet to be treated to book-length studies of their work, including pioneers Lester Flatt and Earl Scruggs. Such had been the case with the Stanley Brothers, who, despite their legendary status in the world of bluegrass music and the long shadow that they have cast on many current bluegrass acts, had not received biographical treatment until the 2013 publication of David W. Johnson's Lonesome Melodies: The Lives and Music of the Stanley Brothers.Footnote 7 Drawing upon a variety of archival sources, genealogy, local history, fan publications, and dozens of interviews with family members and musicians who worked with or were profoundly influenced by the Stanley Brothers, Johnson's study of Carter and Ralph Stanley's lives and work stands as an important contribution to our understanding of bluegrass music and culture.
Much has been made of the Stanley Brothers’ connections to southwestern Virginia, and many contemporary musicians in the region continue to perform Stanley Brothers songs and emulate their iconic sound as a way of marking their own music as being rooted in the region's traditions.Footnote 8 Johnson's biography, too, explores these deep connections to place, documenting the family's history in the region; Carter and Ralph's personal interactions with the land as hunters, fishermen, and farm workers; and their interactions with the musicians and musical traditions of the first generation of hillbilly radio and recording artists. But rather than portraying the Stanley Brothers simply as a product of an idyllic and untainted Appalachian culture, as many journalists and scholars have been tempted to do, Johnson sensitively situates their lives and music within the broader context of pre–World War II national media (especially the many radio stations that were audible from their Clinch Mountain home) and the post–World War II Appalachian outmigration that took thousands of Virginians, Kentuckians, and West Virginians to the industrial Midwest in search of gainful employment.Footnote 9 As a consequence, Johnson presents the brothers not only as a product of a particular place, but also of a very specific historical context, adeptly moving past the seemingly “ancient” sounds of their music to present them as thoroughly modern musicians in every sense of the word.
Although Johnson's writing occasionally takes the tone of an eager journalist providing his readers with special behind-the-scenes access (see, for instance, his description of an interview he conducted with Gillian Welch [36]), he is to be commended for delicately presenting some of the more difficult aspects of the Stanley Brothers biography. In particular, Johnson's treatment of Carter Stanley's long struggle with alcoholism and tragic death at the age of forty-one presents the facts surrounding his illness without resorting to sensationalism, unlike some of the Hank Williams biographies presented in Huber, Goodson, and Anderson's The Hank Williams Reader. Johnson should be commended for presenting this chapter in the Stanley Brothers’ biography in a respectful and balanced manner.
The issue of class has long been a subject of inquiry in country music studies, ranging from the early sociological studies of Richard A. Peterson and Paul DiMaggio to the more recent work of cultural critics Barbara Ching and Pamela Fox and ethnomusicologist Aaron Fox.Footnote 10 Musicologist and gender studies scholar Nadine Hubbs has taken on the daunting task of exploring the ways in which country music has reflected and refracted white working-class politics, gender, and sexuality since the Vietnam War. Through close readings of country songs, visual style, and the discourse around country music, Hubbs's Rednecks, Queers, and Country Music attempts “to spotlight the inscriptions and erasures that frame the white working class as a discrete bigot class responsible for America's social and political ills” (5). Drawing upon extensive literature from gender studies, political science, and sociology, among many other fields, Rednecks, Queers, and Country Music is an intellectual tour de force that offers a nuanced exploration of the ways that white middle-class attitudes toward country music and white working-class modes of discourse have led to the marginalization of the white working class in political and cultural discourse. Moreover, building on Ching's work on “burlesque abjection” as a discursive mode in so-called “hard country” music and Aaron Fox's ethnographic study of country song and white working-class linguistics, Hubbs argues forcefully that country music might be seen to represent a fairly liberal view of gender and sexuality and present a radical critique of white middle-class attitudes toward white working-class culture.
At the heart of Hubbs's book is a critique of what she describes as “literal-minded perspectives on country music,” which she argues has led “middle-class critics—connoisseurs and expert commentators— . . . into naive, unsophisticated readings of country music and its culture by their projection of literalism onto country music and its audiences” (53). Using a variety of examples from Merle Haggard and Roy Edward Burris's “Okie from Muskogee” to David Allan Coe's “Fuck Aneta Bryant” [sic] and Gretchen Wilson's “Redneck Woman,” Hubbs convincingly demonstrates that although country musicians often take on performative roles that are not autobiographical, white middle-class listeners struggle to hear the complex political discourses that arise out of such roles. Although there are a number of important lessons to be gleaned from Hubbs's careful discussion of country music and the politics of class, the greatest contribution that Rednecks, Queers, and Country Music makes to the scholarly discourse around country music—a discourse that, of course, is always already shaped by middle-class notions of respectability and propriety—comes in Hubbs's nuanced work to demonstrate the remarkably liberal attitudes that many country songs, musicians, and fans take toward gender and sexuality. For example, she argues that the “virile female” character portrayed in Wilson's 2005 hit “Redneck Woman” might initially seem to be “gender-crossed and extraordinary from a dominant culture perspective” (123). However, when placed in the context of white working-class discourse, Hubbs argues, the song reveals an engagement with “contemporary intersectional feminism: the Redneck Woman insists that we apprehend her situation as concurrently working class and female” (125, emphasis in original). Similarly, Hubbs's reading of David Allan Coe's underground anti-homophobia song “Fuck Aneta Bryant” proposes that, contrary to commonly deployed images of the racist and homophobic white working-class male that circulate in much popular discourse, country music, musicians, and fans are often quite accepting of diverse expressions of gender and sexual orientations and may, in their own way, challenge dominant middle-class notions of gender and sexuality.
Surveying these four volumes, it becomes clear that country music studies is in a strong state. The preceding five decades of country music scholarship have laid a solid foundation for continued research in the field, and recent scholarship has demonstrated a willingness to seek out the genre's untold stories and challenge the received narratives surrounding this music. Moreover, as the work of Hubbs and Huber, Goodson, and Anderson indicate, country music scholars are increasingly making valuable contributions to the field of popular music studies as a whole and to broader debates about important cultural issues. Each of the authors reviewed here should be commended, therefore, for their efforts to bring country music studies into the mainstream of academic discourse.
