Atlantic history has established itself, somewhat surprisingly for those of us who practised it before it became popular, as an especially dynamic subfield within early modern history. One reason for its seeming inexorable rise as the default frame of reference for early modern American historians is its cosmopolitan promise. I see Atlantic history as a conversation whereby scholars in related historical fields can share ideas and, most importantly, can resist falling into parochialism. It is only by avoiding parochialism, I believe, that the history of early America can continue to be made relevant. Here I follow the lead of Jack Greene, one of the most important promoters of an Atlantic perspective. Even more so, I follow the example of Bernard Bailyn, who has used his institutional clout as a long-time professor at Harvard and, more importantly, his remarkable historical vision and intellectual perspicacity to put forward a cosmopolitan, expansive view of the history of the early modern world.
Bailyn goes further than I do. He insists that there was such a thing as an Atlantic world and that its coherence can be ascertained through “looking at the submerged linkages and structures that bound the region together and the currents of ideas and patterns of belief that flowed from continent to continent, empire to empire, nation to nation” (3). Whether Atlantic history can stand the claims Bailyn makes for it can be debated. It is debated in the varied essays that comprise this volume. What is clear, however, is that the intellectual career of Bailyn and his vital role in developing Atlantic history as a vibrant subfield is one of the most extraordinary in modern American historiography. Bailyn to an extent overshadows the subject. Even so, the twelve essays collected here, from slave-trading seasonality and ecology to the world of David Hume as an intellectual shaped by the scholarly currents of the Atlantic world, are individually excellent – well crafted, wide-ranging, intellectually adventurous and provocative.
Nevertheless, what knits these essays together is the force of Bailyn's vision of what history should be about, well expressed in his excellent introduction. In this introduction he puts forward a powerful case that we need to see the Atlantic Ocean and the lands that are attached to it as a distinct, constantly evolving and ever-fluid world of mobility and intellectual ferment. The introduction lays out his case and his philosophy of Atlantic history and offers readers a template for what constitutes Atlantic studies. Bailyn is insistent that this historical subfield is marked by an expansiveness of vision and the exciting movement of all sorts of things, from goods to ideas, across a constantly changing set of landscapes defined by being within the Atlantic Ocean. It is an extremely convincing case and the best concise introduction to the field that I know about. It confirms what his admirers have long known: Bernard Bailyn remains the best and most perpetually youthful American practicing in the last half-century. One can see his youthfulness in his openness to new ideas and ways of thinking. What is noticeable about these essays is that finally the South Atlantic is getting the same amount of attention as the North Atlantic, although Mark Peterson's fine essay on why Boston has to be seen as an Atlantic city shows we still have much to learn about the North Atlantic as well. This collection of essays and masterful summary of where Atlantic history as a field is going is a great place to start for people who went to find out what historians find fascinating about the field, whether it is a conversation or a unified field of study. Bailyn has done a great deal to make us appreciate what advantages Atlantic history holds for its practitioners.
