It is easy to dismiss racial/ethnic health disparities as ethical issues, because they seem simultaneously too easy and too hard. It is a no-brainer to say that, ethically, one’s racial or ethnic status ought not to determine the quality of the care one receives, or the degree of access to that care. Yet, when these problems are dismissed from larger discussions of socioeconomic inequities, the development of practical policies to eliminate these health disparities seems a matter for policy and technical expertise, with no useful role for a bioethicist at the table.Footnote 1
To identify possible roles of ethics in addressing racial/ethnic health disparities, we survey three aspects of the problem—broad conceptual questions, macro-level policy choices, and micro-level policies as they appear from the vantage point of a community clinic. Such a multilevel inquiry illustrates the usefulness of bioethics as part of policy development and also outlines a future research program for bioethics itself.
Racial/Ethnic Health Disparities: Ethical and Conceptual Issues
Some possible roles of healthcare ethics in relation to racial/ethnic health disparities are to assure that key terms are consistently and accurately used and to identify where important ethical issues arise. “Race” is one key term that is often used in ambiguous ways. One must ascribe racial identifiers to individuals before one can know whether one group receives different healthcare treatment from another, and the comparison presupposes that one has a clear definition of “race” and applies it consistently. Even skilled genomics investigators, for instance, may be indefensibly sloppy in describing their methods, if any, for deciding who is of what race or ethnicity.Footnote 2
One cause for the ambiguity is that there seem to be at least four different relevant senses of “race.”Footnote 3 Two conceive of race as a biologic variable and two as a social construction.
Classic race, which views humanity as divided into a few basic racial “types” that have major genetic and medical differences, has long been disproven as a legitimate biological categoryFootnote 4 and has more recently been thoroughly discredited as a tool of medical research.Footnote 5 A recent effort to rehabilitate biological race is the notion of geographic race, which claims that races represent geographic populations that interbred over time because of proximity and thus have some specific genetic characteristics in common.Footnote 6 We agree with the scholarship that argues geographic race should be viewed with considerable skepticism.Footnote 7, Footnote 8 It is not clear that this new sense of race has been shorn of the undesirable features attributed to classic race. For example, to study geographic race through techniques such as haplotype mapping of so-called ancestry-informative markers (AIMs), one must choose where to recruit subjects. The locations typically chosen are based less on purely geographic considerations and more on subtle biases about where the “purest” racial “types” are found. Also, all human populations share roughly the same AIMs but in different concentrations, and there is no way to say with any great certainty that the AIMs mapped on one person’s DNA verify that he or she is a descendant of any population group. We concur with those who argue that the most consistent and defensible senses of race conceive of it as a social construction.Footnote 9, Footnote 10 In any event, the most important lesson is that interlocutors ought not talk about race in a manner that reifies the discredited notion of biological race and must assure that they are using “race” in the same sense and not talking past one another.
A few bioethical topologies of the health disparities issue have been proposed.Footnote 11 Some, on our view, are driven by theoretical concerns too far removed from the way that actual research into health disparities is conducted. We favor a topology that matches more closely the steps that investigators would most likely go through in the process of addressing health disparities empirically.Footnote 12 The process consists of three general phases.
Data Gathering
As noted, the first stage of data gathering requires ascribing racial identifiers to individual patients. Because race is best viewed as a social construction, this activity cannot be value-free and invokes serious ethical questions. King, for instance, has called attention to the history of abuse and exploitation associated with racial identifiers and has demanded that the burden of proof always be placed on the investigator who wishes to employ them.Footnote 13
Causal Ascription
If data are gathered and no racial differences are found, the disparities inquiry presumably stops. If differences are seen, the next research question is to discover the cause of the differences. For typical disease issues, possible causal ascriptions would include
• Culturally rooted lifestyle differences
• Lifestyle differences largely independent of culture
• Differential access to treatment
• Different psychological/social susceptibilities or risks
• Differential exposure to environmental risk factors such as toxins
• Provider bias
• Genetic differences
Multifactorial cases in which more than one causal ascription applies are probably the norm rather than the exception.
These causal factors have very different ethical and policy implications (presumably, no one is to blame for genetic differences). There are also ethical and policy questions in either prematurely closing off inquiry into alternative causal factors, in order to take immediate action on a factor already identified, or demanding that inquiry continue and thereby delaying action on serious causal factors that have already been shown. Green and colleagues provide an example of the danger of prematurely dismissing a causal factor because it is unpopular with an important constituency, demonstrating that physicians may unintentionally treat patients of different races unequally.Footnote 14
Policy Implementation
Once we become aware of significant health disparities and correctly identify their causes, it remains to design and implement policies to address them. Many ethical problems arise at this stage. For example, how should a policymaker prioritize between two major policy options, one of which will do a great deal to diminish health disparities, the other of which will improve the quality and safety of healthcare for the entire population? In choosing policies to address health disparities, decisionmakers also need to beware commercial interests disguised as voices for racial justice, a prominent feature of the BiDil controversy.Footnote 15, Footnote 16, Footnote 17
Powers and Faden propose a social justice perspective on the ethics of public health specifically aimed toward setting priorities for implementation in a nonideal setting. They propose that the mere quantification of disparities cannot by itself be used to set priorities for intervention. They give as examples data showing that African American men in the United States live on average 6.6 years less than white males, and that Japanese males live 3.8 years longer than American males. What makes the former statistic a much higher priority for public health intervention than the latter is not the difference in quantity but rather the probability that the health disparity in the former case is integrally bound up within a system of inequities that have an impact on multiple dimensions of individual well-being and life prospects. The ethical foundations of public health, they claim, should address a special duty to protect the vulnerable and not merely a utilitarian concern with overall maximization of health.Footnote 18
Powers and Faden’s public health and social justice approach indicates a further ethical challenge. They describe many situations in which a person’s health status is determined less by access to medical care and more by other social variables such as education, employment, economic status, and so on. There is suggestive evidence that addressing those nonmedical social factors would do much more to improve a community’s health than interventions aimed at medical care. Focusing on “solutions” that lie solely within the healthcare system while ignoring the pressing need for broader social reform raises serious questions of ethics and social justice.Footnote 19
Policy implementation raises ethical concerns at both macro and micro levels. We next explore some of these concerns in more detail. At the macro level, we investigate the likely implications of recently enacted health reform in the United States. At the micro level, we list some ethical issues that were exposed by a pedagogical device to increase students’ awareness of the social justice aspects of health disparities.
Macro Level: Health Reform in 2010
Despite the promise and progress represented by the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (PPACA), health disparities will not fade away as the health reform law takes effect. Health insurance is, to be sure, integral to healthcare access. In 2002, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) estimated that, among the uninsured ages 25 to 65, there were 18,000 excess deaths per year.Footnote 20 Researchers have found that uninsured individuals had worse health and worse outcomes than other insured groups.Footnote 21, Footnote 22 PPACA addresses this issue by dramatically expanding both Medicaid and subsidies for private coverage. Because they are disproportionately uninsured, members of underserved racial and ethnic minorities and people of lower socioeconomic status, in particular, should benefit from these expansions.Footnote 23
But coverage alone does not automatically translate into care. This is where PPACA will likely fail to live up to its potential. Half of those newly obtaining coverage under PPACA will get it through Medicaid, the federal/state program for impoverished families, children, elderly people, and disabled people. A sizeable percentage of these will belong to underserved racial and ethnic minority groups, and most will be poor or nearly poor.Footnote 24 Starting in 2014, PPACA will extend Medicaid coverage to all people earning 133% of the federal poverty level or less, regardless of age, disability, or other status.Footnote 25 Yet Medicaid recipients can have a much more difficult time finding providers willing to treat them than do people with other forms of coverage.Footnote 26, Footnote 27, Footnote 28 This makes it more difficult for Medicaid recipients to obtain care from a regular source, which in turn contributes to deficits in the timeliness and amount of care received and, ultimately, in care outcomes.Footnote 29
Many other members of underserved populations will obtain private coverage as a result of PPACA. PPACA mandates that all Americans carry health insurance and provides subsidies for Americans earning less than 400% of the federal poverty level to purchase coverage if they lack employer-sponsored health insurance.Footnote 30, Footnote 31 Yet private coverage alone does not remedy healthcare disparities. The IOM’s 2003 review of studies on disparities in cardiovascular treatment, part of their larger study of racial and ethnic disparities in healthcare, found that “even after adjustment for many potentially confounding factors—including racial differences in access to care, disease severity, site of care (e.g., geographic variation or type of hospital or clinic), disease prevalence, comorbidities or clinical characteristics, refusal rates, and overuse of services by whites—racial and ethnic disparities in cardiovascular care remain.”Footnote 32 The IOM found multiple sources of these disparities, including differences in treatment compliance among different racial and ethnic groups, language barriers, geographic availability of healthcare, cultural disjunctions, provider stereotyping, provider bias, and patient mistrust.Footnote 33 These sources—many of which, as we noted, lie outside the healthcare system as such—are not dependent on health insurance status and will require alternate forms of address.
PPACA does contain a number of provisions intended to help remedy these issues. It appropriates $11 billion over five years to fund additional community health centers and additional funds for school-based health centers for underserved areas.Footnote 34, Footnote 35 Assuming that changes in political winds will not eradicate or defund the program, the initiative will provide “community transformation” grants, intended to promote healthier environments and reduce health disparities.Footnote 36 PPACA also provides funding for a limited number of years to help defray educational loan expenses for trainees in pediatric specialties and dentistry who work for at least two years in underserved communities.Footnote 37 It also temporarily boosts Medicaid reimbursements to at least 100% of Medicare rates for primary care providersFootnote 38 and sponsors provider training programs in workforce diversity and cultural and linguistic competence.Footnote 39 These are all welcome steps. However, overall PPACA represents a market-driven policy whose main objective is to preserve and subsidize the private health insurance industry, as well as private healthcare providers. The business model approach of private health insurance industries not only conflicts with the policy goal of promoting adequate, universal coverage but, as part of a larger market ideology that pervades U.S. policy decisions, is part of the system that exacerbates health inequities.Footnote 40, Footnote 41 As such, PPACA will fall far short of what is needed to remedy problems that are rooted in the endemic and long-standing poverty and the racial, ethnic, and class-based discrimination that pervade our society.
Micro Level: “They Haunt Us”
Neither conceptual clarification nor the most recent national policy initiatives promise any quick solutions to health disparities. Moreover, macro solutions to health disparities cannot be effective if well-trained providers shun the care of vulnerable patients or if providers fail to see that the conditions of vulnerable patients are often tied to larger social justice issues. Bioethics therefore must also address the lived experiences of these patients at the micro level.
We anticipate that many vulnerable patients will continue to rely on community health clinics, many of which are staffed by medical student volunteers. Health students volunteering at free community health clinics face seemingly insurmountable challenges providing needed healthcare to unsponsored patients in the United States. Attempts to treat persons with multiple diagnoses, mental health disorders, and self-medicating substance abuse disorders, as well as those who live in a pervasive home and community environment not conducive to good health, frustrate students in light of their very limited ability to address such multiple issues. These experiences often result in burnout, fatigue, and detrimental stereotype reinforcement without good clinical preceptors and ample time for critical reflection.Footnote 42 Enthusiastic preclinical medical students eager to volunteer in their first two years of school, once they reach their fourth year, often end up praying for a residency match that will steer them clear of such patients in their careers. In light of these observations, one of the authors of the present article (Glenn) taught a course for graduate students and M.D./Ph.D. students at a large public hospital/academic medical center that was aimed at the challenge of preventing such negative outcomes and instead strengthening students’ commitment to a career caring for the underserved.
The course achieved two objectives: First, it provided a model of how to teach students about health disparities in a way calculated to produce a commitment to further positive action rather than avoidance of the problem and the perpetuation of common negative stereotypes. Second, it yielded data about the lived experiences of patients at a local free clinic, which illuminated in critical ways the ethical dimensions of their healthcare and of any policy proposals to improve that care.
The course combined methodological approaches from both the history of medicine and medical anthropology, drawing from the general principles of community-based participatory research.Footnote 43 Students studied the history of health inequities with a special emphasis on health disparities in the American south. Didactic instruction was coupled with an ethnographic assignment to interview patients at a local free health clinic about their health challenges. Students worked with their interviewees to devise a project to address a local health inequity. Additionally, students received instruction in photographic ethnography methods so that their proposed projects could be developed as advocacy multimedia presentations suitable for wider audiences.
Because it was a nontraditional class utilizing mixed disciplinary methodologies, the course presented many challenges for both instructors and students. However, the preliminary results were better than expected. All the students emerged with a commitment to actually implement their proposed interventions, not just write them up as a good idea.
For medical students and doctors enrolled in the course, there was a conflict between the roles of healthcare provider and student-investigator, especially if the student was an active volunteer at the clinic where patients were recruited. In essence, students were being asked to do something that should be a part of regular medical practice—spend extra time listening to patients—but ethically were compelled to expressly communicate that the interview was taking place as a part of student research and was not related to the patient’s medical care, even though it should be. This became particularly problematic when one patient revealed information to a student that she was uncomfortable sharing with her healthcare provider but that was critical to providing her with good medical care.Footnote 44 This is a sometimes common issue in conducting ethnographic research but, nevertheless, for students wanting to help, this presents obvious ethical challenges. The observation also raises ethical questions about how much time is required to deliver good care to the typical patient attending such a clinic, and how many encounters allow that expenditure of time, given the practical constraints within which such clinics operate.
Students also emerged with a better understanding of how much waste and overpricing occurs at huge medical centers. Students discovered that many critical diagnostic services such as MRIs or DEXA scans—prohibitively expensive at large medical centers—are often offered for as little as one-tenth of the price at specialty health service boutiques. The pricing at specialty diagnostic boutiques illustrates a larger issue: the total lack of transparency that patients face in how hospitals determine the costs charged to patients. Take, for instance, patients who present with a particular illness requiring a specific set of diagnostics and a procedure: the insurance company of a fully insured patient will be billed at a considerably lower amount than an uninsured person with the same illness who requires the same care.Footnote 45, Footnote 46
In trying to figure out the reasons behind this discrepancy, students discovered that it has in part to do with how hospitals get reimbursed for unsponsored care. Through federal, state, and local programs and contracts, large safety net hospitals get reimbursed for some portion of provided unsponsored care, although usually at an amount the hospital claims is below what it actually costs to provide those services. For this reason, among others, it is advantageous for medical centers to list the highest-dollar amounts possible in documenting the unsponsored care they provide, in order to receive the highest reimbursement. Also, anticipating that the unsponsored patient will be unable to pay and that the debt may be sold to a collection agency that buys debts far below cost, billing the uninsured patient higher amounts for his or her care helps hospitals secure higher revenue when those debts are sold to third party collections.Footnote 47, Footnote 48
These practices are devastating for the uninsured patients facing such debt. These ballooned bills are what push so many families into bankruptcy when they lack medical insurance and are faced with a serious illness.Footnote 49 The prospect of bankruptcy and all that it entails—home foreclosure, vehicle repossession, and so on—contribute to a person’s stress and thereby their allostatic load.Footnote 50 A higher allostatic load compromises the immune system and thereby may exacerbate illness and even hasten one’s death.Footnote 51 In this way, what seems good economic policy for hospitals and medical centers may instead be harmful to the health of its most vulnerable patients. Students also raised the issue of the ethics behind sending a patient into financial ruin for not being able to pay their medical bills if the hospital is ultimately going to be at least partially reimbursed for providing unsponsored care. Students could find no ethical defense for this policy, and it seemed to be in place strictly to deter uninsured people from seeking care.
Navigating the available services for under- and uninsured patients was a challenge for both patients and providers. Most providers do not know what exactly qualifies or disqualifies someone for Medicaid or for pharmaceutical assistance programs, or how to help patients with the enormous paperwork associated with such aid. Also, many providers are unaware of or unfamiliar with which other assistance programs their patients may qualify for or how to access them, such as medical service transportation assistance programs, physical abuse and domestic violence programs, substance abuse programs, and so on. As a result, many providers find it difficult to counsel patients on the use of such services to supplement their care. These difficulties are compounded at student-run free clinics, where young students often have even less information than seasoned providers.
All interviewed patients had to overcome a great deal of shame and embarrassment before seeking care at a free clinic. It was an indication of the way that citizens in the United States have internalized the stigmatization of not having medical insurance and needing to rely on charity care as a form of welfare dependency. This caused most patients to delay seeking care. Once their illness reached an emergent stage, they often had to visit a number of different providers before they could find a free clinic that treated them with dignity, or whose burden of proof of financial need was not prohibitively cumbersome, adding further delays before receiving care. Providers using typical stereotypes often label such delays as due to culture (fatalism) or noncompliance.
Students discovered how a safety net of free and reduced-cost clinics might provide acceptable primary and preventive care but might break down when patients need tertiary and quaternary care. This is compounded when, due to stigma and to geographic access issues, patients at free clinics show up with advanced stages of illness. They may previously have sought care at an ER, only to be “stabilized,” if necessary, and told to seek care elsewhere.Footnote 52 Even if a clinic has a relationship with a medical center for diagnostic tests and blood work, the information gained via this relationship may be helpful for confirming a diagnosis but not for receiving effective treatment. Poor communities are accustomed to being diagnosed to death at health fairs and clinics that can offer screening but are unable to offer treatment if a serious health issue is detected.Footnote 53 The exception is treatment of breast and cervical cancer; through the National Breast and Cervical Cancer Prevention and Treatment Act of 2000, individual states can offer a disease-specific Medicaid expansion for these cancers to assure the availability of appropriate treatment post diagnosis.Footnote 54 Students learned what it was like for patients to suffer the stress of a diagnosis with no clear opportunity to receive adequate care.
“Listening/bearing witness when you cannot help or cure,” as expressed by one of the M.D. or Ph.D. students,Footnote 55 was one of the social justice values that students identified. Students were outraged that they were interviewing people with treatable illnesses who were going to die sooner than necessary—some of them much sooner—because of financial challenges; as a result, students evolved the ethos that it was important for health providers not to abandon patients in this situation. Instead, students expressed a commitment to, if nothing else, hold a patient’s hand, listen to their story, and bear witness to the injustice of their situation. In contrast, in the hospital or in the clinic, healthcare providers may be purposely segregated from such conversations by their institutions. The opportunities offered by this course made real the injustice of the American healthcare system in a manner that reading about it cannot.
There has been much discussion in the health disparities literature about nutritional food deserts and the lack of healthy foods in poor neighborhoods.Footnote 56, Footnote 57 After talking with patients about their available food resources, students confirmed that for many of their patients, corner stores and fast food outlets offered the only easily accessible and affordable food options. However, more in-depth discussions revealed that many patients shape their diets around their mental and emotional health needs as much as around healthy food access and cost. In times of stress and socioeconomic uncertainty, fatty, high-carbohydrate, high-protein, and high-calorie foods provide people with major end-of-the-day comfort. The value of such foods to patients could not be measured simply in terms of trans-fat ratios. This highlights an additional challenge to developing the ethos of maintaining a healthy diet, particularly for low-income patients with diabetic and obesity-related chronic disease management needs. These interview data not only expose the emptiness of the rhetoric of “fighting the obesity epidemic” but also highlight the lessons of the Black Report in the United Kingdom on how supposedly equitable and color-blind preventive efforts might disproportionately disadvantage poor populations and hence increase health disparities.Footnote 58
Students experienced firsthand “the cascading health crises effect,” a term one student usedFootnote 59 to explain how the inability to receive prompt treatment for one significant but manageable illness episode produces a successive series of health crises. For patients interviewed, this usually started with the loss of employment. The loss of employment then led to the loss of health insurance, both of which can exacerbate the onset of a chronic illness. Free clinics may diagnose the chronic illness but typically fall short in being able to treat patients with tertiary care or to help them to manage and hopefully overcome their disease. Patients’ health continually decreases while they struggle to regain employment, and the ability to get ahead of their disease continually diminishes. Firsthand witnessing of this effect created a strong sense of urgency in the students to search for interventions that can disrupt this continuing downward spiral and highlighted for them the critical role of nonmedical socioeconomic factors in health status.
Having medical and graduate students conduct in-depth interviews with under- or uninsured patients about their health and life challenges proved an invaluable experience and a productive way to motivate students to fight for change. At the end of the course all students felt a compelling moral duty to implement their proposed interventions. “These patients, their stories and their unnecessary suffering . . . they haunt us.”Footnote 60
As a final ironic note, we close by mentioning that almost all of the patients interviewed by students for this course were former healthcare employees who were laid off after Hurricane Ike devastated Galveston and surrounding Gulf Coast communities. It was a poignant illustration of the larger picture of health inequities at the national level, in that most Americans live one disaster away (be it natural or social) from a cascading health crisis that, for far too many, ends in a premature death.
Conclusion
Understanding the ethical implications of racial/ethnic health disparities requires analysis at both macro and micro levels. We require clear concepts to know what we are talking about. We need effective public policy grounded in sound empirical research. We also need to pay closer attention to the stories told in the trenches by both the vulnerable patients and the caregivers who seek to provide for their needs within an unfriendly system, as these stories help illuminate the social injustices at play in the ill health of vulnerable patients.
Discrete ethical issues exist at all these multiple levels of analysis. Policymakers addressing these health disparities can benefit from input from bioethicists. The bioethics community ought to make the exploration of all these issues a higher priority and embrace a macro-level critique of social injustices alongside micro-level critiques of the clinical encounter.
