The second edition of Eric Van Young's work on the rural economy of central Jalisco comes 25 years after the first edition, which became a classic shortly after its publication in 1981. I would recommend this book if only for the excellent introduction to the second edition which constitutes a lengthy and thoughtful discussion of some of the major trends in hacienda studies and the historiography of colonial Mexico since the 1980s.
But Hacienda and Market offers much more. It discusses how market forces and demographic changes configured this important region of western Mexico. In the process, it redefined our knowledge of the hacienda, patterns of labor, and price formation in colonial Mexico. The author challenges the classical view of the colonial hacienda as a feudal and static organization, arguing that investments in agriculture in the Guadalajara region were indeed business-oriented endeavors and capitalistic in nature. The hacienda was economically sound although it often reflected the seigneurial ideal, where the hacienda served to legitimize a family's social aspirations. In the early colonial period the hacienda relied extensively on “paternalistic” practices including coerced labor. Van Young argues that indebted peons, however, often behaved as economic agents capable of making sensible economic choices. This is not to say that markets were fully functional in colonial Mexico. Government meddling and frictions were pervasive. Notwithstanding, Van Young finds a sure path to market development with the dramatic population expansion in the course of the eighteenth century.
Van Young's work relies on an impressive collection of primary sources, which include hacienda records, censuses, court cases, and tax records. The first two parts of the book set the stage for the analysis by providing a through discussion of the city of Guadalajara and a detailed history of the organization of the most important agricultural markets in the region: maize, wheat, and beef. The third part focuses on the hacienda, its evolution over time, sources of capital, and patterns of value and investment. The last part discusses conflicts over land.
The core of the book is dedicated to the discussion of the effects of demographic changes on the hacienda system. The dramatic increase in population growth that engulfed Mexico in the eighteenth century—and in particular the Guadalajara region—is treated by Van Young as exogenous. He maintains that it resulted in an increased demand for foodstuffs and higher grain prices, causing a shift to cereal production. This shift brought major investment in the old estates, although none of it was accompanied by any major technological innovation. These developments translated into worsening economic conditions for rural workers and Indian communities, however, because nominal wages were unchanged while there were substantial increases in the prices of basic foodstuffs. In addition, as a result of this expansion, conflicts over resources, in particular over land, became more common.
The concluding chapter discusses some of these findings in light of the European historiography and other regional studies of colonial Mexico. The chapter is currently not as informative, however, for the European literature has advanced considerably since the publication of the first edition. Notwithstanding, the comparison with other regional economies of colonial Mexico demonstrates the great adaptability of the hacienda to its economic environment and stresses the difficulties in crafting a unique characterization of the large estates. Haciendas that were closer to markets had a more “capitalistic” organization. These findings are quite relevant for the hotly debated issue of whether the path of growth of former colonies was shaped by factor endowments or whether the identity of the colonizer mattered. Van Young's findings suggest an increasingly marginal role of cultural traits in the evolution of the hacienda in the last decades of the empire, when the large estates in the Guadalajara region were more reliant on wage labor and more capitalistic in nature.
Van Young's study of the economy of late colonial Mexico remains a classic. As John Coatsworth puts it in his foreword to the new edition: it “deftly summarizes what historians now believe they know about the evolution of regional markets as well as hacienda ownership, management, labor force, production, and tenure arrangements as the Mexican population and economy expanded over the course of the eighteenth century.” Hacienda and Market is indispensable reading for scholars interested in the economic and social history of Latin America.
