The year 2013 may well mark a watershed in Wallace studies. The co-discoverer of natural selection and ‘father of biogeography’ has, as Peter Bowler highlighted, been ‘rediscovered’ many times. However, the innumerable lectures, conferences and publications to mark the centenary of his death have piqued fresh interest in this Victorian intellectual great. Benton's contribution to this explosion of Wallace-related material is a little unusual. As the front cover playfully asks, is Wallace ‘a thinker for our own times?’ Such a question may suggest to some a worryingly ‘presentist’ angle of research. However, it is handled with aplomb.
Benton recognizes that his approach may create ‘irritation’ amongst historians (p. 13). However, any ‘presentist’ tendencies are carefully rationed and reasoned throughout. Benton is well placed to undertake this approach in a responsible and rigorous manner. With a background in sociology, philosophy, biology and ecological politics, his immersion in current debates relating to Wallace's broad-ranging interests is transparently obvious. Similarly, he comes bearing a long-standing interest in Wallace and his views on human evolution and humanity's relationship with nature. Combined with the close and perceptive reading of Wallace's writing evident throughout, we are left with a charming and challenging historical assessment of this Victorian scientific great.
The first two main chapters can be described as biographical background. For those familiar with Wallace's life it provides little that is new. However, drawing upon both Wallace's own later recollections of his life and expeditions, it offers a bouncy and enjoyable Wallace 101. His early life and detailed accounts of his famous journeys in South America and the Malay archipelago are set alongside a comprehensive description of his long post-expedition life.
Nonetheless, as Benton himself acknowledges, this is not a simple biography. His chief concern is Wallace's thought. From Chapter 4, Benton unpacks Wallace's world view by describing his intellectual journey towards independent formulation of the theory of natural selection. Chapter 5 broaches the issue of sexual selection, female choice, and the evolution of beauty. Benton reveals the incredible productivity derived from Wallace's attempts to defend natural selection from the encroachment of sexual selection. Chapter 6 then analyses Wallace and Darwin's differing responses to the implications of natural selection for man's place in nature. Benton vividly describes the complex tension in Wallace's thought in which man was both one with and one above nature.
The following two chapters turn to Wallace's political development, especially in relation to the future evolution of man. Chapter 7 offers an account of Robert Owen's political philosophy and the complicated influence of Wallace's early Owenism on his later socialistic thought. Chapter 8 outlines Wallace's detailed and ever-evolving attitudes towards landownership and the fundamentals of a socialist future within an increasingly tempestuous and radical sociopolitical environment.
This work displays an impressive scope and coherence. More impressively still, deep and detailed discussion has not been sacrificed at the altar of breadth. A common trend throughout the work is the prominence of inherent tensions in a vast array of Wallace's intellectual explorations. Antagonistic contradictions such as these were ubiquitous across the whole spectrum of Victorian society and culture. Wallace – in this aspect – was a typical Victorian.
Amongst Wallace scholars, such contrasts have developed into deeply debated research threads. Benton's contribution in this regard is worthy of note. For Benton, Wallace's incorporation of female choice into future human evolution whilst simultaneously denying it in animals was not a volte-face. It was consistent with Wallace's belief that, both in civilized man and in nature, conditions were unconducive for genuine female choice. Consequently, humanity could – and should – adjust society in order for female choice to become a meaningful mechanism for evolution. It is a compelling argument. Nonetheless, an exploration of Wallace's understanding of what made women the ideal selectors in man, and whether these traits were exclusively human or shared with the rest of nature, remains undeveloped.
Contrastingly, Wallace's spiritualism emerges as a subtle yet dramatic change of mind. His philosophical metamorphosis from ‘naturalism’ to ‘spiritualism’ brought with it a desertion of long-held uniformitarianism and a plethora of concomitant readjustments. Such a view is, as Benton notes, controversial, with Charles Smith arguing for the continuity of Wallace's philosophical stance in this regard. Benton marshals his evidence and arguments well and raises convincing doubts as to Wallace's ability to hold a ‘stable, inclusive or internally consistent’ world view (p. 12). Although far from conclusive, it is an intriguing counterpoise to Smith's work.
The confidence in drawing clear lines of descent between Wallace's thought and present-day biological and ecological concepts is also highly engaging and a pleasant by-product of Benton's unusual approach. The link between Wallace and modern ideas of environmental sustainability and the ‘handicap principle’ (p. 121) is perhaps familiar. However, that between Wallace and the concept of ‘metabolic rift’ (p. 185) is much less so and hopefully will breed further research in such directions. It is of little doubt that Wallace still offers invaluable insights for contemporary scientists as well as historians of science.
There is little not to like in this work. However, the absence of an index in a book with such a variety of topics under assessment is a glaring omission. It is also lamentable that Wallace's anti-vaccinationism is not discussed due to it having supposedly ‘less contemporary relevance’ (p. 207). Wallace's anti-vaccinationism was central to his understanding of the rapidly evolving relationship between science and politics and was a prominent dimension of his position as a public intellectual. Its contemporary relevance is still apparent through the deceptive similarity between arguments deployed by the likes of Wallace and present-day anti-vaccinationists. Consequently, a study of Wallace as a ‘public intellectual’ feels a little incomplete without it being considered.
Nonetheless, Benton's probing and perceptive questions and assessments of Wallace's thinking are undoubtedly thought-provoking contributions. As a result, it is certainly a valuable addition to scholars working in subjects across the historical spectrum, especially the history of biology, environmental history and political history.
