I. Introduction
One of the most turbulent moments in Timurid intellectual history was the period that culminated in the regicide attempt on Shāhrukh's life in Herat in 830/1427 by a Ḥurūfī activist named Aḥmad-i Lur. The attempt was unsuccessful and Shāhrukh (d. 850/1447) survived the attack with minor injuries, but its political and intellectual reverberations were to be felt far and wide. The investigation following the regicide attempt resulted in extensive interrogations and the purge of prominent intellectuals by Shāhrukh's administration throughout the Timurid Empire. Although the event in general is relatively well known and widely quoted in studies devoted to the history of the Ḥurūfiyya in the fifteenth century, the overall impact of the incident beyond Ḥurūfī circles and the response of those intellectuals who were also affected by the purges have not been studied in a comprehensive manner.Footnote 1 Given the potential ideological implications of a regicide, albeit a failed one, as well as its timing, as it happened at a moment when Shāhrukh felt the political threat coming from messianic and millenarian movements, a contextual analysis of the regicide attempt promises to be a fruitful exercise towards a better understanding of the place of intellectuals in Timurid politics during the first half of the fifteenth century.
We know about the incident mainly through the accounts of the Timurid chronicles. However, a comprehensive analysis of the causes and consequences of the regicide attempt must take into consideration in a holistic way the Timurid chronicles as well as the reaction of other intellectual figures and organisations, such as the nascent Sufi communities and clandestine or informal intellectual networks in the Timurid Empire and beyond.Footnote 2 The first section of this article thus focuses on how the Timurid chronicles present the incident. In this section, while analysing the chroniclers’ view on the incident, I will also attempt to clarify various historiographical and textual issues as long as they shed light upon the issues related to the regicide attempt. In the second section, I will discuss the views of those individual intellectuals who were directly affected by the incident and expressed their reactions in short treatises.
There appears to be a consensus among modern scholars that the regicide attempt was a momentous event in Shāhrukh's reign. However, there is still disagreement about how and why Shāhrukh reacted to the incident in the way he did. Fuad Köprülü and Roger Savory argued that Shāhrukh grew wary of the growing influence of Sufi shaykhs and the regicide attempt was just a ‘convenient excuse’ to get rid of them in Herat. According to Ya'qūb Āzhand, the regicide attempt was a revenge attack for the killing of Fażlallāh Astarābādī, the eponymous founder of the Ḥurūfiyya movement, at the hands of Mīrānshāh b. Timur in 796/1394. Fatih Usluer suggested that the regicide attempt was a reaction to Shāhrukh's repressive rule. According to Beatrice Manz, Shāhrukh was under pressure coming from millenarian Sufis and he simply overreacted to a relatively minor incident, and tried to alleviate the intensity of his reaction by granting tax relief and distributing alms to his subjects afterwards.Footnote 3
A reconstruction of the event poses major chronological and historiographical problems. To a contemporary bystander, the events surrounding the assassination attempt would appear to have unfolded in the following manner. On 23 Rabī‘ II 830/21 February 1427, after the Friday prayer, someone attempted to assassinate Shāhrukh as he was about to leave the Friday Mosque in Herat. Shāhrukh survived the attack and recovered from his injuries in a short period of time, but the attacker was killed immediately. The investigation after the incident revealed that the assailant had a room in a caravanserai in the city, and that Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt, a famous calligrapher in Herat, used to frequent the assailant there. Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt was soon arrested and interrogated for his alleged involvement in the regicide attempt. He first rejected any association with the assailant, but later identified him as Aḥmad-i Lur, who was a purported follower of Fażlallāh Astarābādī, the founder of the Ḥurūfī movement in Timurid Iran. ‘Ażud, a grandson of Fażlallāh, was arrested, charged with masterminding the conspiracy, and executed. The arrests and interrogations were extended to other intellectuals, such as Qāsim-i Anvār, who were suspected of harboring Ḥurūfī sympathies.
The regicide attempt highlights a moment of crisis in the Timurid Empire during the middle period of Shāhrukh's reign, and like any other crisis in history, it exposes ideological fault lines and political and intellectual rivalries that are otherwise blurred by the intentional suppression or lack of evidence available to historical scrutiny.Footnote 4 The crisis of 830/1426–27 had tangible political dimensions, such as Ulugh Beg's humiliating defeat by Baraq Oghlan of the Gök Orda, but the real actors in the crisis were people closer to home, intellectuals of various colours, who were forced to defend their ideas in a series of inquisition-like interrogations. Beyond the personal dramas involved, this moment of crisis unfolding around the regicide attempt also puts the spotlight on the political dynamics of radical intellectual activism in the fifteenth century, and marks one of those rare moments in which political authority and intellectual prestige clashed under the full gaze of the public eye in the Timurid Empire. What makes the regicide attempt an attractive case to study is the fact that the controversy surrounding the event is well documented by those who held diametrically opposed views on the incident. We have sources, mainly chronicles, which can safely be considered as representative of the view of Shāhrukh and his administration, and several short treatises, mainly polemical in nature, which either support the ‘official’ view, or refute the accusations. Read in the context of the assassination attempt, these sources reveal how diverse, vibrant, and interconnected the Timurid intellectual life was, and how anxious Shāhrukh and his administration were because of the increasing power and authority of the intellectual networks. They also draw a vivid picture of the fear and anxiety that the individual intellectual figures felt in this period.
I will argue in this article that the regicide attempt was only the tipping point in a wider conflict between Shāhrukh and the Timurid intellectuals. The conflict climaxed towards the end of the 820s/1420s, and not only the Ḥurūfīs, but other intellectuals, freethinkers, millenarian Sufis, and those who adopted the science of letters as a methodological principle were also affected by Shāhrukh's policies. Therefore, through exile, interrogations, and executions, Shāhrukh appears to have exploited the incident to curb the growing influence of intellectual networks and impose his control over the newly emerging public sphere, which had been expanding in and beyond the Timurid Empire since the collapse of Mongol rule in Western Asia.
II. The Regicide Attempt and the Timurid Historians
There are five Timurid chronicles which include original information on the assassination attempt:
Zubdat al-tavārīkh-i Bāysunghurī by Ḥāfiẓ-i Ābrū (wr. 830/1426–1427)
The first version ending on 16 Muḥarram 830/17 November 1426
The second version ending on 17 Rabī‘ II 830/15 February 1427
The third version ending after 23 Rabī‘ II 830/21 February 1427
The fourth version ending after 23 Rabī‘ II 830/21 February 1427. This version includes the Tatimma.
Tatimma-yi Zubdat al-tavārīkh-i Bāysunghurī (wr. 830?/1426–1427?)
Mujmal-i Faṣīḥī by Faṣīh-i Khvāfī (wr. 845/1441–1442)
Tārīkh-i kabīr by Ja'farī (wr. ca. 851–855/1447–1452)
Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn va majma‘-i baḥrayn by ‘Abd al-Razzāq Samarqandī (wr. 875/1470–71).
The Zubdat al-tavārīkh-i Bāysunghurī is the fourth and last part of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's universal history Majma‘ al-tavārīkh. It includes the history of the Timurid dynasty from the birth of Timur in 736/1335 down to the assassination attempt in 830/1427. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū (d. 833/1430) separately dedicated this part of his chronicle to Mīrzā Bāysunghur b. Shāhrukh; hence the title of the work.Footnote 5 The importance of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's account on the assassination attempt has not been appropriately appreciated mainly due to the absence of a proper edition until recently. It is one of the most important sources on this issue for the following two reasons. Firstly, as a historian who spent much of his time in Herat in Shāhrukh's service, Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū was present in Herat, and possibly an eyewitness to the assassination attempt and the subsequent persecutions. Secondly, the assassination attempt is the last event narrated in the Zubdat al-tavārīkh, and the codicological complexity of its final part may be related to the crisis surrounding the assassination attempt.Footnote 6
The Tatimma-yi Zubdat al-tavārīkh is a supplement to the year 830/1426–27 in the Zubdat al-tavārīkh. Its full title is Ẕikr-i tatimma-yi vaqāyi‘ ki sana-yi salāsīn va samānmi'a ḥādis shud, and it has come down to us in a single incomplete copy at the end of the Bodleian manuscript of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh.Footnote 7 Neither the authorship nor the composition date of the Tatimma is recorded in the text. Since the Zubdat al-tavārīkh includes similar continuations for the years after 825/1421–22, with the exception of 829/1425–26, it is possible to suggest that the Tatimma was composed by Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū himself.Footnote 8 However, the fact that Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū was addressed in the second person in the text lends support to the argument that the Tatimma was composed by someone other than Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū.Footnote 9 Furthermore, Mīrzā Bāysunghur (d. 837/1434) is referred to as alive, a point that indicates that the terminus ante quem for the composition date is 837/1434.Footnote 10 The reference to the assassination attempt in the text is sketchy, and the bulk of the text is devoted to the conflict between Ulugh Beg and Baraq Oghlan, but it still helps us to solve various textual problems related with the Zubdat al-tavārīkh.Footnote 11
After the Zubdat al-tavārīkh and the Tatimma, the next Timurid historians who discussed the assassination attempt, albeit very briefly, were Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī (d. 849/1445) and Ja'farī. Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī was also a member of Shāhrukh's administration. In his Mujmal-i Faṣīḥī, which is a biographical and historiographical compendium from Adam to the year 845/1441–42, he reiterates in a short paragraph what the Zubdat al-tavārīkh says, but also adds an important detail regarding the expulsion of Qāsim-i Anvār from Herat on the orders of Shāhrukh, a detail that is not mentioned by Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū.Footnote 12 Ja'farī was a Ḥusaynī sayyid from Yazd, and did not really belong to the establishment of Herat in the Timurid Empire. He wrote the Tārīkh-i kabīr sometime between 851/1447–48 and 855/1451–52. It is probable that he wrote his work for Sulṭān- Muḥammad b. Bāysunghur. His account on the assassination attempt in the Tārīkh-i kabīr is short and includes few details. Yet it is also the only historiographical account on the assassination attempt written from outside the intellectual circles of Herat.Footnote 13
Samarqandī's account in the Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn is rather late as a source for our purposes. Although he wrote it during the reign of Sulṭān-Abū Sa‘īd b. Sulṭān-Muḥammad (d. 873/1469; r. 855–873/1451–1469), he and his father were thoroughly engaged in the Shāhrukhid administration.Footnote 14 Hence, it would not be entirely wrong to suggest that his chronicle Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn reflects the Shāhrukhid pretensions. Indeed, the first part of the Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn is little more than a retelling of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's Zubdat al-tavārīkh until the year 830/1426–27.Footnote 15 However, as I will discuss in more detail below, the section on the assassination attempt on Shāhrukh diverges from the account found in the Zubdat al-tavārīkh on several important points. Footnote 16 Although it represents a later version of the story, Samarqandī's version of the narrative later acquired a near canonical status in subsequent Persianate historiography.Footnote 17
Of these five accounts, Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and ‘Abd al-Razzāq Samarqandī need to be discussed separately due to their comprehensive coverage of the incident, the textual complexities that they pose to us, and the differences in their take on the assassination attempt. I will also refer to the Tatimma-yi Zubdat al-tavārīkh, Mujmal-i Faṣīḥī, and the Tārīkh-i kabīr as they contribute to the discussion.
The Codicology of the Zubdat al-Tavārīkh
Before we go into the details of how Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and Samarqandī present the assassination attempt, we need to address a textual and codicological problem that may have a bearing on the crisis of 830/1426–27. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū completed his universal chronicle Majma‘ al-tavārīkh in successive stages, and its oldest copy is dated to 829/1425–26. However, this copy does not include the fourth part, called Zubdat al-tavārīkh. The year 830/1426–27 itself is particularly puzzling as there exist at least four different versions of it in different manuscripts of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh.Footnote 18
The Zubdat al-tavārīkh ends with the year of 830/1426–27, but it is difficult to suggest that Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū brought his work to a proper completion. It lacks a true colophon, and the existing colophon, which gives the date 830/1426–27, appears to have been taken from Muḥammad Ṭūsī's (d. 830/1427) Majma‘ al-tahānī, a treatise on the assassination attempt, which will be discussed in more detail in the second part of this article.Footnote 19 This similarity led Āzhand to argue that the Majma‘ al-tahānī was one of the sources of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū for his Zubdat al-tavārīkh. Footnote 20
‘Abd al-Razzāq Samarqandī was very well acquainted with the oeuvre of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, so much so that the Zubdat al-tavārīkh constituted the basis of his Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn until the year 830/1426–27. However, in the section on the assassination attempt on Shāhrukh, we face a rather difficult textual and contextual conundrum. After mentioning Muḥammad Jūkī's departure from Herat on 17 Rabī‘ II 830/15 February 1427 to support Ulugh Beg in his fight against Baraq Oghlan of the Gök Orda over the possession of Khvārazm, Samarqandī abruptly announced that Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's Zubdat al-tavārīkh had reached the end at this point.Footnote 21 In other words, the version of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh that Samarqandī used did not include the account on the assassination attempt. Instead, Samarqandī completed the chapter with his version of the events, which I will discuss below.Footnote 22 This was either because Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū had actually stopped working on the Zubdat al-tavārīkh around 15 February 1427, or Samarqandī had access to an incomplete copy. Alternatively, Samarqandī may have had access to all three versions of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh, but found them too confusing or their collation too time consuming, and therefore created his own version. All three possibilities are indeed plausible. The oldest surviving manuscript of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh ends with the death of Soyurghatmish b. Shāhrukh on 16 Muḥarram 830/17 November 1426, almost three months before the assassination attempt. However, the fact that we have at least two copies of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh which also include the assassination attempt complicates the matter even further.Footnote 23 What is puzzling is that despite Samarqandī's familiarity with the work of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and his prominent position in the Herat court, he seems to have been unaware of the full version of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh. Based on the surviving evidence, four different versions of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh appear to have been circulating in the second half of the fifteenth century:
1) Two manuscripts in the Kitābkhāna-yi Malik in Tehran, Mss. 4166 and 4163, represent the first version, the former being, purportedly, the oldest manuscript of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh. They end at the beginning of the section on the conflict between Ulugh Beg and Baraq Oghlan, and do not include the account of the assassination attempt.Footnote 24
2) The second version concludes with Muḥammad Jūkī's arrival in Samarqand on 17 Rabī‘ II 830/15 February 1427, but excludes the assassination attempt. We have no manuscript representation for this version, but its existence can be inferred on the basis of Samarqandī's statement mentioned above.
3) The third version includes the assassination attempt. This version is represented by the Istanbul manuscript, which is the oldest manuscript of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh that includes the account of the assassination attempt.Footnote 25 It was prepared for the personal library of Shāhrukh, and includes the marginalia taken from the corresponding passages of the Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn.
4) The fourth version includes both the assassination attempt and the Tatimma. Assuming that the entire text was penned by Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū with no editorial intervention by a later hand, this version represents the most complete copy of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh. The Bodleian manuscript is the sole surviving example of this version.Footnote 26
After presenting these four different versions, we can now ask the question more directly. Is the existence of these four different versions a result of inconsistent copying, or does it reflect the successive composition stages by the author, Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, in a turbulent year when Shāhrukh's authority in Herat came under enormous strain due to the death of Soyurghatmish bt. Shāhrukh, Ulugh Beg and Muḥammad Jūkī's defeat at the hands of Baraq Oghlan of the Gök-Orda, and finally the assassination attempt on Shāhrukh in a single year? Based on the extant manuscript corpus of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh, it is also possible to suggest that Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū did not finish his work and left behind several drafts for the year 830/1426–27, all of which later entered circulation. Given the immense complexity of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's oeuvre, it is difficult to give an unreserved positive answer to this question. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū confronts us with a unique challenge of intertextuality by collating and revising his own works under different names and in different genres such as history and geography. Since this seemingly textual problem is related with the year 830/1426–27, it is worth having a closer look at the further details of how Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū ended his chronicle.
The Date of the Regicide Attempt
All our sources agree that the assassination attempt occurred in Herat on a Friday, but they disagree on the exact date of the incident. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū gives the date 23 Rabī‘ I 830/22 January 1427 (which was actually a Wednesday) while Samarqandī dates it to 23 Rabī‘ II 830/21 February 1427 (which was a Friday). Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's dating is rather problematic in terms of the chronology presented in the Zubdat al-tavārīkh. It mentions the departure of Muḥammad Jūkī from Herat in support of his brother Ulugh Beg against Baraq Oghlan on 17 Rabī‘ II 830/15 February 1427 as the last event before the assassination attempt. Furthermore, Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū himself asserts that the assassination attempt occurred on a Friday, a point which also weakens the reliability of his dating. Therefore, Samarqandī's date seems to be more accurate. The manuscripts of the Mujmal-i Faṣīḥī are not consistent on the date of the incident, but the latest edition of the text which relies on a manuscript copied in 857, just twelve years after its composition, gives the date 23 Rabī‘ II. Therefore, the date 23 Rabī‘ II 830/21 February 1427 seems to be the more accurate for the assassination attempt despite the fact that our most important source, Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, who was probably an eyewitness to the incident, does not agree with it.Footnote 27
Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and ‘Abd al-Razzāq Samarqandī on the Regicide Attempt
According to Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's detailed and lively account, Shāhrukh went to the Friday Mosque of Herat (Jāmi‘-i Dār al-Salṭana) for the Friday prayer. His powerful wife, Gawharshād Begüm (d. 861/1457), whom Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū refers to as the queen mother (mahd-i ‘ulyā), tried to detain this procession from going to the mosque through the Portico of Herat (Īvān-i dār al-khilāfa).Footnote 28 Since it was rainy, and the roads were slippery, she was worried that “an agony would be inflicted upon Shāhrukh”, a remark which most probably reflects Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's reaction to the incident ex post facto. Shāhrukh responded that there was no escaping divine will and dismissed her worries. After performing the Friday prayer, he set out to return to his palace. However, in total disregard of the normal practices of kingship, he had not banned the public from attending the royal procession. As the crowd was leaving the mosque, someone approached Shāhrukh and tried to stab him with a knife, but because of Shāhrukh's firm piety, the chronicler tells us, he was not injured seriously. A page was able to catch the collar of the perpetrator and take him down while a eunuch (khāja-sarā) seized the knife and stabbed him. The perpetrator was eventually beheaded by the arriving guards (yasa'ul). “As the fear of apocalypse filled the air”, according to Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, Shāhrukh left the mosque in a litter.Footnote 29
Samarqandī's account does not convey the sense of disorderliness that is so clearly reflected in Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's narrative. According to Samarqandī, a man clad in felt named Aḥmad-i Lur, a disciple of Fażlallāh Astarābādī, approached Shāhrukh with a piece of paper in his hands in the guise of someone seeking justice from the king. Shāhrukh asked his aides to allow him to approach. Suddenly Aḥmad-i Lur drew his knife and plunged it into Shāhrukh's belly. However, he was not seriously wounded, and Aḥmad-i Lur was killed by the members of Shāhrukh's inner circle (ichkiyān), among whom was ‘Alī-Sulṭān b. Mengü Qa'uchin. In the meantime, as the military band struck up the processional music, the crowd noticed the attempt and ran to the roof (bām) of the mosque. Amīr ‘Alā’ al-Dīn ‘Alīka Kökeltash and Amīr Jalāl al-Dīn Fīrūzshāh had mounted their horses, but Shāhrukh asked for Amīr Jalāl al-Dīn Fīrūzshāh and expressed his wish to sit in a litter. However the amīr said that doing so would cause unrest among the people. Therefore, Shāhrukh mounted his horse, left the mosque in the company of the military band, and proceeded to Bāgh-i Zāghān, where his wounds were treated by the doctors.Footnote 30
So far the most noteworthy alteration in Samarqandī's narrative is the exclusion of Gawharshād Begüm and the emphasis on the agency of the amīrs around Shāhrukh. In Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's narrative, only a page and a eunuch are able to subdue the perpetrator, but according to Samarqandī it was Shāhrukh's inner circle (ichkiyān). Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū keeps the identity of the perpetrator anonymous, while Samarqandī reveals both his name and communal affiliation right at the beginning of the narrative.
The differences between the accounts of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and Samarqandī on the events following the assassination attempt are no less revealing. According to Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, Shāhrukh initiated the investigation of the incident immediately, but nobody initially recognised the assailant. Three days later a person who owned a caravanserai in Herat arrived and said that someone resembling the attacker had a room in his caravanserai, but he had not shown up since Friday. Further investigation revealed that the famous calligrapher Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt frequented the attacker in his room. Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt was soon brought in and interrogated. First he rejected any connection with the assassination attempt, but after he was tortured, he revealed that the name of the attacker was Aḥmad-i Lur.Footnote 31 The investigation soon produced the name ‘Ażud as the real perpetrator. ‘Ażud, the son of Mawlānā Majd al-Dīn Astarābādī, was a follower of Mawlānā Faẓlallāḥ Astarābādī, the founder of the Ḥurūfiyya order.Footnote 32 Hence, the association between the assassination attempt and the Ḥurūfīs, whom Ḥāfīẓ-i Abrū calls “the fighters for blasphemy and heretics in nature (mukāfaḥa-yi kufr va zandaqa-yi majbūl)”, was established. Those who were accused of having Ḥurūfī sympathies were apprehended and interrogated. Curiously, Ḥāfīẓ-i Abrū does not name any of these individuals. We are told that they first denied any connection with the assassination attempt, but under torture they admitted knowledge of the conspiracy to kill Shāhrukh, including the role of Aḥmad-i Lur. At the end, they were all executed. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū underlines the overwhelming backing that the city folk gave to these executions and Shāhrukh's generosity towards them for their support. Shāhrukh must have understood the threat that he was facing, as extensive donations to the needy from the treasury, pardoning of tax arrears, and release of prisoners followed the executions.Footnote 33
Samarqandī's narrative is less sophisticated than that of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, which often reads like a real detective novel. Regretting that they had killed Aḥmad-i Lur, Mīrzā Bāysunghur and other amīrs searched his body, and, among other things, found a key in his pocket. The ensuing investigation revealed that the key opened a door in an inn (tīmcha) in Herat. The residents of the inn were questioned, and they said that the attacker had indeed occupied a room there, and that he had had many visitors, among whom was the calligrapher Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt-i Baghdādī. Samarqandī's account of Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt is drastically different from Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's and includes relatively detailed information on Ma'rūf's background that strongly emphasised his intimate relationships first with Iskandar b. ‘Umar-Shaykh in Iṣfahān and then Mīrzā Bāysunghur in Herat. After the assassination attempt, Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt and those youth who were close to him were apprehended, but he was spared and imprisoned in the Ikhtiyār al-Dīn fort in Herat after some officials were bribed. For Samarqandī, the Ḥurūfī associations of the assassination attempt are self-evident, and he simply states that Khvāja ‘Ażud al-Dīn, the grandson of Fażlallāh Astarābādī, and the others who collaborated with Aḥmad-i Lur, were executed.Footnote 34
Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū remains silent on the purge of the intellectuals following the assassination attempt despite the fact that the Majma‘ al-tahānī, a text which is very closely related to the Zubdat al-tavārīkh, is very vocal on this issue. Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī and Samarqandī mention the name of the famous poet Sayyid Qāsim-i Anvār (d. 837/1433–1434), who left for Samarqand after the assassination attempt, and both agree that his expulsion from Herat happened by the order of Mīrzā Bāysunghur, but they are less clear about what the exact nature of the problem between the poet and the prince was. Samarqandī states without further elucidation that Mīrzā Bāysunghur was ill-disposed towards Qāsim-i Anvār. Mīrkhvānd and Khvāndamīr later elaborated upon Samarqandī's narrative and argued that Qāsim-i Anvār was expelled from Herat because Mīrzā Bāysunghur found out that Aḥmad-i Lur had visited him.Footnote 35
Beyond the textual differences presented above, Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and Samarqandī also used different filters in interpreting the event. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū appears to have been more interested in the event itself and its immediate perception by the public. His account is more fatalistic and better reflects Shāhrukh's political predicament.Footnote 36 Shāhrukh was saved by an ordinary page, and the subsequent investigation was in shambles. The investigators were able to establish an alleged link between the incident and the Ḥurūfīs only after they received a tip from an ordinary person and torturing those whom they suspected of having been involved in the conspiracy. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū avoids mentioning any other prominent Timurid figure involved in the incident. Samarqandī brings to the fore the powerful amīrs who rescued Shāhrukh from the melee that broke out after the assassination attempt, and emphasizes their role in the subsequent investigations. Here especially Mīrzā Bāysunghur appears to be a crucial figure.
It is indeed a real puzzle, for if Mīrzā Bāysunghur had any role in saving Shāhrukh or in the subsequent investigation, why would Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū—who usually accords Bāysunghur the highest accolades in the Zubdat al-tavārīkh—exclude him from his account? If he did not play any role in these events, why would Samarqandī include him in his narrative? Samarqandī also blames him for causing the departure of Qāsim-i Anvār, for whom he appears to have had high regard, from Herat to Samarqand. It is tempting to think that Samarqandī's narrative is just court gossip with a tinge of anti-Bāysunghurid prejudice, or that he chose to ignore Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's full account of the story in order to spare Shāhrukh from embarrassment. But this is to remain speculation until we resolve the question of the sources of the Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn for the period following 830/1426–1427.
Ja'farī's account surprisingly lacks any factual details on the assassination attempt itself. He simply says that as Shāhrukh was leaving the mosque after the Friday prayer, the followers of Fażlallāh Astarābādī (Fażlallāhiyān) attempted to stab Shāhrukh, but the assailant was captured and killed immediately by the guards (mulāzimān). As for the aftermath of the incident, however, Ja'farī drastically shifted the emphasis from the investigations and interrogations to a public uprising and lynching in Herat. According to Ja'farī, there was no investigation after the incident. Instead, a great civil strife (fitna-yi ‘aẓīm) broke out after the assassination attempt. Many people armed themselves and started to look for the Ḥurūfīs (ān jamā‘at), and they killed whoever they were able to identify. They also killed ‘Ażud, a maternal grandson of Fażlallāh, and six other Ḥurūfīs along with many others who were mistaken for Ḥurūfīs. Following this civil strife, Shāhrukh exempted his subjects from one-sixth of all taxes.Footnote 37 Ja'farī was a sayyid from Yazd, and his distaste for what happened in 830/1426–27 is obvious. He does not criticise or glorify what the Ḥurūfīs did, but he also does not hesitate to label the following vigilante justice civil strife (fitna).
Before turning our attention to the reactions of intellectual circles to the assassination attempt, a recapitulation of the historiographical corpus on the matter is in order. Given the familiarity of Samarqandī with the work of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū, and the fact that both authors were residents in Herat and belonged to the same courtly and administrative circles, it is surprising that Samarqandī did not have access to the full account of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh on the assassination attempt. However, I am inclined to adopt a less conspiratorial solution to this puzzle, as we have no reliable evidence to suggest that Samarqandī intentionally censored the Zubdat al-tavārīkh. Above I suggested the possibility that this was due to the fact that Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū could not complete and compile his work due to the political turmoil of the year 830/1426–27, and his hesitation about how to go about doing so made him leave it unfinished. It is quite possible that Samarqandī had an incomplete copy of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh in his hands, and was unaware of the existence of other versions. If this was the case, Samarqandī had access to either an early draft or an incomplete copy of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh and incorporated it into his own work. Since the Maṭla‘-i Sa'dayn surpassed the Zubdat al-tavārīkh in popularity, these different drafts of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's work were never properly collated until modern times. Nevertheless, it is curious that such confusion should have had occurred in the year 830/1426–27, when Shāhrukh's administration was undergoing a deep crisis. Although concise and sketchy, Ja'farī's rather gloomy account reminds us that not everybody was happy with what happened in 830/1426–27, and I will now turn my attention to the voice of those who were affected by the assassination attempt in order assess its full impact.
III. The Regicide Attempt and the Timurid Intellectuals
So far I have only relied on the Timurid chronicles, and, with the possible exception of Ja'farī, they all present us with the official Shāhrukhid perspective. The picture they paint is rather straightforward. A heretical sect tried to kill the king, and the king punished the perpetrators. But the story is rather more complex than this. The Timurid chronicles, especially Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī and Samarqandī, do not deny the fact that numerous intellectuals were affected by the purges ensuing the assassination attempt, but they reveal very little that would contribute to our understanding of the issue in any significant way. Other than Ażud, only the names of Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt and Qāsim-i Anvār are mentioned in the contemporary sources. We know very little about the life of Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt, and certainly nothing about his view of the assassination attempt. All we know is that he was imprisoned after the incident.Footnote 38 A later source, Gāzurgāhī (d. 909/1503–04) in his Majālis al-‘ushshāq, adds that two sayyids from Herat were also implicated after the assassination attempt. Amīr Makhtūm Nīshābūrī (d. 833/1429) was first punished through the pouring of hot oil on his head, and then exiled to Hurmuz. His father Amīr Sayyid Bahā’ al-Dīn, a Ḥusaynī sayyid from Medina, was sent to a border town (?Dār al-Marz).Footnote 39 Unfortunately, I could not verify Gāzurgāhī's account in earlier Timurid sources.
We are better informed about Qāsim-i Anvār's (d. 837/1433) life thanks to his widespread reputation as a poet and the attention he received from several biographical dictionaries, but these biographical notices add nothing substantial to what we already know from the chronicles.Footnote 40 Qāsim-i Anvār was a notable poet with a dīvān, and he also penned several short treatises, but unfortunately none of them can securely be dated to 830/1426–27 or afterwards. Therefore, it would be rather speculative at this point to read them in the context of the assassination attempt.Footnote 41
We do not know how Qāsim-i Anvār became actually involved in the incident. According to Khvāfī, he was expelled from Herat on the orders of Shāhrukh.Footnote 42 Samarqandī refers to enmity between him and Mīrzā Bāysunghur, but he doesn't specify the origin of this enmity. A much later source, ‘Abd al-Razzāq Kirmānī's hagiography of Shāh Ni'matallāh Kirmānī, says that supposedly he had foretold the civil strife a few days before the incident, and that a copy of the Dīvān of Qāsim-i Anvār was found in the vault of the perpetrator, who is not named in the text. He was interrogated by Amīr ‘Alīka and Amīr Fīrūzshāh, two prominent amīrs of Shāhrukh's administration, and asked if the rumors were true and he had had premonition of the incident. Qāsim-i Anvār defended himself by saying that sometimes future events spark in the minds of the dervishes, and if he had foreseen the incident, this must have been because of him being a dervish, not because he was one of the perpetrators. Written after 911/1506, Kirmānī's account is of little value for our purposes and its main purpose is to point at Qāsim-i Anvār's prophetic abilities, such as prognostication.Footnote 43 Roger Savory suggested that Qāsim-i Anvār was in charge of Safavid propaganda in Herat, but could not have been involved in the assassination attempt as this would have been counterproductive for his activities as an agent of the Ardabil shrine in Khorasan. Savory prefers to connect his expulsion from Herat to the Timurid attempts to curb growing Safavid influence in the region. According to him, Qāsim-i Anvār was expelled simply because he had become disturbingly popular and influential in the city.Footnote 44
There is no doubt that Qāsim-i Anvār belonged to the network of the Ardabīl shrine, a point which can aptly be demonstrated by references to Ṣadr al-Dīn b. Ṣafī al-Dīn Isḥāq (d. 794/1391) in his works.Footnote 45 However, we do not know much about his relationship with Khvāja ‘Alī (d. 832/1429), who took over the leadership of the Safavid network and the Ardabīl shrine after the death of Ṣadr al-Dīn, and Ibrāhīm b. Khvāja ‘Alī (d. 851/1447). None of these figures are mentioned in Qāsim-i Anvār's works, and we have no firm evidence to suggest that he maintained a close contact with the shrine in Ardabīl after the death of Ṣadr al-Dīn.Footnote 46 It seems that Qāsim-i Anvār was not a mere Safavid propagandist, but rather an intellectual by himself with immense popular and political appeal whose network reached far beyond Safavid circles.
In his Jām-i jahān-namā-yi Shāhī, Muḥammad Ṭabasī (fl. 828–42/1424–39), one of the followers of Shāh Ni'matallāh Valī, provides the following political taxonomy:
At this time in the month of Rajab, the year of 828 (= 19 May – 17 June 1425), after the Ghaws , there is no one of the status of Amīr Sayyid Ni'matallāh; among the deputies of the kingdom of heavens (khulafā-yi malakūt) there is no one of the status of Amīr Sayyid Qāsim, and among the caliphs of the world (khulafā-yi mulk), there is no one of the status of Amīr Shāhrukh.Footnote 47
Ṭabasī's work is one of the most striking formulations of dual kingship written in late medieval Islamic history. The conciliatory tone of the text is noteworthy, as it does emphasize the legitimacy of Shāhrukh's authority. In the paragraph translated above, the Ghaws refers to either one of the twelve imāms or Jesus according to Ṭabasī.Footnote 48 What interests us most here is the elevation of Qāsim-i Anvār to a level that rivals the spiritual authority of Shāh Ni'matallāh Valī and the political authority of Shāhrukh some twenty months before the assassination attempt. This constituted no small challenge to Shāhrukh's authority, and came from an angle not mentioned in the chronicles. The real danger that Qāsim-i Anvār posed for Shāhrukh—whether he was an agent of the Ardabīl shrine or not—was not simply his popularity, but the fact that he epitomized a new constitutional framework through the merger of religious and political authority in the Timurid Empire. Therefore, he was forced to go to exile to Samarqand and then to Kharjird, where he died in 837/1433.Footnote 49
A closer examination of contemporary literature reveals that there were other figures who felt the political pressure. For example, Navā’ī reports that Mawlānā Kamāl al-Dīn Ḥusayn Khvārazmī (d. 839/1435–36), the famous poet and Masnavī commentator, was accused of blasphemy (takfīr) for a ghazal that he wrote. He was called to Herat from Khvārazm, and interrogated. Since he was a very learned man, he was able to respond to all accusations. In the end he was not found guilty for any crime, and returned to his hometown. Unfortunately, we do not know exactly when this incident occurred and how Khvārazmī responded to the accusations.Footnote 50 However, we can connect his interrogation to the context of the assassination attempt through indirect evidence found in his own works. Khvārazmī's commentary on Rūmī's Masnavī demonstrates a clear pro-‘Alīd tendency, and includes a short section on the potency of the science of letters in explaining the question of unity. According to Khvārazmī, there was group of intellectuals who considered the entire universe a book or leaves with text on it, and who believed that they had access to the secrets of letters that revealed the principles of Unity (tawḥīd).Footnote 51 Khvārazmī provides a concise description of the science of letters, and ultimately connects it to the views of Ibn ‘Arabī and Fakhr al-Dīn ‘Irāqī (d. 688/1289). Khvārazmī's tone is unapologetic, but he doesn't present an overly committed stance either. Nevertheless, I believe it wouldn't be too far-fetched to suggest that Khvārazmī's troubles were caused by his views on the science of letters and the pro-‘Alid tone of his work. The reason why we cannot go into further discussion on this matter is the difficulty to date and contextualize his work. He started the commentary on the second book of the Masnavī in 833/1430, three years after the assassination attempt, but we do not know when exactly he started composing his work. In all probability he never finished the entire project, as the extant portions of the text include the commentary on the first three books of the Masnavī only. Devin DeWeese surmised that his death in 839/1435–36 probably prevented him from completing his work. Khvārazmī dedicated his commentary to Ibrāhīm Sulṭān b. Shāh-Malik, the governor of Khvārazm. In his dedication he refers to Shāh-Malik as deceased, so he must have started working on his commentary after 829/1426, the year in which Shāh-Malik died, but for the time being we cannot be sure if it was before or after the assassination attempt. The Jawāhir al-asrār and indeed the entire oeuvre of Khvārazmī requires further study in this regard.Footnote 52
Khvārazmī was not the only intellectual accused of blasphemy, and fortunately some of these intellectuals responded to the political pressure in writing, leaving behind an alternative record of the crisis in 830/1426–27. The following authors and their works appear to be the most prominent one of these writings:
Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i avval and Risāla-yi i'tiqādāt by Ṣā’in al-Dīn Turka (wr. 8 Rajab 829/16 May 1426)
Majma‘ al-tahānī va maḥżar al-amānī by Muḥammad Ṭūsī (wr. 830/1426–27)
Manhaj al-rashād by Zayn al-Dīn Khvāfī (wr. 831/1427–28)
A letter by Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad to Ḥasan on the Ḥurūfī involvement in the incident (wr. 16 Jumādā 836/8 January 1433).
Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad's letter and the Ḥurūfīs
All the chronicles we discussed above agree that ‘Ażud, one of the followers of Fażlallāh Astarābādī, was executed for masterminding the whole conspiracy. Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū tells us that he was the son of Majd al-Dīn Astarābādī without specifying his relationship to Fażlallāh Astarābādī. According to Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī, his name was Khvāja ‘Ażud, and he was a maternal grandson (dukhtarzāda) of Fażlallāh Astarābādī. He also adds that Khvāja ‘Ażud was not only executed, but that his body was also burned. Samarqandī simply changes his name to Khvāja ‘Ażud al-Dīn and repeats Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī's account.Footnote 53 The Ḥurūfī sources confirm that Majd al-Dīn was one of the four vicegerents of Fażlallāh and that he had access to Fażlallāh's inner secrets (maḥram-i asrār), but we cannot be sure if this intimacy also entailed a family connection.Footnote 54 In other words, from Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū to Faṣīḥ-i Khvāfī, he was transformed from being the son of one of the vicegerents of Fażlallāh to a family member of Fażlallāh, and Majd al-Dīn Astarābādī's name disappeared. Samarqandī presents the whole issue as the heinous act of a troublesome family.
A glimpse of the reaction of the Ḥurūfīs to the assassination attempt can be found in a letter written in Persian by Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad to Mawlānā Ḥasan. The events narrated in the letter took place during the period between 832/1429, soon after Shāhrukh left Herat for his second Qaraqoyunlu campaign on 5 Rajab 832/10 April 1429, and the date when the letter was composed, on 16 Jumādā I 836/8 January 1433. The importance of this letter for our purposes derives from the fact that both the sender and the recipient were vicegerents of Fażlallāh Astarābādī, and the contents of the letter can be construed as a reaction of some Ḥurūfīs to the attempt on Shāhrukh's life.Footnote 55
The letter gives a fairly detailed account of how the author and Amīr Nūrallāh, the son of Fażlallāh, were treated after the attack.Footnote 56 Its contents are marred by chronological inconsistencies, and certainly reflect the author's biases on many accounts, but it still includes valuable information on the aftermath of the assassination attempt.
After the assassination attempt, Fażlallāh Astarābādī's son Amīr Nūrallāh and the author of the letter Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad were arrested in Māzandarān and brought to the army camp at Juvayn and Baḥrābād.Footnote 57 This must have been soon after 27 Rajab 832/2 May 1429 when Shāhrukh arrived at Baḥrābād. They were interrogated in front of the amīrs of the dīvān, including Amīr ‘Alī, Amīr Fīrūzshāh, Shaykh Luqmān, Khvāja Pīr Aḥmad, and others.Footnote 58 Some of these figures are quite famous in Timurid history, and the high profile of the interrogators obviously reflects the importance of the accused. During the interrogation, Amīr Nūrallāh was first accused of sending someone to assassinate Shāhrukh. He rejected the accusations and said that at the time of the assassination attempt he had left Tabriz, and had been on his way to Bitlis and Kurdistan for ten days. Amīr Fīrūzshāh immediately produced a letter as evidence written to the Royal Council (Dīvān-i Mīrzā) by Sayyid Shahristānī. In the letter, Sayyid Shahristānī claimed to have visited Amīr Nūrallāh in Tabrīz and had heard that he had sent someone to Herat to kill Shāhrukh. Khvāja Sayyidī Muḥammad, the letter claims, had also witnessed the conversation. Amīr Nūrallāh responded that Shāhrukh and his army were going to Tabrīz anyway to fight against the Qaraqoyunlu and they could easily give a visit to Sayyidī Muḥammad and inquire about the veracity of Sayyid Shahristānī's accusations themselves. Amīr Fīrūzshāh refused to involve Khvāja Sayyidī Muḥammad into the discussion.Footnote 59 According to him, the important point was that Amīr Nūrallāh had sent someone to kill Shāhrukh. Amīr Fīrūzshāh continued his accusations by suggesting that Amīr Nūrallāh joined Iskandar b. Qara Yūsuf (d. 841/1438) and gathered thirty thousand men to fight against Shāhrukh around Dāmghān and Simnān. Upon Amīrzāda Iskandar's request he raised the flag of rebellion in Tabriz, and killed seventy people, ripped open the wombs of women, and killed children on the road between Tabrīz and Sulṭāniyya.Footnote 60 Khvāja Pīr Aḥmad alleged that some tax irregularities were discovered in the books of Amīr Nūrallāh. The defiant Amīr Nūrallāh rejected the first allegation, but conceded that he was not in a position to respond to the question of his tax records, but he promised to check his records when he returned to Tabrīz.Footnote 61 The interrogators also reminded him of the accusation about his beliefs (dīn va maẕhab), but they did not pursue this point any further. Amīr Nūrallāh was imprisoned in the castle of Sarakhs and Ghiyās al-Dīn was sent to the Hinduvān Castle in Balkh.Footnote 62
After a year and seven months, Shāhrukh's army returned from the Qaraqoyunlu campaign, and when they arrived at the famous Sufi complex in Jām, Amīr Nūrallāh and Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad were brought back to the camp for further interrogations.Footnote 63 However, this time the interrogation was not about the assassination attempt, but it was about the fundamentals of the science of letters and the Ḥurūfī creed. Reflecting the change in emphasis, the interrogation was conducted not by the members of Shāhrukh's dīvān, but by Mawlānāzāda-yi Abharī, Mawlānā Nūrallāh, Mawlānā Faṣīḥ, and other scholars, whom Ghiyās al-Dīn collectively calls “the accursed scholars of the madrasa and the devils of Gog and Magog”. The scholars, especially Mawlānā Nūrallāh, tried in vain to pin down Amīr Nūrallāh's blasphemy (takfīr) by referring to his ideas on the science of letters. But his criticisms did not achieve anything other than attracting Shāhrukh's outrage over their inability to charge Amīr Nūrallāh with unbelief.Footnote 64 Upon the failure of the religious scholars to achieve any form of indictment, two amīrs from Azerbaijān, Khvāja Ghiyās al-Dīn, the son of Khvāja Nūr al-Dīn, who was a vizier of Iskandar b. Qara Yūsuf, and Busayḥāq, the son of Shaykh ‘Alī who was the grandson of Khvāja Zayn al-Din Ghazvīnī, leveled the same accusation that Amīr Fīrūzshāh had attempted before. They claimed that Amīr Nūrallāh, whom they called a sayyid, had said during a conversation with Mīrzā Iskandar that all the “Chaghataids” are infidels and he would send someone to kill Shāhrukh. Amīr Nūrallāh brought Sulṭān-Qazan Mīrzā as his witness to prove that all these allegations were false. Sulṭān- Qazan confirmed that the allegations were inaccurate.Footnote 65 The next interrogation appears to have been a big spectacle in the newly completed Gawharshād Madrasa in Herat.Footnote 66 Thousands of people gathered in addition to the Timurid administrative and intellectual dignitaries.Footnote 67 The questioning included such subjects as what kind of religion they adhered to, what Ḥurūfism was, whether they believed that wine was permissible in Islam, and whether Amīr Nūrallāh's lineage as a sayyid was reliable. At the end of the interrogation, they also failed to reach a definite judgment. Still Mawlānā Nūrallāh argued that they should be executed for claiming that wine was permissible in Islam, but Mawlānāzāda Abharī said that nothing was proven during the interrogation, and even if it was, Amīr Nūrallāh could not be executed because of his sayyid status. Curiously, Amīr Fīrūzshāh agreed with the latter opinion, and refused to order any execution.Footnote 68
The interrogations later continued, this time around in the presence of Ulugh Beg, who happened to be in Herat at that time.Footnote
69
Having seen the inability of the political and religious establishment of Herat to formulate a convincing case against two Ḥurūfīs, Ulugh Beg offered to take them to Samarqand so that the scholars and Sufi shaykhs of his own city could also get a chance to convict them of some sort of crime. In Samarqand, they were first put into a short and swift interrogation and questioned about the Ḥurūfī terminology, and then sent to the house of Amīr Bāyazīd Parvānachī.Footnote
70
At this point, Ghiyās al-Dīn speculates that the real incentive of Ulugh Beg in bringing them to Samarqand was not to punish them, but it was to learn the science of letters from them. Indeed, unlike the dull polemical nature of the debates in Herat, intellectually the interrogations in Ulugh Beg's court were more poignant and sophisticated. To start with, Ulugh Beg questioned the importance of the 32 letters in the Persian alphabet, and suggested that there were actually 33 letters, the extra letter being a vāv with three dots on the top, which was used by the Chinese. Amīr Nūrallāh responded to this proposition by giving the example of lām-alif (
) in the Arabic alphabet. If lām-alif is a separate letter instead of being a combination of the letters lām and alif, then the idea that the Persian alphabet consists of 33 letters would not be contrary to his own beliefs. Similarly, the question of the famous astronomer Qāżī-zāda-yi Rūmī (d. ca. 835/1431–32) about the meaning of the mahdī, the Muslim Messiah, or Ulugh Beg's question on the importance of the planets and stars according to Fażlallāh are both much more sophisticated than the problem of the legality of wine, and more pertinent in a political environment in which millenarian ideas posed a real challenge to the established political authorities in the central Islamic lands.Footnote
71
Ulugh Beg's question on the Vujūdīs (the followers of Ibn ‘Arabī), sheds light on the intellectual tensions among the Timurid intellectuals. Asked about who the Vujūdīs were, Amīr Nūrallāh stated that they were people like Sayyid Qāsim-i Anvār and Shāh Ni'matallāh Valī (d. 834/1431). Ulugh Beg asserted that Qāsim-i Anvār swore in front of him that he was not a Vujūdī. Amīr Nūrallāh responded that there were lots of differences between his views and the views of Qāsim-i Anvār.Footnote
72
Eventually, the frustrated Ulugh Beg gave up the idea of charging Amīr Nūrallāh and Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad with any kind of crime and decided to send them back to Herat. Shāhrukh, however, insisted that they should be executed for religious reasons, if not for anything else. Ulugh Beg categorically refused to obey his father's order. According to Ghiyās al-Dīn, Shāhrukh was so enraged with his son's behaviour that he even thought that Ulugh Beg himself had converted to Ḥurūfism. Nevertheless Ulugh Beg sent Amīr Nūrallāh and Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad back to Herat, where they were imprisoned. Shāhrukh later entrusted them to Amīr Ghunnāshīrīn, the darugha of Kirmān. From mid-Muḥarram, they remained in Kirmān for almost six months. On 8th Jumādā II, they managed to escape with the help of another dervish called Darvīsh Najm al-Dīn. First they went to Hurmuz, where they met with other Ḥurūfīs, including Darvīsh Maḥmūd Rūmī, Mawlānā Ibrāhīm, and Darvīsh Shaykh. From Hurmuz, they headed for Shīrāz, and eight months later, in Rabī‘ II (836/1433), they arrived in Baghdad, where they met with Shāh Muḥammad Qaraqoyunlu (d. 836/1433). Shāh Muḥammad welcomed them in Baghdad with great compassion. His radical religious views, especially his attempts to reconcile Islam with Jesus-loving ideas, are relatively well documented by the contemporary sources. It is even reported that he delegated the real authority to a “Christian” called ‘Abd al-Masīḥ, who had died just a few months before Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad and Amīr Nūrallāh arrived in Baghdad. He went so far as to dismiss his army and relieve all tax burdens for seven years. Curiously, Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad and Amīr Nūrallāh felt very uncomfortable with his religious views, especially with his ideas on the prophets. Without his permission they left Baghdad and went to Baqubah (spelled incorrectly Bā‘anqaba in the text), where Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad wrote the letter on 16 Jumādā I 836/8 January 1433.Footnote 73
Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad's letter has its own problems. Other than the theological arguments, which we can compare with other Ḥurūfī works, we have very few external sources to check the veracity of many of the incidents and interrogations mentioned in the letter. However, the chronology of the events and the identities of the figures from the Timurid establishment are remarkably accurate. It is therefore safe to suggest that the letter reflects how a prominent Ḥurūfī would like us to see the incident. Yet, we should not read this letter to find answers to such questions as whether Aḥmad-i Lur was really a Ḥurūfī or whether he was sent by the leaders of the Ḥurūfī community. Even if he was a Ḥurūfī and a hit man for another prominent Ḥurūfī, we should not expect Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad to accept any form of responsibility in the letter. What we can do is read the letter to map out the complex matrix of political and intellectual relationships in the 820s/1420s and 830s/1430s.
The letter was obviously intended to explain Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad's travails together with Amīr Nūrallāh after the assassination attempt. He is obviously incensed at the behaviour of some followers of Fażlallāh Astarābādī. Feeling abandoned, he accuses them in a rather spiteful tone of hypocrisy and not recognising the imām-i zamān and other descendents of Fażlallāh (makhdūm va makhdūmzāda). He says that some of them were worried about money, status, salary, their wives and children, or their lives, and some of them even tried to defend themselves by writing letters. He especially mentions two names: Sayyid Sharīf and Khvāja Sulaymān. Sayyid Sharīf is most probably Mīr Sayyid Sharīf, who authored several Ḥurūfī treatises, and Khvāja Sulaymān is probably one of the vicegerents of Fażlallāh mentioned by Mīr Sayyid Sharīf in his the Bayān al-Wāqi‘.Footnote 74 Therefore, Ghiyās al-Dīn's letter also carries a polemical tone against a rival or competing Ḥurūfī branch. As Shahzad Bashir discussed previously, a split in the Ḥurūfī community occurred some time after the death of Fażlallāh. The first group believed that the death of Fażlallāh had already completed the first prophetic cycle, and they were now all living in paradise. However, the second group believed that he had just initiated the first prophetic cycle, and would return in the near future to complete his work. ‘Alī al-A'lā (d. 1419), a prominent disciple of Fażlallāh, even calculated that the return of Fażlallāh would happen in 830/1426–1427. According to him, Fażlallāh's messianic return would entail three phases. He would descend to this world in Khorasan; acquire the party of the righteous in Mecca; and conquer the city of Constantinople.Footnote 75 Bashir expresses his doubt about the popularity of this view among the Ḥurūfīs. However, it is truly tempting to suggest that some Ḥurūfīs took the matter into their own hands and tried to set off the imminent return of the Messiah, i.e. Fażlallāh Astarābādī, and the eschatological apocalypse, by killing Shāhrukh. This point certainly requires further investigation on the history and theology of the Ḥurūfīs.Footnote 76 However, as I argued at the beginning of this article, the political and intellectual reverberations of the assassination attempt went beyond the Ḥurūfī networks, and I would like to turn my attention to other intellectuals who were also engulfed by its strong tides.
Ṣā’in al-Dīn Turka (d. 835/1431)
Ṣā’in al-Dīn Turka was from a prominent family in Isfahan, whose members included figures like Ṣadr al-Dīn Turka, the author of the Qawā’id al-tamhīd, and Afżal al-Dīn Turka, who translated Shahristānī's famous al-Milal wa al-nihal. Besides being one of the leading Timurid intellectual, Turka was also member of an informal network called Ikhvān al-ṣafa, which stretched from Iṣfahān to Cairo, and from Samarqand to Edirne, and included such prominent figures as Shaykh Ḥusayn Akhlāṭī, Sharaf al-Dīn ‘Alī Yazdī, Shaykh Badr al-Dīn Simavnavī, and ‘Abd al-Raḥmān al-Bisṭāmī.Footnote 77 Yazdī is a household name for the students of Timurid history, as his Ẓafarnāma is one of the most important sources for the biography of Timur. Shaykh Badr al-Dīn was a prominent Ottoman jurist, who was involved in a famous rebellion in 1416 that shocked the Ottoman ruling elite which was still trying to recover from the devastating defeat of 804/1402 by Timur at Ankara. ‘Abd al-Raḥmān al-Bisṭāmī (d. 858/1454) represented arguably the most sophisticated historian of the early Ottoman period, who, in a series of works, applied the science of letters in historiography. Sayyid Ḥusayn Akhlāṭī (799/1397) was the prophetic figure who brought all these separate intellectuals together, and he was the source of the specific understanding of the science of letters, which all the members of the Ikhvān al-ṣafā employed. As discussed by Cornell Fleischer recently, these intellectuals believed in a novel form of piety, which had its roots in Neo-Platonic philosophy, the mystical-prophetic philosophy of Ibn ‘Arabī, late antique Hermeticism, and a deep respect for ‘Alī b. Abī Ṭālib and his descendants. The science of letters was the pot in which they melted all these different intellectual traditions. Through the science of letters, they tried to achieve a comprehensive understanding of the cosmos, and a precise knowledge of past and future events.
Although Turka's interrogations in Herat are often associated with Aḥmad-i Lur's attempt to assassinate Shāhrukh,Footnote 78 under the light of simple chronological evidence, it is impossible to establish a causal relationship between his interrogations and the assassination attempt. Turka went to Herat twice to defend himself, first in 825/1422, and again sometime before 8 Rajab 829/16 May 1426, more than seven months before the assassination attempt.Footnote 79 We have no detailed record of Turka's interrogations, but we have several treatises that he wrote in order to refute the accusations. The defensive tone he adopts in these treatises demonstrates that he was under immense pressure coming from Shāhrukh's administration as well as from those intellectuals who opposed his views on the science of letters. Furthermore, Turka was engaged in intense pamphleteering around the time of the assassination attempt. A year before the assassination attempt, Turka had already composed at least twelve short treatises on the science of letters and other related issues in a period of about ten months. A preliminary list of the treatises that Turka composed before and soon after the assassination attempt would include the following titles:
al-Arba‘īniyya (13 Jumādā II 828/2 May 1425)
al-Bā’iyya (14 Ramażān 828/30 July 1425)
Risāla-yi nuqṭa (16 Ramażān 828/1 August 1425)
Risāla-yi inzāliyya (17 Ramażān 828/2 August 1425)
Asrār al-salāt (Yazd, 26 Ramażān 828/11 August 1425)
Risāla dar ma'na-yi qābiliyyat (Shavvāl 828/August-September 1425)
Aṭwār-i salāsa (Shavvāl 828/August-September 1425)
Risāla-yi anjām (17 Ẕū al-Qa'da 828/30 September 1425)
Al-Manzila ‘alā al-Ḥaḍrat al-Khatamiyya (3 Ẕū al-Ḥijja 828/16 October 1425)
Risāla-yi shaqq-i qamar va sā‘at (18 Rabī‘ I 829/28 January 1426)
Risāla-yi i'tiqādāt (Herat, 19 Jumādā I 829/29 March 1426)
Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i avval (Herat, 8 Rajab 829/16 May 1426)
Tuḥfat al-‘Alā’iyya (Jumādā 831/February-March 1428)
Madārij-i afhām al-afwāj fī tafsīr-i āyat-i samāniyya azwāj (6 Ẕū al-qa'da 831/17 August 1428)
Mabda’ va ma‘ād (Ṣafar 832/November-December 1428)Footnote 80
Turka's almost frantic pamphleteering just before the assassination attempt would suggest that he was in desperate need to explain himself to both the Timurid authorities and those other intellectuals in his own circle who were also under pressure. Among the above titles, especially two, the Risāla-yi i'tiqādāt and the Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i avval, are particularly relevant for our purposes, as they were written after Turka was called to Herat to defend himself against the accusation of being preoccupied with “Sufism” (taṣavvuf).Footnote 81 On the same subject, he wrote a third treatise entitled the Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i duvvum for Mīrzā Bāysungur. The published version of this treatise is dated to 17 Ramażān 838/16 April 1435, but so far I have not been able to determine its exact composition date. It was definitely written after the assassination attempt, as Turka occasionally alludes to this event, but it cannot have been so long after the assassination attempt, as Turka died in 835/1431–32 and Mīrzā Bāysunghur died in 837/1434.Footnote 82 A fourth treatise to which I will be referring is the Risāla-yi shaqq-i qamar va sā‘at, which was written a few months before the Risāla-yi i'tiqādāt, and reveals invaluable information regarding the taxonomies that Turka was applying in his defense. Below, I will try to reconstruct the outlines of the debate as much as possible without delving too deeply into the doctrinal issues.Footnote 83
Unfortunately, Turka provides few details regarding the interrogations. We do not know who was present, and we do not know how the interrogations were conducted. None of the intimate details that Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad provides are present in Turka's treatises. This is mainly because whereas Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad's letter was a personal, if not private, account of the incident, Turka's treatises were addressed to the reading public of the fifteenth century. Turka wrote these treatises to explain his ideas, not to explain a specific situation, hence the lack of references to how he was treated or what specific questions he had to answer in Herat. He says that he went to Khorasan from Yazd twice to defend himself in front of some religious dignitaries, and in the second instance, which was held in the Bagh-i Mukhtār, he submitted two petitions to Shāhrukh.Footnote 84
Turka tells us that he was accused of rejecting the Sunnī-Jamā‘ī creed and adhering to Sufism. He was also accused of practicing various sciences which were inherited from the prophets and saints and could not be understood by ordinary people.Footnote 85 Therefore, he composed the I'tiqādāt to demonstrate his proper Sunnī-Jamā‘ī credentials. He starts with the fundamentals of Islamic theology by asserting God's unity: “First of all, God is one in the truest sense of the oneness”, he says at the beginning of his defence, and continues, “unlike what the philosophers say, he does not need any other cause in creating the universe”.Footnote 86 Turka categorically rejects any accusation connecting him to the Mu'tazila, Shī‘a, or Falāsifa. He says that he and his followers are firm believers in the Sunnī-Jamā‘ī creed, but he also states that they are not imitators.Footnote 87 Turka's tone is sober but unapologetic in the Risāla-yi i'tiqādāt. He stresses the fact that he and people like him are staunch followers of the prophetic message, but they are simply closer to the truth due to their devotion to the Prophetic path. Towards the end of the treatise, he extends his praise to Shāhrukh—without actually naming him—and states, rather condescendingly, that since the rulers have also the inspiration (arbāb al-duwal mulhamūn), he should be able to understand him better than those slanderers (bad-gūyān).Footnote 88 Curiously, none of this self confidence and slight touch of patronisation are to be found in the following treatises.
The next treatise was also written in Herat, and projects a much more direct, even angry tone as its title would also suggest: Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i avval, or the “First Tubercular Spittle”.Footnote 89 It also includes detailed information regarding Turka's biography. He puts strong emphasis on his education in law, Qur’ānic commentary, and Prophetic traditions, and stresses his service as a judge.Footnote 90 In the intervening weeks, he obviously became much more intimately aware of Shāhrukh's religious policies. By publicly repudiating yasa and yarghu, the Chinggisid legal and political framework, and presenting himself as the champion of Sunnī Islam, Shāhrukh had been trying to expand the legitimisation basis of his centralising policies, and Turka was apparently supportive of these policies. He conspicuously praises Shāhrukh's policies of strengthening and renewing Sunnī Islām, and defends his activities and scholarship. He says that the Turco-Mongol Dīvān-i Yārghū, which had polluted the realm of Islam since the time of “previous pādishāhs”, i.e. the Mongols, was abolished, and today nobody had the courage to make this kind of juridical inquiry, except in disguise.Footnote 91 Obviously, he was astonished that Shāhrukh, whom he presents almost a champion of Sunnī Islam, would take the accusations seriously.
According to Turka, not only his father and his brother, both of whom were unequalled in their time, pursued the same knowledge that he did, but such prominent figures as Khvāja Muḥammad Pārsā, Khvāja ‘Abd Allāh Anṣārī, Khvāja Muḥammad Ḥakīm ‘Alī Tirmidhī, and Shaykh Sa'd al-Dīn Hāmūya would also agree with him in the issues of religion and law.Footnote 92 Those who accused him of being a Sufi had no idea what real Sufism was. What they understood by Sufism was just chanting elevated words in ecstasy and dancing like animals, and uttering the sentence “everything is God” without actually understanding what it meant. Not only this, they also abused the words of such great scholars as Shaykh Aḥmad-i Jām (d. 536/1141–42), Mawlānā-yi Rūm (d. 672/1273), and Fakhr al-Dīn ‘Irāqī (d. 688/1289).Footnote 93 Turka believed that true Islam was in fact practised not in Iran and Central Asia, but in the Ottoman lands. “Look at the land of Rūm (mamlakat-i Rūm)”, he said, adding:
The power of Islam is so strong in the land of Rūm that they go to Damascus and Egypt to study, and they reproach them, and they say that the rules of law are stronger in our land, such as that there is no tamghā. But, the people of Rūm such as Molla Shams al-Dīn Fanārī (d. 1431), who is the Chief Judge there, all studied these sciences and read those books, which they revile here.Footnote 94
In the treatises written before the assassination attempt, Turka presented the issue as a clash between those who imitated the prophetic way and those who pursued the prophetic message creatively. However, in the Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i duvvum, which was definitely written after the assassination attempt, the issue suddenly became personal. Turka stated that after the incident, he was immediately imprisoned and tortured, and sent to exile to Kurdistan and Azerbaijān. When Shāhrukh launched his second Qaraqoyunlu campaign in 832, he was living in Tabriz at the corner of a mosque. Turka met with Shāhrukh at Ṣā’in Qal‘ā sometime between 2 Ramażān 833/25 May 1430 and 30 Ẕū al-Qa'da 833/20 August 1430, and sought forgiveness. He went to Herat for nine months, where he waited in vain for a meeting with Shāhrukh.Footnote 95 He was probably still waiting when he died there in 835/1431–32.
In his efforts to acquire a hearing from Shāhrukh, Turka had certainly some practical motives, too. In the Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i duvvum, he demanded the easing of the shar‘ī taxes (takālīf-i shar‘ī) levied upon dervishes like him. These were probably the taxes that had been imposed upon them after the assassination attempt.Footnote 96 However, in general, he carefully drew a picture according to which he and dervishes like him were suffering because of the enmity of the rival intellectuals.Footnote 97
For Turka, his religious views were not different from any other Sufi-scholar, as he was a Shāf i‘ī-Sunnī intellectual with a deep knowledge on Islamic law. However, the source of the troubles that he and other intellectuals like him endured was their peculiar approach to the science of letters. It is evident that he had a deep sense of being misunderstood by his contemporaries. Therefore, it is worth having a quick look at how Turka saw the intellectual world of the fifteenth century in order to understand his mindset.
Turka provides a detailed taxonomy of the intellectual groups in the Risāla-yi shaqq-i qamar va sā‘at. In a short treatise written on 18 Rabī‘ I 829/28 January 1426, he contrasts seven different intellectual groups by comparing how they would interpret a specific Qur’ānic verse (54:1–2): “The Hour (of judgment) is nigh, and the moon has cleft asunder”.Footnote 98
Ahl-i ẓāhir, or the intellectuals who understand the outer meanings by specializing in the study of law and the prophetic traditions
Ahl-i ẓāhir, or the philosophers and theologians, who understand the outer meanings, but passed the level of imitation (taqlīd) and came close to the independent verification (taḥqīq)
Ḥukamā-yi ẓāhir va muta'akhkhirān, ḥukamā-yi mashshā’ī, or the contemporary peripatetic philosophers
Ḥukamā-yi qadīm, Ishrāqiyān, or ancient philosophers and the lluminationists (followers of Shihāb al-Dīn Suhrawardī (d. 591/1194))
Muḥaqqiqān-i ṣūfiyya va ahl-i shuhūd, or the Sufis
Ramz-khvānān-i ḥurūf-i Qur’ānī, or the intellectuals who are able to decipher the mysteries of the Qur’ānic letters
Martaba-yi ūlū al-aydī va al-abṣār, or those who are at the level of being pre-eminent in terms of authority and discernment
Turka's taxonomy is certainly one of the most comprehensive and sophisticated projections of the fifteenth-century Islamic life, and needs to be studied in itself.Footnote 99 For the purposes of this article, I will focus on last two groups, which appear to be the most controversial ones in the period leading up to the assassination attempt.
Turka identifies the sixth group in his taxonomy as the “decipherers of the Qur’ānic letters (Ramz-khvānān-i ḥurūf-i Qur’ānī)” and the “experts in the science of letters (Arbāb-i ‘ilm-i ḥurūf)”.Footnote 100 According to the intellectuals in this group, existence (vujūd) has multiple layers (marātib). Some of these layers are independent (mustaqill) and they can exist in themselves, such as the layers of spirits (arvāḥ), bodies (ajsād), and substances (ajsām). Some other layers are not independent and contingent on other layers, such as acts (af‘āl) and speech (aqvāl). The layer of words (martaba-yi kalām) has a special place among them, as all other layers also exist in the layer of words. Therefore, the meaning of all other layers becomes manifest in this layer. The science of letters becomes the fundamental key to understand all other layers, which by definition encompasses the existence in its entirety. The most radical aspect of the methodology of the Ahl-i ḥurūf is that everything becomes explainable – no secret is beyond the reach of a proper understanding of the science of letters. Turka says that: “from the beginning of the eternity without beginning to the end of the eternity without end, everything becomes manifest and nothing remains hidden”.Footnote 101
The seventh and last group, the Martaba-yi ūlū al-aydī va al-abṣār, is a puzzle to modern researchers. The name of this group can tentatively be translated as “those who are at the level of being pre-eminent in terms of authority and discernment”. Turka says that they were the distinguished people of his own time,Footnote 102 and they were superior to the experts in the science of letters.Footnote 103 They were the distinguished servants of the Prophet Muḥammad and the inheritors of his excellence. Turka hastens to add that unlike previous groups this seventh group is peculiar to the fifteenth century and their very presence is conditioned by a celestial conjunction.Footnote 104 So, who were these people? In brief, they were the holders of prophetic knowledge. According Turka, prophetic knowledge (kalām-i kāmil-i khātim al-nubuvva) embraces the totality of all other meanings, and the meanings of whatever happened in the past and will happen in the future. After the Prophet Muḥammad, only the Ahl-i Bayt, i.e. the descendants of the Prophet, could have had access to the totality of this knowledge. However, Turka continues:
Many masters with access the truth through the greatness of the divine grace of the unravelling of signs and the knowledge of discernment of emblems entered the right path of this knowledge. The great meanings become visible to them, but the entirety of the meanings and the totality of the wishes of obtaining this knowledge were not revealed to just anyone. . . . Indeed, the family of the Prophet (Ahl-i Bayt), who are his glorious descendants, were entrusted with jafr, which included the totality of meanings.Footnote 105
At the centre of Turka's discussion on the characteristics of the seventh group stands Prophetic knowledge, which was available only to his descendants through the Book of Jafr. The Book of Jafr is believed to include the knowledge of all the things and events in the past and in the future. In other words, whoever had access to this book could gain access to the knowledge about all things and events.Footnote 106
The belief in the presence of the Book of Jafr was already well established by the fifteenth century, especially among Shī‘ī-Ismā‘īlī circles. This is the reason why Corbin called Turka's seventh group the Shī‘īs straightforwardly. According the Lewisohn, the seventh group comprises simply the family of the Prophet, because Turka argued that the all-encompassing knowledge of the past, present and future would be revealed only to the descendants of the Prophet.Footnote 107 However, Turka adds that the intellectuals could acquire prophetic knowledge through discernment (taḥqīq) and intuitive knowledge (ẕawq) with the help of the science of letters. Furthermore, the seventh group existed only in Turka's own time. Had the seventh category included only the descendants of the Prophet, or sayyids, Turka would not have restricted its focus to the fifteenth century, as the sayyids had held prominent positions in the social and intellectual life since the early centuries of the Islamic history. Therefore, I would suggest that what Turka is referring to in this category is a much more restricted group, an informal intellectual network, in which Turka played an important role. It is possible that this informal network is actually the Ikhvān al-ṣafā’, which I introduced above, but we need further in-depth research to pursue this line of argumentation.
As the chronology of Ṣā’in al-Dīn Turka's treatises demonstrates, he was forced to defend himself against accusations already before the assassination attempt. He wrote the Risāla-yi i'tiqādāt on 16 Jumādā I 829/26 March 1426, and the Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i avval on 8 Rajab 829/16 May 1426.Footnote 108 In fact, he was forced to defend himself as early as in 825/1422, almost five years before the assassination attempt. Therefore, it would be possible to suggest that the political pressure on the intellectuals who believed in the primary position of the science of letters may have been only indirectly related to the actions of the Ḥurūfīs. This does not mean to suggest that the assassination attempt was an act of revenge, as this would mean all those accused intellectuals were affiliated with the Ḥurūfīs. In fact, as we will see below, they were not, and some of them were even hostile to the Ḥurūfīs. Yet, both the interrogations of the intellectuals and the assassination attempt were part of a wider conflict between Shāhrukh's administration and those intellectuals who believed in the potency of the science of letters.
Muḥammad al-Ṭūsī's Majma‘ al-tahānī
Muḥammad Ṭūsī's Majma‘ al-tahānī va maḥżar al-amānī is the only non-annalistic account of the assassination attempt with an unapologetically pro-Shāhrukhid stance. The authorship of the Majma‘ al-tahānī is a puzzle to solve. The author names himself Muḥammad Ṭūsī in the text without providing further details.Footnote 109 Ṣādiq Kiyā, who partially edited the text in 1954, identified the author as Mawlānā Ṭūsī, a protégé of Abū al-Qāsim Bābur b. Bāysunghur (d. 861/1457). Mawlānā Ṭūsī was an eminent story teller (masal-gūy) and poet, and after the death of Abū al-Qāsim Bābur, he went to Azerbaijān and Baghdād to the courts of Jahānshāh Qaraqoyunlu (d. 872/1467) and his son Pīr Budaq (d. 871/1466). He lived a long life, as he was still alive when Dawlatshāh Samarqandī completed his Taẕkirat al-shu'arā in 892/1487. Navā’ī reports that he was a hundred years of age when he died.Footnote 110 Ṭūsī's close relationship with Mīrzā Bāysunghur's family makes him a likely candidate for the authorship of the Majma‘ al-tahānī for the text ends with an extolment for the same Timurid prince.Footnote 111 However, Ṣādiq Kiyā overlooked the fact that Mawlānā Ṭūsī's name is not Muḥammad, but ‘Abdullāh.Footnote 112 Therefore, the more likely candidate for the authorship of the Majma‘ al-tahānī is Shaykh Muḥyī al-Dīn Muḥammad al-Ghazālī al-Ṭūsī, who was a prominent Sufi and a descendant of the twelfth-century scholar Muḥammad al-Ghazālī (d. 505/1111). The fragmentary information we have on his life suggests that he lived in his home town Ṭūs; he was a very pious man and had very close relationships with the sultans and the umarā’ of his time. He died in the vicinity of Aleppo on 24 Ramażān 830/19 July 1427, just five months after the assassination attempt, while traveling to Mecca for pilgrimage.Footnote 113 The contents of the Majma‘ al-tahānī favour the authorship of Muḥyī al-Dīn Muḥammad Ṭūsī, too. An odd section at the beginning requesting Shāhrukh's support for the repairs of charitable buildings (biqā‘) supports the argument that the author was associated with a scholarly family and large building complex, such as a madrasa or khanqāh.Footnote 114 Given his family background and prominent status in Ṭūs, Muḥyī al-Dīn Muḥammad Ṭūsī is the more likely candidate for the authorship of the Majma‘ al-tahānī.
An inexplicable affinity between the Majma‘ al-tahānī and Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's Zubdat al-tavārīkh puts Muḥammad Ṭusī in the close circle of pro-Shāhrukhid historians. Both texts resemble each other almost word for word especially in the section on the investigations following the assassination attempt, and they end with the same colophon and chronogram.Footnote 115 This similarity led some scholars to argue that the Majma‘ al-tahānī was one of the sources of Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū for his Zubdat al-tavārīkh. Footnote 116 As I demonstrated above in the first part of this article, the textual history of the Zubdat al-tavārīkh is exceedingly complicated, and it is almost impossible to determine which one is the source of the other. For the time being, I would like to leave this question open until further discoveries and other possible interpretations on this matter. Yet, the pro-Shāhrukhid nature of the Majma‘ al-tahānī stands beyond doubt.
The treatise is almost entirely devoted to the attempt on Shāhrukh's life. In an introduction, which exalts Shāhrukh to the level of a sacral ruler, Ṭūsī has no qualms about pronouncing the assassination attempt an intervention in the cosmic order. He says that “when the sultan changes, the time changes”, and “if a malady strikes the king of the land, all the horizons would also fall ill”.Footnote 117 For Ṭūsī, the assassination attempt is a regicide par excellence, aimed at disturbing the cosmic order embodied in the persona of Shāhrukh.
According to Ṭūsī, the zindīqs and mulḥids (“unbelievers”), and the followers of Ḥasan-i Ṣabbāḥ (the Ismā‘īlīs) are to be blamed for the assassination attempt. They are the ones who pervert the meanings of the words and follow the lead of the Devil. They try to explain the difficulties of the Qur’ān without knowledge, and comment upon it according to the rules and principles of the Devil. He complains about their intense activities, and that the assassination attempt was a futile tactical move to intimidate Shāhrukh and force him to retreat in his activities against the propagators of unbelief.Footnote 118 According to Ṭūsī, the attack occurred on a Friday at the Masjid-i Jāmi‘, as Shāhrukh headed towards his palace after the Friday prayer. Shāhrukh escaped the attack with little injuries, and the assailant, whom Ṭūsī does not name, was beheaded by the guards (chavushān). In order to send a strong signal to all who had witnessed the incident, they hung his head from the roof of the gate of the portico, and dumped the body.Footnote 119
The following section of the Majma‘ al-tahānī closely resembles Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's Zubdat al-tavārīkh. However, there are also some important differences in the two narratives. Muḥammad Ṭūsī does not reveal the name of Aḥmad-i Lur immediately. Instead, he quickly identifies Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt as the person who inspired the assailant and encouraged him to commit the crime. He says that a committee (majlis) consisting of the amīrs was set up to investigate the details of the assassination attempt. Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt was put under interrogation, but he did not say anything other than rejecting the accusations. The committee decided to torture him, and seeing the possibility of death, Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt revealed the names of various people who were engaged in unbelief (kufrān va khiẕlān).Footnote 120 The ulama issued a fatwā against him, arguing “an ingrate (kāfir-i ni'mat) is much worse than an infidel (kāfir), but Shāhrukh intervened and pardoned him.Footnote 121 This is most certainly related with the fact that Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt named ‘Ażud, a follower of Mawlānā Fażlallāh Astarābādī, as the mastermind of the whole conspiracy. Curiously, Ṭūsī does not refer to ‘Ażud's family relationship with Astarābādī.Footnote 122 ‘Ażud was also interrogated and tortured, and it is he who reveals the name of Aḥmad-i Lur in the version of the events as they are narrated by Muḥammad Ṭūsī.Footnote 123
Ṭūsī's account on Aḥmad-i Lur is very detailed. According to Ṭūsī, his “heresy” (ilḥād) and unbelief (zandaqa) was such that he even drank wine at some point, and just as the Christians believed in the coming of another prophet after Jesus, he also believed in the continuity of prophethood. According to Ṭūsī, Aḥmad-i Lur was a follower of Amīr Manūchihr b. Amīr Shaykh in Shirvān. After the death Amīr Manūchihr, Aḥmad-i Lur came to Khorasan to kill Shāhrukh.Footnote 124 To the best of my knowledge, the identity of Amīr Manūchihr has not been explained properly in modern scholarship.Footnote 125 He appears not to have had any direct relationship with the Ḥurūfī circles. In fact, Ṭūsī does not suggest that either Amīr Manūchihr or Aḥmad-i Lur were Ḥurūfīs, but that they both had the same motivation as Fażlallāh Astarābādī in deviating from the true path of Islam and taking the path of rebellion (‘iṣyān) and unbelief (ilḥād) instead.Footnote 126 In other words, the association of Aḥmad-i Lur with the Ḥurūfiyya was contextual, not personal.
Whatever Aḥmad-i Lur's association with the Ḥurūfīs, the wrath of Shāhrukh was nevertheless cast upon them. ‘Ażud and an unspecified number of his followers were beheaded in the marketplace of Herat, their bodies were later burned by the people of Herat and their heads were displayed on the porticos of the houses. Following the carnage in Herat, Shāhrukh showed his humility and generosity towards the people, a point which Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū also endorses, although Ṭūsī does not specify the nature of Shāhrukh's beneficence.Footnote 127
Muḥammad Ṭūsī concludes his treatise with a long section praising Shāhrukh and Mīrzā Bāysunghur. Ṭūsī's text challenges the conventional accounts of the assassination attempt from various angles, the most important one being the absence of a direct association between Aḥmad-i Lur and the Ḥurūfīs. This view, in fact, corroborates the account of Ghiyās al-Dīn Muḥammad's letter discussed above.
Zayn al-Dīn Khvāfī's Manhaj al-rashād
Zayn al-Dīn Abū Bakr Muḥammad Khvāfī was arguably one of the most prominent Sufis in Herat during the reign of Shāhrukh. He was a disciple of the Egyptian Nūr al-Dīn ‘Abd al-Raḥmān Miṣrī, and lived outside Herat where he commanded a considerable respect and authority among the Timurid ruling elite until his death during a plague outbreak on 2 Shavvāl 838/1 May 1435.Footnote 128 He wrote the Manhaj al-rashād in Rajab 831/April-May 1428, almost a year after the assassination attempt, in Herat.Footnote 129 We have no direct evidence to suggest that Khvāfī was arrested or interrogated after the assassination attempt. However, since he wrote a treatise in which he demonised certain followers of Ibn ‘Arabī, we can comfortably argue that the Manhaj al-rashād reflects on the circumstances of the period following the assassination attempt.
On the surface, the Manhaj al-rashād is a polemic against Ibn ‘Arabī and his views on vaḥdat-i vujūd, but it actually provides a much broader and sophisticated taxonomy of intellectual groups in his own time. According to Khvāfī, Ibn ‘Arabī's ideas are nothing more than an amalgamation of the ideas of the Sophists (Sūfisṭā’iyān), Materialists (Dahriyān), and Philosophers (Faylasūfān), and they are not the teachings of prophets and saints, but rather they are about the religion of treachery (dīn-i khiyānat).Footnote 130 He calls them the maẕhab-i mulḥidān who adopted the maẕhab-i vujūd va ittiḥād, i.e. the “sect of the unity of being”, and the views of the mashāyikh al-ṭarīqa, i.e. Sufi shaykhs.Footnote 131
The shortest definition of ilḥād for Khvāfī is the deviation from the path of the Book and the prophetic tradition. For example, the Sophists are apostates because they adopt the method of argumentation and disputation (munāẓara va mujādala).Footnote 132 Khvāfī divides the apostates into two large groups: Kuhna-mulḥidān and Naw-mulḥidān. The Kuhna-mulḥidān were simply a continuation of magians (majūsiyān) and fireworshippers (ātash-parastān). Confronted with the overwhelming power of Islam, those magians and fireworshippers decided to clothe themselves in an Islamic garb, and hid their own beliefs in the idea of the bāṭin, i.e. “gnosis”. What Khvāfi is trying to suggest is that the dichotomy of ẓāhir and bāṭin is in fact a legitimisation of the old Magian beliefs in the guise of an Islamic discourse.Footnote 133 The most prominent representative of the Kuhna-mulḥidān in early Islamic history was Ḥamdān-i Qarmāṭī (d. ca. 286/899), the eponymous leader of the Qarmaṭian movement in the ninth century. Khvāfī devotes a section of his treatise to Ḥamdān-i Qarmaṭī and suggests that he was sent to Iṣfahān to propagate his views. However, he was not successful in Iṣfahān as the people there were not wont to change their ideas on specific issues. Therefore, Qarmāṭī spread his views in Quhistān, and the famous Ḥasan-i Ṣabbāh (d. 518/1124), the leader of Niẓārī-Ismā‘īlīs in Alamūt, eventually emerged out of this propagation.Footnote 134
As for the Naw-mulḥidān, a term which denotes the mulḥids of the Timurid period, their ultimate aim was to eradicate Islamic law. According to Khvāfī, these latter-day apostates appear in three forms: Sophists (Sūfisṭā’iyān), Materialists (Dahriyān), and those Philosophers who do not follow any prophet (Falsafiyān-i ghayr-i tavābi‘-i payghambarān), and finally the “Proponents of the unity of being” (Vujūdiyān).Footnote 135 The Sophists are those who believe that things have no existence (vujūdī) and permanence ( sabātī), and whatever we see is illusion and fantasy (khayālāt va mawhūmāt), and their ultimate purpose is to overthrow prophecy and law (nubuvvat va sharī‘at). He also argues that they were the proponents of the unity of being (Vujūdīs), too. They should be beaten and burnt so that they understand that the scourge of beating and the fire of burning have also existence (vujūdī dārad), and confess that the things have existence in this world.Footnote 136 As for the Materialists (Dahriyān), according to Khvāfī, the term mainly refers to those who believed in the eternity of life and being.Footnote 137 The Dahriyān reject the Day of Judgment, and the Day of Resurrection, but they do not deny the existence of God.Footnote 138 Khvāfī seems to be using the term Philosophers (Faylasūfān) in an even broader sense. He says that the philosophers are those who do not see politics and law, and temporal authority (lit. ḥall: elliptically for ḥall va ‘aqd, ‘loosing and tying’) and veneration (ḥurmat) as an important affair in this life, and that Heaven and Hell, and reward and punishment are all in this world, not in the afterlife.Footnote 139 He is particularly disturbed by the fact that some of his contemporaries took the guidance of the Greek philosophers (ḥukamā-yi Yūnān) rather than the prophets.Footnote 140
The idea that tied all three beliefs to the category of the Naw-mulḥidān was the Maẕhab-i Vujūdiyān. The fundamental belief of the Vujūdiyān was that existence is unique (vāḥid) and that existence itself is God truly and exclusively (rāst va bas). Other than God, nothing has any existence. The existence of God does not have any external attribution (ta'ayyun), and the existence of those visible things are the existence of God. The attributes of these visible things are the attributes of the Divine Knowledge (‘ilm-i ilāhī), not the attributes of their visible being (ta'ayyunāt-i ‘aynī). In other words, the existence of God (vujūd-i Ḥaqq) and the existence of creatures (vujūd-i khalq) are the same thing.Footnote 141
If these Naw-mulḥidān say that the things have no existence other than their existence in God's unity, they are Sophists, and they commit blasphemy by rejecting the Qur’ān and the Day of Judgement. And if they claim that the created things have existence, but their existence is indistinguishable from God's existence, then it means that God's existence also has the qualities of life such as birth and death. Therefore, the idea of the vaḥdat-i vujūd is false.
The Manhaj al-rashād is a defense of Khvāfī's own position as a prominent intellectual of Herat. Khvāfī seems to have felt a certain pressure and needed to clarify his ideas. In every section, it is obvious that Khvāfī's main concern was the very unity of the community, which was established and secured by the Qur’ān and the sunna. Khvāfī constantly points the finger at the followers of Ibn ‘Arabī, or the Naw-mulḥidān, who were responsible for destroying the unity of the community. Shāhrukh, according to Khvāfī, had exerted great efforts to support the sharī‘a and abolished the Chinggisid law (tura-yi Changiz Khān), and now all those people with false beliefs (bad-maẕhabān) in all corners of the world became increasingly daring in rejecting the prophetic traditions and law, and he encourages Shāhrukh to eliminate them.Footnote 142
Khvāfī's intention in his treatise is not simply to attribute a genealogy for various intellectual movements that he does not approve of in his own time, and reading his work to discover the traces of late antique and early medieval sectarian movements would be falling into the trap of Khvāfī's aggressive rhetoric. In fact, Khvāfī was trying to formulate a new taxonomy according to which the political authority, i.e. Shāhrukh in this case, is warned about the limits of what is acceptable and what is not. His rhetoric is so petulant that no other person other than his own followers would escape persecution. Therefore, it would be naïve to suggest that the Manhaj al-rashād was entirely unrelated to the purges of intellectuals which had been going on since the late 820s/1420s and peaked after the assassination attempt in 830/1427. What we cannot tell, at this point, is whether the Manhaj al-rashād was a defensive or offensive treatise. It is possible that suspicion fell on him due to his connections to the intellectual circles of Azerbaijān—he was a disciple of Kamāl Khujandī in Tabrīz—and because of the significant influence he had on the Timurid ruling elite in Herat.Footnote 143 On the other hand, Khvāfī was also known to be a fierce opponent of Ibn ‘Arabī and his idea of the vaḥdat-i vujūd. He did not even hesitate to attack his own protégé, Aḥmad Samarqandī, for reciting the poetry of Qāsim-i Anvār during his sermons in Herat, and persecute him and those close to him. As Shahzad Bashir observed, Khvāfī considered the notion of vaḥdat-i vujūd “amongst the most reprehensible intellectual movements in Islamic history”.Footnote 144 Therefore, in the context of the assassination attempt, Khvāfī's Manhaj al-rashād appears to be an attempt to exploit the situation in which the tide turned against those who subscribed to the idea of the vaḥdat-i vujūd.
IV. Conclusion
After a close examination of the sources, we appear to be in a worse position in terms of understanding the regicide attempt on 23 Rabī‘ II 830/21 February 1427 than we were at the beginning of this article. There is almost no single element in the story of Aḥmad-i Lur and Shāhrukh that remains unchallenged by another source, and we are left with no definite answer to the question of what really happened on that day, in Herat, after the Friday prayer. Who was Aḥmad-i Lur? Was he a Ḥurūfī assassin ordered to kill Shāhrukh, as Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū and ‘Abd al-Razzāq Samarqandī would like us to believe, or was he sent by someone else to assassinate Shāhrukh, as Muḥammad Ṭūsī seems to be suggesting? What was the role of the Ḥurūfīs? Were they the troublesome heretics or were they simply scapegoats who were easy targets for branding as heretics or unbelievers? What about Ṣā’in al-Dīn Turka, who was arrested and interrogated long before the assassination attempt? How were his troubles connected to the assassination attempt? Was Zayn al-Dīn Khvāfī simply scared when he menacingly brandished the accusation of ilḥād against many other Timurid intellectuals—especially the ones who centred around Iṣfahan, or did he really believe that those unbelievers were about to take over the world? It is indeed difficult to build up a case based on the evidence available to us. However, in an investigation, be it a criminal or a historical one, actors matter as much as the motives and processes, and with a few exceptions, our sources demonstrate a remarkable consistency in emphasising the actors: Shāhrukh was the target, the assassin was Aḥmad-i Lur; the Ḥurūfīs were either the perpetrators or victims, but other intellectuals, especially those who professed the science of letters, were definitely the victims.
One important exception is Mīrzā Bāysunghur. If we solely believe Samarqandī, how can we explain Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū's failure to mention his patron's presence on such an eventful day? After all, it was to Mīrzā Bāysunghur that he dedicated the Zubdat al-tavārīkh-i Bāysunghurī. Perhaps he was trying to hide his patron's misjudgement, which led to the killing of the most important witness to the event, Aḥmad-i Lur. But if Mīrzā Bāysunghur was not present, why would Samarqandī put such a prominent Timurid prince in the boots of someone who failed to protect his father and his king? Indeed, Mīrzā Bāysunghur's role in the whole event invites suspicion. We do not really know what the nature of his relationship with Ma'rūf-i Khaṭṭāt and the reason of his enmity toward Qāsim-i Anvār was. Muḥammad Ṭūsī's account of Mīrzā Bāysunghur is particularly noteworthy. Ṭūsī ends his treatise with a long dedication to Mīrzā Bāysunghur, in which he ascribes the title sulṭān to him and calls him the original king (pādishāh-i aṣl). He goes on to describe how Mīrzā Bāysunghur's temper and qualities would be suitable for rulership.Footnote 145 It is curious that Ṭūsī left his hometown soon after the assassination attempt and died en route to Mecca. Mīrzā Bāysunghur commanded an enormous respect in the army and among the learned classes of the capital Herat, and he had been a de facto heir designé at least since 819/1416, when he was appointed as the amīr-i dīvān. He was also an accomplished calligrapher and a great patron of artistic production in Herat.Footnote 146 Yet his exact role in the events of 830/1426–27 is still shrouded in mystery.
Shāhrukh is touted to have been a great restorer of Sunnī Islam, and he was in fact relatively successful in casting himself as the defender of the shar‘ī principles after Timur, who, by contrast, had been presented by the Timurid historians as the great supporter of the Chinggisid principles of politics.Footnote 147 However, as the most recent research has demonstrated, the relationship of Shāhrukh with the Timurid intellectuals was a contested and constantly negotiated affair.Footnote 148 The events surrounding the regicide attempt highlight the fact that Shāhrukh must have been seriously worried about his authority vis-à-vis the learned classes towards the middle of his reign.Footnote 149 The prevalence of messianic movements is a symptom of the political momentum gathering around radical millenarian ideologies, but it seems as though the problem did not simply consist of the containment of intellectual movements that had a direct political agenda, but it was rather about how to define and control the intellectual sphere which had been increasingly gaining autonomy either in the form of Sufi networks, such as the various competing Khvājagānī lineages in Central Asia, or in the shape of informal intellectual networks, such as the fifteenth-century Ikhvān al-ṣafā. The growing participation of intellectuals in the formal or informal intellectual networks created a new and independent intellectual sphere, which the Timurids often tried to control and manipulate through patronage and administrative regulation.Footnote 150 This cohabitation of the political and intellectual spheres appears to have turned into an open conflict in the late 820s/1420s, when Shāhrukh decided to interfere in the organisation of intellectual networks. What triggered this change of mind on Shāhrukh's part is not certain, but it is possible that the affair of Isḥāq Khuttalānī and his disciple Sayyid Nūrbakhsh, who led a messianic rebellion in 826/1423 in Khuttalān, was a decisive moment when Shāhrukh decided to be proactive about attempting to regulate the intellectual sphere on his own terms.Footnote 151
The cases of Zayn al-Dīn Khvāfī and Ṣā’in al-Dīn Turka epitomise the conflict as a whole and herald the status of Sufi networks in the second half of the fifteenth century. The former played a prominent role among the emerging Sufi networks, and the latter was the leading figure in the cluster of the informal network called Ikhvān al-ṣafā in Fārs. Khvāfī distanced himself from any form of political ambition by resorting to invented traditions and the “revival” of the perceived ills of earlier Islamic centuries, such as the Qarmaṭīs, the Ismā‘īlīs, and the Bāṭinīs, whereas Turka tried in vain to explain what he was trying to propose without reverting to centuries-old clichés and tropes. Shāhrukh and his powerful amīrs preferred the ways of the former and punished the latter.
Whether the regicide attempt was a genuine Ḥurūfī plot or not, the Ḥurūfīs and those intellectuals who adopted the science of letters as a method of inquiry and organised themselves in informal intellectual networks bore the brunt of the purges in the wake of the assassination attempt. They were actually minor players in a bigger game in which the cards were dealt for a new age, in which new forms of polities, politics, and a new form of piety were about to be born.
Abbreviations
HMA
Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū (d. 833/1430). Mu'izz al-Ansāb. Paris Bibliothèque Nationale Ms. ancien fonds pers. 67.
HAB
Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū. Zubdat al-tavārīkh. 4 vols. Ed. Sayyid Kamāl Ḥajj Sayyid Javādī, Tehran, 1380 H.sh./2001–02.
HAJ
Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū. Jughrāfiyā-yi Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū-Bakhsh-i Khurāsān = Dorothea Krawulsky (ed.), Ḫorāsān zur Timuridenzeit nach dem Tārīḫ-e Ḥāfeẓ-e Abrū (verf. 817–823 h.). Wiesbaden, 1982.
JTK
Ja'farī, (fl. 851–855/1447–1451), Tārīkh-i kabīr. St Petersburg Gosudarstvennaia publichnaia biblioteka im. M. E. Saltykova-Shchedrina Ms. Pers. Nov. Seriia 201; Târîh-i Kebîr (Tevârîh-i Enbiyâ ve Mülûk, facsimile ed. and trans. İsmail Aka, Ankara, 2011.
KHS
Khvāndamīr (d. 946/1539–40). Ḥabīb al-siyar fī akhbār-i afrād-i bashar. Ed. J. Humā’ī and M. Dabīr-Siyāqī, Tehran, 1380 H.sh./2001.
KMF
Faṣīḥ al-Khvāfī (d. 849/1445). Mujmal-i Faṣīḥī. Ed. Sayyid Muḥammad Nājī Naṣrābādī, Tehran, 1386 H.sh./2007–2008.
KMR
Zayn al-Dīn Khvāfī, (d. 838/1435). Manhaj al-rashād. Published in Najib Māyil Haravī (ed.), Īn barghā-yi pīr. Majmu'a-yi bīst asar-i chāp-nashuda-yi fārsī az qalam-rū-yi taṣavvuf, Tehran, 1381 H.sh./2002–2003.
MGM
Abdülbaki Gölpınarlı, “Faḍlallāh-i Ḥurūfī’nin oğluna [sic.] ait bir mektup,” Şarkiyat Mecmuası 1(1956): 37–57.
MRS
Mīrkhvānd (d. 903/1498). Rawżat al-ṣafā’ fī sīrat al-anbiyā’ wa al-mulūk wa al-khulafā. 10 vols., ed. ‘Abbās Parvīz, Tehran, 1338–9 H.sh./1959–60.
MTMA
Muḥammad Ṭūsī, Majma‘ al-tahānī va maḥżar al-amānī, ed. Najīb Māyil Haravī in Majmū‘a-yi rasā’il-i fārsī 3 (1372 H.sh./1993): 9–43; Tehran Kitābkhāna-yi Millī-yi Malik Ms. 477/3, ff. 1b-31b.
NMT
Naṭanzī, Mu‘īn al-Dīn (f. 816/143–14). Muntakhab-i tavārīkh-i Mu‘īnī = Extraits du Muntakhab al-Tavarikh-i Muini (Anonyme d'Iskandar), ed. Jean Aubin, Tehran, 1336 H.sh./1957.
PL3
Storey, C. A., Adabiyāt-i fārsī. Trans. to Russian. Y. E. Bregel and trans. to Persian Yaḥyā Āryanpūr et al., Tehran, 1362 H.sh./1983–84
SMS
Samarqandī, Kamāl al-Dīn ‘Abd al-Razzāq (d. 887/1482). Maṭla‘-i sa'dayn va majma‘-i baḥrayn. Vol. I.1: Ed. ‘Abd al-Ḥusayn Navā’ī, Tehran, 1353 H.sh./1974; Vol. I.2. Ed. ‘Abd al-Ḥusayn Navā’ī and Vol. II.1 and II.2. Ed. Muḥammad Shafi‘ in 1941–49 in Lahore [re-set by Navā’ī] Tehran, 1383 H.sh./2004–05.
TNMA
Turka, Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī (835/1431–32). Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i avval. Published in Chahārdah risāla-yi fārsī az Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī b. Muḥammad Turka-yi Iṣfahānī, eds. Sayyid ‘Alī Mūsavī Bihbahānī and Sayyid Ibrāhīm Dībājī, (Tehran, 1351 H.sh./1972), pp. 169–94.
TNMD
Turka, Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī. Nafsat al-maṣdūr-i duvvum. Published in Chahārdah risāla-yi fārsī az Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī b. Muḥammad Turka-yi Iṣfahānī, pp. 197–217.
TRI
Turka, Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī. I'tiqādāt. Published in Chahārdah risāla-yi fārsī az Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī b. Muḥammad Turka-yi Iṣfahānī, pp. 219–64.
TRShQS
Turka, Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī. Risāla-yi Shaqq-i qamar va sā‘at. Published in Chahārdah risāla-yi fārsī az Ṣā’in al-Dīn ‘Alī b. Muḥammad Turka-yi Iṣfahānī, pp. 101–17.
TZT
Ḥāfiẓ-i Abrū (?), Tatimma-yi Zubdat al-tavārīkh-i Bāysunghurī. Oxford Bodleian Library Ms. Elliot 422, ff. 440b-446b.
YZN
Yazdī, Sharaf al-Dīn ‘Alī (d. 858/1454). Ẓafarnāma. 2 vols. Eds. Sa‘īd Mīr Muḥammad Ṣādiq and ‘Abd al-Ḥusayn Navā’ī, Tehran, 1387 H.sh./2008–09. evrim.binbas@rhul.ac.uk
