This well-researched and engaging study convincingly demonstrates the degree to which our present scholarly understanding of the early Naqshbandiyya (before the 17th-century Mujaddidiyya) has been due to scholars' overemphasis on 19th century Mujaddidi and Khalidi sources that have been projected uncritically into the past. The author, using mostly Arabic and Ottoman sources spanning a 250-year period, also corrects the still all too common perception of well-organized and politicized Sufi lineages. Le Gall shows how early Ottoman Naqshbandi self-promotion as a shari

a-minded lineage with a superior mystical practice is balanced with open veneration of Shi

i imams. Nor were the early Naqshbandis as anti-Shi

i as 19th-century sources would have us believe. In short, the author has not only refocused scholarly perception of the early Ottoman Naqshbandiyya, but she has retuned scholarly approaches to the study of Sufism.
The book discusses Sufi organization through an insightful presentation of lineage identity, genealogy, and modes that Naqshbandis have used to expand their geographical range—from Khwaja Ahrar to the Safavid period and the establishment of the Naqshbandiyya in Ottoman Istanbul. Particularly useful is the author's inquiry into nonhereditary succession, an analysis of lineal continuity (why some subbranches of lineages end and others continue for centuries), and the factors promoting such (rare) continuity in the Ottoman context. Le Gall convincingly shows how a shaykh's influence has little relationship to the number of disciples or government patronage. Indeed, even the number of Naqshbandi Sufi lodges in Istanbul at any given time does not correlate with Naqshbandi influence (for most of the period studied the Khalwatiyya were the most “politically popular” lineage). Nor do the Naqshbandiyya overwhelm the ranks of the ulema in Istanbul, despite their professed shari

a mindedness. Scholarly arguments based upon the quantitative data found in biographical treatises have been further compromised.
After a two-chapter overview of the Naqshbandiyya in the Balkans, Anatolia, and Arabia, the study concentrates on spiritual practice and its relationship to Naqshbandi constructions of orthodoxy. Le Gall outlines the complexity of practice, ranging from silent dhikr and forty-day solitary retreats to an explicitly ascetic practice—the common thread being a mode of sobriety. Many Naqshbandi shaykhs of this period were avid Ibn al-

Arabi advocates which, combined with Persian literary culture, could explain why the early Naqshbandiyya had many admirers in the non-Arab Ottoman lands but were significantly less popular in the Arab world.
The author has consulted a wide range of sources ranging from waqf documents to devotional manuals, including an array of relevant manuscripts. The end result is a nuanced, pioneering account of early Ottoman Naqshbandi Sufism. A Culture of Sufism could be used in an upper level course in Sufism, especially with the useful ten-page glossary, which—in addition to the writing style—makes the book accessible to nonspecialists. There are few English works on Sufism that effectively address the confluence of Central Asian, Indian, and Ottoman spheres, making this study a valuable contribution to Sufi studies in general, both analytically and geographically. It should be in every university library.
