In 2011, eighteen scholars from history, classics and religious studies convened a workshop at the University of California, Davis. Four years later, this book of essays appeared, published by the University of California Press, edited by Catherine Chin and Moulie Vidas. In the words of its opening paragraph — that place where authors can patiently tie a lure and cast a hook for other readers — the book is about: ‘how the process of knowing shared a variety of historical actions in late antiquity, and in turn how a variety of historical actions and circumstances produced what became the content and practice of knowing’ (1). The editors go on to explain that they ‘consider late ancient knowing to be both the intellectually grasping of knowledge, as late antique epistemology suggests, but also, and more important, the very practical process of negotiating the late ancient world as it was known, or as it came to be knowable’ (1). Scholars who find opaque theoretical reflection and frustrating jargon unappealing may unfortunately swim right by.
What the best essays in Late An cient Knowing do is showcase how a scholar's creativity and imagination can bring the late antique past back to life in unique ways. In many chapters, the contributors have dared to leave the comfort of a traditional approach and are clearly testing the waters of expression. A chapter called ‘Artifact’ boldly features no images, but is based rather on an interpretation of a Hebrew text, the mishnah, and how it sets forth rules for interacting with objects (M. Balberg). Another, on the many languages spoken in the late antique period, flirts with an anti-narrative structure and self-consciously ‘embraces an aesthetic of being incomplete and unfinished’ (75) (J. Schott). ‘Rather than attempt a coherently unfolding, scroll-life account of late ancient specialist knowledges … this chapter explores the late ancient “book of the cosmos” as a vade mecum or enchiridion for late ancient practical knowledge and action’ (59).
The experiments continue. A ‘transdisciplinary’ (91) chapter on ancient medicine — crossing philosophy, astrology, science and religion (H. Marx-Wolf) — begins with a reflection on the birth of the author's first child and the moments spent, as a parent, ‘reading Porphyry on the plantlike nature of the fetus’, only suddenly to grow aware of how ‘the baby [was] repeatedly banging a foot into my ribs’ (82). In a fourth chapter, the writer looks at late antique authors who used animals, like the ‘clever ox’ (37) of rabbinic literature, to investigate the human condition (B. Berkowitz). And, in perhaps the most striking moment of the book, one writer recounts the dramatic rediscovery of a lost Latin agricultural treatise, then gives a translation of and commentary on it (243–51) (C. Grey). Only in an afterword is the illusion revealed: the writer has fabricated the account to talk about the challenges of writing about the people of the countryside — non-urban dwellers, that is — historical folks whose way of life, economic realities and social struggles are, indeed, rarely documented. (Vladimir Nabokov's estate will no doubt see a spike in the sale of his 1962 novel Pale Fire, his own invented-text-with-commentary.) All these somewhat unorthodox texts exist, and admirably I might say, on an island of their own invention.
That is not to say the book is driven by experimentalism. Other chapters offer straightforward, traditional surveys, likely to appeal to readers with a more meat-and-potatoes approach to social and cultural topics. There is an excellent comparative political discussion of what it meant to be the leader of an empire during the time of both Rome and Sasanian Persia (M. Canepa), and a thorough discussion of the levels of distinction that were perceptible in late Roman society and shaped people's futures (M. Kulikowski). One contribution is a neat, refreshing exploration of how people who served in churches gradually came to understand their role as something distinct from the world around them, something inherently ‘clerical’ (K. Sessa).
The editors’ focus (both have appointments in religious studies) has certainly shaped the tenor of the book, and it is nice to see the history of religious ideas in antiquity treated so earnestly here. A chapter on the mental grip that angels had over people's lives (E. Muehlberger) is followed later by a similar approach to demons (D. Kalleres). ‘God’ (L. Ayres) and the ‘Cosmos’ (C. Chin) also each merit discussion. As for the discussion of religious change in the Roman world over time, ‘Christianization’ (E. Watts), the presentation is perhaps not daring enough — too caught up in received dichotomies about non-Christian v. Christian belief and overlooking new appreciation for the creative ways in which all ancient people navigated Roman society through their actions, choices and behaviour. ‘Pagans did not need to believe anything in particular; they merely needed to honor the gods appropriately’; ‘traditional Mediterranean religion was defined by actions, not beliefs’ (210).
So what have these participants hauled in from their workshop? The fairest move would be to let the editors describe their own catch: ‘These essays show us a late ancient knowing that is a habit of systematization built on epistemological heterogeneity, an inquiry after a singular, universal rationality that is nonetheless experienced from multiple, incomplete perspectives’ (11). I wished, notwithstanding the introduction, which strings together (in less than two paragraphs) C. Ando, The Matter of the Gods, D. Lehoux, What Did the Romans Know?, T. Kuhn, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions and M. Foucault, The Archaeology of Knowledge, that the editors had taken more time to explain not just how this book is situated in the field of cognition, but also how it is situated in the broader field of ancient Mediterranean and late antique studies.
Perhaps that would have clarified some of their choices. Why, for example, are angels and demons separated as topics when religion scholars like John J. Collins and others have long identified them as belonging to a coherent worldview? Apocalyptic thinking, with its associated trope of spiritual warfare, is an important feature of the fourth- and fifth-century Roman political conversation. And its twinned protagonists, born in the crucible of Second Temple Judaism, would go on to shape the history of the Jesus movement, as well as the sixth- and seventh-century world of the East Roman (‘Byzantine’) Empire and the ‘Believers’ movement of early Islam. The editors’ decision to present these beings as if they were discretely knowable – ‘angels’ in one chapter, ‘demons’ in another – hinders researchers of a social-historical persuasion who want to analyse how belief in spiritual battles may have motivated the changing political culture of the late Roman Empire. This discussion would have dovetailed nicely with the reflections, in this book's afterword, on what precisely may have characterised a late ancient ‘worldview’ (286) (M. Gleason). Strange too, given recent work on the agency of material culture, that a chapter exploring a specific data-set from the physical world is missing. Surely something could have been said about how, say, staring at the grisly images of an execution by lions at the bottom of one's party plates taught (or, if you prefer, ‘structured knowledge for’) many wealthy Romans about the history and myths of Christianity. Not everyone learns in the abstract.
