Prospective readers of Melissa Shields Jenkins's insightful book about Victorian fatherhood should understand, first of all, that it is only partially and intermittently concerned with Victorian fathers. It is rather the second term of the book's title that most impels this study, which is fascinated by problems of authority as it appeared to the Victorian novelists who sought to claim it, subvert it, or revise it in their literary work. The fathers in this book are thus presented primarily as instances of or figures for a broader idea of fatherhood, a “complex abstraction” (8) through which authority extended its reach from family relationships to such diverse domains as religion, science, politics, and, above all, the literary tradition.
Each of the book's six chapters examines the struggles of an individual novelist to come to terms with the implications of fatherly authority. The chapters are organized into three sets according to a structure Jenkins has derived by layering two tripartite systems for classifying authority, one suggested by John Stuart Mill and the other by Max Weber, to produce what she calls “a taxonomy—a working map” (3) with which to distinguish forms of patriarchal authority. The resulting system organizes the chapters under the three heads of traditional, charismatic, and legal-rational forms of authority. In practice, however, these overlapping abstractions do little to enrich the individual chapters or bring them into productive dialogue, and the structure sometimes complicates the analysis needlessly (especially in the final section). The book's real value lies not in this unwieldy scheme of classification, but rather in its individual chapters.
The first of these argues that Elizabeth Gaskell's work on her biography of Charlotte Brontë—and especially on the troublesome figure of Brontë's father, Patrick—led in Gaskell's later fiction to a revised and more complicated representation of fatherhood, and therefore of literary conventions and narrative authority more broadly. The following chapter, on George Meredith, turns from biographies to men's conduct books and shows how Meredith's suspicion of those old tutelary volumes and their systems of patriarchal education mirrors his distaste for an authoritative literary tradition from which he could not wholly disengage. The two chapters of the second section focus on performative dimensions of paternal authority, albeit on performances that are supported by established texts. The subject of family prayer books, which advised fathers how best to lead their families and servants in spiritual devotions, leads Jenkins to a fresh approach to Thackeray's ambivalent and evolving relationship to the dubiously theatrical power of sentimentality in novels. Political speeches supplant sermons in the next chapter, in which Jenkins argues that George Eliot's sense of fiction's potentially broad and transformative moral influence prompted her to imagine ways in which a politically potent rhetoric of fatherhood might be appropriated as a performative stance by speakers who were not fathers themselves.
The final pair of chapters resists easy classification in the book's scheme, which presents them as case studies of a more worldly paternal authority; in fact, each is concerned specifically with the burdens of inheritance as it weighs upon the present. The fifth chapter centers on that noted father-hater, Samuel Butler, finding that his filial rebellion shaped his understanding of intellectual inheritance in surprising ways, from his iconoclastic approach to the systematization of received wisdom in libraries and museums, to his curious Lamarckian interpretations of instinct as inherited knowledge. The final chapter considers Thomas Hardy's figuration of fatherhood through books and palimpsestic texts to represent haunting problems of literary authority and history's indelible shadow.
In each of these chapters, Jenkins's central focus of analysis is an authorial career, which is one of the book's great strengths. While many critics would be content to concentrate on a single, exemplary text, Jenkins manages both to illuminate individual works and to provide a sense of their dynamic coherence with one another. This approach requires a considerable amount of research, which is rewarded by the book's ability to capture the arc of a writer's career as successive novels revise and refigure persistent themes. Adept at describing these broad patterns, Jenkins is also attentive to particular details, and she shows herself to be an admirably talented close reader. Her analyses are sensitive to the implications of metaphors in the texts she studies, especially in tracing the many instances in which these authors employ figures of family relations and textual production to express one another.
Some readers may find this book's approach to fatherhood too narrowly literary, and certainly Jenkins tacks against the prevailing currents of a more thoroughly historicist cultural criticism. Though Jenkins attends in almost every chapter to some extraliterary textual mode—such as biographies, books of men's maxims, family prayer guides—these genres receive little analysis in their own right and are sometimes subsumed, along with novels, into broader notions of textuality or writing. Moreover, in conflating fatherhood with ahistorical patterns of authority and an abstract patriarchal literary tradition, the book pays scant attention to the many concrete and practical ways in which Victorian notions of fatherhood (not to mention relevant ideals of manliness and childhood) were challenged and redefined during the period. There is historical context in Jenkins's argument, but it serves as a relatively inert backdrop before which her six novelists act out their idiosyncratic professional dramas.
Other scholars will certainly benefit from the book's impressive research and perceptive observations. It offers insights which may not follow from a nuanced causal narrative, but which emerge readily from the many wonderfully suggestive correspondences and metaphoric echoes Jenkins discovers within and between her texts. Readers interested in vexed questions of gendered authority as they were experienced by a range of Victorian novelists will find much to value here, and readers investigating the work of these particular writers will find even more.
