In a sentence, the content of this book is useful and well-presented, although the integration of the chapters leaves something to be desired. The book’s goals as a full text are somewhat unclear; the remit of the text is perhaps too large. Per the title, it focuses on environmental issues related to hydraulic fracturing (HF). Nevertheless, most of the environmental issues highlighted relate to water quality and consumption, whilst little research is presented relating to other environmental topics such as air quality, climate change impacts, or fish and wildlife health. This focus is not, in itself, a problem; the attention to water issues associated with HF is quite good and varied (touching on fracture-fluid interactions, radioactivity in wastewater, measurement of ion concentrations in wastewater, and the methodology for the US EPA’s drinking water impacts study). Nevertheless, the book’s title and remit could have been framed more in line with the content presented therein.
One facet of the book I truly appreciated was its inclusion of a range of chapters from different perspectives and disciplines. Beyond the aforementioned water-focused chapters, other chapters attended to HF regulation, legal analysis of lawsuit viability related to HF regulations, and a rather comprehensive case study of a broad suite of impacts of HF in one particular region (North Dakota, USA). Combined with the water-focused research, these chapters offer a wealth of relevant information to anyone seeking to learn more about the environmental and social context surrounding unconventional hydrocarbon development. Unfortunately, not many prospective readers would be aware of these chapters, considering the book title or the fact that the book is part of the American Chemical Society (ACS) Symposium series. The geographic focus of all chapters is limited to the United States, or to specific jurisdictions therein; however, this is not problematic, considering the amount of understanding that has come from that nation due to the magnitude of development there.
Although most of the chapters are quite useful, well researched, and well written, the combination of them falls short of what is required for a book. The book can only really be read as a series of chapters, or academic papers, loosely linked by topic, but not meaningfully integrated. Perhaps this is the intention for ACS Symposium series titles, but if so, it limits the use of the book (eg, it might be appropriate for university libraries, but not likely for use in a course, except for using individual chapters). In light of the book being presented very much as a collection of discrete chapters, I now comment briefly on each.
Chapter 1: The first chapter nicely introduces the topic of hydraulic fracturing and some of its environmental impacts. Particularly useful attention is given to: the pathways by which environmental contamination can occur, the history of the HF industry and of best practices, methane migration in groundwater, history of well leakage, and water use for HF. The chapter switches back and forth between highly technical information (eg, HF fluid composition) and lucidly accessible descriptions of impacts.
Chapter 2: This chapter unfortunately reads like an industry advertisement and exists in strong distinction to the nuance contained in Chapter 1 and throughout the following chapters. Phrases such as “without hydraulic fracturing the US, and the world, would be in a world of hurt” and “the benefits … are obviously enormous” simply have no place in academic writing. Claims about environmental protection under HF being “proven” directly contrast with assertions in almost every other chapter. The references on economic benefits are nearly all from industry reports (consistently shown to overestimate actual benefits) and from newspaper articles, even though several peer-reviewed academic articles exist. Despite the propaganda-esque tone, the chapter still has some relevant content on industry practices and why the phenomenon of HF developed first and primarily in the US.
Chapter 3: A breath of fresh air after Chapter 2, this highly technical article on fracture-fluid interactions is often difficult to understand for a non-expert in the field, but it is always easy to appreciate the need for and relevance of this research – the research points to ways of making the fracturing process more efficient and safe.
Chapter 4: The explicitly stated chapter goal is ‘to inform appropriate waste management decision making’, and it promises to achieve this goal nicely. The lucid description of radioactive ingrowth and its relevance to understanding the environmental impacts of HF is particularly useful, as are the descriptions of NORM concerns at each stage of unconventional development. Again, some technical chemistry is difficult to understand for a non-specialist, but the overall message and implications are clear to all.
Chapter 5: This chapter, which provides an overview of water issues, seems oddly placed (following two very technical chapters). Although perhaps useful in a broad sense, due to offering a few good examples, it is unreferenced and does not fit well in the book. Readers can skip it.
Chapter 6: The focus on measurement approaches for wastewater composition (ion) analysis highlights important technical aspects of how to ensure best practice. The empirical data illustrate huge differences in ion presence based on the area in which samples were collected, evincing the need for substantially different treatment required in, for example, North Dakota versus Texas. The data also point to recommendations for how to avoid scale build-up for reused wastewater.
Chapter 7: A case study of environmental impacts of HF in North Dakota, this chapter offers a systematic treatment of how each stage of the development of oil shale in ND could lead to environmental issues. The combination of this detailed case study, with a wide focus on many environmental impacts alongside its specific attention to a particular geography, works well in tandem with the previous chapters that have a diffuse geographic focus but examine only one or two specific impacts. The tables herein are particularly revealing and well-constructed.
Chapter 8: This legal analysis of potential for lawsuits under varying HF regulations is useful, clear, and comprehensive. The final few pages of the chapter offer a cursory analysis of economic consequences of development; this analysis is quite speculative, speaking to reasons for action from the public and decision makers without citing any empirical data from these individuals. The legal analysis portion is certainly worth reading; the second section is not.
Chapter 9: A brief, but laconic and useful description of the methodology used for the landmark US EPA study on the effects of HF on drinking water. No results are provided, only the methodology, but it is still useful to understand the scope of that important and expansive study.
Chapter 10: This chapter explains how advances in well stimulation regulation in California led to increased data availability for analysis, and then uses that data to offer recommendations for furthering policy in this area in California. The focus on CA also allows readers to appreciate differences in regulation across states.
Overall, the book is mostly solid scholarship that is accessible enough to a generally informed individual. Because the chapters are not thematically linked or connected to produce a single narrative, I recommend that readers first engage in a judicious viewing of the Table of Contents and chapter abstracts and then select a few individual chapters that are most relevant to them (save Chapters 2 and 5, which should be ignored entirely).
