Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T11:57:02.552Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

On effectiveness of optimal perturbation in hastening instability of counter-rotating vortex pair behind a wing

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  24 November 2025

Mohd. Suhail Naim
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur , UP 208016, India
Navrose*
Affiliation:
Department of Aerospace Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur , UP 208016, India
Vincent Brion
Affiliation:
DAAA, ONERA, Institut Polytechnique de Paris, 92190 Meudon, France
*
Corresponding author: Navrose, navrose@iitk.ac.in

Abstract

We investigate the effectiveness of linear optimal perturbation (LOP) for the flow past a finite span wing in reducing the lifespan of its trailing vortex system. Two approaches, referred to as local and model analysis, are introduced and used for our investigation. Both analyses assume that the baseflow is parallel. Local analysis is suited for intermediate distance from the wing where both tip vortices (TVs) and trailing edge wake (TEW) are present. Its results suggest that the unperturbed baseflow is stable. The separation between TVs and TEW increases downstream and their dynamics appear to be uncoupled at large distance from the wing. When perturbation corresponding to LOP is added to the baseflow, the vortices are displaced forming a helical twist. With time, the maximum displacement initially increases and then saturates. The perturbation retains its compact wavepacket-like structure, and perturbation energy within the tip vortex remains nearly constant. In the model analysis, the far wake is modelled as a pair of counter-rotating $q$-vortices. For low Reynolds number, the flow is stable. However, for higher Reynolds number, the trailing vortices develop Crow instability. Its growth rate is found to be in good agreement with earlier studies. Instability leads to contact of vortices, resulting in the formation of vortex rings. The time for vortex contact decreases with increase in the strength of the initial perturbation. The results suggest that LOP is effective in reducing the lifespan of trailing vortices.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2025. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ flow past a flat plate wing. (a) Iso-contours of total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.1$) for the unperturbed flow. In the inset, spanwise vorticity (bottom) and streamwise vorticity (top) in the $y_w{-}z_w$ plane at $x_w=30c$ is shown. (b) Perturbation wavepacket around $x_w = 30c$ shown using iso-contours of streamwise vorticity ($\omega _{x_w}=\pm 0.01$). Inset illustrates the streamwise vorticity within the tip vortex. (c) Perturbed flow. Inset shows the helical deformation of the tip vortex. The streamwise, spanwise and vertical co-ordinates are indicated by $x_w$, $y_w$ and $z_w$, respectively. The origin of the co-ordinate system is at the leading edge and on the plane of symmetry.

Figure 1

Figure 2.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ flow past a flat plate wing: periodic injection of LOP. The frequency of periodic injection is 0.1$U_\infty /c$. (a) Iso-surface of total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.1$). The broken rectangles highlight the streamwise locations of the perturbation wavepacket. (b) Spanwise and vertical deviation of the vortex centre from its unperturbed location. For comparison, the displacements corresponding to an isolated perturbation wavepacket (Navrose et al.2019) are added in red colour.

Figure 2

Figure 3.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis. (a) Baseflow corresponding to $x_w=30c$ and (b) perturbed flow. The location of the perturbation wavepacket is highlighted with a broken circle. The streamwise length of the domain is $8b$, where $b$ is the separation between the vortex centres.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Computational set-up: (a) domain showing the tip vortex and trailing edge wake; and (b) view of the spectral element mesh in the streamwise direction. The zoom-in view of the mesh near TV and TEW is shown in panel (c). The mesh contains elements $N_x=20$, $N_y=30$ and $N_z=100$ in the streamwise, spanwise and vertical directions, respectively, and $\textit{GLL}=12$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis: evolution of unperturbed flow with time. (a,c,e,g) Top-view of iso-surface of total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.03$). (b,d,f,h) Corresponding spanwise and streamwise vorticity in the y–z plane ($\omega _y=-0.01:0.01$ and $\omega _x=0:0.01$). Alongside time, the equivalent streamwise distance from the wing is indicated in parentheses. As an example, the vertical line along which the velocity data are taken is shown as a broken line in panel (b).

Figure 5

Figure 6.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of unperturbed flow: (a) streamwise; (b) spanwise; and (c) vertical components of velocity along a line that is parallel to the vertical axis and passes through the vortex centre, at different time instants. The approximate extents of the tip vortex (red) and trailing edge wake (grey) based on velocity data at $t=0$ have been shaded. Blue solid circle indicates the location of vortex centre. The temporal variation of axial velocity deficit, and gap between TV and TEW is shown in panels (d) and (e), respectively. ( f) Fit of the simulation data at $t=100$ to the $q$-vortex model.

Figure 6

Figure 7.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of unperturbed flow: variation of vortex characteristics with time. (a) Vertical co-ordinate of vortex centre, (b) spanwise co-ordinate of vortex centre, (c) circulation, and (d) square of the vortex dispersion radius. For reference, results reported by Navrose et al. (2019) are plotted in red. The result of wing simulation with finer mesh is plotted in magenta.

Figure 7

Figure 8.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow: evolution of the perturbation wavepacket, shown using iso-surface of total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.01$), with time. The tip vortex is highlighted using grey colour. In some of the frames, a cartoon illustrating the separation between TV and TEW, as viewed in the y–z plane, is added.

Figure 8

Figure 9.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow: evolution of the perturbation wavepacket with time. First column shows the iso-surface of streamwise vorticity ($\omega _x=\pm 0.001$). Other columns show the streamwise vorticity in the y–z plane at different streamwise locations. The locations correspond to that near the head, tail and middle of the perturbation wavepacket. As an example, the locations for $t=50$ are marked in the first column. Red dot indicates the vortex centre and yellow broken curve shows the approximate extent of the vortex core.

Figure 9

Figure 10.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. (a) Variation of energy of the perturbation wavepacket with time. For comparison, the result reported by Navrose et al. (2019) is also included. Broken vertical line corresponds to the streamwise location $x_w=30c$. (b) Zoom-in view around $t=0$ . (c) and (d) Structure of the perturbation wavepacket obtained via local analysis and that computed by Navrose et al. (2019) compared at $t=10$ and $t=20$, respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 11.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. (a) Variation of perturbation energy within the tip vortex () and trailing edge wake (), with time. For reference, the plot for total perturbation energy () is also included. The corresponding data from Navrose et al. (2019) are shown using hollow symbols. The inset shows the perturbation wavepacket at $t=375$ with the TV highlighted: (b) three-dimensional view and (c) zoom-in view in the streamwise direction.

Figure 11

Figure 12.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. (a) Iso-surface of total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.025$) and (b) co-ordinates of the vortex centre, for the initial flow. The inset in panel (b) shows the vortex displacement as viewed in the streamwise direction. The tentative location of the head and tail of the perturbation wavepacket is marked in the figures.

Figure 12

Figure 13.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow: evolution of flow with time. (a,c,e,g) Iso-surface of total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.025$). (b,d, f,h) Co-ordinates of vortex centre. The insets in panel (b,d, f,h) show the vortex displacement as viewed in the streamwise direction.

Figure 13

Figure 14.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. (a) Variation of maximum deviation of vortex centre from its unperturbed location, and gap between tip vortex and trailing edge wake, with time. In the inset, flow corresponding to two time instants are shown: (b,d) Iso-surface of total vorticity, (c,e) spanwise (left) and streamwise (right) vorticity in streamwise plane.

Figure 14

Figure 15.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. Streamwise variation of (a) spanwise and (b) vertical position of the vortex centre. Time is indicated on each plot. Plots in panel (a) have been shifted for better illustration. The shaded region highlights the approximate extent of the perturbation wavepacket. The colour-coded solid circles correspond to the same phase at different time instants.

Figure 15

Figure 16.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. Evolution of flow for different frequencies of injection of optimal perturbation. (a) Streamwise vorticity of the perturbation ($\omega _x=\pm 0.01$) at $t=0$. (b–e) Total vorticity ($|\omega |=0.025$) of the combined flow. The first, second and third columns correspond to 1X, 2X and 3X simulation, respectively.

Figure 16

Figure 17.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. Streamwise variation of (a) spanwise and (b) vertical position of the vortex centre for 3X simulation. Time is indicated on each plot. Plots in panel (a) have been shifted for better illustration.

Figure 17

Figure 18.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. Variation of perturbation energy (solid symbols) and maximum deviation of vortex centre (hollow symbols), with time, for different frequencies of injection of optimal perturbation. For reference, the plots for 1X simulation are shown using a line, broken for energy and solid for maximum deviation.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$, ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma = 1000$. Flow evolution shown using iso-surface of total vorticity. For better illustration, the flow has been extended in the streamwise direction by one period and vortices are coloured differently: red for counter-clockwise and blue for clockwise vortex. The extension is highlighted in panel (a) that shows the flow at $t=0$. The first, second and third columns show the three-dimensional, top and side-view, respectively.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$, ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma = 1000$. Variation of maximum deviation of vortex centre with time. Exponential fit to the data points is shown using dash-dotted line Time at which the two vortices come in contact is indicated with a vertical broken line. Beyond this, vortex-linking starts (shaded region) resulting in the formation of vortex rings. In the inset, helical perturbation is shown at two different time instants.

Figure 20

Figure 21.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$, ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma = 1000$: effect of Reynolds number (columns I and II), and effect of initial perturbation energy (columns III and IV). Columns I and III show the flow at $t=0$. Columns II and IV show the flow at a time instant around vortex contact. ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma$ decreases from top to bottom in I and II. Similarly, $E(0)$ decreases from top to bottom in III and IV. For better illustration, the flow has been extended in the streamwise direction by one period and vortices are coloured differently: red for counter-clockwise and blue for clockwise vortex.

Figure 21

Figure 22.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$. Variation of vortex-contact time with (a) Reynolds number and (b) initial energy of the perturbation and corresponding initial maximum deviation for ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma =1000$.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$, ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma = 1000$. Streamwise variation of (a) spanwise and (b) vertical position of vortex centre at $t=0$ for different $E(0)$.

Figure 23

Figure 24.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$, ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma = 1000$. Variation of maximum deviation of vortex centre with time. The initial energy of the perturbation is $E(0)=10^{-3}$. Exponential fit to the data points is shown using dash-dotted line. The time instant around which vortices come in contact is shown using a vertical broken line. Also shown as insets are the flow at different instants of time.

Figure 24

Table 1.Comparison of wavelength of perturbation ($\kappa b$, $\kappa$ is wavenumber), growth rate of instability ($\alpha ^*$) and inclination of the deformation plane ($\varTheta$) obtained in the present study with earlier works.

Figure 25

Table 2.Details of the domain size and mesh employed for local-analysis. $\Delta l(\textit{min},\textit{max})$ denotes the minimum and maximum grid spacing in the corresponding direction. GLL is the number of Gauss–Lobato–Legendre points inside each spectral element.

Figure 26

Table 3.Comparison of the perturbation wavepacket energy data obtained through local analysis with results of Navrose et al. (2019).

Figure 27

Figure 25.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. Effect of mesh resolution on energy of the perturbation wavepacket.

Figure 28

Figure 26.${\textit{Re}}_c=1000$ local analysis of perturbed flow. Comparison with simulation of Navrose et al. (2019) at two time instants. (a,b) Spanwise deviation and (c,d) vertical deviation.

Figure 29

Table 4.Details of the domain size and mesh employed for model analysis. $\Delta l(\textit{min},\textit{max})$ denotes the minimum and maximum grid spacing in the corresponding direction. GLL is the number of Gauss–Lobato–Legendre points inside each spectral element.

Figure 30

Figure 27.Model analysis of perturbed flow $a/b=0.18$, ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma = 1000$ and $E(0)=10^{-3}$. Effect of mesh resolution on maximum deviation of the vortex centre.

Figure 31

Figure 28.(a) Spanwise and (b) vertical deviation of vortex centre when the perturbation wavepacket is located at $x_w=30c$, $40c$ and $50c$ in wing simulation (Navrose et al.2019). The deviation corresponding to the helical-twist perturbation used in model analysis is also included in the figure. (c) Illustration of vortex with (red) and without (black) the helical twist.

Figure 32

Figure 29.Model analysis of unperturbed flow. Variation of aspect ratio of vortex in CRQV pair with time for ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma =27$ and ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma =250$ (in inset). The shaded region in each denotes the time interval corresponding to initial adjustment of the vortex (Brion 2009; Johnson et al.2016).

Figure 33

Figure 30.Model analysis of the perturbed flow ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma =27$. Comparison of maximum deviation of the vortex centre with simulation that takes into account the initial adjustment of CRQV.

Figure 34

Figure 31.Model analysis of perturbed flow ${\textit{Re}}_\varGamma =250$. Comparison of maximum deviation of the vortex centre with simulation that takes into account the initial adjustment of CRQV. The time instant around which the vortices come into account is marked with a vertical broken line. Beyond this, vortex linking starts, eventually resulting in the formation of vortex rings.