March 17
I'm shaking hands with Bill Clinton, and about to turn him over to the coaches and players of the Rhodes College baseball team for handshakes of their own. The team has just spent two hours touring the museum part of the Clinton Presidential Library in Little Rock after defeating Hendrix College 6-0 in an afternoon game in nearby Conway. Bruce Lindsey, Clinton's right hand for the past 20-plus years and a Rhodes alum, graciously arranged the meet-and-greet at my ardent request.
I'm with the team playing one of my favorite roles as a professor: faculty associate for baseball. As the team's informal faculty adviser, I add a semi-academic element to a varsity sports experience that, even in Division III, ties up much of the players' time during the spring semester with practice, games, and travel. A task force on the future of intercollegiate athletics at Rhodes that I chaired in 2002 at the request of President Bill Troutt borrowed an idea from Princeton and Middlebury and recommended that Rhodes create a faculty associates program of our own. Visiting the Clinton Library last year (no Clinton) and this year (Clinton) wove an academic event into an athletics road trip, a rare combination in college sports.
Being the baseball team's faculty associate is pure pleasure—they are students first, athletes second, and they like being treated that way in our interactions. The best of these tend to take place on the occasional road trip I make with the team, when the many hours I spend in their company on the bus and over meals make informal conversation a natural rather than an unnatural act. Another treat for me and, I think, for the players is having them over to our house for pizza one evening during spring break, when the rest of the student body is home or at the beach and the athletes who are stuck on campus may be feeling a little forlorn. It's amazing how much pleasure they take in, say, petting our dog.
March 27
Mondays are my heaviest teaching day by far: two 50-minute classes and a two-and-a-half hour seminar that meets once per week. By design, I teach these classes back-to-back-to-back, starting at noon and continuing until 4:30 (at which point I stagger out of the building, barely capable of forming even the simplest coherent sentence). Why cluster all of my classes together on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday afternoons? Mostly because I'm a morning person.
That surely sounds strange (wouldn't a morning person want to teach, well, in the morning?) but the arrangement fits me like a glove. Mornings are for research, writing, editing, and class preparation—solitary endeavors that I can only do under my own steam, and mornings are when my metabolic engine runs at full throttle. Teaching, on the other hand, is the farthest thing from solitary: it puts me in the midst of other people, all of whom are looking right at me and expecting me to interest and illuminate them. In the afternoon, when my own energy is at its lowest ebb, I can count on the students to get my adrenal glands firing on all cylinders. As for doing the classes consecutively, with only a 10-minute break before each one, I have found that it's much easier, once I have gotten revved up to teach, to stay on that plateau (oops, mixed metaphor) than to come down between classes and have to climb back up again an hour or two later.
The courses I'm teaching this semester are an interesting and unusual mix. All are discussion-based, with anywhere from 13 to 19 students. As such, all involve reading works in common, then gathering around a table to talk about what we have read. I made the same speech at the start of the semester in all three: You take a class (that is, you spend a good bit of time receiving what the professor transmits) but you are a member of a seminar. Being a member of a seminar is like being a member of a team or a club or a family: you have a personal responsibility to contribute to the success of the whole (in this case, by reading the day's assignment with care and joining in the discussion of it) and failing to do so means letting everyone down, not just yourself.
There the similarity among this semester's courses ends. The one that meets once per week on Mondays is a seminar on the Constitutional Convention, designed mostly for junior and senior political science majors. I organize it the same way I organized my graduate seminars when I was teaching at Vanderbilt from 1979 to 1991. We spend around two-thirds of the semester reading and discussing works in common, and the remainder is devoted to students presenting their research papers to the seminar.
My other two seminars (the ones that meet three times a week for 50 minutes) are sections of Rhodes's renowned Search course. Formally called The Search for Values in the Light of Western History and Religion, Search began more than 60 years ago as a 12-credit humanities course spread over students' freshman and sophomore years. During the first half of the course (in which I used to teach and expect someday to teach again), students study primary texts of the ancient Hebrews, Greeks, and Romans, as well as of the early Christians from the New Testament through St. Augustine. All first-year Search students follow the same calendar of readings, whether their section is taught by a classicist, a biblical scholar, a philosopher, a historian, a political scientist, or a French professor. In the second year of the course, which carries the Western tradition from the Middle Ages to the present, students can specialize to some extent (there's still a lot of overlap in the reading lists) by pursuing one of five tracks: history, religion, literature, philosophy, or politics. A good number of my colleagues in the humanities resist calling Search a “great books” course, but I and the two other political scientists who teach Search, Dan Cullen and Steve Wirls, embrace the term and the understanding that underlies it—namely, that we and our students need to read and discuss these books both to become educated people and because they continue to speak to us in our day.
Before coming to Rhodes, I was not one of those educated people—outside my major, my college curriculum was full of textbook-based surveys and user-friendly electives. My main motive for teaching Search when I came to Rhodes was that I wanted to read the Iliad, The Peloponnesian Wars, the Old Testament prophets, Augustine's Confessions, and all the other classic texts that Rhodes freshmen read as a matter of course but that I never had and, realistically, never would read—unless I had to teach them. It was my own education I wanted to improve, and if my students learned something too, all the better.
Happily, the nature of Search and similar courses at other colleges and universities (several of them inspired by Rhodes) is that all of us who teach are amateurs—amateurs in the modern sense that none of us is professionally trained in the several disciplines that are represented in the course, and amateurs in the old sense of people who do something for the love of it. (The Latin root of amateur is, after all, amare.) We learn from each other—we even spend a week at the end of the spring semester studying a work in common—and we demonstrate to our students that learning is a lifelong process in which even their professors engage.
For the curious, here's a sampling of what we've read this year in the politics track: de Pizan's Book of the City of Ladies, Dante's Divine Comedy, Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion, Machiavelli's The Prince (coupled with Shakespeare's Richard III), Locke's Second Treatise of Government, Defoe's Robinson Crusoe, Shelley's Frankenstein, Twain's A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court, Mill's On Liberty, Freud's Five Lectures on Psychoanalysis, Huxley's Brave New World, and Wiesenthal's The Sunflower. With a month to go in the semester, here's what we have left: C. S. Lewis's The Great Divorce, Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four, Camus's The Stranger, and Achebe's Things Fall Apart. Our last reading of the year is Martin Luther King's “Letter from a Birmingham Jail.” Just think, I'll tell the students, King was able to write this letter, with all its invocations of the great books, while in confinement, with nothing to draw on but what he had read and made part of himself.
April 6
With no classes today, I spent several hours working on The Politics of Gambling in the South, a book I'm in the process of finishing for Louisiana State University Press. Seven chapters (an introduction and case studies of Mississippi, Georgia, Alabama, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Arkansas) are done, and the eighth (Louisiana) is almost done, thanks to what I was able to accomplish today. That leaves the conclusion, which I'm supposed to submit by mid May.
I'm a presidency guy, so it surprises some people to find that I'm working in the area of state policy innovation. (More than once, people who have read an article or chapter already published from the research have assumed that it was by some other Michael Nelson.) But I've always tailored my research to whatever interested me at the time. In this case, one evening during the fall 1998 semester, I and a former student and new Rhodes colleague named Jay Mason were driving back to Memphis from a (rare) evening at one of the casinos in Tunica, Mississippi. We got to talking about how interesting it was that Mississippi, of all states, had become such a center of casino gambling. The explanation for this peculiar phenomenon had to lie in politics—somehow the state government had decided to make casinos legal—but neither of us could imagine what that explanation might be. From our conversation a research project was born. Jay has since left academics for the business world, but I've carried on the project, and it's gratifying to know that the book will soon be done.
During the course of the research for this book, I became interested in tribal casinos, which is the subject of my other main writing project this spring. Because of their particular status as sovereign entities, federally recognized tribes may operate casinos on tribal lands that fall within the boundaries of any state that allows similar forms of gambling. Not surprisingly, all sorts of claimants have lined up to petition for federal recognition as tribes, an elaborate and expensive process that often is bankrolled by investors hoping to build and manage whatever casinos eventually may be authorized and built. Happily, I was able to persuade Allen Cigler and Burdett Loomis, the editors of the much admired Interest Groups Politics reader for CQ Press, to let me write a chapter on the politics of tribal recognition for the seventh edition of their book. The deadline for my chapter (like the deadline for the final manuscript of Politics of Gambling) is in May. Clearly I'll need plenty more days as productive as today.
April 13
An email from Marc Hetherington at Vanderbilt says that the article we published in the January 2003 issue of PS on President's Bush's post-9/11 rally in public support was downloaded more often than any other article published in the journal during the past three years. I email back: “This is so cool.”
April 22
Years ago, a famous political scientist at a Washington think tank told me that during his years at a major research university he had regarded teaching as the price he had to pay to do research. I disagreed strenuously with him at the time and still do. What he should have said was: grading is the price you have to pay to teach.
I have two conflicting impulses when a batch of papers or exams is turned in. The better of the two is to grade them as soon as possible, on the theory that it's going to take just as much time to do them later as sooner, and the longer I put them off the more the low-level buzz of dread, guilt, and anxiety will permeate my days and dreams. The lesser impulse—and the one to which I all too often succumb—is to wait until a convenient time arrives, which, of course, never happens. Either way, a pile of papers almost always means a lost weekend.
That's not to say that grading is completely without pleasure. Reading a good paper or exam—the kind I wish I could have written when I was an undergraduate—is enormously satisfying. In freshman or sophomore classes, I love being able to write at the end of such a paper: “Have you thought of majoring in political science? You really have a knack for it.” In the case of majors, the corresponding comment is: “Aren't you glad you majored in political science? You're really good at it.”
One unfortunate grading habit of mine that I hope to break is my end-of-paper summary comments, which typically take the form of “praise, but criticism” instead of the other way around. When students read professors' comments, there's a big difference between how they perceive “You have some really interesting arguments, but the evidence you present for them is sometimes insufficient” and “The evidence for your arguments is sometimes insufficient, but the arguments are really interesting.” The comments are the same, but (as this sentence illustrates) the power of what comes after the “but” is greater than the power of what precedes it.
May 1
Jonathan is going to write about welfare reform, Emily about the Family and Medical Leave Act, and Taylor about Medicaid. All three are student fellows of the Rhodes Institute for Regional Studies (RIRS) who will be doing research at the Clinton Library this summer under my supervision. RIRS is a four-year-old program headed by history professor Timothy Huebner, who essentially created it from scratch. Every summer five or six members of the Rhodes faculty each help three students do eight-week, Midsouth-related research projects of the students' own devising. It's a marvelous program—RIRS pays the students a $3,000-plus stipend and covers their living and research expenses—and the students who compete to be part of it are intellectually curious high achievers. The program begins this summer on June 12 with a two-week seminar on the history, politics, music, religion, and economy of Memphis and the surrounding region. In the past, I have directed research on, for example, Mississippi casinos, Memphis mayor Willie Herenton's election campaigns, and Memphis's response to secession efforts on the eve of the Civil War. This summer, all three of my fellows will be working at the Clinton Library, which recently made available its first round of presidential documents.
Our meeting today is designed to launch Jonathan, Emily, and Taylor into the summer (exams began today) with a few books to read and some tips about how to use the library's web site (www.clintonlibrary.gov) to find out which documents are available and relevant to their projects. Tim Huebner and I met with the library's archivist, David Alsobrook, and his staff a couple of months ago, and they were wonderfully helpful in telling us which aspects of the Clinton presidency are ripe for research using the papers.
May 4
I'm at the University of Maryland to give a talk called “Teaching Outside Your Competence” at the Center for Teaching Excellence. It's a great group, and they seem interested in hearing about the Search course and the challenges (and joys) of teaching books from such a wide variety of genres. Tonight I'll see the Washington Nationals play at RFK Stadium as the guest of Charlie Cook, congressional elections guru and, more important, father of Becky, who just finished her sophomore year at Rhodes. Charlie is as much fun as he is thoughtful and perceptive, which is to say, a lot of fun.
In March 2005, when President George W. Bush was in town touting his Social Security plan, I ran into Rep. Harold Ford, Jr. at the event and told him that Charlie was a Rhodes dad who came to town at least once every semester to see his daughter. “Professor,” Ford said, “next time he's here I want to have dinner with you and Charlie at your house.” I set it up and, a month later, Ford spent three hours eating barbecue and persuading Charlie that he really could win Tennessee's open Senate seat. It was obvious why this was so important to Ford—if he could tell prospective donors around the country that Charlie Cook regarded his race as a toss-up, he could raise a lot of money from Democrats eager to win back the Senate.
While in Washington, I stay near Dupont Circle with Steve Ceccoli, a Rhodes colleague who is an APSA Congressional Fellow this year with Arkansas Senator Blanche Lincoln. The morning after the game I have breakfast with Alex Kafka, a young and talented editor of the Chronicle of Higher Education's Review section for whom I do two or three essays every year, and we agree on my next two assignments: a piece for their “Must Read” section discussing the three or four works by political scientists that shed the most light on congressional elections like the ones coming up in November, and a review essay, pegged to the August publication of historian Randall Woods's new pro-Lyndon B. Johnson biography, assessing how different Johnson biographers (Woods, Robert Caro, Robert Dallek, etc.) have treated their subject and how that relates to presidential scholarship in general.
May 8
I'm back in Memphis, and (as of 12:00 noon) I've nearly finished drafting the last chapter of the gambling book, now provisionally titled How the South Joined the Gambling Nation in response to LSU Press's interest in selling a few copies in real-world bookstores. A few more days of polishing and it's off to the publisher. I'm going to have to work my schedule like a puzzle to find those few days. This is senior week, with graduation activities on Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday. The Search faculty is also gathering on Wednesday and Thursday to read and discuss works from the Middle Ages by Aquinas, Anselm, and Avicenna under the guidance of visiting scholar R. E. Houser of the Thomistic Studies Center at the University of St. Thomas. My wife, Linda, is off tomorrow morning to visit my mother in New Jersey, which means I'll also be keeping house (kinda) for myself and our two sons, Michael and Sam. Happily, Bird Loomis has given me an extension on the tribal recognition essay for his and Allen Cigler's interest groups book.
May 9
I'm sounded out for the deanship at a school I much admire by a member of the search committee. I have spent my entire career avoiding administrative jobs, all of which I've caustically regarded as draining time and energy from teaching and research in the service of dealing with other people's problems. But, like I say, this is a school I admire and being dean there would provide just the sort of major new challenge I seem to need every few years. I email back: Does the committee know that I've never even chaired a department? The response: Please send your CV anyway. Wondering why I'm doing it, I do.
May 10
A burst of productive energy and as of this morning the gambling book is off to LSU Press. Now I can settle into Aquinas without distraction.
May 11
Reading Aquinas is like lifting weights—difficult, even painful, but deeply satisfying. Part of that satisfaction is seeing how robustly Aquinas states the arguments with which he disagrees. He's not trying to pile up rhetorical points by tearing down straw men. Rather, his premise seems to be that unless he can refute opposing arguments in their strongest form, he really hasn't accomplished much of anything.
A kindred pleasure (this one utterly painless) attends our discussions of Aquinas and other thinkers in today's Search faculty workshop. For a while we get to be students again, sitting around a table discussing important works, rekindling the sheer love of learning that caused us to choose this life in the first place. No one is out to score points; instead we're eager to learn from each other, even when—especially when—we see things differently. The habits of generous, civil discussion that we revive at the start of each summer's Search workshop stand us in good stead when we turn, as we must next week, to the curricular matters on which we sometimes disagree and might, in the absence of experiences like today's, disagree disagreeably.
May 13
Graduation, like small classes and Division III sports, always reminds me why I left a tenured position at a research university to come to Rhodes 15 years ago. The entire faculty is present for the entire ceremony. I know nearly all of the roughly 300 graduates who cross the stage to get their diplomas by sight and many of them by name, even ones I've never had in class. Afterward, I and my colleagues linger to greet parents and grandparents, pose for photos, and exchange promises with the departing seniors to stay in touch. To a fair number, I say, “It's time to start calling me Mike.”
Author Bio
Michael Nelson is professor of political science at Rhodes College. He has published 20 books on the presidency, elections, the bureaucracy, public policy, and higher education and has written nearly two-hundred articles on a wide range of political, religious, literary, and cultural topics for scholarly journals and other periodicals. He has won several writing, teaching, and research awards.
