In Lost Causes, Charli Carpenter asks why some problems make it onto the international agenda and others do not. She argues that in global issue networks identified with “human security,” structural power accruing to a small set of prominent actors/organizations from their centrality in global networks makes them gatekeepers, able to determine whether and how new issues garner international attention. Norm entrepreneurs may bring new problems to the attention of gatekeepers, but remain subject to these systemic features. Nor can issue characteristics explain the adoption of some issues over others. In stressing structural power in an expanded global system, Carpenter differentiates herself both from more agentic approaches to “advocacy networks” that she associates with Margaret Keck and Kathryn Sikkink’s Activists beyond Borders, as well as from work like Clifford Bob’s that explores the political economy of the global advocacy “market.”
In some of the book's most interesting insights, Carpenter views issues as well as actors relationally. Whether and how an emerging issue or problem connects with issues on an existing organizational agenda may influence the likelihood of its adoption—though not always in ways we might expect. Proximity of a problem to a gatekeeper's existing campaign priorities works both ways. Organizations may see the addition of new campaign issues as enriching existing activities or diluting them.
Carpenter approaches agenda vetting by attempting to identify issues that might be expected to receive international attention but do not. She does so by employing surveys and focus groups as well as web-crawler and content mapping technologies. She illustrates her arguments with three case studies, each presented in a chapter, in which issue entrepreneurs attempt with greater or lesser success to convince “advocacy superpowers” to adopt their causes.
In the first case, activists espoused a norm of compensating unintended victims of warfare (so-called collateral damage), targeting in particular the UN office of Humanitarian Affairs. Carpenter traces both gradual changes in the targeting strategies of the norm promoters and also a shift in the normative emphasis away from seeking financial compensation towards recognizing harm and making amends. In this and in other cases, she shows the important role personal networks and skills of individual organizers played in building links among organizations.
The second case tracks efforts to ban or regulate the use of fully autonomous weapons systems, interesting both for its own organizational story and because of the issue’s rather complicated relationship with already existing efforts around semi-autonomous weapons or drones. Defining a “campaign” is complicated by the fact that there were actually two “epistemic communities” drawing attention to the issue, one of which considered fully autonomous systems preferable to the semi-autonomous ones (as less likely to make human mistakes) and another that questioned the ability of “killer robots” to differentiate between combatants and non-combatants. Personal networks were once again very important, as proponents of a ban on such weapons tried to work at the nexus of arms control, humanitarian, and human rights networks, among others, while distancing themselves from less internationally “respectable” peace activists. This campaign has made progress but has not yet achieved full agenda status.
The third case involved efforts to pitch infant male circumcision as a human rights issue, framed either as a form of bodily harm to vulnerable populations, as the functional equivalent of female genital mutilation, or as a violation of the rights of the child. Issue entrepreneurs in this case were the least successful at convincing major international organizations to take it on. Carpenter is more convinced than I am that this issue's characteristics ought to have prompted its adoption by human rights activists, and she seems to consider the response of human rights organizations unexpectedly dismissive. I found this case study to be weaker than the others, not only because the nature of issue itself is highly contested, but also because the account was heavily U.S.-centric. From reading it, one would not have known, for example, that patterns of infant male circumcision in most European countries are very different from those in the United States. These differences might well affect how the issue is perceived in some of the “gatekeeper” organizations that have demonstrated reluctance to take on a campaign against the practice.
There is much of value in this book. Studies of collective action of all kinds overwhelmingly focus on dogs that did bark; we sorely need careful studies of political processes where outcomes are less clear, where activists were not successful at reaching their goals or even at getting their campaigns off the ground. Carpenter’s book provides a great deal of this, and gives us food for thought.
There are some aspects of the book that I found less satisfying. In particular, I found Carpenter’s constitution of the “human security” issue area unconvincing, and wish she had made better use of the network analysis outlined in the introductory chapters. Her “network of networks” was constructed both from surveys asking respondents to name the three organizations most associated with “human security,” and by webcrawler identification of “organizations with two incoming links from the network around the top ten Google search results for the term ‘human security’ in October 2007” (See footnote: p. 31). This included an array of governmental, intergovernmental, and nongovernmental organizations in the areas of peace and security, arms control, health, environment, development, human rights, humanitarian affairs, human security, and so forth. Over the last decade or so, the term “human security” has provided a bridge across many of these issues; for some it is a buzzword and for others an emerging paradigm. Carpenter does not justify building her networked universe around it, so one can presume she is in the latter camp. Nonetheless, a fuller theoretical treatment of the term would have made the book stronger.
The problems in making that universe real for us are apparent in the colorful yet rather crowded plates inserted between pages 30 and 31 of the book. Numbers and titles would have made references to these figures in the text more clear. The network measures on which the visualizations are based do not appear either in the text or in the appendix; as a result, the reader's grasp of the “between-ness” centrality of particular organizations remains highly dependent on the way the sociograms are drawn. This is too bad, since scholars like Marisa von Bülow and Wendy Wong have shown how social network analysis can uncover important insights about interorganizational relations.
The appendix contains a useful discussion of the complicated relations between sympathetic researcher and interview subjects in this kind of research. This is an important area for examination, in that many people who choose to study transnational activism (myself included) are drawn to it in part through their own commitment to change. Carpenter’s discussion of what the researcher owes to the activists being studied is especially stimulating, and worth pursuing further—perhaps even in an APSA workshop or panel.
