What can analysis of the ethnic music scene in contemporary Israel reveal about the power of music to promote visions of peaceful coexistence among Israelis and Palestinians in that contested land? How might musical interaction transform social and political realities marked by enormous division, tension, and loss of hope? Drawing on a rich theoretical foundation and ethnography among Jewish and Palestinian musicians in Israel, Benjamin Brinner explores new forms of musical expression that combine various Middle Eastern and other song forms in order to foster cooperation among Jewish and Arab musicians and audiences. Brinner focuses on two Israeli ensembles (Alei Hazayit and Bustan Abraham) and one major performer (Yair Dalal) to trace how they are situated in expanding local and global networks and how their forms of interaction, musical competencies, and complex relationships with various market forces reveal the prospects for—and potential barriers to—peaceful coexistence. His nuanced use of network theory and his complex reading of the discourse and performance practice of Israeli and Palestinian musicians makes for compelling reading that will engage students and scholars of the Middle East alike.
Part I, “Setting the Stage,” offers a sociocultural map of contemporary Israel and an overview of musical life in Israel for Israeli and Palestinian musicians. In tracing the complex networks that tie Israeli and Palestinian artists to one another and to regional and international networks, Brinner pays special attention to the difficulties faced by Palestinian artists due to political and economic barriers. His discussion of the working life of Arab and Jewish musicians is especially revealing of the contradictions faced by artists who navigate a fractured landscape of multiple ethnic, religious, and regional identities. Yet these same complex nodes of identity also form the basis for expanding networks of social relations that provide the anchor to musical life in this complex environment.
Part II, “Musicians, Bands, Networks,” focuses on musicians and the various overlapping networks in which their practices are situated. Eschewing a general survey, Brinner closely analyzes the ensembles Alei Hazayit and Bustan Abraham in addition to Yair Dalal. His discussion of these three clusters of musicians reveals the complex relations among musicians, institutions, and audiences in Israel and beyond. The musical networks among these various musicians and their collaborators in Israel and abroad forms the core of Brinner's analysis, and he shows how the multiple connections among musicians, institutions, recording companies, and audiences create the conditions for the elaboration of musical competencies as well as for the intensification of interaction that might lead to deeper forms of intercultural cooperation.
Part III examines the repertoires and musical resources utilized by Alei Hazayit, Bustan Abraham, and Yair Dalal in the construction of their musical styles, which the author identifies as not only styles of fusion music but also fusions of various musical styles. He also traces the complex interactions between improvisation and composition in the works of all three clusters of musicians, with close critical analysis of the original compositions of Bustan Abraham. Although the text's rich musical analysis may have limited appeal to nonspecialists, general readers will gain insights into musical performance practice from the musical examples provided on the companion website.
Finally, Part IV explores representations of place and time by musicians in Israel's ethnic music scene, as well as potential pathways toward a future marked less by conflict and more by peaceful collaboration and coexistence. The musicians at the heart of Brinner's analysis promote complex and often contradictory representations of the land they occupy (in both senses of the word). Moreover, these representations of the land are embedded in understandings of temporality that aim to legitimate notions of rootedness and musical authenticity and thereby promote visions of peaceful cooperation among peoples with often competing interests. While some groups, such as Bustan Abraham, tend to avoid explicitly political interpretations of their work, artists such as Yair Dalal embrace an overt political mission and in many ways are future directed. While casting a sanguine eye on their possibilities for effecting lasting change, Brinner argues that Israeli–Palestinian musical collaborations at a minimum lay the foundations for a more inclusive musical imaginary that could suggest new sociopolitical imaginaries. Grounded in the realities of the challenges faced by these artists, Brinner's analysis of the contemporary scene nonetheless offers hope for lasting change.
Brinner does not hide behind platitudes about cultural exchange, peace, and love but casts a hard if respectful eye (and ear) on the musicians and their interactions to reveal the underlying complexities of musical performance in Israel today. At the same time, his use of network theory shows the real possibilities of such analysis in uncovering not only the musical and social circuits that tie performers together but also the larger constellation of institutions, repertoires, competencies, and styles in which musicians are embedded and that form a foundation for building bridges toward a better future. Strong and complex networks allow for change, while weaker ones are more easily shaken by social, political, and economic tensions (as was the case with Bustan Abraham, which disbanded in 2003).
The relative lack of groups performing music of this sort in contemporary Israel is important to note. Brinner focuses essentially on two ensembles and one performer while mentioning a limited number of other agents in the current scene. One would think that if intercultural relations were important to Israeli society, then there would be more intercultural groups, because artists and musicians are among the most frequent agents of such change in zones of conflict. This does not appear to be the case, and the paucity of groups speaks to the difficult political situation (border crossings remain an impediment to such collaborations) and perhaps even to the relative lack of interest among Israelis in forging a peaceful coexistence with their Arab Palestinian neighbors. Recent politics (e.g., election returns) shows this latter conclusion to be a distinct possibility. So the question remains, can musical exchanges lead to meaningful change, or is this a fantasy of a liberal-minded author and his audience? We have to admit the latter possibility even as we cheer on Brinner's musical interlocutors and hope for a better outcome. Brinner's important study shows us some of the possible pathways forward as well as the inevitable pitfalls.
The book is clearly written, and the theoretical sections, while complex, are elaborated in a manner that would be accessible to undergraduates. Although specialists in Middle East studies might find certain historical sections oversimplified (the text being written primarily for ethnomusicologists), scholars in related fields will find much of value in this book. It will form an essential part of the extensive literature on music, conflict, and social change not only in the Middle East but also in general.
