Sir Henry Layard (1817–1894) was nothing if not a man of many interests. Throughout the course of an intensely productive life, he variously found employment as a traveller, writer, art historian, and politician. He is perhaps best known, however, for his work as an archaeologist: he was the famed excavator of the ruins at Nimrud on the Tigris. His archaeological efforts over a number of years spawned a number of important publications, which, combined with a side interest in the contemporary life of the places he visited, resulted in some major academic accolades – donations of a number of Assyrian antiquities to the British Museum (where they are still held today) no doubt also did his reputation little harm.
But, in-between spells in Mesopotamia and Parliament, Layard also managed to serve as a diplomat, more than once in the capital of the Ottoman Empire, where he first arrived in the early 1840s. An introduction to the revered Stratford Canning resulted in employment as a diplomatic ‘odd job’ man in Ottoman territories and his reversion to this professional sideline over the course of his life led, ultimately, to the ambassadorship in 1877. His tumultuous residence in Constantinople lasted three years and, not surprisingly, when Layard came to pen his memoirs during his retirement in Venice, this part of his life received detailed attention. The edited version of the section of his memoirs covering 1877 to 1880 is the subject of this review.
The Centre d'Histoire Diplomatique Ottomane at Isis Press in Istanbul has produced a number of works over recent years which focus on the international predicament of the Ottoman Empire in the late nineteenth, early twentieth century periods, specifically on the so called ‘Eastern Question’ and the origins of the First World War. A good portion of these publications have been based on documents from the Ottoman Foreign Ministry, a relatively new archive (only available to researchers during the last few years in its current form) presently housed in the old offices of the Sublime Porte. The Centre is also interested in the activities of foreign diplomats in the Ottoman Empire, which is why Layard's memoirs, which are held in the British Museum, attracted attention.
These memoirs were not the product of an egotist trying to secure or exaggerate his place in history and, moreover, patently merit independent publication. As British ambassador to the Ottoman Empire during the latter stages of the momentous Eastern Crisis of 1875–78, Layard's embassy is of no small relevance to the political history of Europe during the last years of the Congress System. In addition, observations by foreign diplomats who enjoyed access to the highest levels of the Ottoman Government provide an insight into events which cannot always be matched by Ottoman accounts. As a leading professor of international history recently commented, if you want to know what was going on in Elizabethan England, you need to read the Venetian ambassador's despatches. Observations by foreigners of the Ottoman political scene are all the more helpful because of the paucity of available memoirs, private letters and diaries of leading Ottoman statesmen. Clearly, a health warning needs to be applied to Layard's memoirs in this respect given his position as an outsider with his own agenda, but it should be noted that there is a steady stream of historians from around the world visiting London and Paris for primary sources on certain aspects of late Ottoman history.
That said, Layard's desire to inform posterity was not entirely altruistic. His residence was a highly problematic one during a momentous period and inevitably encountered controversy, at home and in the Ottoman ‘well-protected domains’. As the editor of the memoirs, Sinan Kuneralp, notes in the introduction, Layard ended up being vilified by both British and Ottoman Governments: the former fretted about his supposed ‘pro-Turk’ attitude, which, given the state of British public opinion after the ‘Bulgarian horrors’ of 1876 (ably fuelled by Layard's nemesis, W.E. Gladstone), was politically inexpedient to say the least; the latter believed Layard made promises he knew he could not keep about British support for the ‘sick man of Europe’ and never forgave him for his perceived transgressions. Through the course of several hundred pages, Layard seeks to qualify his philo-Turkism and deny any hint of deception in his dealings with the Sultan, Abdülhamid II.
Mention of Abdülhamid (1842–1918 / r.1876–1909) raises one of the most interesting aspects of these memoirs: a first-hand account of the early career of this most enigmatic of Ottoman sultans. Layard arrived towards the beginning of Abdülhamid's reign and witnessed the inexperienced and diffident Sultan struggle with the near disintegration of his Empire. As Kuneralp notes, “The portrait of Abdülhamid as depicted by Layard in his Memoirs is probably one of the most perceptive and balanced characterisations of the Sultan in the early years of his reign”. Layard's real strength as a contemporary commentator was to treat the 34th Ottoman Sultan as a human character trying to come to terms with a difficult reality, not merely the physical representation of an imperial institution. Too few such descriptions exist.
The memoirs are presented chronologically, beginning with Layard's arrival in post in April 1877 at the request of the Conservative Government, and ending with his recall by the Liberals in 1880. Layard was therefore closely involved with the Russo-Ottoman war of 1877–78, which in fact broke out within days of his arrival. Again, the attraction of Layard's narrative is not so much his description of the politics of this disastrous (for the Ottomans) war, but rather the flavour of life in an imperilled city. This is not to say Layard's own political position was uninteresting: his frustration with the prevarications of the British Government and his near total eclipse from the drama of the Congress of Berlin in 1878 shed important new light on events.
Through the course of his memoirs, Layard comes across as a visionary who was unable to break free from the intellectual constraints of his time and his position. He was something of a trendsetter when it came to British ambassadors’ acknowledging western hypocrisy towards the Ottoman Empire: he may have been the first but he certainly was not the last to see an awkward double standard at play. During subsequent decades, his successors in the embassy in Pera, on the northern side of the Golden Horn, would enjoy reading the archives for his pithy comments on British policy. Yet, despite wielding no small amount of power at a critical juncture in the development of the Ottoman Empire, he never progressed any solution to some deep-rooted problems and instead resorted to trite simplicities concerning administrative reform. There is a sense in these pages that he was witness to great events, but he failed to seize the opportunity to guide those events to a satisfactory conclusion. For a variety of reasons, no British ambassador to the Porte (with the possible exception of Sir William White in the late 1880s) would ever command so much influence again.
If nothing else, this work highlights the need for a full biography of Layard that brings together the many different facets of his life. In the meantime, this expertly introduced and edited publication makes a significant contribution to the primary sources on both British and Ottoman political and social history.
