The popularity of ‘disease biography’ as a genre of medical history writing has grown markedly in recent years, with Oxford University Press and Johns Hopkins leading the way in book-length treatments of various conditions. As the tenth anniversary of the anthrax attacks of September 2001 looms, Hopkins has brought out a biography of anthrax, Death in a Small Package. Susan D. Jones's aim is to chart ‘the history of anthrax through the lens of human actions and beliefs as they are linked to anthrax's fascinating life cycle and ecology’ (p. 6). Chronologically, she ranges from what are arguably the very earliest recorded incidences of the disease – in the so-called Fertile Crescent between five thousand and ten thousand years ago – through to the events surrounding and following the attacks in 2001. The name ‘anthrax’ thus comes to refer in her text to conditions which manifested in very different circumstances, from the death of cattle grazing near the river Nile in the fifth biblical plague to the deadly white powder sent through the US mail system a decade ago.
In a significant challenge to the often rigid boundaries sometimes drawn between the ‘biological’ and the ‘social’, Jones encourages us to think of these categories far more fluidly, and so to acknowledge that ‘anthrax’ has meant both the causative organism Bacillus anthracis and the disease resulting from infection. Her inclusivity enables her to make a point very often overlooked by historians of infectious disease: the organism itself has been significantly altered by human interaction. An excellent example of the value of her approach comes in her treatment of the manner in which Robert Koch ‘mastered’ (her term) the bacillus during his epochal work on anthrax in the 1870s. Here, Jones argues, was a classic example of both disease and organism being substantially changed through the wilful manipulation of the researcher. Consideration of this episode neatly reinforces her opening epigraph, attributed to Ovid: Omnia mutantur, nos et mutamur in illis (all things are changed, and we change with them).
More generally, her emphasis on the dynamic and shifting relationship between human civilization and anthrax is a major strength of the book, helping to facilitate another of its major arguments: that anthrax is one of the truly global diseases. There are very few regions of the world which did not encounter the disease in one form or another – and Jones helpfully and ably outlines the different varieties of anthrax (cutaneous, gastrointestinal and inhalation) early on. The sheer variety of names used to refer to anthrax gives an indication of just how successful Bacillus anthracis has been at travelling between different populations, sometimes aided by human and animal activity, sometimes not.
The book is arranged thematically, with the six chapters covering ground including – to quote some titles – infectivity and fear, transmission and casualty effectiveness. Whilst this organization helps to reinforce a sense of the multiplicity of contexts in which anthrax has occurred – most notably agriculture, industry and warfare – from time to time it makes for zigzagging chronology. We learn in Chapter 1 (‘Infectivity and fear’), for instance, about the work of Jean Fournier in classifying supposedly different ‘anthraxes’ in late eighteenth-century France, before being taken abruptly back to the Fertile Crescent. Similar problems affect Chapter 5 (‘Resistance’), where discussion of anthrax in apartheid South Africa between 1981 and 1994 leads on to coverage of two major mid-twentieth-century ‘theatres of proof’, Gruinard Island in Scotland and Vozrozhdeniye Island in Uzbekistan (then a part of the USSR). The book's overarching narrative of continual causal interaction between organism and humanity thus becomes somewhat hard to follow.
There is also a rather lopsided feel to the book as a whole, with well over half of it dedicated to discussion of anthrax since the First World War. Undoubtedly this period – which saw ‘laboratized’ anthrax become ever more central – is important in its own right and offers the historian of anthrax the greatest wealth of sources. But the resulting narrative rather leaves the impression that this kind of anthrax has somehow been dominant through the disease's history – a take-home message at odds with the book's overall acknowledgement of anthrax's ubiquity, its persistence and, especially, its variety from ancient times.
Nevertheless, Susan D. Jones provides a rich account of the history of anthrax, which weaves together themes ranging across laboratory science, preventive medicine and the technological developments which brought together biological agents and pre-existing military expertise. We learn along the way about the mysterious circumstances surrounding the suicide of Bruce Ivins, a major figure in late twentieth-century anthrax research and a leading suspect in the investigations surrounding the US mail attacks, as well as the ‘cloud chambers’ of the 1940s, which were used to test increasingly virulent strains of Bacillus anthracis on animals without the need for experimenters to wear protective clothing. In summary, this excellent book covers a great deal of ground both chronologically and geographically, and demonstrates that the ancient, deadly anthrax bacillus can act in still another way: as a useful tool through which historians can examine the complex links between civilization and disease.
