Walt Kelly (1913–73) certainly deserves a critical study of this kind: in the middle of the twentieth century his newspaper strip Pogo was syndicated in hundreds of US newspapers, and “by 1953 it was one of the top five strips in the country” (33). Pogo narrated the lives of the anthropomorphic animals that inhabited the swamps of Okefenokee in the American South, and the strip enjoys privileged status in comics history for its satirical resistance to McCarthyism. In the face of editorial hostility and personal pressure, Kelly attacked Senator Joseph McCarthy's tactics of scapegoating and intimidation by depicting the senator as a bullying, shotgun-wielding bobcat called Simple J. Malarkey. The lead character of the newspaper strip, Pogo the possum, was the figurehead of a mock presidential campaign in 1952 and 1956; during these campaigns, the shrewd self-publicist Kelly greatly enhanced Pogo's popularity and subversive credentials by addressing crowds of college students.
Kerry Soper has undertaken extensive and revealing archival research, with the aim of providing the biographical context missing from previous accounts of Kelly's work. Soper particularly refers to Kelly's early roles as an animator at Disney, as a comic-book creator, and as a political cartoonist, in order to illustrate the techniques and sensibility he brought to Pogo. We Go Pogo provides a series of lenses to examine Kelly's satirical project: his use of verbal and visual comedy, his negotiation of industrial and institutional opportunities, his use of African American cultural forms, the visual style of Pogo, and Kelly's status as a “poplorist.” This is a concept Soper takes from folklore scholar Gene Bluestein; what makes Kelly a poplorist is how he revived elements from traditional culture and achieved wide popularity through grassroots activities. It also refers to the development of Pogo out of a dialogue “between creator and engaged readers” (199). Kelly's role as poplorist is a major touchstone for Soper in his high valuation of Pogo.
Soper has a clear writing style, and even when the conceptual issues lean towards critical theory and philosophy, he articulates ideas in simple, accessible terms. Kelly's jokes come across well – Soper has seized the opportunity to quote from a number of witty letters and other manuscripts. Nonetheless, at times We Go Pogo is a tiresome read. This is partly because Soper repeats his points with greater frequency than necessary. Another grating aspect of We Go Pogo – especially in the early stages of the book – is the incessant celebration of Kelly's work. On one level this means that Kelly's greatness is repeatedly and explicitly stressed, such as “one could argue that Kelly is one of the top artists to ever work in comic strips” (10). This drive to hymn Kelly's ability leads Soper to make some awkward claims; for instance, when Kelly worked as a junior animator at Disney, his work would be criticized by senior animators because he hadn't sufficiently followed the model sheet that set out the template for how characters should look. Soper's interpretation? “Kelly's professional struggles at Disney may have been due, in part, to a lack of ability, but it probably had as much to do with his independent disposition” (25). It is rare to find any acceptance of Kelly's failings, artistically or morally, in We Go Pogo. This is especially problematic where Kelly's personal life, and his presidency of the National Cartoonists Society (NCS), is concerned. Kelly oversaw an organization that was uninterested in addressing the professional concerns of junior members, and the NCS was a bastion of sexism. To his credit, Soper does not shy away from the NCS's failings (and the failings of Kelly's presidency), but initially he tries to explain Kelly's “low-boiling contempt for less-experienced colleagues” in terms of Kelly's philosophical system (40–45). Later in We Go Pogo, Soper's analysis of Kelly's attitude towards women is refreshingly free of rationalization: “Kelly was a product of his time and profession, and made little effort to see beyond those low horizons” (130). In this instance, Soper is able to judge the limitations of Kelly's accomplishments soberly and fairly, but this should have been embedded through the book more extensively.
One aspect of We Go Pogo is thoroughly disappointing: the referencing apparatus. Several texts are referred to in the main text of the book without having a corresponding entry in the Works Cited (e.g. Barrier at 24, the “Walt Kelly” entry on Wikipedia quoted at 71, Turner at 100, and Lears at 106), and the Works Cited itself is dogged by problems. There are inexplicable spaces between entries and inconsistent use of --- to indicate multiple works by a single author. Many entries are listed twice (and not always in alphabetical order) – there are, in fact, three separate entries for Kelly's Ten Ever-Lovin’ Blue-Eyed Years with Pogo (1959).
Overall, Soper makes the case for the craft and strategy that went into Pogo strongly – so strongly, in fact, that the effusive tone with which Soper praises Kelly is counterproductive. Soper's research is convincing and interesting enough not to need overselling, and We Go Pogo constitutes a valuable contribution to scholarship.
