As nations across the globe struggle to consolidate democracy, we have witnessed a surge of promising scholarship on the critical role of the rule of law. This is notable considering that as recently as the early 1990s there was very little research on the role of the judiciary in democratizing regimes. Not just the subfield of democratization but the field of comparative politics more generally had overlooked the courts. Daniel M. Brinks's The Judicial Response to Police Killings in Latin America represents an important contribution to the growing literature on the rule of law in nascent democracies. Brinks sheds light on the relationship between economic inequality and the rule of law, in particular on how socioeconomic inequity impacts access to justice in Latin America. Although the conclusion that the wealthy and powerful tend to have advantages in the legal system while the courts often fail to protect vulnerable groups is not new, Brinks provides scholars of democratization with a valuable reminder to expand their conception of the rule of law to include greater emphasis on access to justice.
Brinks's skillful use of in-depth case studies is impressive. In order to capture the factors behind different judicial responses to police killings, Brinks conducted research on over five hundred homicides in five different jurisdictions, which necessitated extensive fieldwork in Argentina (Buenos Aires and Córdoba), Brazil (Salvador da Bahia and São Paolo), and Uruguay (Montevideo). Although parsimony is not one of the book's strengths, Brinks makes a wise decision to forgo simplicity in favor of accuracy and thereby captures the complexity of the relationship between social exclusion and the rule of law. The systematic application of the comparative method across five cases in three countries allows Brinks to explore numerous explanatory variables behind the effectiveness of a judicial system in defending the rights of citizens, including socioeconomic context, institutional arrangement, informational autonomy, political climate, procedural structure, police and prosecutorial resources, and various social and civil society actors involved in prosecution efforts.
Brinks argues convincingly that any legal system is a reflection of deeply rooted social hierarchies. The failure to prosecute members of the police force is largely a result of disparities between the political, monetary, and legal resources of claimants and defendants. Brinks's innovative use of the notion of “legal tolls” is particularly compelling. Legal tolls are present in all societies, but they tend to be more prevalent and less evenly distributed in areas characterized by widespread inequality. Underprivileged segments of society have few resources to pay the various legal tolls, which can include the fees for expensive legal representation and bribes. This observation is critical to understanding Latin America, a region with one of the most unequal distributions of wealth in the world. Although institutional design and nonstate legal assistance can help overcome impediments to justice, the contextual factors put forth by Brinks are resilient. As a result, informal practices that allow security officials to ignore the rights of the poor often overshadow formal guarantees of civil liberties.
The fact that, along with inequality, security concerns represent a major challenge for Latin America enhances the book's timeliness. Throughout the region, crime has skyrocketed and the recent crackdown by security forces has serious implications for the rule of law beyond the cases examined by Brinks. The rule of law requires that all actors, including law enforcement officials, are held accountable to the law and that all citizens have access to justice. Unfortunately, as Brinks demonstrates, because the majority of victims of police homicide are poor, members of the police force are often above the law and the victims of police violence lack recourse. As in the shantytowns of Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay, in much of Central America, a subregion that rests on fragile democratic scaffolding, the judicial system fails to protect the rights of those who live in poverty. In countries such as El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras, the mano dura (iron fist) policy employed by security forces to confront the gang problem erodes the rule of law. The iron fist policies grant security officials unchecked powers, which impinge on civil liberties and foster impunity for human rights abusers, including those members of the police force and vigilante groups who are guilty of homicide. As the citizens of Latin America increasingly clamor for order and security in light of the crime epidemic, it is likely that violations such as police killings will continue.
On the whole, Brinks's book is a welcome contribution to our understanding of the impact of social marginalization on the rule of law. This empirically rich study should be read by anyone interested in judicial politics in Latin America. The book's scope makes it a valuable addition to the scholarship on the rule of law not only in Latin America but across the developing world.
