This short book is probably the most detailed study available of post-war violence in El Salvador and one of the best studies of violence in Central America. Hume worked in ‘La Vía’ and ‘El Boulevar’, pseudonyms for two communities of Soyapango, a generally poor and crowded municipality which forms part of San Salvador's sprawling metropolitan area, and which is often referred to by the not very affectionate name of ‘Soyabronx’, due to the area's reputation as a site of danger, violence and gang control. Hume did not reside in either community, but attended local meetings, interviewed residents and conducted focus groups, supplementing the material with the results of interviews with incarcerated men and other research. She documents a wide variety of forms of violence that extend from broad social-structural relationships around wealth and poverty to intercommunity conflicts and intra-familial relationships.
The book is organised into five chapters and a conclusion. The first two chapters take up approaches to violence (chapter 1) and the misrecognition of violence in Latin America (chapter 2). Hume elides dichotomous definitions of behaviour (violent–non-violent) and an interest in naming causes for a broader, feminist-inspired relational approach and the examination of the social production and reproduction of violence. The middle chapters (3 and 4) take up violence in La Vía and El Boulevar. In chapter 3 Hume details the perception of violence and reactions to it in the community setting; in chapter 4 she homes in on families and the complex dynamics of beliefs and relationships through which women both suffer from and contribute to the production of violent men. The final chapter addresses responses to violence. There Hume discusses the failures of the government's hard line (Mano Dura) approach to youth gangs and laments the lack of interest in and funding for alternatives. She notes how, in response to government strategies, gangs have evolved into better structured, more hardened and even more violent organisations.
Key to much of her analysis are ‘gendered hierarchies of violence that are not based on material harm, but on the differentiated value placed on different forms of violence’ (p. 168). This is to say that some forms of violence, against women and children in particular, have become internalised as part of everyday interactions and are not regarded as violence at all. Yet these normalised forms, ideologically justified by perpetrators and often by their victims, contribute to its production and reproduction in other spheres. For instance, Hume notes how the same male children whom mothers commonly beat in order to make men of them frequently become spouse abusers and gang members when they grow to adulthood. The victims of such abuse commonly understand the violence to which they are subject as normal and expected. When violence is not socially recognised as such, it makes it exceedingly difficult to develop effective responses. In this Hume follows Bourdieu and others in deromanticising the poor and analysing how they play roles in their own exploitation. As she observes, ‘Violence is at the heart of everyday relations’ (p. 107).
Hume notes that many people in both communities respond to local episodes of violence with silence, out of mistrust of the authorities and fear that speaking out would result in reprisals on the part of perpetrators. She sees this kind of silence as a personal strategy of resistance in the context of weak and ineffective institutions, but argues that it also leads to impunity, individualisation and a weakening of the collective relationships necessary to respond to violence: ‘Mistrust and fear have become so embedded in social relations that they constitute the principal components of a vicious cycle that continues to undermine collective well-being’ (p. 93).
Ultimately the violence that plagues La Vía and El Boulevar has to be linked to broader sets of social and economic contradictions involved in the reproduction of wealth and poverty but also, and in a related sense, social inclusion and social exclusion. Not only were many of the subjects of Hume's study deprived of a dignified life, but they were commonly viewed with disdain and even suspicion when they entered public areas dominated by middle- and upper-class Salvadoreans. Hume discusses the limits of post-war settlements, which produced a democratic facade without thereby generating the political and material resources for broad participation. Elite-dominated post-war governments have strategically utilised the history of wartime violence, gangs and the high post-1992 murder rate both to marginalise the poor and to delegitimise collective struggles for social justice. In a final section Hume concludes that ‘as this study has done, it is necessary to move beyond a narrow analysis of individual responsibility to analyse the structures that give meaning to violence. The challenge is to dissect the larger systems of oppression and exploitation that allow violence to be an acceptable and routine element of everyday social and political interaction’ (p. 172).
This is a well-written, closely argued and carefully documented book that should receive attention from scholars working throughout Latin America and elsewhere. Hume's emphasis on the way violence is understood, its everyday forms, a perspective that allows her to move from the family to community and class relationships without sacrificing analytical rigour, and her discussion of ‘gendered hierarchies of violence’ should prove useful to researchers, policy-makers, service providers and activists. As an anthropologist I would have liked more detailed discussion of the histories and social relationships encountered in La Vía and El Boulevar, but the wide range of material offered, often of a sensitive nature, convinced me that Hume had established great rapport with her subjects and understood well the dynamics of local interactions.
