Sophia Hoffmann, in Iraqi Migrants in Syria, analyzes the Iraqi migration to Syria that began in the midst of the civil war that engulfed Iraq after the 2003 US-led invasion. Utilizing empirical and theoretical arguments, Hoffmann attempts to show how the migration impacted Syria's attitude toward refugees and humanitarian organizations, and thus provides a canvas for the statehood of Syria.
Hoffmann's fieldwork and interviews show that “Iraqis’ lives had become an arena for interventions by Syria and foreign actors” (10). She argues that the absence of liberal politics in Syria explains the relative freedom that Iraqis enjoyed in the country. Hoffmann's opening chapters focus on the Syrian state and Bashar al-Asad's regime. She then devotes three chapters to examining the actors of the foreign aid community: UNHCR, international NGOs, and donor states. Her last chapter explores the Iraqi population in Syria to underline “its diversity and varied strategies of accommodation and resistance” (30). Some of these chapters appeared in a different fashion in the International Journal of Middle East Studies 48(2) as “International Humanitarian Agencies and Iraqi Migration in Preconflict Syria.”
Although Iraqi Migrants in Syria is an examination of the Iraqi population in Syria, Hoffmann barely discusses the push factors that drove thousands of Iraqis to flee their country; the impact of sectarianism on these waves of migration; or the economic conditions prevailing in Iraq and their implications on those migrants. Furthermore, her chapter on Syrian statehood could have benefited from more background on how authoritarian regimes such as Syria function and how the organs of the state interact with their people.
Given that Syria has not joined the Geneva Refugee convention, Hoffmann sheds light on how the Syrian state reacted to the Iraqi migration by intervening domestically and internationally to cope with this crisis. The author connects these dealings of the state with what happened in the Syrian uprising that spotlighted the well-known dark side of the Syrian regime, particularly with regard to violence. Ironically, not many people wrote about these dark aspects of the regime in those years, and in fact most journalists, academics, and NGO workers complimented the Syrian regime for opening the doors to receive hundreds of thousands of Iraqis in the country, prior to the uprising. Furthermore, access to education and health was more liberal in Syria than what Jordan offered Iraqis entering the country during the civil war. Hoffman argues that there is a dichotomy in the way the Syrian regime used violence: on one hand, it portrayed itself as open and liberal to the west; opened its borders to Iraqi refugees, but simultaneously silenced internal opposition to the regime. The Syrian regime saw no conflict between being liberal economically and open to refugees, but using violence against its opponents. Similarly, in her chapter on international NGOs, she attempts to show how these organizations “embedded themselves in relationships of bureaucracy, money, emotion, and violence that partly constituted statehood in the Syrian context” (98). Hoffmann clearly depicts how international organizations had no significant role in the aid effort until the Iraqi migration drastically changed the scene.
The final chapter struck this reader as the most intriguing. Based on ethnographic data collected during field research and interviews with a diverse group of Iraqis, Hoffmann identifies three political behavioral groups: conformity; contestation; and disobedience and deception. What becomes apparent is that most of these refugees undermined the different forms of power applied to them as the “overall governance of Iraqi migration to Syria emerged from the interplay of regulation, contestation, and violence” (178-79). Hoffman further demonstrates in her conclusion that aid projects present a difficult challenge to illiberally ruled states and connects this difficulty to Syria's uprising and ongoing civil war.
From a technical point of view, the book could have benefited from better editing. For instance, the author states “the al-Asad” throughout, a tautology given that ‘the’ and ‘al’ are the same. However, Hoffmann's book is an important contribution to the study of migration in the Middle East and underlines the interaction between NGOs, donor states, an authoritarian regime, and the refugees who escaped the violence of a brutal sectarian civil war.
