Shelagh Weir's anthropology field research was in mountainous Jabal Razih in the far north of then Yemen Arab Republic near the Saudi border. When her work commenced in 1977, Razih was, as it is today, remote from the capital and regional economic and political centers. In three stays, totaling seventeen months, Weir gathered an impressive amount of data. In addition to articles and book chapters, some of this material has been published in the widely acclaimed Qat in Yemen: Consumption and Social Change (1985), a study of the socioeconomic role of this plant.
Weir's primary research focus was not qāt but rather tribal organization, at the time a central topic of anthropological inquiry. Although it has been thirty years since the study commenced, A Tribal Order benefits from distance. During the intervening years, Weir made several brief visits to Razih and worked with some informants in London. Especially useful was the opportunity to translate the more than 150 documents, spanning four centuries, that she was fortunate enough to photocopy early in her fieldwork. The historical dimension these materials provide deepen our understanding of the intricacies of Razihi tribal organization, the nature and structure of political leadership, and the application of tribal and Islamic law.
What constitutes a tribe and how one is organized has been a core question in anthropology since Evans-Pritchard described the patrilineal segmentary lineage system of the Nuer of Sudan. Unilineal descent was the core organizational principle and the basis for lineage aggregation and separation. Anthropologists adopted this model, assuming all tribes, with minor variations, were organized along similar kinship lines. Over the years it has become clear that tribes have different structures, but kinship has remained the central analytic and descriptive framework.
Although Yemeni tribes are all referred to as qabāʾil in an assumption of uniformity, there are a variety of tribal structures. Early in my fieldwork in Yemen, I listened, confounded, as a friend explained to a tribesman from another part of the country how “our” tribe was organized. The latter was adamant that his was a real tribe. Taking this as an aberration, I did not pursue these differences, which would have informed my understanding.
As Weir's analysis reveals, although kinship is the primary idiom of connectedness, tribal membership in Razih is defined by residence, land ownership, and affiliation—the latter two based, like all tribal relations, on qawāʿid or documents. A tribe's size is determined by geography and most interestingly by the leadership being able to travel, usually on foot, to all areas. Limited arable land and mountain terrain restrict group size. Indeed, tribes are subdivided into localized fractions, each with its own head and defined territory.
A tribe's power and prominence is influenced by its control of a regional market. However, the emphasis on land ensures tribes cannot expand through aggression. Moreover, each tribe is paired with another, and these concatenate as sets of countervailing forces.
A tribe is nothing if it does not have an effective leader to resolve disputes, activate support networks, and levy subscriptions upon members. Tribal leadership tends to be hereditary because sons are well positioned to learn the requisite skills. Weir clearly describes the economic and political components of shaykhly status. Wealth, significant marriage alliances, and possession of important documents all contribute to the office. Of special interest is the important role of women in shaykhly households in enabling these men to achieve and maintain their status. Leadership is not simply a matter of election or heredity; leaders and their deputies must also be adept arbiters who work diligently to meet the needs of constituents.
Old photographs frequently show wild-eyed, bushy-haired, rifle-toting Yemeni tribesmen. To outsiders, the images convey lawlessness and violence; to insiders the pictures reflect self-reliance. Neither depiction is accurate. In Razih, tribesmen live in a carefully circumscribed world governed by a complex system of tribal and Islamic laws through which accomplished leaders preserve order and deter violence. Tribesmen's weapons notwithstanding, legal documents are the tools of coercion. Indeed, Weir's photographs show shaykhs for what they are—staid representatives of moral and legal authority.
Despite its relative isolation, Razih was incorporated into the Yemeni state. In the final section Weir discusses relations between Razih and the Qasimi and Hamid al-Din Zaydi imamates governing Yemen. The imamate posted officials to Razih. By balancing state and district needs, and with local cooperation, they administered the region. With the advent of Yemen's republic, Razih's connection to the state increased.
Weir writes in an engaging, clear style. She devotes proper attention to detailing the environment, agriculture and markets, residential patterns, status inequality, occupations, and the significant, if often unseen, roles of women. Her description of the economy establishes both local patterns and connections to neighboring areas.
Case studies elucidate the historical depth of the Razihi system. Documentary materials trace Razih's changing relations with political centers. The text incorporates a wealth of Razihi or Yemeni terms, and these are collected in a glossary. Charts, maps, photographs, and a catalogue of the documents collected supplement her comprehensive text.
Although discussion of tribes in Yemen or the Middle East has been supplanted by other topics, the current prominence of and confusion about Iraqi tribes suggest it is time to resume this inquiry. Weir's study indicates new directions.
A Tribal Order recalls classic ethnography in the best sense. The reader is impressed by the thoroughness of the presentation, the clarity and comprehensiveness of the description, and the careful integration of historical elements. This book is a most welcome addition to studies of tribes in general and Yemeni tribes in particular. It was definitely worth the wait.
