This article deviates slightly from others in this symposium because we compare the environment, the benefits, and the substance related to the work of what we term “mainstream conferences” and “group-specific conferences.” Mainstream conferences are those in which researchers tend to operate a priori from a broad set of theories consisting of a universal set of concepts that are assumed to apply to broad categories with little regard to subgroups or context. In contrast, group-specific conferences focus on topics associated with singular or intersectional group-based identities. We investigate the American Political Science Association (APSA) and the National Conference of Black Political Scientists (NCOBPS) because of their shared history and prominence as leading organizations in political science. We argue that because mainstream research often fails to provide the historical and cultural context necessary to properly analyze Black politics, those scholars who grapple with these issues are forced to pursue alternative spaces for engaging their work. Following Gaines and Reed (Reference Gaines and Reed1994) we use the concept “going underground” to reference conferences that allow scholars to address topics often ignored or undervalued in the mainstream literature. Footnote 1
The emergence of the NCOBPS highlights the importance of conference context in shaping the overall treatment of research questions in the field of Black politics, broadly defined. For scholars from underrepresented groups and for those whose research questions often are marginalized within the broader discipline, group-specific conferences provide a meaningful space for receiving critical feedback on scholarly products, fruitful avenues for professional development, and networking with scholars with similar research interests. These conferences, we argue, offer a better opportunity to engage in the type of community building that Rom (Reference Rom2012) views as essential for professional conferences. The creation of organizations such as the NCOBPS does not detract from the development of political science writ large. Indeed, it provides a means of remapping the terrain of political science as an intellectual space (Alexander-Floyd Reference Alexander-Floyd2014). This stance does not suggest that scholars of Black politics should abandon the APSA or participate in conferences that focus only on their particular research area. In this article we revisit the genesis of the NCOBPS and the strained relationship with the APSA that led to its founding. This history is important for understanding the origins of the NCOBPS and the continuing relevance of similar group- and subfield-specific conferences. The focus then turns to comparing the relative benefits and shortcomings of attending the conferences.
ORGANIZED INTERESTS AND INSTITUTION BUILDING
In 1969, APSA leaders joined 35 Black political scientists on the campus of Southern University and A&M College, a historically black university located in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, to attend The Conference of Political Science Curriculum at Predominantly Black Institutions. Footnote 2 This meeting was convened by Jewel Prestage, chair of the political science department at Southern University, and financed by a grant that she received from the Ford Foundation. Footnote 3 The project was designed to examine the political science curriculum at historically Black colleges and universities as well as to address various concerns of Black political scientists regarding the dearth of scholarship focused on Black politics and the marginalization of scholars who conducted research in this area. For example, one session was titled “Greater Involvement of Blacks in the Professional Associations.” The conclusion of this panel highlighted Black political scientists’ concerns that Blacks who taught at predominantly Black schools were alienated by the APSA and not included in its deliberations. These scholars argued that the omission of their ideas and research weakened the APSA’s ability to develop a more comprehensive understanding of both the study and practice of politics.
The four-day meeting in Baton Rouge led to a comprehensive report concluding that the discipline simply had failed to illuminate adequately those aspects of politics that are of most interest to America’s out-groups: “Black political scientists [also] should strive to explicate and carefully examine the standards of relevance that guide [their] research and teaching and try to emphasize those concerns that are important for out-groups, the poor, and Afro Americans” (Woodard Reference Woodard and Woodard1977, iv). Footnote 4 The report also captured a consistent theme that resonated throughout the conference: namely, the need for the discipline to consider the study of Black politics as a legitimate subfield. However, there was significant variation in regard to how that field should be studied and which approaches should be emphasized. Some participants argued that there was a need for the discipline to “deal with the Black perspective” as a frame of reference when studying politics as a whole. Footnote 5 The tenor of this position was reflected in the first session, titled “Political Science Curricula in the Predominantly Black Colleges.” One of the most vocal participants in this session was Mack Jones, then an assistant professor at Atlanta University, who suggested that courses be built around the Black-liberation struggle that seeks to “subvert the existing order insofar as it reflects the racism which abounds in American society. Jones endorsed the position that the Black colleges and their political science departments should seek to promote disenchantment among Black students so that they will be inclined to challenge rather than support the existing order” (Woodard Reference Woodard and Woodard1977, 6–7). Although some attendees supported Jones, others appeared to be “wary” of the teaching of a Black-liberation philosophy that would weaken the discipline’s focus on the existing system. This sentiment was consistent with the participants’ contention that the meeting at Southern University was not considered the nucleus of a separate organization. Rather it was an opportunity to determine which problems they might have in common with other political scientists and to transmit their findings to the APSA (Woodard Reference Woodard and Woodard1977, 20).
FROM CAUCUS TO CONFERENCE
Building on the momentum of the meeting at Southern University, participants recommended that they form a caucus and reconvene later that year at the APSA Annual Meeting in New York to formally voice their concerns. Despite agreeing to formally present their grievances, similar to the Southern meeting, it was not unanimous in the Black Politics Caucus that publicly voicing its concerns with the APSA was the best course of action. Some felt that it was time for Black political scientists to “chart their own course” and not rely on the APSA for legitimacy. Despite these contentions, the Caucus moved forward with its plan to formally present its grievances.
The APSA sent representatives to respond to the demands of the NCOBPS. Although they met some of the demands, members of the Black Politics Caucus were not satisfied and rejected their offer. This rejection led to the creation of a separate organization, the NCOBPS. According to its mission statement, the NCOBPS was founded on the belief that Black scholars face unique challenges that require a dedicated space to engage with those who share their lived experiences and their scholarly commitments.
We now discuss the current status of scholars who attend both conferences to explore whether (1) they continue to face some of the same challenges that led to Black political scientists bolting from the APSA in 1969, or (2) the APSA has evolved to adequately address specific issues germane to the study of Black Politics. To discuss this issue, we specifically examine the case of intersectionality research.
Although they met some of the demands, members of the Black Politics Caucus were not satisfied and rejected their offer. This rejection led to the creation of a separate organization, the NCOBPS.
The Challenges and Compromises of Mainstream Conference Participation
Academic conferences have become contested sites for debating the exclusion of marginalized groups, in terms of both the methodology and the political orientation and impact of political science as a discipline. Questions of exclusion are especially critical in terms of addressing “mutually constitutive” identities, such as race and gender (Alexander-Floyd Reference Alexander-Floyd2007; Fernandes Reference Fernandes1997; Gillman Reference Gillman2010; Harris Reference Harris1999; McClintock Reference McClintock1995). Recently, political scientists have sought to include an “intersectional” approach to the study of politics. Rather than using a constitutive model of identity in examining Black women or other women of color as political actors, however, most studies simply reduce identities to dichotomous variables of race and gender or another combination of demographic attributes. In this light, Alexander-Floyd (Reference Alexander-Floyd2012) discussed how “intersectionality”—a concept that evolved from the work of Black and other women of color scholar-activists—was co-opted for broader consumption within traditional disciplines, such as political science. Black women and women of color as political actors, according to Alexander-Floyd, have “disappeared” from such research, thereby undermining the political projects and intellectual agenda behind their genesis. Intersectionality thus framed is a “post-Black feminist intersectionality,” Alexander-Floyd stated—one that invokes Black feminist theory only to strip it of its political relevance and intellectual integrity. Building on this work, Jordan-Zachery (Reference Jordan-Zachery2014) similarly found an “omission project” afoot in work on intersectionality in political science. To be sure, the practical outworking of this post-Black feminist co-optation of intersectional or constitutive models of identity is in full display in the research presented at traditional political science conferences.
Other than the misappropriation of the frameworks of Black women and women of color, important factors such as context and language often are lost in translation at mainstream conferences. A specific example illustrates the challenges faced by students of Black politics. While preparing their research at a mainstream conference, two scholars engaged in a debate regarding the concepts used to describe their research. Substantively, the specific research was the study of Black women’s hairstyles and candidate evaluations. This topic fits within the broader literature on how aesthetics shape candidates’ favorability (i.e., in this case, Black women candidates with natural hairstyles are evaluated less favorably than those with straighter hairstyles). However, the debate that ensued revolved around whether the researchers should (1) frame their research to conform to the much broader scope of research conducted in the subfield of American politics (e.g., hirsute politics), or (2) simply present it with a substantive analysis of the political phenomenon at issue rather than inductively try to fit it into an existing theory that was not originally designed to apply to Blacks. Conceptually, there was also a debate about the language that would be used. Would the specific term “twist outs” be used to describe a particular hairstyle, or should a broader label (e.g., Afrocentric hairstyles) be used? The argument against using the former was based in the notion that because of assumed limitations of the audience’s familiarity with Black hair—given that it was a mainstream conference—that broader language should be used. That is, to appease the audience, the suggestion was made to discard the use of language describing specific hairstyles and to move to broader concepts, such as Afrocentric versus Eurocentric hairstyles. This conformity proved to be highly problematic for one of the scholars. To buttress the point regarding the lack of understanding and, by extension, the limited worldview, of mainstream scholars, a discussant of this same article commented, “When looking at the abstract I found it was a crazy idea to hypothesize that Black women’s hairstyles matter in voters’ or citizens’ perceptions of Black ideology. Having read the literature review, I am now rather convinced that for Afro-Americans, hairstyles have a political connotation.” The recent reversal of the Pentagon’s contested restrictions on African American women’s hairstyles underscores the relevance of such notions regarding beauty, femininity, identity, and race studies in this research.
This pressure to conform to traditional concepts reflects the more general experience of Black and other non-white scholars as “space invaders” in the APSA (Puwar Reference Puwar2004). As Puwar noted, there are “somatic norms” within institutions, and when people who do not fit those norms enter, they face a number of responses, which include having a “burden of representation” and confronting stereotypes about their lack of ability. Scholars of Black politics, particularly those who are Black, also are influenced by neutral policies (e.g., the limitations of panels based on session attendance) that have a disparate impact on scholars of race and ethnic politics. Given the previous discussion, the NCOBPS has been a vital resource for specialists in Black politics, in particular, and Black political scientists more generally.
The NCOBPS has had a powerful impact on the discipline as a whole. Some scholars, particularly members of the founding generation, attend the NCOBPS exclusively. Others see the NCOBPS as an important part of a constellation of conferences that they attend. Furthermore, whatever their location is in the academy, Black-politics scholars have found the NCOBPS to be indispensable to their scholarship and careers. Many well-known Black scholars who are members of the APSA attend the NCOBPS, have gained leadership experience through service in the organization, and have found it to be a fertile ground for the maturation of their scholarship and their professional development. As Michael Dawson noted in the acknowledgments of his groundbreaking work, Behind the Mule, Dianne Pinderhughes (former president of the NCOBPS and the APSA) and Hanes Warton Jr. not only incisively critiqued “not only incisively critiqued the work, but also helped to introduce me to the complexities and importance of work in the field of black politics. Conversations with them and with many other colleagues in the National Conference of Black Political Scientists will continue to shape the direction of my work and keep me grounded in my roots” (Dawson 1995, xi). Such sentiments reflect the general tenor of scholars who have benefited from membership in the NCOBPS. However, despite the benefits of attending the NCOBPS, some scholars are forced to forgo this experience due to pressures invoked by the discipline and scarce financial resources during the economic downturn.
When Inclusion Breeds Exclusion: The Group-Specific Backlash
The economic downturn exacerbated the financial struggles that many universities face. Given the scarcity of departmental funds, many students and faculty are forced to finance their own attendance at professional conferences and/or limit which meetings they will attend. In many ways, the pressure to attend mainstream conferences penalizes those students and faculty who might find it more beneficial to attend group-specific conferences. This pressure is generated through expectations associated with faculty-merit evaluations, promotion and tenure, and the hiring process. Typically, Research I universities consider mainstream conferences to be more competitive or prestigious and, therefore, rate them higher than group-specific conferences. As a result, many scholars are forced to opt-out of attending group-specific conferences. Similarly, there is a disincentive for graduate students in the job market to attend group-specific conferences because an overwhelming number of universities that want to enhance the racial and ethnic diversity of their faculty restrict recruitment efforts to mainstream conferences. Indeed, in the NCOBPS case, universities rarely recruit at the conference unless an affiliated faculty member from their institution attends. These circumstances have the potential to attenuate student and faculty memberships and attendance at the NCOBPS. Furthermore, there are those who may be on the job market and decide not to attend a mainstream conference, or whose work is perceived to be too narrow to fit in the program. In this case, they are at a disadvantage because recruiters attend mainstream conferences but forgo the NCOBPS.
In many ways, the pressure to attend mainstream conferences penalizes those students and faculty who might find it more beneficial to attend group-specific conferences.
Group-specific conferences such as the NCOBPS also may provide intimate settings in which experts in their field are more accessible. Topics related to their field of study often are more substantively related to their research when compared to mainstream conferences, in which scholars often are forced to inductively situate their research in an existing mainstream theory. Indeed, based on an APSA task force report, Political Science in the 21st Century, the extant literature in political science is “ill-equipped to address in a sustained way why many of the most marginal members of political communities around the world are often unable to have their needs effectively addressed by governments” (APSA 2011, 1). A plausible explanation in the report is that the existing literature often has failed to include identity as a “core analytical category” in the study of political phenomena. This proves not to be the case with research that frequently is presented at the NCOBPS, where racial identity is embraced and often the center of scholarly debate. In addition to panels, organizational awards are named for activists and scholars who fought for the liberation of people throughout the African diaspora. This may seem trivial; however, it is a notable intervention—one that affirms the legitimacy of Black politics scholarship and recognizes and holds as a standard the radical traditions of scholarship, teaching, and service embodied in those individuals for which the awards are named. Given that one goal of conferences, as noted by Rom (2012), is for scholars to share their research with colleagues who can provide rich, substantive feedback, there is a greater benefit and incentive to attend conferences in which the environment is more receptive and one’s research is better understood. These conferences also reenergize faculty and students who are enrolled in graduate programs or work in isolated departments or programs with only a few faculty members who engage in research related to Black politics. Footnote 6 It is refreshing to have the opportunity to network in professional and social settings with other scholars who engage in similar research. Although this is taken as a given—indeed, the second main reason Rom provides for the benefit of conferences generally—the failure of mainstream conferences to meet this need is acutely felt and therefore remedied by conferences such as the NCOBPS. Culturally, these conferences also provide a safe haven for scholars who conduct research that focuses on politics within the African diaspora.
Of course, the NCOBPS, like the APSA, has struggled with institutional limitations. Efforts to improve on these limitations have been successful, particularly around the issue of sexism. In recent years, the organization has made progress in addressing issues of equity along several fronts. The NCOBPS established a financial award in support of research on Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) issues. The organization also made a concerted effort to ensure gender equity in terms of representation on the executive council and among conference co-chairs. Recently, NCOBPS established a formal affiliation with the Association for the Study of Black Women in Politics to co-organize panels at the NCOBPS annual meeting, provide the site for its annual business meeting, and promote mentoring for younger scholars. Finally, the NCOBPS journal, the National Political Science Review, released Volume 16, “Black Women in Politics: Power, Identity, and Transformation,” which is the first ever to publish an issue focusing on Black women as political actors. Although there is ongoing room for improvement, these milestones represent the commitment of the organization’s leaders and members to forge a dynamic, politically responsive, and progressive space in which to support Black political scientists and the study of Black Politics.
Although this article focuses almost solely on the benefits of attending group-specific conferences such as the NCOBPS, there is space for scholars of Black politics to advance the subfield at mainstream conferences. Indeed, members of the NCOBPS were instrumental in creating the race, ethnicity, and politics section of the APSA. The APSA also offers workshops during its annual conference that allow groups of scholars with similar interests to choose panels related to their topic of interest. After attending the panels, the groups reconvene at the end of the day to discuss how this research can be synthesized and how it might inform their own work. These meetings have proven to be more informative, and they help scholars build communities that allow them to engage in more lengthy discussions than those in the time allotted for each panel. The creation of the race and ethnic politics sections at the APSA—as well as The Western Political Science Association’s feminist theory and Latino politics workshops and intersectionality section—also reflect efforts to move beyond simply claiming space within the context of traditional conferences. The Southern Political Science Association, generally regarded as a more open environment for discussing race and ethnic politics, provides the opportunity to arrange “conferences within a conference,” and the Midwestern Political Science Association has a newly created set of panels that falls under the rubric of professional development. Each conference provides meaningful arenas for those who study Black politics and who want to assemble—within the context of traditional political science conferences—to disseminate their work to colleagues whose work aligns with their own. It also presents the opportunity for mainstream scholars to be exposed to more in-depth research regarding issues related to Black politics.
In this article we underscore the value of specialized conferences in the fullest development of political science research. They are a vital means of counteracting the “undergrounding” of specific groups and subfields within our discipline writ large. Moreover, the conferences serve as a model of intellectual engagement from which traditional or mainstream conferences can learn. Understanding the genesis of the NCOBPS and its continued prominence illuminates the challenges facing scholars of Black politics and provides opportunities to highlight best practices for the APSA and other traditional conferences to more fully reflect the diversity of profiles and interests of its members.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We would like to express our appreciation to Joseph McCormick, Wendy Smooth, and James Taylor for their valuable feedback.
