The present paperback volume, which results from a workshop in Göttingen in 2015, adds to the growing number of studies on late antique leadership in recent years. The eleven chapters cover the period from Constantine to the Theodosians, treating aspects of how authority was maintained and construed through communications. ‘Leadership’ is reserved for bishops and, especially, emperors (the subject of seven chapters). By comparison, another recent volume on leadership includes chapters on saints, abbesses, queens and even ‘Rome’ as a symbol (Y.R. Kim and A.E.T McLaughlin, Leadership and Community in Late Antiquity. Essays in Honour of Raymond Van Dam (2020)). Limitations can be creative, however, and the volume is well worth reading as a collection of analytical perspectives on episcopal and imperial authority. The production is good but modest, with no illustrations or maps.
Most chapters are brief and focused, answering in varying degrees to the volume's methodological call to engage with ‘systematic medium analysis’, which dictates that ‘specific local and medial traditions should be taken into account when analysing the sources’ (both 13). Overall, the contributions that most clearly take up this call (notably Manders, Cvetković and McEvoy) are also the most successful. The stated aim of analysing ecclesiastical and imperial authority as interdependent (13) is, however, not evident in the contributions, which treat one or the other.
The chapter by Verena Janschke on the architecture of imperial residences represents an overview, which is a pity, seeing that the material would benefit from a more detailed ‘systematic medium analysis’. Adrastos Omissi's chapter treats the outlook of the authors of imperial panegyrics, which he argues differed by class. To high-status individuals, panegyrics offered a socially acceptable space for reconciliation with emperors (40), while intellectuals of humbler status angled for promotions. Omissi reminds us of the frequency of such speeches, which had been a regular feature of high political discourse for centuries. It is here assumed that they served the emperors’ needs (35), but one could argue that the one who politely accommodated the other was the emperor.
Erika Manders examines coins with pagan deities struck in Nicomedia, Antioch and Alexandria in 312, raising interesting questions regarding the dynamics between civic and central authorites. Manders rejects the notion that these coins responded to Maximin Daia's persecution of Christians, showing that they followed both local and imperial traditions. She identifies the real question as why pseudo-autonomous coinage was suddenly allowed, and one suspects that Daia was increasingly dependent on local support. Elisabeth Hermann-Otto re-examines the moralising rhetoric and draconian punishment of Constantinian laws (famously in CTh 9.24.1 on rape), arguing that, rather than an ideological shift in jurisdiction, these represented a communicative strategy that masked pragmatic intentions. The material is slim, as the author admits, but it opens up new lines of inquiry. More could perhaps have been made with it; for instance, a discussion on specific audience(s), and why these would be receptive to such rhetoric, would have been useful.
Conversely, John Curran's chapter is packed to the brim, analysing no less than three aspects of the relations between Jews and (internal and external) authorities: the aims of adversus iudaeos literature (especially John Chrysostom's homilies); an apparent ambivalence toward the Jews in legislation; and the position of Jewish patriarch(s). Each discussion could have been expanded to stand alone, and from the editors’ perspective this might have been preferable. That said, there is much of interest here for the historian, not least in the preliminary examination of terminology. Curran concludes that ‘Judaism’ as an ideology is post-antique: what mattered in antiquity was what Jews did, not what they were. This would seem to have ramifications for the separation of ‘Jews’ as a political and ‘Judaism’ as a religious phenomenon in scholarly discourse.
Gerda De Kleijn applies modern leadership terminology to the reign of Constantius II, laying out theoretical models with admirable clarity. The ‘warrior model of autocracy’ (104–5) has particular promise to unlock new analytical potential. There could perhaps have been more sensitivity to rhetorical stereotypes, especially seeing the almost universal vilification of this emperor, but as an evaluation of such stereotypes the analysis works well. The sadly departed Marianne Saghý describes Damasus’ martyr commemorations as a strategy for conflict resolution. Her arguments are partly convincing, but she does not do enough to interrogate the partisan bias of the sources; for instance, she takes the allegation that Damasus associated with ruffians at face value. It is also a pity that the sociological terminology introduced at the beginning is not applied in the examination.
Carmen Angela Cvetković examines accounts of the Illyrian bishop Niceta, reframing the underlying conflict in terms of the rivalry between Nicenes and Homoians rather than the Roman and Constantinopolitan sees. Niceta, Cvetković argues, is framed as a Nicene champion, in language that evokes the political and military authority of emperorship. The study fleshes out both the real and ideal Niceta, and provides a window into episcopal networks, priorities and rhetorical strategies. Also interesting is the chapter by Julio Cesar Magalhaës de Oliveira, in which he revisits two episodes in Roman North Africa usually associated with crowd violence instigated by bishops: the resistance put up by Donatus of Bagaï against the emissaries of Constans, and Augustine's sermon regarding the destruction of pagan statues (Aug. Serm. 24). Magalhaës de Oliveira dissolves these ‘crowds’ into independent actors, with whom bishops could, or were compelled to, negotiate.
The book ends with two chapters on adjacent topics. Martijn Icks explores the visibility of emperors from two contradictory perspectives: the ‘palace-bound’ emperors contrasted with the accessibility of emperors in the field, and the hierarchy of the gaze which ascribes the inferior position to the one beheld. These make for interesting tensions in the presentation of emperors, which were readily exploited; for instance, Synesius could blame Arcadius for invisibility, while at the same time describing his aspect in humiliating detail. Perhaps understandably, Icks’ attempt to establish patterns in the application of these values is not entirely successful, but both the material and the discussion are interesting and illuminating. Finally, Meaghan McEvoy examines evidence for Arcadius’ actual public engagement, finding these far more frequent and multi-faceted than usually recognised. The chapter is one of the more important in the volume, revealing on the one hand the dissonance between rhetoric and reality, on the other the growing political importance of the Constantinopolitans as a population.
A concluding chapter that extracts and systematises insights from across the chapters would have been welcome. The overall impression of the volume is uneven, but the best chapters add facets to our understanding of imperial and ecclesiastical authority and deepen our knowledge of the sources. Most readers will probably be drawn to particular sources or areas of interest, but the book merits reading in sequence. Between its pages, power emerges as negotiated rather than monolithic, both leaders and led as individual agents with complex agendas.
