Hope in a Collapsing World documents a multi-site applied-theatre project for youth, which combined ethnographic research with collaborative theatre workshops in five countries – Canada, Britain, Greece, India and Taiwan – during a five-year period and culminated in the creation and performance of Kushnir's Towards Youth: A Play on Radical Hope. The project and performance explore ‘notions of hope and care … by way of examining how theatre-making with young people’ in diverse global communities might encourage adults to listen attentively to youth and help young people work through their political and social anxieties about today's complex world (p. 8). The authors use verbatim theatre to create a ‘fictional non-fiction experience’ that captures ‘often-underrepresented voices (or historically misrepresented voices)’ (p. 10). The research had four objectives: to learn what students across the globe care about, to determine whether and how drama can ‘intentionally mobilize’ hope, to see whether ‘collaborative work in the drama classroom’ can ‘catalyze broader civic engagement’, and to examine how ideas and activism travel ‘across cultural and linguistic borders’ (p. 80).
Part I establishes the theoretical grounding, describes the project's objectives, explains the ethnographic, qualitative and quantitative methodologies; introduces the social/geographical contexts; and presents the informants. Chapter 1 highlights listening as ‘an activist tool’ and justifies the verbatim format and drama space as devices to inspire youth agency (pp. 16–17). The book succeeds in contextualizing the social tensions and political worries that might lead to youth hopelessness in each country: poverty, the stigma of homosexuality and the lack of economic and social mobility in Taiwan; racism toward refugees intertwined with Greece's economic crises; oppression of and violence toward girls and women in India; the Brexit referendum in Britain; and marginalization, indigenous and trans peoples’ rights, US imperialism and mental illness in Canada. Interspersed throughout are fragments of Gallagher's interviews with students and drama instructors. A strong chapter 6 details and analyses performance workshops with Canadian youth, all centred on race, gender or disabilities. One particular activity shows how critical thinking skills were sharpened because students discovered that their performance had reproduced – rather than challenged – sociocultural norms. Gallagher argues that ‘drama in a justice and care-focused context is about survivable failure’ (p. 180), which is exactly what these students experienced.
Positing the drama room as a space for imagination and hopefulness, Gallagher argues that ‘it was an invitational space that welcomed into the room the troubles and joys of the world outside’ and that it activated care and built solidarity, while working with the ‘materials and conditions of students’ lives’ (p. 95). She maintains that youth across the world have ‘adult worries’ (p. 101) and that theatre can help them work through these in productive ways.
Part II, penned by Kushnir, describes, analyses and presents his play, staged in Toronto in 2019. Because Part I's descriptions and analyses are thorough and captivating, Part II is sometimes redundant. However, Kushnir's chapter titled ‘A Step towards Youth’ convincingly highlights the transformative power of verbatim theatre to ‘trouble the fiction/non-fiction binary’ and expose the ‘punctum’, or moments where ‘preconceptions have been dismantled by an event or statement’ presented onstage (p. 226). Kushnir describes his play's evolution from five hour-long vignettes to one two-hour performance encompassing all their global research sites, and he describes and reflects on the production's style and format.
An ambitious project, Radical Hope consumed more than five years of these researchers’/artists’ lives and brought them into contact with hundreds of people of all ages in many diverse parts of the globe. Nonetheless, because the book emphasizes Gallagher's and Kushnir's accounts of the project and because the researcher and artist insert themselves into every encounter with the young people and their teachers, the reader does not have much opportunity to actively ‘listen to’ the young people's concerns or hear them working through them. Kushnir seems to recognize this when he writes about the Taiwan experience: ‘Any attempts to transfer the student performances we observed into the body of Towards Youth fell flat’ (p. 240). In some ways, Kushnir's comment that ‘something that is inherently theatrical cannot be easily or as effectively re-presented in the theatre’ unhinges the entire project, which was, in effect, built to actively listen to youth and allow them ‘the possibility of having their voices and stories heard in their society’ (p. 240). Moreover, sometimes, the ‘students’ performances’ become more about Gallagher, Kushnir or the teachers’ thoughts, troubles and actions than about the students’ fears, dreams and hopes. Nonetheless, these scholars/artists should be commended for completing and documenting this expansive project. The book is a unique, original attempt to articulate ways in which theatre classrooms around the globe might awaken activism and inspire hope.
