Introduction
Since it gained its independence in 1948, Israel has sought to have positive relations with most members of the international community. It has tried to establish and maintain friendly relations with as many states as possible. During the 1990s, Israel developed its relations with many of the Asian and African countries and inaugurated diplomatic relations. Especially after the beginning of the peace process, Israel has developed ties, and has diplomatic relations with many states that it had never had any links with in the past. Israel's relations with China, India, and the economic tigers of Asia have also been bolstered, as well as with Mexico, Brazil, and Argentina. In this regard, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been one of the Israeli leaders who has been keen on expanding ties with many of these states. In January 2015, he told his cabinet that ‘the State of Israel must vary the markets in which we are active . . . In the last two years, I have met with the leaders of China, Japan and India as part of a comprehensive policy of turning to major markets, including Latin America and Africa’ (Taylor, Reference Taylor2015). As part of the Asian continent, Israel has been interested from its inception in good ties with Asian states, China and India in particular. During the 1990s, Israel finally established full diplomatic ties with both of these countries, and Israel's relations especially with India have taken on an ever-greater significance since the beginning of the new millennium.
Besides India, China, and the other states, another important Asian country with which Israel's relations are flourishing is Japan. Over recent years, the two countries’ relations have steadily progressed. The absence of conflicting political interests have helped to grow stable relations between the two countries. Leaders of both countries have exchanged visits, which played a crucial role in enhancing mutual understanding and trust through deepening cooperation and coordination. When Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visited Japan in May 2014, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe expressed their willingness to further develop relations with Israel: ‘I am determined, together with Prime Minister Netanyahu, to make further efforts to strengthen Japan–Israel relations, so that the potentials are fully materialized’ (Liphshiz, Reference Liphshiz2015). On the other hand, the developing relations have been best exemplified by the visit of Abe to Israel in 2015, which was the first visit of a Japanese Prime Minister to Israel in nine years (Yashar, Reference Yashar2015).
While Israel is located at the southwestern tip of Asia on the eastern shore of the Mediterranean Sea, Japan is located on the eastern edge of Asia. Despite this great geographical distance, as Israel's first Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion stated, ‘Israel and Japan are situated at opposite ends of Asia, but this is a fact which binds them together rather than separates them. The vast continent of Asia is their connecting link, and the consciousness of their Asian destiny is their common thought’ (Cohen, Reference Cohen2015a). Geographically, Israel is a Middle Eastern country; however, its culture, society, and political system remain primarily Western in nature and orientation. On the other hand, Japan has a unique rich culture and traditions dating back many centuries, although more recent times have seen huge technological advances. Both countries have similarities and constraints in their own conditions. Economically and technologically, Israel and Japan are among the most advanced nations in the world. They have ancient origins and traditions, and they both lack in natural resources. After World War II, both countries were short of capital, technology, trained human resources, and even the food needed to thrive. Therefore, they depended on the development of their human skills and know-how, and they both have been successful in this respect.
Although Israel was among the first nations to establish diplomatic contacts with Japan, the relations between the two states that are mutually beneficial have been very slow to develop. Only quite recently has there been changes in the context of their relations which promise positive developments. Great geographical distance and the absence of meaningful cultural or historical connections between Israel and Japan might explain only part of the lack of development in the relationship. In fact, the main reason was the Arab boycott of trade with Israel. Because of its heavy dependence on Arab oil imports, Japan was one of the developed countries that adhered most to the boycott. As a result, the relations between these two important countries were historically cool up until the 1990s.
However, over the past ten years the two countries’ relations have steadily progressed. Leaders of both countries have exchanged visits, which played a crucial role in enhancing mutual understanding and trust through deepening cooperation and coordination. Cooperation between the two countries could be productive, and both Israel and Japan have much to gain from the developing relationship between the two countries. As for Israel, Japan might become one of Israel's significant political and economic friends, given the isolation of Israel especially in the Middle East. Israel may diversify its foreign relations and economic ties. It can enjoy the positive role Japan plays in the world and the opportunities presented by a stronger relationship with it. On the other hand, there are many potential benefits that Japan may accrue by associating herself with the Jewish state.
Israel's developing relations with Asian states are a part of a combined effort which aims to maintain diplomatic relations with most Asian states. The growing economic strength and political influence of these states have contributed to the intensification of ties in the political, economic, and cultural spheres. Israel is not about to replace its strategic alliance with the United States; and Europe will probably remain its main trading partner for the foreseeable future. However, there is massive untapped potential in the east, and Israel seeks to balance its increasingly damaged Western alliances with stronger ties in Asia. When one thinks of Israel's relations with Asia, two countries may come to mind before Japan. The first one is India. Israel's trade ties with India have been fairly constant over recent decades and diplomatic relations have been notably warming under the current premiership of Narendra Modi. The second one is China. As with India, Israel's trade ties with China are substantial and growing. ‘China and India offer Jerusalem vast trade opportunities without the political challenges it faces in parts of Europe’ (Sales, Reference Sales2015). In addition, there stands the largely neglected story of Israel and Japan, which should receive some attention. Japan is another prominent Asian state that has developed significant relations with Israel. Whereas Israel's ties with China and India have flourished over the past three decades, its relations with Japan also seem to follow the same path. Israel's ties with China and India do not directly impact its relations with Japan; however, Israel's relations with Japan could be accepted as a part of Israel's developing ties with Asian states. For this reason, although the main purpose of this article is to describe Israel's developing relations with Japan, this article begins by giving a brief summary of Israel's relations with the Asian states, especially with the two important states of Asia, namely India and China, to show how Israel has developed cordial relations with Asian states in a broader context. It then tries to explain the nature of the developing relations between Israel and Japan, and aims to point out possible future areas of cooperation.
Israel in Asia
The late 1980s and early 1990s were marked by important developments for Israel's relations with important Asian countries. The peace process enhanced Israel's international position, and major breakthroughs were achieved in Israel's relations, not only with the countries of the Middle East periphery, but also with the most populous Asian states such as China and India. As part of the transformation of Israel's standing in Asia, one of the important developments was the establishment of diplomatic relations with China in 1992 (Shichor, Reference Shichor1994). Israel has been interested from its inception in good ties with Asian states, and one of the other important Asian country Israel has consolidated its relations has been India. Since the 1990s, Israel and India have strengthened their relations. A military and commercial relationship between India and Israel has developed; both countries have diversified their military–security relations; and India has been one of the important partners of Israel from Asia (Kumaraswamy, Reference Kumaraswamy and Karsh2004: 263–4).
As part of the development in Israel's foreign policy with Asian states, the relations between Israel and India were officially normalized on 29 January 1992 (Kandel, Reference Kandel2009) and full diplomatic ties were established. Israel's relations with India have been indeed a breakthrough for Israel's standing in Asia. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, the peace negotiations between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1990s removed India's fears of a hostile reaction on the part of the Arab states. The loss of Moscow's support increased the importance of India's relations with the US as well as with its Jewish community. These developments influenced India's decision to normalize the relations with Israel, and with the establishment of formal relations, comprehensive ties rapidly evolved in the field of security, agriculture, medicine, culture, science, and aviation (Neuberger, Reference Neuberger2009: 23).
The bilateral relationship between India and Israel has steadily increased since its formal establishment, nevertheless it was Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's visit to India in September 2003 that stepped up the relationship. It was the first-ever visit by an Israeli Prime Minister to India. The visit was a significant milestone signaling the change in atmosphere, and an opportunity to enhance each others’ understanding at the highest levels to promote bilateral defense and trade ties. During the visit, Sharon held talks on a wide range of issues with India's Prime Minister and other senior Indian officials. At the same time, six bilateral agreements were signed which included agreements on environment protection, drugs trafficking, visa free travel for diplomats, and cooperation in health, education, and culture (Malhotra, Reference Malhotra2003). The developments on the diplomatic front were paralleled by those on the economic one. A growing interest in economic opportunities in India on the part of the Israeli business sector, and an increasing volume of trade between the two countries were seen. Though it did not initially form the main impetus for improved ties, economic cooperation between the two countries has steadily increased since 1992. Economic ties have greatly expanded in the fields of agriculture, science, and technology. Joint research and development projects in the fields of telecommunications and software have been the main areas of cooperation. Additionally, Indian and Israeli companies and research institutes have formed many joint ventures for cooperation in agriculture, mainly in the areas of irrigation, water management, and crop production (Kandel, Reference Kandel2009).
Moreover, in the years that followed Sharon's visit, Israel and India strengthened their military relations, and Israel became one of India's largest arms providers (Pant, Reference Pant2004). Cooperation in the areas of arms sales and defense have been two core issues which demonstrate the improved relationship between India and Israel. Military ties between both countries have considerably expanded since 1992. India's quest for the latest military technologies have complemented Israel's need to broaden the market for its military products, and today military cooperation continues to form the core of the relations between the two countries. Several strategic interests have accounted for the development of military ties since diplomatic relations were normalized. When the Soviet Union was dissolved, India lost its primary strategic and military partner, and Israel rapidly emerged as an alternative military supplier for India. For Israel's part, the country's limited domestic market and the need to finance the development of new weapons systems required Israeli defense companies to generate revenue through exports (Maoz, Reference Maoz2006: 7). That is why India, with its large domestic market and growing defense budget, has been an attractive partner for Israel. Whereas Israel surpassed Russia as the largest arms supplier to India (World Tribune, 2009), the military relationship between two countries is not confined to Israeli arms sales to India. Both Israel and India share the common goal of seeking technological independence, and India's search for new technologies led to joint projects being realized, which lead to the foundations for a sustained and long-term partnership (Kumaraswamy, Reference Kumaraswamy and Karsh2004: 267–8).
Since the establishment of diplomatic relations, Israel and India have witnessed tremendous growth in their relations and have implemented many measures to promote them. Even though the relations between the two states have been upswing since the 1990s, the recent improvement in relations has much to do with the personality of India's Prime Minister, Narendra Modi. He has been a staunch friend of Israel, and has been credited with promoting Israel–India relations into a strategic partnership (Panda, Reference Panda2015). Israel's relations with India have strengthened significantly in the past decade with both states experiencing a convergence of interests on a range of issues. This relationship is mainly driven by close defense ties. Both Israel and India have much to gain from the developing relationship between the two countries. Cooperation in the economic and military–security arenas has grown, and there are widespread popular exchanges between the people of the two countries. As for Israel, India might become Israel's political friend, given the growing isolation of Israel around the world. Also, there are many potential benefits that both countries will accrue by cementing their friendship.Footnote 1
Israel and China established full diplomatic relations on 24 January 1992 (Goldstein, Reference Goldstein and Karsh2004: 243). It was an important step in Israel's standing in Asia, as well as China's in the Middle East. In fact, for about a decade before the establishment of formal relations, Israel and China maintained close secret relations in the military field (Goldstein, Reference Goldstein and Karsh2004: 241–3; Shai, Reference Shai2009: 23–4). During this period, there was also growth in unofficial exchanges between Israel and China, especially in trade and technology (Tjong-Alvares, Reference Tjong-Alvares2012: 102–4). Since formal relations have been established, in the context of the balanced policy of China, ties between them have grown, initially moderately and later more rapidly. Politically, high-level visits have helped enhance bilateral relations. Not only has every Israeli President since Chaim Herzog visited China, but Israeli Prime Ministers Yitzhak Rabin and Benjamin Netanyahu also visited Beijing during their terms (Zhu, Reference Zhu2007: 31). In January 2007, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert visited Beijing to commemorate the fifteenth anniversary of diplomatic ties and to seek the China's support on the Iran nuclear issue (Shai, Reference Shai2009: 44).
With the development of political relations came the increase in economic and commercial activities. Technologies in fields such as hi-tech, chemical industries, communications, medical optics, and agriculture were exported from Israel to China. Moreover, Israel became an important investor in the development projects in China and supplier of high technology weapons. Netanyahu once stated that the ‘Israeli know-how is more valuable than the Arab oil’ (Rubin, Reference Rubin1999: 51). Whether or not that is true, Israeli technology does have a high value for China. Until the early years of the 2000s, military technology had been the main Israeli export. Russian arms sales to China during the 1990s topped those of all other countries combined, but Israel was China's second largest source of military technology transfer in the 1990s (Shai, Reference Shai2009: 26). However, both countries were interested in more than just military hardware, and prospects existed for increased civil trade. In this context, the growing political contacts have paid off as they resulted in growing economic relations between the two countries. Economically, the volume of trade between the two countries has increased since the inception of the relations, and China has become Israel's third-largest trading partner globally, and its biggest trading partner in Asia. Trade volume increased from just under $50 million in 1992 to more than $10 billion in 2013 (Yanping, Reference Yanping2014). In Reference Yanping2014, when compared to 2013, China was one of the countries that increased the export of goods to Israel. In 2014 (excluding diamonds), Israel's export of goods to China amounted to $2.36 billion, while the import of goods from China amounted to $5.47 billion (Brusilovsky and Vinokur, Reference Brusilovsky and Vinokur2015). China now stands as Israel's second top export destination after the US and the largest in Asia (Al-Tamimi, Reference Al-Tamimi2014).
Even though there are some important issues, such as Iran, Palestine, and India which have the potential to affect the relations between Israel and China, the deepening diplomatic, military, and economic ties with China constitute a welcome development in Israel. China, who used to shun having relations with Israel in the past, now follows a pragmatic path, and despite the restricting effect of the US, values its ties with Israel. Much of the focus of the relations between Israel and China has been on trade and economic cooperation. In light of the amount of trade, and exchange of high officials, the relations between Israel and China have huge potential for development.Footnote 2
Apart from China and India, Israel has had friendly relations, or has been developing its ties, with other Asian states. After decades of focusing most of its diplomatic and trade efforts on Europe and the United States, Israel is turning to Asia. The shift is not entirely new, but previously low-profile diplomacy is now moving out of the shadows:
Israel maintains diplomatic relations with most Asian states. The growing economic strength and political influence of these countries has contributed to the intensification of ties in the political, cultural and, above all, economic spheres. Technical cooperation with Israel in the areas of scientific R&D, rural development, agriculture and education has played an important role in strengthening relations with the developing countries of the region. . .Israel also maintains good relations with many ASEAN member countries. Some of these ties date back 50 years and more, as in the case of Myanmar, Thailand and the Philippines. Some ties began more recently, when Israel established relations with Mongolia, Cambodia, and Laos. (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2016)
Myanmar (Burma) was the first state in Southeast Asia that recognized Israel as an independent state, and was the first Asian country to develop cordial relations with Israel (Embassy of Israel in Yangon, 2012). ‘Mynamar recognized Israel in December 1949 despite its earlier objections to its admission to the United Nations in May 1949’ (Abadi, Reference Abadi2004: 151), and U Nu, Myanmar's Prime Minister, became the first foreign prime minister to visit Israel (Freeman, Reference Freeman2014; Abadi, Reference Abadi2004: xvi). Since the establishment of diplomatic relations, the two states have nurtured a strong bond of friendship, which has included visits of high level officials from both sides. For instance, Commander-in-Chief of the Myanmar Armed Forces, Senior General Min Aung Hlaing visited Israel in September 2015. This was the first visit by a military leader from Myanmar to the Jewish state in 55 years (Cohen, Reference Cohen2015b). Despite Western sanctions, this visit was a clear indication of Israel tightening its relations with Myanmar.
Combined with ongoing efforts to cultivate its relations with China and India, Israel has recently developed thriving economic relations with South Korea. Even though Israel's diplomatic relations with South Korea were established in 1962, it was not until the 1990s that the Israel–South Korea relationship began to flourish, and in the last few years the relations have been booming in almost every field (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2016). Israel's economic dynamism and cutting-edge technology has attracted South Korea, and trade between the two states has exceeded over $2 billion (Ackerman and Lee, Reference Ackerman and Lee2014). On the other hand, Israel has had covert relations with certain Moslem countries in Asia as well. In this regard, Kumaraswamy (Reference Kumaraswamy2005: 2) has even reported on secret ties between Israel and Pakistan, which is considered a pro-Arab state. Israel developed different models of public and clandestine relations, including official recognition of Iran while concealing the true nature of the relations, and secret ties with Jordan before 1994 without official recognition (Kumaraswamy, Reference Kumaraswamy2005: 10–11).
As Israel has developed its relations with the Asian states, not only changing regional and global realities, and Israel's priorities, but also Israel's image in the world which has been disproportionate to its actual size, strength, and global sway has helped its efforts to diversify its foreign contacts. There has been the naive belief in some circles in the world that Jews control the capitalist world and significantly affect the policies of the United States. For instance, a senior Japanese minister told Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir that ‘you have unlimited access to every place and boundless influence. You have tremendous power. You've got the United States in your pocket’ (Neuberger, Reference Neuberger2009: 28). In this regard, one of the reasons for the Asian states to improve their relations with Israel might be this ‘image of Israel (which was perhaps fueled by latent anti-Semitic notions of the power of ‘international Jewry’) as a country capable of moving mountains in the American Congress and the White House and of securing credit, stipends, and investments to its heart's desire’ (Neuberger, Reference Neuberger2009: 28). It is highly probable that this anti-Semitic notion has helped Israel to establish itself in Africa, Latin America, and the former Soviet Union as well as in Asia.
The year 2012 was called ‘the year of Asia’ in Israel and the Israeli government sponsored an Asian Science Camp attracting Asian students to join Israeli students for a week long program of lectures by world class Israeli researchers (Adelman and Romirowsky, Reference Adelman and Romirowsky2013). The intentions to diversify Israel's foreign relations have helped Israel pursue new friends in Asia. Israel's efforts in Asia reaped tangible results, and it has established meaningful ties with the continent's three most important countries: India, China, and Japan (Neuberger, Reference Neuberger2009: 17). According to Israeli Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel's developing relations have been partially affected by Israel's relations with Western countries:
I emphasize eastern markets not because we want to give up on other markets, but we certainly want to decrease our dependence on certain markets in Western Europe. Certain markets in Western Europe are undergoing a wave of Islamization, anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism. These waves are washing over it and we would like to ensure that the State of Israel will have varied markets around the world. (Gady, Reference Gady2015a)
In this context, Japan is no exception. Even though Israel has far more developed relations with India and China, its improving relations with Japan is taking bilateral ties to a new level (Ningthoujam, Reference Ningthoujam2015). Israel's relations with Japan are becoming closer than ever; Japan can be an important partner in Asian trade and diplomacy for Israel as are China and India; and the two countries’ officials share a common desire to improve the relations.
Relations with Japan: historical background
After Israel was born in 1948, it tried to get the recognition of Japan and to establish good relations with it. In January 1952, it proposed mutual recognition and the exchange of diplomatic missions with Japan. These efforts paid off and diplomatic relations between Tokyo and Tel Aviv were established in 1952. An Israeli legation was inaugurated in Tokyo that year, and was upgraded to an embassy in 1963 (Shillony, Reference Shillony and Moorse1986b: 83). ‘Israel was the first Middle Eastern country to open a diplomatic mission in Tokyo’ (Cohen, Reference Cohen2005). Two years later, in 1954, Japan's ambassador to Turkey was posted as a minister to Israel, and this Japanese legation was also upgraded to an embassy in 1963 (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2014a). Since the establishment of diplomatic ties, both parties have steadily developed mutual relations.
However, it would not be wrong to express that the state of this relationship was undeveloped until 2000s. During the 1950s and 1960s, because of its increasing dependence on Arab oil, Japan focussed its interests on the Arab world, and relations with Israel did not flourish (Ikeda, Reference Ikeda, Sugihara and Allan1993: 156). Besides, the relations between Israel and Japan faced tension as a result of the attack on Tel Aviv airport by three Japanese terrorists in May 1972. The Japanese government responded by sending an official delegation to Israel to pay its condolences and provided $700,000 as compensation for the victims’ families (Ikeda, Reference Ikeda, Sugihara and Allan1993: 156–9). After the October War of 1973, Japan tried to maintain a low profile in its relations with Israel. Measures taken by the Arab countries, and Japan's need for Middle East oil compelled it to comply with the Arab economic boycott against Israel. From 1973 until Israeli Foreign Minister Yitzhak Shamir's visit to Japan in 1985, Japan had a pro-Arab position in its foreign relations (Cohen, Reference Cohen2005). During this time, Japan expressed its support for the Arabs and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) (Cohen, Reference Cohen2015a). For instance, Japan abstained from voting in favor of the resolutions about Palestine during General Assembly meetings of the United Nations in 1974, because they did not reaffirm Resolution 242 (Yoshitsu, Reference Yoshitsu1984: 13–14). Moreover, Japan reacted negatively to the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982 (Carvely, Reference Carvely1985: 164–8), and the head of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs’ Middle East-Africa Bureau urged Israel to withdraw from the Golan Heights (Kuroda, Reference Kuroda1983: 26–7). Indeed, throughout the 1970s and the first half of the 1980s, Japanese policy towards Israel was dependent on its relations with both the United States and the Arab countries (Ikeda, Reference Ikeda, Sugihara and Allan1993: 158–9). Energy, particularly oil, has been the dominant economic factor in Japan's approach to dealings with Israel and the Arab countries (Shaoul, Reference Shaoul and Karsh2004: 270). In this regard, until the mid-1980s, Japan steered clear of exchanging official ministerial visits with Israel, and the infrequent visits of Israeli officials to Japan during the 1980s were usually described as special visits in order not to upset the Arab countries. Therefore, securing a smooth flow of crude oil from the Middle East has been a priority in Japanese foreign policy and has significantly affected Japan's policy towards Israel (Miyagi, Reference Miyagi2008: 1–2). In this context, relations between Israel and Japan were almost in the same state of affairs until the Gulf War in 1991. Even though there were gradual improvements in relations, it seems that Japan remained committed to the Arab boycott against Israel (Stern, Reference Stern1988: 47).
Despite the Arab boycott, the 1980s bore witness to an improvement in Israel's standing in Asia (Shillony, Reference Shillony1986a: 17–24). During the course of the 1990s, Israel's relations with Japan also began to improve gradually. In the wake of the collapse of the Arab boycott, bilateral trade began to improve and diplomatic ties became increasingly open and cordial (Neuberger, Reference Neuberger2009: 23). After the start of the peace talks in 1991, Japan's endeavours to assume a more active political role in the international arena provided Japan with an opportunity to participate in multilateral efforts in the Middle East. In this context, Japanese officials visited Israel and Middle East in order to monitor the peace process. Besides, mutual visits between Israeli and Japanese officials were conducted, and these visits reflected the progress made between the two countries (Dowty, Reference Dowty2000: 72). Also, economic and commercial ties were formed during the 1990s, and by the end of the decade a scientific cooperation agreement between the two countries had been signed. With the growth in the volume of commercial transactions, many large Japanese companies opened offices in Israel (Ikeda, Reference Ikeda, Sugihara and Allan1993: 153–4). All these developments made it necessary for Japan to lose its traditional image as biased towards the Arabs, and both countries have developed more open bilateral relations.
Relations since 2005
The 2000s saw important developments in the relations. Ties between two countries grew, initially moderately and later more rapidly. Politically, high-level visits helped enhance bilateral relations. As part of these visits, Japan's Foreign Minister, Nobutaka Machimura, visited Israel in January 2005. He held meetings with President Moshe Katsav, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, and Minister of Foreign Affairs Silvan Shalom. Israeli and Japanese officials discussed a wide range of issues, and both parties agreed to improve bilateral relations. On the diplomatic front, whereas Machimura requested Israel to stop its arms exports to East Asian countries, Israeli officials stated their expectation that Japan would be actively involved in world affairs. Moreover, in the same manner, the Israeli side expressed their view that ‘Japan was qualified to become a permanent member of the Security Council’ (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2005). On the other hand, after meeting with Machimura, Shalom expressed his feelings about the similarities of both countries:
Israel and Japan have much in common, despite the geographical distance between us. We are both ancient peoples who have risen from the ashes of the Second World War to build on the platform of our ancient cultures thriving, successful and advanced societies. This mutual success has been based not on the wealth of natural resources, but on the richness of our human resources. (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2005)
The following year (2006), the Prime Minister of Japan, Junichiro Koizumi, visited Israel. He was the second Japanese Prime Minister to visit Israel, and it was the first visit by a Japanese Prime Minister to Israel in that decade (The Japan Times, 2006). Koizumi's visit was an opportunity for both countries to strengthen their bilateral ties (Asia News, 2006). Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert stressed the developing relations in the economic field, and pointed to the need to further enhance the relations in different areas:
I ascribe great importance to this visit. This visit constitutes an important milestone in our deepening bilateral relations and I am certain that it will contribute to the enhancement of ties between us . . . Israel and Japan have much in common; we are two democracies with a long tradition of seeking peace and with common values. Bilateral relations are strong and we intend to develop them further. (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2006).
Olmert made a reciprocal official visit to Japan in February 2008. This visit was very significant, because, despite the deepening of bilateral relations, no Israeli Prime Minister had visited Japan since then Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's visit in 1997. Olmert's visit had two main aspects: diplomatic and economic. Officials from both sides stressed their determination to further strengthen the bilateral relations through cooperation on all levels. The main areas of discussion were political and economic relations, cooperation in science and technology, and cooperation in the Middle East Peace Process and the ‘Corridor for Peace and Prosperity’ initiative (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2008). On the economic front, Olmert's main aim was to increase Israeli exports to Japan, and, for this reason, some of the leading Israeli industrialists and business people joined him during the visit (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2008).
Six years after Olmert's visit to Japan in 2008, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made an official visit to Japan in May 2014. His visit was about economic, diplomatic, and security issues. In this regard, several bilateral agreements about high-level visits, security and defense cooperation, economics, agriculture, space, tourism, and culture were signed; and both premiers stated their expectation to cooperate in the field of cyber-security, and affirmed the importance of bilateral defense cooperation (The Times of Israel, 2014). For this reason, Netanyahu and his counterpart, Japanese Prime Minister, Shinzo Abe, decided to upgrade defence cooperation and bolster economic ties. This visit was a major breakthrough in the relations between Israel and Japan. Because it was announced that an agreement was to be signed to increase defense cooperation, which would include ‘mutual visits by ministers and senior members of Japan's Self-Defense Forces’ (Reynolds, Reference Reynolds2014). In addition, Netanyahu's trip was especially important for hi-tech trade between the two countries. He stated that
One particular area, that is absolutely critical for Japan. . .is how to protect your bank accounts, how to protect your traffic grid, your electricity power plants from cyber-attacks. Israel is a world center of cybersecurity, and we are seeking to cooperate. . .with other countries and certainly with Japan. (Yashar, Reference Yashar2014a)
In the same year, in July 2014, both countries signed an agreement on industrial research and development (R&D). This agreement was historical, because Israel was the first state to sign such an agreement on cooperation in industrial R&D with Japan (Elis, Reference Elis2014). The breakthrough agreement was signed by Japanese Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry, Toshimitsu Motegi, with Israel's Minister of Economy, Naftali Bennett. The agreement was signed during Motegi's visit to Israel in July 2014. It was supposed to support joint industrial R&D projects between Israeli and Japanese companies and organizations. During the visit, Motegi led a delegation of Japanese industrialists, as well senior officials of the Ministry of Economics, Trade and Industry, which is responsible for Japanese industry, industrial R&D, and cyber technology (Yashar, Reference Yashar2014b). On the signing of the agreement, Bennett stated that:
We are continuing efforts to strengthen economic ties with the countries of East Asia, as exemplified in this reciprocal funding agreement for industrial R&D between Japan and Israel. This is a breakthrough achievement and represents a dramatic change in Japanese policy towards its economic relations with Israel. . .International R&D cooperation is an unparalleled springboard for Israeli companies to break into new markets. The agreement creates an excellent platform for joint initiatives, innovation and for Israeli companies to enter the Japanese market. (MATIMOP Israeli Industry Center for R&D, 2014)
Soon after the R&D agreement, Abe visited Israel in January 2015. This move was significant, as it was the first visit of a Japanese Prime Minister to Israel since Koizumi's visit in the summer of 2006. Abe travelled to Israel with a 100-person delegation of government officials and top business executives (The Times of Israel, 2015). He met with Prime Minister Netanyahu and the main agenda items were ways to improve cooperation and the economic ties between two countries as well as measures to fight cyber terrorism (Yashar, Reference Yashar2015). Netanyahu termed the visit ‘historic’, called for greater economic cooperation between Japan and Israel, and said that Israel ‘must diversify its markets to include Japan and the other great economies of Asia. That's why your visit here . . . is important for both our countries. We all understand that there is great untapped potential in our relations.’ Abe, in turn, said that ‘the economy is the one area which has the greatest potential for advancement of the bilateral relations’ (The Times of Israel, 2015). Both leaders expressed their satisfaction on the exchanges that took place between the national security and defense authorities. They also stated their expectations regarding cooperation on cyber issues, and a bilateral dialogue was held in November 2014 (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2015a). During the visit, Abe and Netanyahu also attended the Japan–Israel Business Forum. At the beginning of the meeting, Abe pointed out that
Netanyahu's visit to Japan in May 2014 comprehensively elevated the status of the relationship between the two countries, and in particular, economic relations between the two countries harbor significant potential. . .bilateral relations are deepening in all fields, but within that the progress on the economic front is particularly striking, and there is no reason for Japan, which positions ‘innovation’ as the engine of economic growth, not to cooperate with Israel, which produces innovative technologies. (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2015a)
As mentioned before, both Israel and Japan have been especially keen to further develop ties on cyberspace issues. During the Business Forum held in January 2015, as part of Israel's willingness to cooperate on cyber security, Netanyahu emphasized Israel's prominence in this area: ‘Despite the fact that we're only a country of a few million people, we receive almost 10 percent, almost 10 percent of the investment in cyber security start-ups’ (Gady, Reference Gady2015a). In fact, Israel and Japan had held their first dialogue on cyber issues back in November 2014. According to the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, both sides emphasized the importance of cyber security, and confirmed their determination to cooperate on issues such as ‘general overview of measures, governmental structure and strategy, as well as economic issues, and norms, rules and principles regarding cyber space’ (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2014b). The dialogue was part of a plan approved by the Israeli Cabinet in January 2014, which has aimed to bolster Israel's trade ties with Japan (Gady, Reference Gady2015b). The plan has involved the cooperation of different ministries in both countries which would help bolster joint research on space and cyber security.
In practical terms, there have been efforts to improve bilateral relations, and ‘Israel seeks to increase penetration of the Japanese market, while Japan wants Israeli technology and expertise’ (Taylor, Reference Taylor2015). These efforts have involved reciprocal visits to bolster especially cooperation in trade. As the Israeli Minister of Economy, Aryeh Machluf Deri, stated in July 2015, Israel attaches ‘great importance in the Japanese market’, and works to ‘strengthen cooperation with Japan and increase exports to the country’ (Gelber, Reference Gelber2015). Even though both countries have tried to improve their economic ties, mutual trade has remained modest. In 2013, Israeli exports to Japan stood at $0.72 billion, against imports of $1.1 billion (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2014a). Exports from Israel included machinery, electrical equipment, medical equipment, chemical products, and polished diamonds, while imports from Japan mainly included automobiles, machinery, electrical equipment, and chemical products. The figures and cooperation areas suggest scope for expanding the economic aspect of the relationship, something Israel has been doing with China and India (Ningthoujam, Reference Ningthoujam2015). In 2014, total trade between Japan and Israel reached at $2.3 billion, with Israel's exports to Japan reaching $800 million and imports from it $1.5 billion (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2015). In this regard, Israel's decision in January 2015 to open a trade office in Osaka in addition to the one in Tokyo has been a good step to strenghten bilateral economic ties (Cohen, Reference Cohen2015a; Embassy of Israel in Japan, 2015). Besides bolstering economic relations, the first Japan–Israel economic dialogue was held in July 2015. Officials from the Japanese Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry jointly with the officials from Ministry of Economy of the State of Israel exchanged views on various fields, such as ‘measures for the promotion of investment and trade between the two countries, cooperation in R&D, cyber security and venture policies’ (Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry of Japan, 2015).
One of the most important areas of cooperation between Israel and Japan, which has development potential, seems to be defence. Under the leadership of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, there has been significant changes in Japan's foreign and defence policies. Japan is moving away from the pacifist policies that have guided the country's foreign policy since World War II (Yellen, Reference Yellen2014). Abe seems to feel that Japan can no longer ensure its security, within the context of the constantly shifting regional environment, and has taken steps to reform Japan's national security policies with a purely defense-oriented military, a prohibition on protecting allies, and the lack of a national security council. He is trying to move Japan from ‘passive pacifism’ to a ‘proactive pacifism’ in international relations. In this regard, the manner in which Japan has been responding to rising threats to its security and sovereignty would change significantly. As a result, Abe has initiated a series of significant improvements to Japan's already advanced defense forces, ‘established a National Security Council, announced the first National Security Strategy and National Defence Programme Guidelines which introduced the concepth of a Dynamic Joint Defence Force’ (Takahashi, Reference Takahashi2014). Although Japan remains and intends to remain a country that contributes to international security and prosperity, its efforts might involve growing collaboration with Israel on defence issues. In this context, during Netanyahu's visit to Japan in May 2014, both he and his counterpart Abe agreed to ‘bolster bilateral defense cooperation, including in cyberspace’. The two leaders have also agreed ‘to hold talks between their national security organizations, and to increase exchanges of defense authorities’ (Aoki, Reference Aoki2014). And as part of this agreement, senior members of the Japan's defence forces are to visit Israel in the coming years (Kin, Reference Kin2014). Even though it has been stated for Israel that ‘it will take a long time to cultivate anything close to the defense trade ties we enjoy with India, South Korea or other East Asian partners’ (Opall-Rome, Reference Opall-Rome2015), the two countries already seem to be entering a productive future in this area, and thus ongoing changes in Japanese security policy make it very likely that these ties will expand.
On the other hand, two more aspects that need to be mentioned are tourism and culture between Israel and Japan. For instance, Japanese food items, such as sushi, and its popular culture, particularly animation, are widely popular in Israel. Cooperation in these civilian areas is planned to be boosted. There is a significant number of Israeli tourists flocking to Japan as against the modest number of Japanese tourists visiting Israel, and Israel has planned to increase the number of Japanese tourists by 45% in 2017 (Ningthoujam, Reference Ningthoujam2015). As part of this effort, the embassy of Israel in Tokyo launched an animated, online series to attract Japanese tourists (Berger, Reference Berger2014). Moreover, the Jerusalem municipality organized a week-long Japanese culture festival in October 2014. The event was officially called the Japanese Culture Week, which included the celebration of a broad range of Japanese traditions and modern developments, such as ‘culinary fare, artistry, cinema, sports, martial arts, and technology’ (Eisenbund, Reference Eisenbund2014).
Conclusions
Israel has been interested from its inception in good ties with Asian states, and hostility from its neighbors forced it to look beyond those Arab neighbors in search of friends and markets (Inbar, Reference Inbar2008: 174). Japan has been one of these countries recently and both Israel and Japan have begun cooperating on several areas. In fact, until 2000s, the relations between Israel and Japan were not so close. The geographical distance, the absence of cultural or historical connections between the two nations and Japan's dependence on Arab oil imports were the reasons for the undeveloped state of the relations between the two countries. An expert on Israel–Japan business ties stated that ‘the Japanese are very interested in growing their trade and business relations with Israel, but prefer to keep it quiet, partially because they still fear the Arab boycott’ (Shamah, Reference Shamah2014). As a result, the relations between two countries were historically cool up until the 1990s. Even though the two countries established diplomatic relations in 1952, it was not until the 1990s that the bilateral relations began to improve. Nevertheless, both countries may benefit from improved relations, and there is ample potential for growth and development in different areas, including economic, political, and defence related issues. Economic and political factors have led to an improvement in the relations between the two countries. High-level political contacts, opening up new bilateral dialogue and cooperation in different areas, has grown.
Relations between Israel and Japan have improved and economic cooperation is an important part of it. Trade between the two countries is increasing and there are plans for closer economic relations. Both Japan and Israel have export-driven economies, they rely on international markets, and the global economy is critically important to their future. Companies from both Israel and Japan export a high level of products and talent, and the development of economic ties between the two countries help bolster trade relations. They may either invest in new technologies, or develop commercial relationships. However, the European economy, a key export market for Israel, has not been doing well, and also Israel faces the economic threat from the boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement (Connolly, Reference Connolly2015), with growing political isolation as a consequence. Israel is waking up to this reality, and, in recent years, Netanyahu has put a lot of time and effort into expanding Israel's network of foreign relations, and has been working hard to open up more foreign markets to Israeli exports, especially in Asia. The numbers speak for themselves. In 2014, the European Union stood as the biggest trade partner of Israel; however Asia was Israel's second-largest trading region ahead of the United States (Levitt, Reference Levitt2014). In this regard, Israel is willing to cooperate on economic issues and is determined to increase its trade with Japan. Its goal is to increase exports to Japan by 50% by 2020 (Taylor, Reference Taylor2015), and as Ohad Cohen, head of the Foreign Trade Administration in the Israeli Ministry of Economy stated:
The Japanese economy and society have been undergoing a unique process of change and openness, which presents a golden opportunity for Israel – as a source of knowledge and global exporter of advanced technology – to increase cooperation and tighten economic relations with this country. (Gelber, Reference Gelber2015)
For Israel, in addition to being a trustworthy security partner and a reliable diplomatic ally, Japan has a stable economy to invest in and trade with. Japan may help Israel diversify its economic relations. Both countries have important high-tech know-how in software and cyber security. Greater interaction between both diplomatic and business leaders and flourishing relations can help develop cooperation in these areas. In this regard, a significant area of potential in Japanese–Israeli cooperation, which needs high-tech and strict cooperation, is energy. Both countries have always needed to import oil and gas, and they have recently begun moving in opposite directions in terms of energy supply. Japan either imports its domestic energy requirements or supplies it with with nuclear power. Following the March 2011 tsunami disaster, the Japanese public turned decisively against nuclear energy (World Nuclear Association, 2015). As a result, Japan has become the world's largest importer of liquefied natural gas (LNG) (US Energy Information Association, 2015). Japan's reliance on natural gas has dramatically worsened its energy security. For this reason, it needs reliable partner countries for energy imports, and it has to diversify its suppliers. Israel, on the other hand, has seen a major shift in its favor in terms of energy supplies. After the discovery of large reserves of natural gas in its territorial waters, Israel has gone from an importer of natural gas to a domestic producer. In 2009, the Tamar field was discovered with enough gas to supply Israel's domestic needs for 15 years, and, in 2010, an even larger discovery was made in the Leviathan field west of Tamar (Henderson, Reference Henderson2012). The Tamar field is estimated to contain approximately 9 trillion cubic feet (TCF) of gas, while the Leviathan field is estimated to contain approximately 17 TCF of gas (Khadduri, Reference Khadduri2012: 111). The amount of gas in these fields exceeds Israel's domestic consumption, and Israel can become a major natural gas exporter. Israel's energy sector is going through a maturation process, and Israel has been quick to leverage its new supplies to serve foreign policy goals. In this regard, both Israel and Japan know the ramifications of poor energy security, and this may be cause for both of them to cooperate in this field. Building an LNG terminal in Eilat in Israel and then shipping the gas to Japan would benefit both Israel and Japan. However, it seems that Israel would not be able to build an LNG terminal for export purposes in the foreseeable future. Because the space is limited in Israel, environmentalists tend to be unyielding and security is hard to guarantee (The Economist, 2013). In this case, Israel might export its gas to Europe or other near markets. This, in turn, might help Japan indirectly ‘by reducing the amount of gas sent to Europe by some of Japan's suppliers, improving the energy market to Japan's advantage’ (Menenberg, Reference Menenberg2015).
A potential cooperation area between Israel and Japan is defence. Most of Japan's military technology and power depend on the United States, and both states have agreed to strenghten their military ties recently (Mehta and Kallender-Umezu, Reference Mehta and Kallender-Umezu2015). However, as Japan moves away from pacifist policies and makes reforms to its defence structure, it might need to diversify its foreign partnerships on military issues. In this case, as being the most important ally of the United States, Israel might help enhance Japan's military capabilities. Japan stands to benefit from such a relationship with Israel in a variety of ways. ‘The two states are already part of the F-35 fighter plane program and signed an agreement on cyber security’ (Menenberg, Reference Menenberg2015). Military cooperation with Israel may lead to tangible benefits for the Japanese military units, and they may receive military training and expertise from the Israeli defence forces. By adopting Israeli defence tactics, the Japanese forces may enhance their status in East Asia. Moreover, ‘Tokyo wants to benefit from Israel's military industries in enhancing its defense capabilities, particularly against an increasingly defiant North Korea’ (Ningthoujam, Reference Ningthoujam2015). Both countries may colloborate in developing various missile systems and homeland security capabilities. Japanese defence industry companies could cooperate with their Israeli counterparts to penetrate the newest technologies, and one such area of cooperation between Israel and Japan that could be strengthened is cyber security. With cyber security issues taking on growing prominence, both countries see significant potential for cooperation, given their strengths in this area.
The relations between Israel and Japan are important, especially in light of Israel's strategic role and position in the Middle East, and Japan's growing role in world affairs. In this regard, the Israeli–Palestinian problem is another important issue which may affect the relations between Israel and Japan. Japan has shown great interest in the diplomatic process between Israel and the Palestinian Authority. Even though there is an increasingly close relationship between the two countries, Japan also has tried to maintain good relations with the Palestine Authority. It has taken a balanced position, supporting the need for an independent Palestinian state. On the other hand, the Arab Spring has created a new and challenging environment in the Middle East for both Israel and Japan. During the upheavals, the Japanese Middle East policy has been to maintain a stable international environment. For this reason, Japan has advocated cooperation and negotiation to deal with the conflicts, has tried to ‘support to promote and strenghten emerging democratic reforms’ and has pursued stability (Japan International Cooperation Agency, 2012).
On the other hand, Japan tries to contribute in the peace process through three pillars, which are ‘political dialogues with the parties concerned, promoting confidence-building between Israeli and the Palestinian sides, and extending economic assistance to the Palestinians’ (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2015b). In this context, in 2005, the Japanese Foreign Minister Machimura urged the Israeli side to reopen dialogue with the new leaders of the Palestinian Authority to make progress in the peace process; whereas Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon praised ‘Japan for its serious efforts concerning Middle East issues, despite its geographic distance from the region’ (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2005). When Japanese Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi visited Israel in 2006, he also held talks with Palestinian Authority officials and tried to ‘encourage both sides to engage in dialogue “as the only way to solve the ongoing conflict”’ (Asia News, 2006). Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's remarks also welcomed Japanese officials’ efforts concerning the disputes between Israel and Arab countries:
Japan has a significant role in helping to advance diplomatic processes in the Middle East. Under your leadership, Prime Minister Koizumi, Japan has contributed to the implementation of many important regional projects, and I am certain that Japan will, in the future, contribute to calming the Middle East and to the implementation of important projects that will constitute a bridge between us and our neighbors. (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2006)
Japan has also affirmed that economic stability would contribute to political stability and help advance the peace process, and, for this reason, invested considerable funds in Palestine Authority's economic infrastructure. In this regard, Japan's efforts focused mostly on an economic project, named ‘Corridor for Peace and Prosperity’. This project included the building of joint Israeli, Jordanian and Palestine Authority factories in the Jericho area, which would provide jobs and a source of livelihood for the Palestinian people. Israeli Prime Minister Olmert accepted the importance of economics as a lever for the diplomatic process, and expressed his appreciation for Japan's active contribution to the peace process and its assistance to the Palestinian people (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2008). In this context, Japanese Prime Minister Fukuda expressed Japan's readiness to extend assistance to peace efforts, and stated his support for the bilateral negotiations between the Israeli and the Palestinian sides (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2008). In other words, both Japanese and Israeli officials shared the vision of the two states living side by side in peace and security, and put forward their commitment to materialize the ‘Corridor for Peace and Prosperity’ initiative (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, 2008). Later, when Netanyahu visited Japan in 2014, Japanese premier Abe urged his counterpart Netanyahu to restart peace talks with the Palestinians and emphasized the importance of a negotiated two-state solution (Reynolds, Reference Reynolds2014). He warned that the collapse of the peace talks and the continuing settlement building could trigger Israel's isolation in the international arena. He recommended that both sides refrain from actions that would further lead to deterioration in the relations, and he also urged Netanyahu to restart negotiations with the Palestinians (Aoki, Reference Aoki2014). Japan has accepted that the most important element of the peace process is bilateral negotiations, and, for this reason, has constantly urged the leaders of Israel and Palestinian Arabs to negotiate. As a result, repeated declarations by Japanese leaders to maintain and advance the negotiations between Israel and Palestine have been an integral part of the Japanese position towards the Palestinian question. In this context, both Japan and Israel have a common interest in promoting political and economic stability in the Middle East. This would not only protect the uninterrupted flow of oil, especially to Japan, but also would enable greater access to local markets. Even though economic cooperation seems to become the main pillar of the bilateral relations between Japan and Israel, Japan has become more actively involved in the regional disputes and diplomatic endeavours. Because Japan has not an imperial or Anti-Semitic history, and because it has normal relations with many of the Middle Eastern countries, its growing influence and the soft power diplomacy in the region might be well received. Therefore, Japan could play a bigger role in conflicting issues, such as the Israel–Palestine conflict, and use its leverage to help find a solution to the Palestinian question.
The developing relations between Israel and Japan might be closely watched by other Asian countries, and one of the significant states that should be taken into account while dealing with the relations between Israel and Japan is China. Whereas both Israel and Japan aim to enhance their partnership, China may not fully support, and can try to influence the development of that relationship. On the other hand, Israel's relations in the defence industry with China may cause concern in Japan. Because of the strategic rivalry and concerns over the East China Sea (Goldstein, Reference Goldstein2014; Takenaka, Reference Takenaka2015), Japan might be wary of Israel selling sophisticated equipment and technology to China. In the future, if Israel's relations with China and Japan continue to strengthen, Israel risks finding itself between Japan and China. China's role in the relations between Israel and Japan may be an important factor; however, it should not be a decisive. For its own interests, Israel might explore the role of mediating differences between China and Japan.
A closer relationship between Israel and Japan promises major benefits to both sides in different areas, such as on economic, security, diplomatic, and energy issues. With many countries moving away from unqualified support for Israel, the importance of Japan is growing. Thus, the deepening diplomatic, military, and economic ties with Japan constitute a welcome development in Israel. Japan, who used to shun relations with Israel, now follows a different path and seems to value its ties with Israel. In light of the exchange of high officials, the relations between Israel and Japan have huge potential for development in the future. Although Japan's trade with Israel has risen modestly over the past decede, the strong synergies and new measures may increase the volume of trade. Moreover, Japan may cooperate with Israel in areas such as science, technology, and innovation, whereas Israel needs to diversify away from markets in the West. Both countries’ expertise in new technologies suggest a huge potential for both sides to cooperate. Both countries have much to offer, and there is great promise for cooperation in different areas.
About the author
A. Murat Agdemir works in Turkish Ministry of National Defence and holds a Ph.D. on International Security and Terrorism. He received his degree from the Defence Sciences Institute-Land Forces Academy, Turkey. His main areas of specialization include the Middle East Politics and Foreign Policies of the Middle Eastern States. His recent research focuses on Israel's foreign relations and security issues in the Middle East. He has had articles published on Israel's domestic and foreign policy, and his latest works include: ‘The Arab Spring and Israel's Relations with Egypt: A View from Turkey’, Israel Journal of Foreign Affairs, 10(2) (2016): 223–35; ‘All Quiet on the Western Front: The Outcome of Israel's March 2015 Elections and the Peace Process’, Arab Studies Quarterly, 8(4) (2016): 639–55.
