The nineteenth century witnessed the invention of a vast number of new English words, many of which related to society and morality. These regions of experience furnished the tropes for new Victorian words as the realm of the computer furnished the trope for new late twentieth- and early twenty-first-century vocabulary. Thomas Dixon has written a remarkable history of the word ‘altruism’ and its cognates as, over the course of approximately a half-century, they foliated into Victorian social and moral discourse. His superb volume goes well beyond what might have been conceived as a narrow exposition of word usage and constitutes a powerful re-reading of mid- and late Victorian thought. Again and again Dixon's analysis of individual author's analysis of and appeal to ‘altruism’ serves as the occasion for rethinking or refocusing our thought on major Victorian writers.
As a term, ‘altruism’ originates on the margins of mid-nineteenth-century thought. George Henry Lewes introduced the word in l852 in a Westminster Review essay on Auguste Comte. The latter had originated the term altruisme (perhaps drawing upon an earlier writer) the previous year. Both Comte and the Westminster Review circle represented advanced thinkers critical of Christianity, the churches, everyday British politics and the social policies associated with contemporary liberalism whose thought remained largely isolated from the mid-century mainstream. A goodly part of Dixon's story is how this new word first associated with the unorthodox came over the decades to be incorporated by Christian, evolutionary, socialist and liberal writers into numerous regions of British public discourse. Although ‘altruism’ initially encountered much criticism and even ridicule, eventually, as Dixon so persuasively argues, its ‘creation and acceptance … made it possible to experience oneself and the world in new ways, to communicate new ethical concepts, and to create new moral and religious identities’ (p. 1).
What so distinguishes Dixon's book is his capacity to explore the numerous byways through which the word ‘altruism’ made its way transforming and being transformed by those who used it. He refrains from the temptation to indicate who used it correctly or incorrectly, sincerely or insincerely. Rather he watches its use grow and its transformation into a powerful concept, much debated but equally much used. His approach recalls Alison Winter's study of mesmerism, wherein she simply treated the phenomenon as a visitor to Victorian culture. Dixon for his part explores the term not only as it appears in major writers but in provincial pamphlets and even classified advertising. He displays a catholic receptivity to the appearances of the word and concept in the most unlikely spots and in doing so reminds us that the articulation of moral and social vocabulary does not reside only in the activities of the intellectual elite.
As Dixon pursues his subject, he repeatedly redirects our previous thinking on major subjects. The original use of ‘altruism’ arose among English positivists. In his analysis of this encounter Dixon moves far beyond the standard histories of that subject, which tend to make the influence of the school of thought seem eccentric and ultimately nil. For Dixon the thought and value of the positivists, and particularly their altruist ideal of a life benefiting others, extends to the deeply personal spiritual experience of the Cambridge philosopher Henry Sidgwick and to the highly unconventional life work of the physician James Hinton. Altruism as a concept permitted both orthodox and unorthodox Christian thinkers to define Christianity as something other than a matter of individual salvation; rather it could be imagined as the abnegation of personal selfishness in the service of others. Dixon thus helps us understand that the impact of positivism went far beyond its presence as a small sect.
In a masterful chapter Dixon explores in considerable detail Darwin's account of the origin of human moral consciousness in The Descent of Man. He demonstrates how in that volume Darwin proved himself concerned far more with presenting humankind as social creatures than as competitive individuals. These arguments were appropriated and then further transformed by Arabella Buckley, a writer of children's books and ethical guides for adults. She presented evolution as demonstrating that social sympathy and empathy also arose through the processes of nature. Dixon emphasizes how Buckley and others saw this kind of argument originating in Darwin's book. Thus Dixon in this chapter and others presents the emergence of an unexpected social Darwinism with a human face rather than the face of harsh competition. Altruism had made possible this different kind of interpretation of human morality and allowed sceptics to present a morality based on human sympathy separate from Christianity.
Dixon's account of the ‘semantic progression’ (p. 361) of ‘altruism’ demonstrates that this progression could follow different paths. Some led to the emphasis on others against the interests of self while some interpreters of the concept emphasized service to others as a means of realizing self. By the close of the century liberal Christians and progressive socialists had adopted the term usually for the purpose of emphasizing a collective morality, but not necessarily for the secular morality that had been in the mind of Comte and his early followers. Dixon carries the reader through these differing and sometimes conflicting interpretations in careful detail, yet never becomes lost in that detail.
Dixon's Invention of Altruism assumes a distinguished place among several truly important recent books published by the young generation of Victorianists. It is the single best study of the emergence of new moral and social terminology in the Victorian age. The book reshapes, and for this reviewer much clarifies, the multiplicity of directions that Victorian thought took after l880. Imaginatively researched, carefully argued and finely written, this is a volume which scholars from a variety of disciplines will be able to engage, contest and build upon.
