This very readable and carefully edited book is dedicated to daily life in Rome's ancient harbour town of Ostia between c. a.d. 200 and 800. It is based on a selection of archaeological, epigraphic and literary sources. The content is rich and thought provoking, with captivating digressions to modern times, from De Chirico's townscape painting The Soothsayer's Recompense to the Temple Mount-Noble Sanctuary at Jerusalem. No complete picture of late antique Ostia is intended; nor is the impact of the two artificial harbours, Portus uterque, discussed.
In the Introduction, Boin explains the structure and scope of his book: his focus is not on the quotidian business of life in Ostia, but rather on longue durée shifts in social and especially religious life, and particularly on the relationship between Christian and non-Christian religions. B. shows that the latter remained far more important after a.d. 313 than is commonly supposed. In ch. 1 of Part One (Background), B. suggests that Republican monuments like the Castrum wall may have played a rôle in the memory of Ostienses in much later centuries. He rejects the usual concepts of Christianization and paganism and prefers to define Roman religions as pluralistic, the eastern ones being far more ‘Roman’ than ‘exotic’. He deploys Geertz's definition of religion as a system of symbols, in which belief is culturally embedded, depending on personal behaviour. In ch. 2, ‘the new urban landscape’ is dealt with more concretely: the long use of the inner harbour at the Tiber mouth, some buildings along the seashore, particularly baths, and fora in the city centre. B. exposes the ‘dead ends’ in the identification and dating of Christian buildings, especially the so-called Decumanus Basilica (a guesthouse?) and a space (a chapel?) in the Baths of Mithras.
In Part Two (Foreground), chs 3–6 deal successively with the third, fourth, fifth and sixth plus seventh centuries. I offer a brief summary. B. does not see solid evidence for a third-century crisis at Ostia (86–9). The so-called Round Temple, a Pantheon-like building, perhaps built between a.d. 238 and 244, is for B. evidence of positive activity. Though Ostia may have had a bishop named Cyriacus, Christianity did not at this stage influence the shape of the city. Jews, however, were permitted a synagogue, by the sea outside the city walls, because they respected the emperor. During the fourth century, temples were still in use; and none was ever converted into a church. The only intramural Christian basilica was built soon after a.d. 313 and dedicated to St Lawrence (and not to Peter, Paul and John, the view of F. A. Bauer and M. Heinzelmann) (160). At any rate, its location demonstrates that Christianity was not dominant. Outside the city walls, a church under the Sant'Aurea, a church at Pianabella and one dedicated to Sant'Ercolano, the latter two probably having a funerary function, were built around a.d. 400. In the fifth century, there are indications that traditional cults and festivals persisted, for example in the sanctuary of Magna Mater. In the same century, the synagogue aquired its bema; and the image on a glass cup from Domus del Protiro shows the popularity of St Lawrence. In the last chapter, B. suggests that three cults (of Castor and Pollux, Isis, and Vulcan) survived after the fifth century. Christianity became dominant only in the sixth and seventh centuries when martyr stories about Cyriacus and Aurea and the memory of Augustine's mother Monica also became popular. In the eighth or ninth century, Ostia was depopulated; nearby Gregoriopolis, including the Sant'Aurea, became the new centre.
In response to this general picture, the following constructive comments might be offered. For the continuity of some traditional cults in the sixth and seventh centuries, B. uses the Codex-Calendar of 354, the Calendar of Polemius Silvius of 448–449 and the Cosmographia, which probably also dates from the fifth century (207). These sources, however, do not prove cultic survivals after c. a.d. 500. B. states that the intramural basilica was ‘at the edge of the city’ (78). M. Heinzelmann's geophysical research, however, shows that Ostia was far larger than the space inside the Ciceronian city walls (see RM 105 (1998), 175–225; 425–9). B.'s attribution of the so-called Temple of Hercules to Vulcanus is not convincing (133–4). On the contrary, the famous sortilegium relief and three inscriptions all mentioning Hercules found in or near the temple (AE 1971, 71–2; CIL XIV S 428 and AE 1948, 126) leave no doubt that it was dedicated to Hercules. B. further suggests that the column with the graffito ‘lege et intellige mutu(m) loqui ad macellu(m)’ (‘read and understand that a mute speaks near the market’) need not have been written by a Christian (235). However, the words ‘lege et intellige’ seem clearly to reference Matthew 24.15, Mark 13.14 and Acts 8.30. Further, the supposed place of the meat market (regio 4.5.2) is disputed (see V. Kockel and S. Ortisi, in RM 107 (2000), 351–64). For other criticisms see B. Nongbri in BMCR 2014.01.6, online and D. Steuernagel in AHD Online Reviews 4 (2014), 11–14.
Despite these disagreements, B.'s book is a very welcome, innovative and critical addition to R. Meiggs’ Ostia (19732). It will certainly interest a wide range of readers.
