Héctor Pablo Agosti (1911–84) was the most important organic intellectual of the Partido Comunista de la Argentina (Communist Party of Argentina, PCA). This book about Agosti's ideas and works started life as Laura Prado Acosta's Master's dissertation. The time period considered by the author goes from the late 1920s, with the start of Agosti's political activism, until 1963, when a large group of activists – including some of his inner-circle disciples – left the party. This book aims to describe the relations between culture, ideology and politics in local communism through this particular case. The author also attempts to show how Agosti represented a particular kind of organic intellectual, stressing the conflict between the intellectual and the activist as she follows Agosti through his life as journalist, writer and organiser of cultural events.
The first two chapters are focused on the 1930s and early 1940s and include Agosti's communist activism as a young student and his imprisonment (portrayed in his own book El hombre prisionero). During this period he followed the anti-fascist ideas of his teacher Aníbal Ponce. Chapters 3 and 4 are a description of his political views on Peronism, a challenge for the interpretative framework of communism. Agosti's book Defensa del realismo and the work he did as a leader of the cultural branch of the party were in conflict with Zhdanov report of 1947. One of the key elements to understanding the importance of Agosti is his early familiarity with Antonio Gramsci's Prison Notebooks. The Argentine author expounded that important Italian Marxist's political and theoretical ideas in an original way. Finally, Chapter 5 is a not totally thorough analysis of another key element in Agosti's life story: his recognition as an organic intellectual of the PCA. Those were times marked by the Cuban Revolution and the rise of a ‘New Left’. Agosti was facing a young generation inspired by him and his Gramscian momentum. Prado Acosta's description leads us to conclude that Agosti was some sort of ‘free thinker’ who could vindicate José Ingenieros and Esteban Echeverría (Agosti wrote a book on each) as writers in line with the democratic bourgeois, agrarian and anti-imperialist revolution. His ideas were a combination of a Marxist humanism within a Gramscian frame. He contested Peronism, the nationalist traditions and conservative liberalism in his books El mito liberal and Nación y cultura.
Agosti's life and work are also a reminder of the difficult and strained relationships between communists parties and their intellectuals, who faced the political dilemma of accepting or refusing the political, aesthetic and ideological impositions coming from Moscow. Having to choose between subordination to politics and threat of expulsion was not easy for Agosti and many others.
The ‘Agosti case’ is illustrative of that tension and has been explored by other authors in the past. For example, José Aricó and Juan Carlos Portantiero, both members of the academic journal Cuadernos de Cultura when Agosti was a member of the editorial staff, have made useful observations. Néstor Kohan, Jorge Cernadas, Raúl Burgos, and more recently Ricardo Pasolini, Adriana Petra and Alexia Massholder have written books, articles and theses on this subject as well. Although Prado Acosta reviews some new documents, the book does not offer a detailed discussion of this other literature nor draw a conclusion about it. The book lacks originality. Moreover, by going only up to 1963, the book is unable to achieve a general assessment of Agosti's significance and the positions he held in the PCA until his death in 1984. This is problematic since one of the objectives of the book was to provide a full perspective on Agosti's life.
The book describes rather than explains the tension in Agosti's life and choices. He was a free thinker who had to follow, and occasionally obey, the objectives of the communist party. That is why he struggled to become a true independent intellectual. He started as a minor figure and grew to be the party's main intellectual. It was in this way that Stalinism promoted a political culture based on a dogmatic, even oppressive, set of ideas. Oddly, Prado Acosta does not consider this framework in her analysis.
Over the last 20 years historiography on communism in Argentina has made significant progress. However, there are still unexplored topics, including the rise of Peronism and how the organic intellectuals dealt with it. In this area, Prado Acosta makes some useful contribution by summarising the work of other researchers. There is another area for further research: the links between the artists and intellectuals of the different Latin America communist parties, especially those of Brazil, Chile, Uruguay, Peru and Mexico during the period 1920–80. This book provides some clues to understanding this network and opens a research agenda for comparative studies in the future.
