What does it mean to talk about ‘the UK’ in a referendum year that makes that question more pressing than it has been in centuries? Dominic Johnson opens up the question in the introduction to this diverse essay collection, citing historian David Cannadine, who confronts contemporary British insecurity by noting the pointlessness, for international readers, of ‘specializing in British history’ post-empire, ‘now that no one but the British were interested in it’ (p. 7). His comment touches on a strand of self-abnegation that runs through British life, often used to lacerating effect in novels and television sitcoms. We were all mouth and no trousers, it seems to say, even when we had it, we had it by force, and when that was finished, we were exiled to the middle of the North Sea, where we had always been. The point of the story is that this, in many ways, is where Live Art begins, in a country we can't define, at some point as the empire crumpled into dust and a much more interesting and heterogenous culture emerged. Live Art in these isles is a constellation of daring practices, jokes, events, absurd undertakings and countercultural politics, addressed not to our power – as in the USA – but to our demise. The British novel and British drama (but not British poetry) in some way connect to a collective history that Live Art, by its nature, complicates, undoes and undermines. Live Art is an event-based art practice made on shifting sands that seeks to mine the critical edge of being and doing, here in this disunited kingdom. This book addresses this complex state by refusing to make things add up, either historically or in terms of national identity, and by including pieces that take off, that riff, that remind, that alert, that suggest. Johnson takes the construction of identities, both national and personal, very seriously. As a result he has included pieces that explore a range of historical situations and trajectories, often from artists working with personal risk, including a terrific piece on Breyer P-Orridge. Johnson is astute and well informed; he understands the significance of categories, and of the generative power of subversion, irony and absurdity.
In bringing these essays together, he exposes the nature of ‘criticality’ in ways that subtly engage both with histories of Live Art in the UK and with the way in which Live Art speaks to historical context. The writing, by a range of writers with a range of experience, does not always come to meet the significance of the subject. It is a book that emerged from a journal issue, and in many ways journals assemble multiple voices better than books do. That is, however, a quibble with a book that does deserve to be read and used, responded to and enjoyed.
