Lourdes Orozco's Theatre & Animals and Una Chaudhuri and Holly Hughes's Animal Acts: Performing Species Today are valuable points of entry to the burgeoning field of theatre and performance research on animals. Orozco's slim volume—a recent addition to the Palgrave Macmillan Theatre& series, which aims to provide readers with concise introductions to major topics in contemporary theatre scholarship—gives a historical and philosophical overview of the debates surrounding animal performance, whereas Chaudhuri and Hughes's collection showcases work by theatre and performance artists who have grappled with these debates in their own practice. Taken together, Theatre & Animals and Animal Acts provide a relatively comprehensive introduction to this important area of study.
Orozco begins Theatre & Animals with a brief but very useful history of animals in Western performance and philosophy. I emphasize the Western orientation of this history—which Orozco is quick to recognize as well (4)—because the place of animals in Western philosophical discourse and performance practice cannot be taken as universal, and because theatre and performance studies scholarship on animals has yet to engage sufficiently with non-Western traditions that conceive of the animal in radically different ways. Be that as it may, however, I commend Theatre & Animals for its openness to the many forms of Western performance that involve animals. Orozco's genealogy takes readers from the Greek theatre, in which “[h]orses belonged to tragedy” (11) and donkeys to comedy; through Roman gladiator contests, medieval jousts, and Enlightenment menageries; to a wide variety of contemporary practices, including rodeos, circuses, puppet shows, and Broadway musicals. Although Orozco goes on to explore avant-garde theatre and performance art in greater depth, this preliminary genealogy helps orient readers to the vast field of animal performance and the many ideologies that it sustains.
Even more useful, perhaps, is Orozco's summary of the development of Western philosophical thinking around the question of the animal. Here, Theatre & Animals reprises the work of Matthew Calarco and others to show the extent to which philosophers from Aristotle to Emmanuel Lévinas have either ignored animals entirely or defined the human being in contradistinction to its animal Other. Orozco sees this tradition as emblematic of a pervasive anthropocentrism in the service of “the naturalisation of the notion of human supremacy over the natural world” (23). This disposition toward animals has left its mark on many performance practices that put animals in the position of always having to obey. However, a recent turn toward the animal in contemporary critical theory has begun to contest what Orozco calls “human dominion” (19). She cites the work of Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari, Donna Haraway, Jacques Derrida and Giorgio Agamben as emblematic of a significant reorientation of Western philosophical discourse vis-à-vis the animal. The ideas of these theorists have been foundational to the establishment of animal studies and have also helped to sustain—and, at least in Haraway's case, have actively entered into dialogue with—avant-garde theatre and performance art that attempts to reconceive of the animal onstage. Orozco highlights the work of Rachel Rosenthal, Kira O'Reilly, and Catherine Bell, among others, and shows how these artists work to imagine the performance space as one that might be shared on a more equal basis with animals, “exposing the close proximity of … human and non-human … bodies” (27).
Orozco closes Theatre & Animals with a fascinating discussion of the ethics of animal performance. These are not simply reducible to questions of animal welfare, important though they no doubt are, but rather encompass much broader debates about labor, agency, and representation. All human artists who work with animals should—must—grapple with Orozco's question, “Does the animal want to be there?,” as “the shadow of animals' (un)willingness to perform … falls over the work of practitioners who believe themselves to be attentive to the needs and desires of animal performers” (39) as much as it does over the work of those who hold no such concern. Here, Orozco builds on the work of Nicholas Ridout and Peter Singer to draw attention to “the material conditions that surround the presence of real animals in performance” (43), and in particular these animals' lack of agency. But, as Orozco notes, the ethics of animal performance extend still further, into the immaterial realm of representation. Even performances that feature puppets or other human approximations of “real animals” (50) contend with the ultimately anthropocentric tendency to make meaning out of animal life.
This was the only moment in Orozco's otherwise excellent book when I found myself wishing that her editors had allowed her another thousand words. I agree that “anthropomorphism is also at the centre of how non-live/unreal animals are represented,” and that “[a]s human creations … they are subject to humanity and its centrism” (50). However, anthropocentrism is not a straightforward ethical failing, but the conceptual substrate on which most human art making is based. Grouping “real” and “unreal” animal performances under the sign of the anthropocentric is politically important but conceptually insufficient; the real work facing scholars of animal performance is to disaggregate its many techniques, to hold “real” and “unreal” animals apart, if only provisionally, in order to understand how anthropocentrism operates. Only then will it be possible to move beyond truisms to real critique.
A commitment to examine anthropocentrism's many (animal) faces underlies Chaudhuri and Hughes's edited volume, Animal Acts: Performing Species Today. The editors deliberately reduced the scope of their collection to those plays and performance artworks that feature humans playing or otherwise imagining animals—the only exception to this rule being Rachel Rosenthal's watershed piece The Others, which routinely features dozens of human-and-companion-animal pairs. In her Introduction, Chaudhuri notes that the “interspecies” performances that she and Hughes chose to include “are … reflections on the relationships—real and imagined—between human and nonhuman animals” (6). In fact, Chaudhuri takes “the first article of faith of interspecies performance” (4) to be “that we are trying hard to talk about actual animals now… [that] we will want to remind ourselves … of their real existence, their actual being” (5, emphasis hers). That “we” still cannot help but turn these animals into metaphors is, as Chaudhuri invokes Claude Lévi-Strauss and John Berger to suggest, a testament to the enduring appeal of their “powerful metaphoricity” (5). Chaudhuri's concept of “zooësis”—which “mark[s] the ways the animal is put into discourse” (6)—is an absolutely indispensable analytical frame within which to situate and differentiate the many manifestations of anthropocentrism that emerge in animal and interspecies performance.
The plays and performance artworks included in Animal Acts are uniformly fascinating and, taken together, constitute a representative sample of contemporary interspecies practice in North America and the UK. Carmelita Tropicana aka Alina Troyano's With What Ass Does the Cockroach Sit? / ¿Con Qué Culo Se Sienta la Cucaracha? unsettles the Westernness of the collection with its tale of a Cuban cockroach who accidently becomes a Miami-bound stowaway—as does, to a lesser extent, Deke Weaver's account, in Elephant, of the time he spent with Asian elephants and their mahouts in Thailand. I very much appreciated this invitation, in an otherwise Western-centric and Anglophonic text, to think about other perspectives and begin a truly planetary conversation about animals and performance. I also appreciated Chaudhuri and Hughes's efforts to push back against their collection's unavoidable privileging of text-based performance. Animal Acts includes a number of excellent photographs of featured performers in action, and the companion Web site that the University of Michigan Press has set up for the book is a treasure trove of performance videos. Given this multimedia dimension to the project, one might fault Animal Acts for not including the work of bio-art practitioners like Kira O'Reilly and Catherine Bell, who are certainly pioneers of interspecies performance; but then, even with photographs and video at their disposal, the editors cannot reasonably be expected to account in book form for performances that are almost militantly nonverbal.
With the exception, again, of Rosenthal's The Others, each of the plays and performance artworks collected in Animal Acts is accompanied by an essay that in some way responds to it. These responses range from personal reflections to deeply incisive works of dramatic criticism. Of particular note are Donna Haraway's response to Holly Hughes's The Dog and Pony Show (bring your own pony), Jill Dolan's response to Jess Dobkin's Everything I've Got, and Jane Desmond's response to Kim Marra's Horseback Views: A Queer Hippological Performance. These three essays represent the best that theatre and performance studies have to offer the field of animal studies. They contend, like the performances they discuss, with the impossibility of completely understanding our animal Others. Faced with that impossibility, with the intrinsic anthropocentrism of human cognition, they, as Desmond argues so beautifully, “imagine otherwise … render[ing] to some slight degree a sense of what animal worlds might be” (137, emphasis hers).
