Studies on colonial medicine, imperial medicine and tropical medicine have flourished for several decades, but their timeframe has been confined to the period up to the middle of the twentieth century. In terms of space these works have been based mostly on each colony's historiography. Decolonizing International Health breaks these limits down to open a new area of research. The book focuses upon the emergence of international health in postwar Asia, particularly India, but prior history is not neglected. The author brings together many fields and timeframes of historical research: colonial medicine (prewar period), international health (prewar and postwar period), development study (postwar period) and international politics (postwar period).
This work shows the development of ideas on international health from the 1930s to the 1960s; as such, it is more of an intellectual history than an institutional history. Among its numerous historical sources are official documents of international organizations and sovereign state governments, aural histories, and even works of literature. Its storytelling is magnificent. I found that it stimulated my thinking on a wide range of topics.
The book's first part (Chapters 1 and 2) narrates the prewar history of international health. Focusing on the League of Nation Health Organization (LNHO), it points out that rural public health was highlighted in the LNHO's Conference on Rural Hygiene in the Far East in 1937. The approach of the LNHO, which can be traced back to social medicine or nutritional science, attached importance to socio-economic factors in medical and public health issues, and was critical of capitalist development. During the interwar period the idea of social medicine or nutritional science reached officials, scientists and nationalists in the Asian colonies. Even Gandhi's “Construction Programme” contained elements of this approach. These tendencies eventually culminated in the above-mentioned 1937 conference.
The Second World War and the advent of new technology changed the situation. First was the emergence of new chemicals such as DDT and new medicines such as antibiotic drugs, which in turn led to techno-centric approaches to problems of rural health. Most typically, DDT spraying was used against malaria during the war, rendering the socio-economic approach to that problem obsolete. Second, during the same period the notion that health was a government responsibility became pervasive, even in the colonies. Health became an important part of Asian nationalists’ future plans, although at this stage their views on health were rather idealistic. In the postwar story, these two plotlines intertwined.
The latter part of the book (Chapters 3–6) describes the emergence of the World Health Organization (WHO) and its role in the development of international health in postwar Asia. The early WHO played a very important role in helping newly independent states in Asia implement effective public health measures against infectious diseases. Consequently, mortality rates in many Asian countries declined drastically during the 1950s. Sovereign Asian states cooperated with the WHO to introduce “magic bullets” (DDT against malaria, penicillin against yaws and BCG vaccination against TB). Such was the techno-centric approach to public health issues. It enabled public health measures to avoid having to address problems of socio-economic complexities and insufficient health infrastructures in rural Asia. Just after achieving independence many sovereign Asian states faced difficult problems, the tragedy of partition in the Indian subcontinent, for example, and soon thereafter the Cold War. These situations forced postcolonial states to abandon their idealistic stances and seize upon cost-effective means of disease control.
But, as already mentioned, this techno-centric approach tended to neglect socio-economic factors: poverty, ethnic conflicts, inequality and a lack of infrastructure. Therefore, even at the height of its success, it was subject to many unforeseen difficulties. In Burma, for example, population movements caused by ethnic conflict generated poverty and overcrowding, ideal conditions for the spread of TB. The techno-centric approach never took these socio-economic conditions into account. Another example is south India, where a veteran nationalist was able to manipulate political resistance to BCG vaccinations. He reminded people of India's former subordinate position by claiming that experiments on cost-effective means of disease control were conducted only in underdeveloped areas such as south India or Ceylon.
The techno-centric approach hit the wall in the early 1960s. New difficulties emerged, such as resistance of vector to insecticide used to fight malaria, and the lack of medical surveillance for TB. Population control, moreover, replaced public health as a prime concern in the international agenda, because it seemed more useful to the purposes of encouraging economic development than public health. At this stage, the intrinsic value of public health was abandoned.
Two features of the book deserve special attention. The first is the space covered. The network space of the LNHO during the 1930s was peculiar. Persons from marginal Eastern European countries such as A. Stamper and L. Rajchman played very important roles in the LNHO, and even people from colonies contributed to devising and consolidating the concept of “rural health”, based upon the key term, “social medicine”. Many experts of this school of thought were active in both the LNHO and colonial governments (e.g. John Grant, a member of the Bhore Committee in British India). Even NGO such as the Rockefeller Foundation had some social medics who were sent to the underdeveloped world. This network probably symbolized the vacuum of hegemony in the League of Nations during the interwar period.
During the postwar period the network in the WHO was dominated to some extent by the USA. But, as the author points out, “The WHO carved a space, between American hegemony and the aspiration of Asian nation-builders, for the practice of biopolitics”. We might call it a “non-aligned” space. I found it interesting that the colonial network still functioned in this “non-aligned” space during the early postwar period. As far as doctors were concerned, the network of the British Empire remained in the campaigns of disease control and eradication in India, Burma, Ceylon and even Indonesia. This aspect of network epitomized a kind of intellectual or technological hegemony by Indians at the regional level, namely South and Southeast Asia, at least until the 1960s.
The second point to be taken up concerns the keyword “social medicine”. My research findings on the history of malaria control in British India concur with many of the findings in this book. In British India during the early twentieth century there was a rivalry between advocates of different forms of malaria control, the vector-centric approach and the human-centric approach. The vector-centric malaria control concentrated on eradication of Anopheles mosquitoes, while the human-centric approach paid attention to eradication of malaria parasites in the human body. Interestingly, this human-centric approach tended to become more and more socio-economic-conscious, and its advocates finally criticized the outcomes of colonial development – poverty, population movements and environmental changes – in British India. After the First World War there appeared a common epistemological ground on malaria control between this approach and the LNHO's experts. A few British malariologists from India played important roles in the Malaria Commission of the LNHO. As this book shows, their approach must have resonated with “social medicine” and nutritional study.
Even so, the means of malaria control promoted by the Rockefeller Foundation inherited the vector-centric approach during the interwar period. This approach often neglected socio-economic factors and tended to be techno-centric. As we have seen, once this approach was adopted by the WHO and independent sovereign states, it largely succeeded in eradicating malaria. At the same time, it left many problems that could only be tackled by dealing with socio-economic factors such as poverty, malnutrition, population movements and environmental changes. The tradition of “social medicine” in tropical medicine appears to have run its course by the early postwar period. Unfortunately this work does not trace the process of its extinction; nor does my research.
The reason why this reviewer is particular about “social medicine” lies in a present move of the WHO. The WHO recently organized the Commission on Social Determinants of Health, whose final report has been just published. It seems to me that the WHO is trying to bring back the perspective of “social medicine” into a new context of international health policy. At present, globalization is widening the health gap in ways unprecedented. In this sense, the publication of this fascinating book is very timely. Both historians and contemporary experts in international health would be well served by reading it.
