— As cries of “Black Trans Lives Matter” reverberated throughout the United States during the summer of 2020, New York City agreed to a $5.9 million settlement with the family of Layleen Polanco, a transgender Afro-Latinx woman who died in solitary confinement.Footnote 2 Ms. Polanco's death and the resulting settlement, the largest recorded for an incarcerated individual's death on Riker's Island,Footnote 3 motivated Mayor Bill de Blasio (“de Blasio”) to call for the abolition of solitary confinement in New York City jails. Given that many trans individuals are in solitary confinement due to situations beyond their control,Footnote 4 the resulting ban is a necessary step both for criminal justice and LGBTQ+ advocacy. Despite this much needed reform, however, de Blasio and New York City have failed to address why Ms. Polanco was first incarcerated: her inability to pay $500 bail from an outstanding bench warrant for sex work charges. Particularly in the context of the coronavirus pandemic, where sex workers have not received federal government aid, the Polanco settlement must galvanize legislation to decriminalize sex work, not only for transgender individuals, who are disproportionately prosecuted for participating in the sex industry,Footnote 5 but among all consenting adults.
I. LAYLEEN POLANCO
On April 13, 2019, Layleen Polanco, a transgender Afro-Latinx woman, was arrested on misdemeanor assault charges. Although the charges were not sufficient to require pre-trial detention, Polanco was incarcerated on Rikers Island because she could not afford the $500 bail from an outstanding bench warrant for failure to complete classes for a previous sex work conviction.Footnote 6
The Department of Corrections (“DOC”) knew that Ms. Polanco suffered from epilepsy and schizophrenia.Footnote 7 In fact, she had multiple seizures while in DOC custody.Footnote 8 Despite this knowledge and a psychiatrist's warnings,Footnote 9 DOC officials placed Ms. Polanco in “punitive segregation,” the functional equivalent of solitary confinement.Footnote 10 Ms. Polanco was left alone for hours at a time in contravention of DOC regulations requiring officers to check on individuals in solitary confinement every fifteen minutes.Footnote 11 On June 7, 2019, approximately two hours after the officers' last check-in, during which an officer remarked that Ms. Polanco appeared to be asleep, Ms. Polanco was found dead in her cell.Footnote 12 Video evidence reveals that officers spent minutes just staring into Ms. Polanco's cell, waiting, calling other officers over, and laughing, which according to the Polanco family’s attorney, is “not something that you do for somebody who you think is asleep.”Footnote 13 Her death was later determined to be due to an epileptic seizure.Footnote 14 The complaint states that “[s]he had been dead so long that first responders found her body cold to the touch.”Footnote 15
Just a month before Ms. Polanco's death, New York City settled another wrongful death case with the family of Rolando Perez, who also died from a seizure while in solitary confinement on Rikers Island.Footnote 16
No criminal charges were ever pressed against the DOC officers responsible for Ms. Polanco's death.Footnote 17 In a final act of disrespect, the DOC issued a report finding the officers not culpable while misgendering Ms. Polanco and using her deadname.Footnote 18 Ms. Polanco's family filed a civil suit, raising deliberate indifference claims under the Fourteenth Amendment and failure to provide reasonable accommodation claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”) against the DOC officers and New York City.Footnote 19 On August 24, 2020, New York City agreed to settle the case for $5.9 million, the largest recorded settlement for an incarcerated individual's death on Riker's Island.Footnote 20 As Ms. Polanco's sister candidly notes, “I do hope this settlement makes a powerful statement that Black trans lives do matter and that we need a change moving forward.”Footnote 21 The Polanco family’s lawyer agrees: “This being the largest settlement in the city’s history for a death in jail should serve as a powerful statement that trans lives matter.”Footnote 22
II. IMPLICATIONS: ABOLISH SOLITARY CONFINEMENT
Responding to Ms. Polanco's tragic death, de Blasio created a working group in June 2020 with "a simple mandate: find a way to end solitary confinement."Footnote 23 The working group, consisting of DOC representatives, a representative from the correction officers union, and a representative from a nonprofit that advocates on behalf of incarcerated individuals, was asked to submit a plan by the fall of 2020 to end solitary confinement on Rikers Island.Footnote 24 Although the plan has not yet been released, the working group promises to do so soon.Footnote 25 In addition, on December 10, 2020, a bill was introduced before the New York City Council that would ban the use of solitary confinement in all New York City jails.Footnote 26 If passed, New York City would be the first major city in the United States to officially ban solitary confinement.Footnote 27
III. IMPLICATIONS: REASONABLE ACCOMMODATIONS UNDER THE ADA
Furthermore, de Blasio ordered New York City to immediately stop placing incarcerated individuals with serious medical conditions in solitary confinement, including individuals with asthma, those who use wheelchairs, and those who suffer from seizures.Footnote 28 According to de Blasio, per DOC policy, “Layleen Polanco should not have been in solitary confinement”Footnote 29 due to her epilepsy. He has vowed to discipline the involved officers.Footnote 30 Although de Blasio did not explain his reasons for immediately banning the use of solitary confinement against those with serious medical needs, the urgency of his order gives hope to disability rights advocates. Under Title II of the ADA, “no qualified individual with a disability shall, by reason of such disability, … be subjected to discrimination by any [public] entity.”Footnote 31 The regulations implementing Title II require public entities, including correctional facilities,Footnote 32 to “administer services, programs, and activities in the most integrated setting appropriate to the needs of qualified individuals with disabilities”Footnote 33 and to make reasonable modifications based upon one’s disability.Footnote 34 Considering the frequent denial of health services to those in solitary confinement,Footnote 35 as well as the compounding detrimental health effects of isolation, particularly for those with pre-existing health conditions,Footnote 36 de Blasio’s orders support the growing outcry that solitary confinement is not appropriate for those who qualify as disabled under the ADA.Footnote 37
IV. IMPLICATIONS: DECRIMINALIZE SEX WORK
In the same press conference where de Blasio announced his intention to ban New York City's use of solitary confinement in city jails, he acknowledged that “[Polanco] should not have been in Rikers to begin with.”Footnote 38 When asked in September 2020 whether sex work should be decriminalized, de Blasio responded, “[t]o the question of whether sex workers should be arrested, my broad answer is no.”Footnote 39 De Blasio's answer, although vague, marks a major shift from his position in 2017, where he commented in an interview that he was “not there” as to decriminalizing sex work and instead advocated for improvements in neighborhood policing to “disrupt” the sex work industry.Footnote 40 To date, statewide efforts to decriminalize sex work have been unsuccessful.Footnote 41 Neither de Blasio nor New York City has proposed a plan to tackle decriminalizing the city's sex work industry.Footnote 42
Ms. Polanco's death serves as a mournful reminder of the urgent need to confront the criminalization of consensual sex work. The sole reason Ms. Polanco was incarcerated was due to her failure to complete a court-mandated counseling program for sex work charges, a program that has been criticized as “conflating sex workers and victims of trafficking.”Footnote 43 As a proud sex worker and prominent member of New York City's drag scene, Ms. Polanco did not ask for victim counseling. Footnote 44 This punishment for failure to complete court-mandate programs is perhaps even more problematic considering that it punishes survivors of sex trafficking who know their own needs better than the justice system. But for this unnecessary punitive program, Ms. Polanco would still be alive today.
A. Addressing Racial, Gender, and Sexual Disparities Through Decriminalization
Furthermore, the racial, gender, and sexual disparities among those criminalized for their participation in sex work demonstrate the pressing need to decriminalize the sex work industry.Footnote 45 Often compared to New York City's unconstitutional policy of stop and frisk,Footnote 46 “walking while trans” laws target already marginalized communities.Footnote 47 One transgender New York City sex worker revealed that she carries her marriage certificate when going anywhere with her husband to prove to police officers that the person whom she is walking with is her partner.Footnote 48 Former New York City police officers admit that monitoring minority neighborhoods to arrest sex workers and collect overtime pay “motivated them for years.”Footnote 49 Eighty-nine percent of New Yorkers arrested for sex work since 2015 have been people of color.Footnote 50 Although it is impossible to accurately measure the number of transgender individuals of color arrested, since in many cases the NYPD misgenders arrestees, police officers often target areas where transgender women of color are known to live, work, and socialize.Footnote 51 A lawsuit challenging the “walking while trans” policies was settled in 2019, thus avoiding these constitutional questions.Footnote 52
The coronavirus pandemic compounds the legal and economic inequities of this disparate criminalization. Sex workers are caught in a life-threatening catch-22: either risk contracting the virus if they continue working in-person or lose their livelihood if they cease working.Footnote 53 Under the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security ("CARES") Act, which offers financial assistance to out-of-work or self-employed workers, sex workers are categorially ineligible for government aid.Footnote 54 Specific New York City efforts to allocate financial resources to sex workers have been unsuccessful.Footnote 55 Sex workers, then, are left with little choice but to work.
Considering the millions of unemployed sex workers and the increase in the number of individuals who have turned to online sex work platforms “as a way to make ends meet" since the start of the coronavirus pandemic, now is the time to decriminalize sex work.Footnote 56 As Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tweeted in response to the online shaming of a paramedic who used sex work to support herself during the coronavirus pandemic, “[s]ex work is work.”Footnote 57 For this reason, Representative Ocasio-Cortez has endorsed the SAFE SEX Workers Study Act, a bill that if passed would scrutinize recent legislation restricting online sex work with the purpose of promoting safe consensual sex work, particularly for sex workers of color and transgender sex workers.Footnote 58 Other pending federal legislation includes a house bill to decriminalize consensual sex work between adults.Footnote 59 Yet, as of January 2021, sex work remains illegal in every state except Nevada, where consensual sex work is permitted only in a regulated “house of prostitution.”Footnote 60 Not only will decriminalizing sex work allow sex workers to obtain immediate economic relief through opportunities such as the CARES Act, this logical step could prevent another needless, heartbreaking death.
