No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 February 2005
Based on the meticulous examination of company and union records and enlightening interviews with workers, Contracting Masculinity is a successful attempt to show how “doing gender” at the provincial utility British Columbia Electric (BE) created systematic sexual inequality from the 1940s to the present. Tellingly, the first union organization at BE was formed in 1944 and the first personnel management department followed in 1945. Creese's aim is to show how the leadership of one white-collar union collaborated with company executives and personnel managers to institutionalize job evaluation (or classification) systems and collective bargaining agreements that normalized “the rights of male breadwinners to higher pay and career mobility” (107). In the process, the (white) male worker became the norm and the object of most union strategies.
Based on the meticulous examination of company and union records and enlightening interviews with workers, Contracting Masculinity is a successful attempt to show how “doing gender” at the provincial utility British Columbia Electric (BE) created systematic sexual inequality from the 1940s to the present. Tellingly, the first union organization at BE was formed in 1944 and the first personnel management department followed in 1945. Creese's aim is to show how the leadership of one white-collar union collaborated with company executives and personnel managers to institutionalize job evaluation (or classification) systems and collective bargaining agreements that normalized “the rights of male breadwinners to higher pay and career mobility” (107). In the process, the (white) male worker became the norm and the object of most union strategies.
Founded in 1897, the British Columbia Electric Railway Company (BE) expanded dramatically during the 1940s and became a major employer in Vancouver. Long-established customs of employment classified men as supervisor, engineers, and technical personnel. By 1949, eighty percent of all the women who worked at BE were in the first four—and lowest paid—job evaluation levels. Their jobs were defined as “non-technical” (i.e., unskilled), even though most women clerical workers at BE were high school graduates and had trained in stenography, typing and office machine use before coming to BE. A twenty percent pay differential between men's and women's salaries for the same work was justified by the company as a “community standard” and the necessity of meeting old protective legislation for women that required they have a rest break each day. The typical career trajectory for a male worker was to begin as a meter reader and then to move up the job evaluation ladder into supervisory work or engineering departments. Arguing that women would have to roam the streets or enter dangerous job sites to read meters, union leaders and company officials kept women out of job opportunities that might have secured them access to promotions and higher salaries. Most women at BE worked as clerical workers for a number of years and then married. Creese does not pay much attention to the historical evolution of the marriage bar, its effects on female promotions, or how and when married women and single mothers began to work at BE in larger numbers, presumably a major factor in the rising consciousness of women workers in the 1970s.
A surge of union organizing after the Second World War, helped along by new collective bargaining legislation in Canada, resulted in the establishment of white-collar unions with thousands of members. BE's Office Employees Association joined the US based Office Employees International Union (OEIU) in 1955. Creese is ambivalent about what she describes as “business unionism” at BE, arguing that while it did bring benefits to both male and female workers, it also reified the white male breadwinner as the average worker and downplayed “politicized forms of social unionism” (38). Creese does not discuss the historical evolution of the left's influence in white collar organizing in Canada except to say that it had disappeared by the 1950s. Given the grave consequences of redbaiting in the US for egalitarian and progressive policies in union organizing, more attention to this factor might have been instructive.
Through a series of bargaining agreements and changes in personnel practices at BE, the twenty percent pay differential between men and women was formally done away with in the 1950s but remained embedded in what seemed to be a “scientific” job evaluation system. In 1961, BE was nationalized by the province of British Columbia, and along with the removal of most blue-collar workers and engineers into a separate subsidiary a year earlier, this development posed grave problems for future unionization efforts. Office workers at BE, now public sector workers, regrouped as the Office and Technical Workers Union (OTWU). A surge of public sector worker organizing in Canada in the 1960s strengthened the OTWU's hand, and BE workers staged a successful walkout to oppose the implementation of a time-management study in 1972. While the OTWU's leadership did champion higher wages for women employees and a series of individual women's grievances, they also attempted to move most men's office work into the technical category, claiming that male office workers should receive salaries equivalent to blue collar workers in the British Electrical Workers' Union. Arguing that male office workers were “breadwinners” and in need of family wage salaries, male unionists created a “disembodied worker” who was “actually embodied in the white male” (135).
Women workers at BE began to critique this embodiment and to demand that attention be paid to their issues in the 1980s. They joined the union in large numbers and moved into executive positions, offering training sessions in leadership and encouraging women to run for union offices. One of their first demands was to end “personal service” tasks such as making coffee and running errands for bosses, a demand that most male unionists saw as trivial. The union Women's Committee brought family matters into the workplace by demanding childcare, flextime, and family leave. Discussions of sexual harassment evoked the deepest resentments among men. The results of a controversial women's survey in 1978, however, downplayed sexual harassment. The most popular demand was a four-day workweek, followed by career paths, on-the-job training, and educational leave.
With massive layoffs, a rise in temporary work and privatized sub-contracting, workers at BE faced a problematic future in the 1990s. These worsening conditions came along with liberal governmental attempts to institute affirmative action policies for aboriginals, people of color, and the disabled. At the higher end of the pay scale and in skilled job evaluation categories, men were affected most dramatically by restructuring, deskilling, and automation. Some responded with charges of “reverse discrimination” and continued to frame equity demands in terms of a masculinist (and white) breadwinner ideology.
Creese's painstaking attention to how all of this evolved over five decades of changing job classification schemes does not always make for stimulating reading, but is critical to the proving of her case: that “doing gender” over time institutionalized gender inequality in a system that appeared to be based on the rights of the individual in a neutral job evaluation system. She argues that by paying more attention to entrenched differences, women unionists were able to demonstrate the falsity of the premise that the system was sex neutral. In a closing chapter aimed at presenting new strategies for Canadian organizers she suggests that attention to gender difference and a focus on “living wages” for all workers should be a part of union policies in the future.
Some historians may find the sociological thrust of Contracting Masculinity off-putting, but the language is nonetheless, jargon free and easy to understand; wonderful quotes from workers illustrate Creese's more abstract points nicely. Labor historians in the US should find helpful models to apply to recent developments in communications and energy companies and in public sector employment. More collaborative work in all of North America might shed considerable light on the gender and class issues that Creese has made salient in her fine study.