In this well-researched book Beth Linker constructs a history of the rehabilitation of physically disabled World War I veterans as they progressed through a regime designed to “rebuild” those seriously injured in the fighting. Linker demonstrates that medical practices do not occur in a vacuum and delves into the nature of politics and society that affected the construction of rehabilitation in the United States during and after the Great War. The book is presented in seven thematic chapters that also provide a chronological structure.
Although Joanna Bourke's seminal work Dismembering the Male: Men's Bodies, Britain and the Great War appeared in 1999, much of the scholarship on rehabilitation and the First World War is comparatively recent. Linker's work on disability in the war complements research on other countries, such as Heather Perry's examination of Germany and the multinational study by Ana Carden-Coyne. Much research focuses on the nations that participated in the war for the longer duration. Because the United States entered the conflict in 1917, it might be thought that the impact of war did not weigh too heavily on its military. However, Linker constructs a detailed narrative of this relatively short period in American history and assesses the long-term implications for those who came back with physical reminders of their service.
The book's argument centers on the concerns surrounding the financial burden of disabled veterans. As men returned from the front in Europe, the reason that rehabilitation was taken up to such an extent was the enormous cost of pensions that the American government had already paid to its Civil War veterans. This generous compensation, to the winning side at least, ensured that by 1915 the government had paid out about $3 billion dollars, which was more than the war itself had cost (12). Rehabilitation was also a compensatory system, which in the World War I era demonstrated that the government was prepared to support those who had gone to fight in a war that many Americans felt had little to do with them. So there was a double imperative: control costs while demonstrating support by rebuilding the bodies of those who had been maimed.
Linker contends that this shift toward reconstructing disabled soldiers in a medical sense was spearheaded by orthopaedic surgeons. These men had a history in the establishment of vocational schools for disabled children and practiced what Linker calls a “medical welfarism” that “validated the felt social need to make the disabled useful through the production of capital” (38). In this endeavor, orthopedic surgeons were ably assisted by female physical therapists. One chapter focuses on the role of these women and their conflicting representations. They were symbols of the domesticity that a disabled man wished to achieve as an outcome of his rehabilitation, but they were also medical practitioners who needed to maintain a professional distance.
Linker details the importance of propaganda for selling both the war and the rehabilitative practices for those injured in it. Unlike many nations, the United States made rehabilitation a compulsory part of military service. Compliance was deemed essential to successful rehabilitation, and soldiers who refused were threatened with dishonorable discharge. Hospital authorities enforced early discharge if a veteran failed to fully engage with rehabilitative practices, but the hospitals were inundated with complaints and accusations of racism.
Linker details the construction of the newly “engineered” male body and the way that technology such as artificial limbs aided, and sometimes frustrated, the creation of a rehabilitated identity. Not only did a prosthesis disguise a limbless individual, it also ensured that through the enforced regimes of limb wear, the disabled veteran became adept at its use.
The impact of the rehabilitative practices outlasted the war. The book's penultimate chapter details the wider implications of rehabilitative practice and vocational education. The establishment of the Civilian Vocational Rehabilitation Act in 1920 paved the way for new levels of support for disabled workers. However, this did not express itself in a broad system of government-sponsored health care, which was reserved for veterans. Other federal institutions were established to maintain the levels of support for these physically disabled men. The legacy of the Great War expressed itself in the United States and other countries, including Britain, in formalized institutions to represent veterans' interests. The establishment of the U.S. Veteran's Bureau, as Linker points out, was one of “the greatest legacies of World War I” (165).
As a system to ensure that costs would not spiral out of control, Linker offers a reminder that rehabilitation was a failure. As early as 1920, spending on those disabled in the Great War equaled that spent on support for all veterans of the Civil War (166). However, Linker demonstrates that the legacy of rehabilitative practices and vocational training was enduring. By the end of the 1920s, fifty-eight specialist hospitals were built and placed under the control of the U.S. Veterans Bureau. New advances in medical and surgical practices ensured that veterans received more advanced treatments and were provided with free care to repay their bodily sacrifice.
Overall, Linker has provided a useful addition to the work undertaken in the study of disability as it relates to the First World War. Linker's book is timely. It not only reveals a little-known area of history and war, but also highlights historical continuities surrounding concerns over the levels of support of those who were sent away to fight and returned maimed. Although their part in the official conflict is over, disabled veterans' fight for support, recognition, and rights, coupled with their new identity as “disabled,” puts them on a path that, from what Linker shows, is well trodden.
