This volume offers a strong collection of articles, each covering a different aspect of economic life in Turkey. Books in English on Middle Eastern economies in general and the Turkish economy in particular are rare academic endeavors, with the notable exception of Ziya Öniş and Barry Rubin's The Turkish Economy in Crisis: Critical Perspectives on the 2000–1 Crises (London: Frank Cass, 2003). In contrast to Öniş and Rubin's edited volume, which includes articles from critical perspectives on the financial system, corruption, and distributional concerns in Turkey, the articles in this collection are largely written from the perspective of neoclassical (mainstream) economics. With the hope that it will start a fruitful debate and contribute to our understanding of Middle Eastern economies, I find The Turkish Economy to be a welcome addition to the literature.
The book is divided into three sections, with an introduction and short preface. The first part contains four articles on the real economy (the productive sector). The first article uses a business-cycle approach to examine productivity growth in Turkey since 1923. Its analysis of regional convergence confirms that Turkey's production capacity is still unevenly distributed between western and eastern Turkey, and its comparison of international productivity data indicates that Turkey has lagged behind its peers in fashioning sustainable productivity and economic growth. The second article, on income and consumption inequality, is noteworthy especially for its demonstration of the intergenerational persistence of economic inequality through unequal opportunities in education. It provides base material for sociologists of consumption to put spending behavior into a wider framework. The third article, on female-labor supply, examines the participation of married women in the labor force from 1988 to 2003, during which significant changes occurred in employment trends in Turkey. Its results are an excellent source for scholars of women's studies to analyze the effects of education, delayed marriage, and declining fertility rates. The last article, on price adjustments, determines that unsynchronized nominal price changes across vendors, on average, have a time lag of around three months. This important finding asks for a subtler monetary policy. All four articles are useful in establishing the fundamentals of the Turkish economy, from which scholars of Turkey in other disciplines may also benefit.
The second part includes three articles on corporate finance and governance, focusing on firm profitability, investment decisions, and ownership structures. Even though each article has its own strength, all succinctly illustrate the high degree of ownership concentration in the Turkish private sector, operating within a relatively weak institutional framework. The first article focuses on firms' capital structures, exhibiting their slow processes of adjustment to market changes (especially when the firms grow). The second article discusses the microfoundations of investment, detailing how the predominantly family-owned big holding firms use each other's internal funds to finance investment in order to avoid asymmetric information problems and agency costs. The third article assesses the effects of the concentrated ownership structure on these firms' performance. Together, this section is more interesting than the usual macro sections and adds substantially to the newly flourishing literature. Hopefully the societal implications of the papers, especially on wealth inequality, will attract the further attention of Middle East scholars.
The third part concerns the commonly researched topic of the ongoing structural adjustment. The article on privatization sums up the existing literature on the Turkish experience since the 1980s. The article on pension reform questions the deteriorating financial health of social security due to populist interventions. It also presents parametric alternatives for social security reform in Turkey. The last article provides a good picture of the banking sector, especially during and after the 2000–01 economic crisis and the reform efforts in its aftermath. All the articles in this section are highly informative, yet also descriptive, providing historical accounts.
A couple of words are in order regarding the volume's style. Most articles are unnecessarily wordy, with a few exceptions. There are numerous typographical and transliteration errors throughout the text. The reference lists at the end of each chapter are not synchronized in style. Some books in Turkish are cited as if they were printed in English. Besides these minor concerns, the book's style reflects academic professionalism.
This collection has something to offer a variety of audiences. For economists, it provides a good panorama of the Turkish economy as depicted by neoclassical models (with limited theoretical contributions) using recently available data sets, including new sets compiled by contributing authors. For area specialists with hard-core economics training, most articles provide a good starting point for further research. For area specialists with some economics background (those familiar with the assumptions of general equilibrium analysis), the articles portraying the contemporary Turkish economic landscape may assist research that could eventually put a more human face on everyday life in Turkey. For graduate students, this edited volume opens up new avenues for exploration of Middle Eastern economies, a research topic not fully explored. Overall, Altuğ and Filiztekin have done an excellent job collecting interesting articles that investigate different aspects of the Turkish economy.
