If, as promised by the book's title, you are looking for a good overview of the current state of local government in South Africa, this is not the place to find it. What this book does do is provide a historical narrative of governance – or what the authors call the ‘local state’ in South Africa's rural areas over the last three centuries. The authors take us from Dutch and British colonial-era, top down ‘prefectoralism’, to the Union government practice of using white district officers to govern rural areas in concert with co-opted or intimidated African chiefs, through to apartheid-era ‘Bantu administration’ with white officials ‘seconded’ to homeland authorities. But the real contribution of the book is the authors’ argument that the current paradigm of South African local government (democratic elections notwithstanding) retains the most important themes of previous epochs. Locked into a partnership of ‘cooperative governance’ with central government, the ultimate purpose of local government is to achieve national priorities as defined by central government, rather than to provide a site of autonomous, democratic self-government at the local level. Local government works today as it has for decades, and even centuries, as a deconcentrated form of national government service delivery and state presence at the local level, rather than a form of decentralised authority.
With the vantage point provided by this historical survey, the student of South African politics is better positioned to understand the continuities between the paternalist and patronising images of rural folk (e.g. people who are not quite ready for democracy) held by the modernising elite of the ANC in the post-apartheid era, and that of their white colonial and apartheid forebears.
But I use the phrase ‘historical survey’ advisably. The book is based almost wholly on secondary research. Even though it makes some very strong criticisms about the state of rural local government in the post-apartheid period, it makes almost no use of the great deal of systematic evidence we now have on the subject, whether in the form of data on public opinion, protests, corruption, civil servant skills or local government capacity, and how this varies across rural and urban areas, or makes any reference to other studies that do use such data. And the frustrating repetition of certain arguments and sentinel facts also gives one the sense that the book was not developed from a central idea, but rather resulted from the stitching together of pre-existing pieces as chapters in this volume. All that aside, this book could not have come out at a better time, for it provides a deep historical context in which to situate the attempts of the government of President Jacob Zuma to pass new legislation enhancing the political and economic power of unelected traditional leaders in rural South Africa.
