While academic work on the effects of gender quotas on Latin American politics has proliferated in recent years, there is less analysis of the more subtle ways in which women's demands are communicated and represented in the region's traditionally male-dominated political systems. Fiona Macaulay's excellent study goes a long way in beginning to fill that gap. In particular, this is one of the first comprehensive studies of the intersection between feminism and political parties and how the complex puzzle of electoral systems, federalism, and the internal structures and traditions of political parties either advance or inhibit the advancement of a progressive women's agenda.
Macaulay analyses the distinct ways that party systems and political parties have filtered women's demands for political representation and how these demands affect state gender policies. In her comparative case studies of Brazil and Chile, Macaulay identifies three independent variables that affect women's voz y voto (voice and vote) within political parties and the political system as a whole, as well as ‘the formation and implementation of state gender policy’ (p. 172). These include the existence of a secular-religious cleavage that cuts across the economic one; the nature and quality of party institutionalisation and organisation; and the tendency or not of a ‘gendered political habitus’ to emerge within parties (p. 7). She asks how these variables play out differently in the two cases, finding substantial variations in Brazil and Chile with respect to the nature and process of women's representation.
This study has many strengths. Macaulay brings to bear truly extraordinary fieldwork and interviews to provide detailed accounts of the very complex interactions between feminism and women's issues (in all of their forms and interpretations) and party formal, informal and leadership variables. Strikingly, rather than suggesting that a single model or set of institutions are the formula for success, she finds different kinds of successes and different kinds of failures in each of her case studies, with important implications for our understanding of the optimal framework for the promotion of issues of concern to women in Latin America. In particular, whereas in Brazil gender policy and women's representation have been advanced primarily by one political party, the PT, in Chile a centralised state bureaucracy in the form of a presidential level cabinet office, SERNAM (Servicio Nacional de la Mujer), was the central actor in advancing women's agendas and interests. The early establishment of legitimate equality claims within the Brazilian PT, without the complication of the cross-party bargaining prevalent in the Chilean pattern, provided additional space for the development of an equality agenda untarnished by a particular conception of women's political agency shaped by ideological conflict. In the case of SERNAM, this progressive women's agenda tended to get caught up in intra- and inter-party conflicts related to deeper cleavages in the party system. This contributed to differences in both the forms of representation and the particular conception of women's rights in the two countries. In particular, while in Chile the marianist or ‘supermadre’ (super-mother) conception of women's rights tended to prevail, in Brazil early feminist claims were advanced on the basis of equality, which became later consolidated with the development of a broader role of, and concern for, women's interests. Therefore, women's representation can emerge both in systems characterised by clientelism, weak parties and federalism, and in centralised countries, with strong parties and institutions. However, it emerges in different ways, in different forms, and faces different obstacles along the way.
Another path-breaking contribution of Macaulay's study is her mapping of women and municipal power. In Brazil, feminists within the PT used very creative strategies within newly created municipal institutional arrangements to advance gender equity policies through innovations in local level social participation. In contrast, in Chile's highly centralised political terrain, local forms of civic participation of the type that provided opportunities for women in Brazil have been slow to develop. However, Macaulay's commitment to avoid simplistic univariate claims leads her to acknowledge that it is not only federalism or the cultures of parties which determine how gender representation is conceptualised and processed, but electoral systems also provide the institutional base that can allow more or less permissive representation of women at the national level. Brazil's very permissive proportional representation system for legislative elections certainly allowed gender advancement at the local level to translate more easily into the national legislature than Chile's very restrictive two-member binominal election system.
Macaulay's study goes a long way in advancing our understanding of the connection between women's representation and political parties. However, while there are several cross-national references throughout the book, and primarily in the introduction, Macaulay could have marshalled additional evidence from other countries to reinforce her very strong arguments and place them better within an overarching theoretical framework so that the reader could take away something about how her findings apply in other cases. In particular, it would be interesting to discuss more specifically whether, with a similarly arrayed set of independent variables in other cases, we should expect similar outcomes with respect to gender representation and women's access to political and economic resources. That said, this study will endure as an exemplary piece of political analysis that will make a long-term contribution to our understanding of the connection among political parties, political institutions, political cleavages and gender.
